Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

which languages to learn and why?

137 replies

JupiterJan · 21/10/2023 06:59

AIBU to say everybody should be able to speak a few words of Mandarin and Hindi? AS these are two of the 3 most spoken languages in the world.

I want to learn another language now, partly for fun, but also for possibly travel and career opportunities. Should it be one of these? Or is there another language you would recommend, and why?

I am expecting people to say no to everyone learning a bit of Mandarin and Hindi, but I am interested in why we don't as it seems logical that we should

OP posts:
BeeJeezUs · 21/10/2023 09:39

It depends where you go on holiday.

I speak some Greek (always appreciated out there) and, if I was learning another, then I'd go for Spanish!

Meniscus · 21/10/2023 09:37

RosaGallica · 21/10/2023 09:21

There are many many people, working people, who can barely afford a trip to the next town. Those who can’t afford a holiday. There are many who have never been abroad in their lives.

No we will not be learning some language from the other side of the world. No matter how much your elites want to revenge colonise. Even the French that I learned, and was very good at, was only useful to me for less than 10 years of my life.

No one is suggesting languages are some niche holiday cultural indulgence for the holidaying rich. I’m from an extremely poor background, had never left the country and had barely left my home city (neither parent had ever had a passport) until I went to work as an au pair in France with my bad school French aged 18. That was a steep learning curve, but gave me the confidence to go home and win a scholarship to do languages at university, and subsequently to live and work abroad.

Loulou599 · 21/10/2023 09:37

@Normalsizedsalad
Interesting, this confirms my suspicion! Of course the Dutch are top, they are almost innately bilingual it seems :)

Caspianberg · 21/10/2023 09:35

I wouldn’t say that. I now live in a German speaking country. I would say 95% of people I talk to can’t speak English.
It’s probably different in the capital, but here in a regular small town, I couldn’t get by day to day using English at all.

TheLongGloriesOfTheWinterMoon · 21/10/2023 09:34

Also languages teacher. I speak: French, Spanish and Italian fluently.

They're useful for holidays and the translation work I pick up.

I know a few words in Danish, Greek, Japanese and Gaelic. Personal interest only. Is that useful? Only for me to amuse myself.

I have A' level German. I can tell you about the Caucasian Chalk Circle but I couldn't order a meal.

If you want a well-paid career using a language, then you need a far more "interesting" combination than mine.

Chinese and Japanese are always attractive on a CV. Hindi less so because English is a state language in India and Hindi native speakers almost always have far better English skills from birth than any English speaker who has learned Hindi will have in that language.

MargotBamborough · 21/10/2023 09:32

Loulou599 · 21/10/2023 09:16

For professional progression depending on your industry I would say Chinese or Arabic.
European languages are nice to have but most Europeans have enough English for you to muddle through, so if it's for personal interest then fine but in a professional context unless you master your second language you will probably find it gets switched back to English once the niceties are over.
Only problem with Arabic is I think there is a "formal" Arabic non native speakers are taught and I'm not sure whether actual Arabic speakers speak that variety?
If I were going to learn another European language it would probably be Spanish, I'm French so it doesn't seem too far removed, plus it's spoken by so many people in different places.
Scandinavian languages, Dutch, German, these are nice languages to study for your own personal interest but these are also probably the Europeans who master English the best.

European languages that often get forgotten in these conversations are Russian and Cyrillic languages, central and East European languages, which nobody ever seems to want to learn and would probably be very useful as I'm not sure English is mastered to the same widespread extent as in western European countries

I live in France and work in a French speaking professional environment. I have mastered French as has another English speaking colleague of mine. Some have not. On one of the projects I am working on now we switch to English not for my benefit but for that of a Dutch guy who has obviously mastered English but not French despite living here for quite a few years. The reality is that even living here you can get by reasonably well with only limited French and the only foreigners who learn it properly are the ones who really want to.

I would say that German is of limited use if you want to converse with Germans because they tend to speak such good English, but in Eastern Europe in places like Poland you quite often meet people who speak German but not English, so it can be a useful lingua franca.

Normalsizedsalad · 21/10/2023 09:30

RosaGallica · 21/10/2023 09:21

There are many many people, working people, who can barely afford a trip to the next town. Those who can’t afford a holiday. There are many who have never been abroad in their lives.

No we will not be learning some language from the other side of the world. No matter how much your elites want to revenge colonise. Even the French that I learned, and was very good at, was only useful to me for less than 10 years of my life.

Learning languages is not just for holidays.
It can help with job prospects, very important- helps against congnitive decline with age and can help better executive function, can open door to learning other new things like cultures, other languages etc.

mizu · 21/10/2023 09:30

Language teacher here too. Spanish or Arabic for me. Depends totally though on who you are mixing with / where you go.

A few words will not go far but is always appreciated!

My Arabic is not very good but is understood by most Arabic speakers.

European wise, French is also a good one.

Normalsizedsalad · 21/10/2023 09:26

European languages that often get forgotten in these conversations are Russian and Cyrillic languages, central and East European languages, which nobody ever seems to want to learn and would probably be very useful as I'm not sure English is mastered to the same widespread extent as in western European countries

https://www.ef.com/wwen/epi/

EF EPI 2022 – EF English Proficiency Index

The 2022 edition of the EF English Proficiency Index ranks 111 countries and regions by their English skills.

https://www.ef.com/wwen/epi

RosaGallica · 21/10/2023 09:21

There are many many people, working people, who can barely afford a trip to the next town. Those who can’t afford a holiday. There are many who have never been abroad in their lives.

