Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

which languages to learn and why?

137 replies

JupiterJan · 21/10/2023 06:59

AIBU to say everybody should be able to speak a few words of Mandarin and Hindi? AS these are two of the 3 most spoken languages in the world.

I want to learn another language now, partly for fun, but also for possibly travel and career opportunities. Should it be one of these? Or is there another language you would recommend, and why?

I am expecting people to say no to everyone learning a bit of Mandarin and Hindi, but I am interested in why we don't as it seems logical that we should

OP posts:
cariadlet · 21/10/2023 14:54

girlfriend44 · 21/10/2023 14:45

Everyone speaks English everywhere you go anyway.

No, they really don't.

There are many places where people who come into regular contact with foreign tourists (eg guides, hotel staff, waiters etc) speak some English but where many other local people speak none.

Parakeetamol · 21/10/2023 14:53

Python, c++ maybe?

girlfriend44 · 21/10/2023 14:45

Everyone speaks English everywhere you go anyway.

TheLongGloriesOfTheWinterMoon · 21/10/2023 13:44

Melassa · 21/10/2023 11:53

Oh but I have. My DM was a single mum on income support in the 70s. I used to go shopping at the end of the month when the money had run out because shopkeepers would let a kid off if I was a few pence short but not an adult. We only got new clothes and winter coats as hand me downs from friends and neighbours. We never went on holiday anywhere, not even the U.K. we had one trip to see my DM’s family but that was saved up for over 4 years to afford the flights and we stayed with family. So don’t make sweeping assumptions.

nothing wrong with having ambitions and finding ways to achieve that goal. Languages were not my way out but they have been hugely beneficial in my career, as I took advantage of freedom of movement and travelled, doing minimum wage jobs to support myself. So no, not holidays. Such a Brexshit mindset ascribing languages to holidays in St Tropez.

Agree totally.

@RosaGallica it can also be for cultural enrichment and Duolingo is free. You might take up knitting or water polo or watching soaps in your free time. Others learn languages.

The OP didn't ask "which language will make me rich?" btw.

(I'm also the daughter of a single mother who qualified for free school meals and was the first in my family, and the only person in my year at school to go to university - none of which is remotely relevant to the OP but which seems to fit in with your race to the bottom "I eat coal sandwiches" merail. )

magicmole · 21/10/2023 12:41

It depends on what you hope to do with the language. To use on holiday? For work? For the love of learning? To challenge yourself? Read books/watch films in that language? If I liked K-pop I'd learn a bit more Korean than the few phrases I know. If I liked Bollywood films I'd want to learn Hindi-Urdu.

I studied Mandarin to degree level and still do translation work/listen to the radio to keep my hand in but I've forgotten so much because I don't get to speak it regularly. It gets attention on a c.v. but apart from my first job out of university I've rarely actually used it in work.

My French A-level from decades ago has been FAR more useful for that. Plus I'd still like to retire to France if I can afford it (Brexit makes that much harder) and you need a reasonable standard of French for citizenship. I reckon that's a good reason to keep learning any language!

faw2009 · 21/10/2023 12:14

I'm learning Spanish, I love it. We travelled to a Latin American country and most people did not speak English and so it was lucky I had some Spanish!

Also the resources available now are crazy! Youtube, online classes (look at Babbel or Lingoda), apps, netflix, books on Kindle with inbuilt foreign language dictionary (at least in most common languages). Check out different ways of learning e.g. conprehnesible input.

I do speak Chinese too due to heritage. It's a very different language to learn. I've known people adept at a 6 or 7 European languages to give up on Chinese.

MrsSkylerWhite · 21/10/2023 12:13

Agree. Easier said than done, though! (As someone who struggled and gave up with French and German 😁)

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 21/10/2023 12:12

Really. How do you think learning languages has benefitted my job prospects? As I explained it has been of little value at all. The only times they were called for at work brought no extra pay nor prospects: we’re supposed to take on extra work and responsibility for fun nowadays.

Just because it didn’t benefit you, that doesn't mean it doesn't benefit anyone who isn't 'elite', whether in their jobs or in terms of enjoyment or culture. God forbid we try to preserve a broad curriculum that offers more than just the basics to create the next generation of workers.

LoreleiG · 21/10/2023 11:58

I learned French, German, Spanish and Italian, three to degree level. They have been next to useless work wise but I enjoyed it and visit these countries for pleasure - whereas I can’t afford to go on holiday to China.

Melassa · 21/10/2023 11:53

RosaGallica · 21/10/2023 10:30

Travel is the preserve of wealth and therefore the elite. You clearly have never lived in poverty.

