Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a Solicitor shouldn't be allowed to do this?

59 replies

Moonlightbythesea · 21/10/2023 06:18

I can't go into all the ins and outs as I don't want to out myself potentially.

I'm involved in Court proceedings regarding unpaid child maintenance. Ex has a Solicitor acting for him, I can't afford to have one represent me, although hopefully I will be ok by myself.
As part of my case I've received paperwork, copied from the Court to both parties, and I'm truly aghast at how his Solicitor has slated me in a couple of her letters.

She has made a few points about me not being very 'stable mentally', words to that affect anyway. She doesn't know me, and besides. I guess she's just writing what my ex tells her to.
Can a Solicitor do this?
I thought Solicitors had to abide by a code of conduct, or as it's Court proceedings, is there such a thing as litigation privilege where Solicitors can get away with writing all manner of derogatory words and they can't be classed as defamatory?

OP posts:
Reugny · 21/10/2023 07:37

Puncturedbicycle85 · 21/10/2023 07:33

Also child maintenance wouldn’t be something the courts would be dealing with as it’s done by the Child Maintenance Service so I am guessing your case is about something else. In law, payment or not of maintenance is irrelevant to whether a parent has contact with a child. You will look bad if you withhold contact on the basis that he is not paying, crappy as it may be that he’s not.

High income earners -as in very high income earners - can have court orders for child maintenance as the Child Maintenance Service only deals with income up to a certain amount.

Moonlightbythesea · 21/10/2023 07:37

Puncturedbicycle85 · 21/10/2023 07:33

Also child maintenance wouldn’t be something the courts would be dealing with as it’s done by the Child Maintenance Service so I am guessing your case is about something else. In law, payment or not of maintenance is irrelevant to whether a parent has contact with a child. You will look bad if you withhold contact on the basis that he is not paying, crappy as it may be that he’s not.

It's a Tribunal appeal.

OP posts:
MikeRafone · 21/10/2023 07:34

You get to ask questions in court, your ex doesn’t

Moonlightbythesea · 21/10/2023 07:33

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 21/10/2023 07:15

This, unless you are saying 'give me 60% of your income to fund me for spousal income', why on earth would he rather pay a lawyer than give money to his children!

Edited

I think some men would rather pay as much as they have to to a Solicitor to fight their corner, rather than pay towards their Children, as they see it as giving money to the ex and not their own Children. Unbelievable.

OP posts:
Puncturedbicycle85 · 21/10/2023 07:33

Also child maintenance wouldn’t be something the courts would be dealing with as it’s done by the Child Maintenance Service so I am guessing your case is about something else. In law, payment or not of maintenance is irrelevant to whether a parent has contact with a child. You will look bad if you withhold contact on the basis that he is not paying, crappy as it may be that he’s not.

Hibiscrubbed · 21/10/2023 07:31

Interesting how he thinks claiming you’re mentally unstable will help defend his failure to pay maintenance.

“If your former partner was so unstable, why did you fail to pay to help the lives of your children that you left with this apparently unstable mother?”

BettyPhuckzer · 21/10/2023 07:31

I should have thought it is fine for your ex to say anything he chooses to believe

However if his solicitor is also saying that they believe it, that can't be correct

Also, for the judge to believe it, I'd have thought there would need to be a medical report to back it up

Puncturedbicycle85 · 21/10/2023 07:30

She isn’t defaming you, she is writing what her client is telling her to. It’s actually good that she is writing the letters and not him, as he would no doubt be abusive. You won’t have any course of action against her and I wouldn’t bother complaining to any regulating body because it makes you look unhinged.

Judges won’t listen to a solicitor more just because they are a solicitor but if you have legal representation it means your case will be presented better and will probably come across as more persuasive. In most family cases though at least one party is not represented so judges are very used to it.

Moonlightbythesea · 21/10/2023 07:30

Reugny · 21/10/2023 07:19

I'm another one who doesn't understand how your mental instability can be linked to him not paying maintenance for your joint children.

His own mental instability could be an excuse it could easily effect his income.

The judge will likely ignore it as it isn't relevant plus if you go into the court room and act calmly, you will have proved they are talking shit.

I'm seriously annoyed they are writing this crap, but I'll remain calm!

OP posts:
Moonlightbythesea · 21/10/2023 07:29

Reugny · 21/10/2023 07:27

Family court cases are full of this shit. Some of the lawyers I know and have met refuse to go anywhere family law because of it.

It's a Tribunal Court

OP posts:
Moonlightbythesea · 21/10/2023 07:28

MattDamon · 21/10/2023 07:15

The opposing solicitor in a case I was involved with lied so many times (about filing paperwork, receiving/sending letters, the actual content of the case, all easily disproved) that the judge spent a good 5 minutes at our CMD yelling at her for lying. But nothing was done about it. No punishment at all.

I asked our barrister about making a professional complaint (her lies cost extra time and money to disapprove) and he said not to bother, the SRA wouldn't do anything about it. It was so disheartening to hear.

That's disgraceful!
It makes you wonder how some people get away with their lies.