No we will not be learning some language from the other side of the world. No matter how much your elites want to revenge colonise. Even the French that I learned, and was very good at, was only useful to me for less than 10 years of my life.

Loulou599 · 21/10/2023 09:16

For professional progression depending on your industry I would say Chinese or Arabic.
European languages are nice to have but most Europeans have enough English for you to muddle through, so if it's for personal interest then fine but in a professional context unless you master your second language you will probably find it gets switched back to English once the niceties are over.
Only problem with Arabic is I think there is a "formal" Arabic non native speakers are taught and I'm not sure whether actual Arabic speakers speak that variety?
If I were going to learn another European language it would probably be Spanish, I'm French so it doesn't seem too far removed, plus it's spoken by so many people in different places.
Scandinavian languages, Dutch, German, these are nice languages to study for your own personal interest but these are also probably the Europeans who master English the best.

European languages that often get forgotten in these conversations are Russian and Cyrillic languages, central and East European languages, which nobody ever seems to want to learn and would probably be very useful as I'm not sure English is mastered to the same widespread extent as in western European countries

StamppotAndGravy · 21/10/2023 09:15

Drat, my grin came out as gin. We're pretty advanced in making gin too though!

StamppotAndGravy · 21/10/2023 09:14

@Ducksinthebath sustainable energy, niche bits of financing, everything argitech, quite a few bits of normal tech, high level engineering, everything with computer chips, machines that make croissant, everything with water managing, beer...

Can you tell I'm a Dutch engineer? Grin

Ducksinthebath · 21/10/2023 09:07

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 21/10/2023 07:42

I speak pretty good conversational French, and "holiday" Spanish.

I have been learning a bit of Dutch (just dabbling in Duolingo) as I work in an industry dominated by the Dutch. Also? the Netherlands is our nearest neighbour - overnight ferry from an hour away. We do a trip over every couple of years.

I am really intrigued by which industry is dominated by the Dutch. My best guesses are flower bulbs or professional darts.

cariadlet · 21/10/2023 08:45

I think the best language to learn is the one which will be most useful for the individual.

I learned French and German at school because they were the only languages on offer.

The French has come in handy a couple of times on holiday in North Africa and Canada. German is less widely spoken outside Germany but I did use it once when I needed to go to a pharmacy in one of the Stans (I forget which one) and it was the only language which both myself and the pharmacist spoke a little of.

I'm currently learning Spanish because myself and DP are planning to move to Costa Rica in a few years. We've been on holiday to Central and South America a few times in the past and it would have been nice to have been able to speak some Spanish then.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 21/10/2023 08:42

I think “A few words in…” is almost useless. You say hello and how are you in Hindi and then what?

Learn what interests you or what is likely to provide opportunities for practice. I’m trying to learn DH’s native language, DH mine. And the bilingual six year old is doing Duolingo for the language they do at school.

koalaknickers · 21/10/2023 08:37

Learning a language is hard and takes a lot of commitment.

If you are doing it for fun, I'd choose the language you feel most drawn to. It helps if there is a lot of media to consume in that language that you would enjoy. Watching/listening/reading as much as you can helps.

For me, this language is French, but whatever makes your heart sing!

ErrolTheDragon · 21/10/2023 08:35

(Spoken English re bsl I meant? I assume most can read or write it)

ErrolTheDragon · 21/10/2023 08:34

My criterion would be that there's less point learning a language if the people who speak who you are likely to meet it will almost certainly speak and understand more English than you'll learn of theirs. Which is most of them, as English is the lingua franca. I doubt you'll meet many hindi speakers who don't have some English.

The big exception is BSL, who may be unable to understand or speak English.

RabbitsRock · 21/10/2023 08:33

I have always wanted to learn Italian because I love the country & think it’s a romantic language. It would also be good to be able to understand opera without surtitles.
I am also looking into learning BSL with DF as his hearing has deteriorated over the last few years & I could use at on the till at work too.

Warum · 21/10/2023 08:32

YABVU.
I say that as someone currently learning what I think is one of the most expressive and beautiful languages in the world, but which also has a fair few strict rules and complications!

Meniscus · 21/10/2023 08:30

I don’t speak either of those, though have a small bit of Gujerati from communicating with a friend’s granny, but much enjoyed learning Arabic when living in the ME (was living in the UAE but had a Lebanese teacher). It’s a lovely language.

BIWI · 21/10/2023 08:30

I've been learning Mandarin for over 10 years now - at a very slow snail's pace! It's hard, because you not only have to learn the vocabulary but you also have to be able to read (and hopefully write) the characters.

Add to that the fact that it's a tonal language, and it does add to the complexity. There are four tones for each vowel, and so the 'same' word is pronounced differently - e.g. the word 'ma' depending on how you pronounce it could be 'horse' or 'mother' (or many other meanings!)

But as I have already learnt French, German and Spanish (albeit to very different levels) I wanted the challenge of something different.

So it's up to you - how easy/difficult do you want the language to be, and how much are you considering being able to use it anywhere.

tttigress · 21/10/2023 08:28

I started to learn Spanish about 15 years ago, one of the things Spanish teaches said was "hey this is one of the most widely spoken languages so is really useful". But apart from some traveling in Spayand South America, I found it pretty pointless from a career point of view.

I now live in Switzerland and speak German to B2 level. Within Europe I would say German is much more useful from a career point of view. It is the most widely spoken language in Europe, and the countries it is spoken in are wealth, hence career opportunities.

towriteyoumustlive · 21/10/2023 08:24

I use Duolingo.

I already speak reasonable french, but I'm also learning Arabic as its useful for work.

It's better to learn useful languages.