Oh but I have. My DM was a single mum on income support in the 70s. I used to go shopping at the end of the month when the money had run out because shopkeepers would let a kid off if I was a few pence short but not an adult. We only got new clothes and winter coats as hand me downs from friends and neighbours. We never went on holiday anywhere, not even the U.K. we had one trip to see my DM’s family but that was saved up for over 4 years to afford the flights and we stayed with family. So don’t make sweeping assumptions.

nothing wrong with having ambitions and finding ways to achieve that goal. Languages were not my way out but they have been hugely beneficial in my career, as I took advantage of freedom of movement and travelled, doing minimum wage jobs to support myself. So no, not holidays. Such a Brexshit mindset ascribing languages to holidays in St Tropez.

EmpressaurusOfCats · 21/10/2023 11:46

I did Italian on Duolingo for a few years (family reasons) but what made the really big difference was signing up for actual classes, with a teacher & people to talk with.

EBearhug · 21/10/2023 11:39

In many parts of the world, growing up monoglot is quite unusual. Many people grow up learning more than one language.

It depends what you want to do with learning a language and why. Your options may be limited by opportunity - at school, we all had to do French, and to start with, that was the only MFL on offer.

As a child, I lived Roger Lancelyn Green's Tales of the Greek Heroes, and it led me to read other myths, so I knew I'd find Latin interesting, and at secondary, I had the choice of Latin or German. I knew German would be much easier to do as an adult (my mother was quite heavily involved in adult education, so I knew they did lots of things like that,) so Latin it was - right through to A-level. I did start doing German at evening classes, because I'd also told myself I would, so I did that to AS-level (as far as I could go with evenings.) Also had a German boyfriend through part of my 30s, which helped, though he was fluent in English.

Then because I could read some Spanish because of having French and Latin, I did that to AS-level in evening classes, too. I find I can understand some Italian, but as yet have not found time for learning it, and wouldn't be able to speak it. As I got to a point where I couldn't take German or Spanish further at evening classes, I signed up for Russian (have done quite a bit of Russian history in the past,) but they didn't get enough people enrolling to run it, so I ended up doing Welsh instead, which I'm still doing, around B1/B2 CEFR level, with classes now online rather than in person as they started.

I'm doing all those on Duolingo to keep my hand in, but I find it frustrating to learn from scratch there, as I'm doing with Dutch, which is mostly to prove a former colleague wrong about no one ever bothers learning it... I'm finding it fairly easy with knowing German and English, but Duolingo is rubbish at explaining grammar, so I've bought a grammar guide alongside so I know what it's trying to teach me.

I also have a tiny bit of Malay from having spent some months in Malaysia. Couldn't do more than get round a food menu these days, though. Boyfriend has Mandarin after living in China for 6 or 7 years.

I worked in IT for about 30 years, and that was partly because it was like learning another language.

I like languages, particularly the patterns and etymology and links between them. I've always known why I chose each language I've learnt. I don't speak any fluently. But the interest makes me quite a good learner. Opportunity is important - less so now we have the Internet (which we didn't in my childhood and 20s.) I know there have always been teach yourself books, and sometimes tapes/CDs, but that is nothing like being with a real, interactive teacher. Learning languages is much easier these days in terms of available resources (apart from funding for adult education, which is dire these days.)

But you need to have some reason to motivate you to learn. For many people, finding language generally interesting isn't enough. There needs to be travel, work, love or something to be a motivation. It takes time, which can be challenging when you have a job to bring in money, a house to run, etc. Had i more time, I've a list of other languages I'd learn...

Opportunity is key - not everything is on Duolingo etc, there may not be evening classes or tutors (real or online) available. A school can't offer a language thry don't have a teacher in - and just knowing a language doesn't mean you can teach it. It helps to have real speakers to talk to for practice, which may not be possible.

But I think choosing a language because it might be useful, and then never having an opportunity to use it isn't likely to result in much learning unless you are the sort to enjoy language learning for its own sake.

Warum · 21/10/2023 11:13

Warum · 21/10/2023 11:12

I started with Duolingo and completed the course - I feel that the whole course doesn't take us much beyond the basics though, and there's a lot of pointless stuff! I love Easy German on YouTube, Seedlang, DW Deutsch and also find listening to German music helps too (there is good stuff out there), as well as watching films/tv etc.

PS There are so many dialects, but I love hearing Austrian German the most! I think it's like the Western Isles Scots accent in a way, for some odd reason (I speak more 'standard' Scottish English lol).

Warum · 21/10/2023 11:12

TeresaCrowd · 21/10/2023 10:53

Im currently learning German with Duolingo. My ‘holiday German’ is pretty good, my DP is fluent. It’s a useful language to me, mainly for ‘fun’ travel but also a bit for work.

Im currently trying to decide if my current most regular exposure is in german speaking Switzerland however, which to the uninitiated feels like what Geordie first felt like to this southerner of no discernible accent, is helping or hindering! Regional differences are certainly very interesting.

I started with Duolingo and completed the course - I feel that the whole course doesn't take us much beyond the basics though, and there's a lot of pointless stuff! I love Easy German on YouTube, Seedlang, DW Deutsch and also find listening to German music helps too (there is good stuff out there), as well as watching films/tv etc.

