Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a Solicitor shouldn't be allowed to do this?

59 replies

Moonlightbythesea · 21/10/2023 06:18

I can't go into all the ins and outs as I don't want to out myself potentially.

I'm involved in Court proceedings regarding unpaid child maintenance. Ex has a Solicitor acting for him, I can't afford to have one represent me, although hopefully I will be ok by myself.
As part of my case I've received paperwork, copied from the Court to both parties, and I'm truly aghast at how his Solicitor has slated me in a couple of her letters.

She has made a few points about me not being very 'stable mentally', words to that affect anyway. She doesn't know me, and besides. I guess she's just writing what my ex tells her to.
Can a Solicitor do this?
I thought Solicitors had to abide by a code of conduct, or as it's Court proceedings, is there such a thing as litigation privilege where Solicitors can get away with writing all manner of derogatory words and they can't be classed as defamatory?

OP posts:
Oaktree1233 · 21/10/2023 07:00

A solicitor is paid to present their clients version of events but it makes not a jot of difference unless they can evidence it for the judge. They have to produce proof. In day to day litigation it’s often the case that one sides versions conflict with another’s ( that is why there is a dispute) but that fine as long as the lawyer believes in their clients version. So I could assert that my client could not walk without pain but if the other side had clear contradictory video evidence I would have to tell client to change their evidence or I would not act. I was never a family lawyer but I’m unclear why your mental stability is relevant to unpaid monies. It would be relevant to custody but presumably that’s already determined.

Graciebobcat · 21/10/2023 06:54

Depends how it is written.

bonzaitree · 21/10/2023 06:52

Moonlightbythesea · 21/10/2023 06:46

Thanks all, I can't see the point then of the other party paying someone to write what they tell them to, when they could just write to the Court and represent themselves!

I guess it boils down to the belief that the Judge will listen to a Solicitor more.

The judges job is to listen to both sides.

If the solicitor says in court that you’re mentally unstable. You calmly say that you’re not and that there is no evidence of that.

The judge will be very very used to hearing allegations of someone being unstable etc. They will look at the evidence they’re presented with.

MyDogCalledMax · 21/10/2023 06:50

@Moonlightbythesea there are a lot of reasons for using solicitors. I don’t know if I would agree that the judge would listen more just because a solicitor is involved. Usually, people representing themselves get A LOT more leeway because they’re not expected to know as much about the process. I have seen judges be pretty helpful in that regard, although that is largely down to the personality of the judge!!

Moonlightbythesea · 21/10/2023 06:46

Thanks all, I can't see the point then of the other party paying someone to write what they tell them to, when they could just write to the Court and represent themselves!

I guess it boils down to the belief that the Judge will listen to a Solicitor more.

OP posts:
sparklefresh · 21/10/2023 06:33

If it helps, she probably toned down the language as much as her client would let her, but ultimately she's acting on her client's instructions. A judge won't be swayed by that language though.

MyDogCalledMax · 21/10/2023 06:29

Hey OP, solicitor here (albeit not family!)

Solicitors follow the instructions of their client. If that’s what he has told them, that is what they will write, within reason. They are being paid by their client to try and win so their aim is clearly to make you look as bad as possible.
They may well have questioned their client whether such strong language be used in the letter but if it’s what the client wants, then it’s what they do.

evrey · 21/10/2023 06:26

All information passed to the judge will have to be factual not opinion based nor third hand. The solicitor risks looking very unprofessional unless he or she can back this up with proof .
Personally I would write my own cover letter to the judge stating facts only and be respectful to your ex partner .

Whattodo112222 · 21/10/2023 06:21

Solicitors are paid to say and do exactly as the client instructs. I got told I'm hostile, abusive and I'm causing my daughter emotional damage in letters before. If it bothers you then you can write back to correct her.
You need to develop a thicker skin.