TeresaCrowd · 21/10/2023 10:53

Im currently learning German with Duolingo. My ‘holiday German’ is pretty good, my DP is fluent. It’s a useful language to me, mainly for ‘fun’ travel but also a bit for work.

Im currently trying to decide if my current most regular exposure is in german speaking Switzerland however, which to the uninitiated feels like what Geordie first felt like to this southerner of no discernible accent, is helping or hindering! Regional differences are certainly very interesting.

Freepublictransport · 21/10/2023 10:51

I work for a German company in a country that has both German and French as their official languages. So I speak both even though my job is in English. I understand a lot of Dutch because of my German.
French I learnt at school in the UK from the age of 7 until I left. I have been dabbling in German for a while but because of Brexit I‘m going for the test so I can have a European passport again.
I don’t think I would bother with a language that I couldn’t practice frequently. I use all of mine on a daily basis. The French I learnt at school was ok but not nearly enough for „living“ in French.
I have learnt basics in Croatian and Spanish that I can say hello, please, thank you and order coffee. I would like to learn more and luckily work in a company with 65 nationalities so could practice regularly.

Robinbuildsbears · 21/10/2023 10:40

I'm learning BSL because there's a large deaf community around where I live. I'm not planning on going abroad so wouldn't need any other languages.

Normalsizedsalad · 21/10/2023 10:32

Learning language is not "politically correct skill". 🙄
I said it can help with job prospects. Not that it always will. Many companies are looking for people who speak other than English language when they deal with business in other countries/people who do not speak English well.
The fact that you never needed it doesn't mean no one does.

RosaGallica · 21/10/2023 10:30

Travel is the preserve of wealth and therefore the elite. You clearly have never lived in poverty.

RosaGallica · 21/10/2023 10:28

Normalsizedsalad · 21/10/2023 09:30

Learning languages is not just for holidays.
It can help with job prospects, very important- helps against congnitive decline with age and can help better executive function, can open door to learning other new things like cultures, other languages etc.

Really. How do you think learning languages has benefitted my job prospects? As I explained it has been of little value at all. The only times they were called for at work brought no extra pay nor prospects: we’re supposed to take on extra work and responsibility for fun nowadays.

My dh, on the other hand, found his lack of languages no barrier to his continued employment. We all need penises, not politically correct skills.

Melassa · 21/10/2023 10:18

RosaGallica · 21/10/2023 09:21

There are many many people, working people, who can barely afford a trip to the next town. Those who can’t afford a holiday. There are many who have never been abroad in their lives.

No we will not be learning some language from the other side of the world. No matter how much your elites want to revenge colonise. Even the French that I learned, and was very good at, was only useful to me for less than 10 years of my life.

So depressing that this mindset still exists. Language learning is not an elite activity. It’s not just for going on holiday. It can enhance your career opportunities, but at the very least can expand your mind and improve neural pathways, which help you with problem solving in life in general. Knowing and using more than one language can also help stave off dementia.

Most of the world’s poor speak more than one language - eg. India, Africa etc will speak local dialect (and maybe also neighbouring ones), the country’s official language, plus English or French or what the colonial language was at the time. Hardly an elite activity there.

Zonder · 21/10/2023 10:09

Ghostlight · 21/10/2023 08:21

I'd want to learn one that I would use in the UK as I don't get the opportunity to travel. So BSL would probably be the 1st one I'd pick. I know and have met many more people who are deaf than those who exclusively speak hindi or mandarin.

Very few deaf people use BSL so it isn't that easy to practise with someone proficient.

Melassa · 21/10/2023 10:04

The languages that have been most useful in my career have been French and, to some some extent, Russian. I live outside the U.K. in southern Europe and whilst English has been relatively useful, it was my fluent French that got me most of my jobs. Lots of people were learning English but fewer people were learning French to the level required in my industry. Russian has been useful as a had a stint of working closely with Eastern Europe, and Slavic languages have a lot of common words or roots. I can read Cyrillic which also helps to a small extent when holidaying in Greece 😁

I think what helps the most as opposed to choosing a specific language is that another language opens doors and facilitates comprehension of other, similar ones. See Russian example above. Also, with a fluent knowledge of Latin based languages I find I can get by in Spanish and understand a bit of Portuguese, which has helped when dealing with South America. I’ve not studied either if these languages but find it easy to pick up words and phrases, and understand them to varying degrees when spoken.

MargotBamborough · 21/10/2023 09:42

Meniscus · 21/10/2023 09:37

No one is suggesting languages are some niche holiday cultural indulgence for the holidaying rich. I’m from an extremely poor background, had never left the country and had barely left my home city (neither parent had ever had a passport) until I went to work as an au pair in France with my bad school French aged 18. That was a steep learning curve, but gave me the confidence to go home and win a scholarship to do languages at university, and subsequently to live and work abroad.

I also did this but unfortunately au pairing is a lot more difficult than it used to be thanks to Brexshit!