OP posts:
Reugny · 21/10/2023 07:27

lazysundaymorningcoffee · 21/10/2023 07:20

I'm a lawyer and I think that's appalling if there isn't a medical report to support that. There were much better ways the solicitors could have inferred something to that effect without stating that to be a fact.

Personally I'd complain to the SRA and they will look into that.

Family court cases are full of this shit. Some of the lawyers I know and have met refuse to go anywhere family law because of it.

TigersTea · 21/10/2023 07:22

Theunamedcat · 21/10/2023 07:20

So your mentally unstable but he has left your children in your care and custody for years? (I'm assuming years if it's got to court for child maintenance)

Your mentally unstable and that prevents him from paying for his child how?

Your mentally unstable and his response is to apply financial pressure by not paying?

Your mentally unstable and his choice isn't to raise his children himself so they are safe and secure its to financially abuse you by withholding monies meant to help raise the children?

Perfect response

SquishyGloopyBum · 21/10/2023 07:20

When you are there be very calm and professional. The same with all your written stuff- be factual and to the point. It will look better.

If it comes up, calmly say that you aren't mentally unstable as alleged, there is no evidence of this and in any case, it's irrelevant to these proceedings.

lazysundaymorningcoffee · 21/10/2023 07:20

I'm a lawyer and I think that's appalling if there isn't a medical report to support that. There were much better ways the solicitors could have inferred something to that effect without stating that to be a fact.

Personally I'd complain to the SRA and they will look into that.

Theunamedcat · 21/10/2023 07:20

So your mentally unstable but he has left your children in your care and custody for years? (I'm assuming years if it's got to court for child maintenance)

Your mentally unstable and that prevents him from paying for his child how?

Your mentally unstable and his response is to apply financial pressure by not paying?

Your mentally unstable and his choice isn't to raise his children himself so they are safe and secure its to financially abuse you by withholding monies meant to help raise the children?

Reugny · 21/10/2023 07:19

I'm another one who doesn't understand how your mental instability can be linked to him not paying maintenance for your joint children.

His own mental instability could be an excuse it could easily effect his income.

The judge will likely ignore it as it isn't relevant plus if you go into the court room and act calmly, you will have proved they are talking shit.

Moonlightbythesea · 21/10/2023 07:17

Stringervest · 21/10/2023 07:03

Also a solicitor, but not a family lawyer.

Solicitors are NOT supposed to just write what their client tells them. They shouldn't make statements of fact that they do not know to be true / are not supported by evidence. Stating that someone is unstable without evidence is not professional in my view and would not be regarded well by a judge. I might write "my client believes that [ex] is unstable" but that is a very different thing.

However as pp have said, although the solicitor may be unprofessional, don't let it worry you as a judge won't pay any attention to a statement like that. It could even play in your favour. I once heard a speech from a High Court judge who said they checked the correspondence file at the outset of the trial to decide which party's lawyers they could trust.

She has mostly written it as "Mr XXXXX believes that moonlightbythesea is unstable" , but then has also written "I believe moonlightbythesea is unstable" , words to these affects, but she slipped up by writing as though it's her opinion too.

OP posts:
MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 21/10/2023 07:15

Oaktree1233 · 21/10/2023 07:10

He’s spending his money on lawyers and you are spending money on feeding and clothing the children might be the point to make.

This, unless you are saying 'give me 60% of your income to fund me for spousal income', why on earth would he rather pay a lawyer than give money to his children!

MattDamon · 21/10/2023 07:15

The opposing solicitor in a case I was involved with lied so many times (about filing paperwork, receiving/sending letters, the actual content of the case, all easily disproved) that the judge spent a good 5 minutes at our CMD yelling at her for lying. But nothing was done about it. No punishment at all.

I asked our barrister about making a professional complaint (her lies cost extra time and money to disapprove) and he said not to bother, the SRA wouldn't do anything about it. It was so disheartening to hear.

Moonlightbythesea · 21/10/2023 07:12

Oaktree1233 · 21/10/2023 07:00

A solicitor is paid to present their clients version of events but it makes not a jot of difference unless they can evidence it for the judge. They have to produce proof. In day to day litigation it’s often the case that one sides versions conflict with another’s ( that is why there is a dispute) but that fine as long as the lawyer believes in their clients version. So I could assert that my client could not walk without pain but if the other side had clear contradictory video evidence I would have to tell client to change their evidence or I would not act. I was never a family lawyer but I’m unclear why your mental stability is relevant to unpaid monies. It would be relevant to custody but presumably that’s already determined.

Edited

My kids are older now, so custody isn't an issue. I agree that there's no relevance at all to my supposed mental health and the fact the other party has not paid what he should have.

OP posts:
Oaktree1233 · 21/10/2023 07:10

He’s spending his money on lawyers and you are spending money on feeding and clothing the children might be the point to make.

Moonlightbythesea · 21/10/2023 07:10

Graciebobcat · 21/10/2023 06:54

Depends how it is written.

It's extremely derogatory about me. I'm not upset by it, just angry that a Solicitor could write such drivel, even when instructed to do so.

OP posts:
Moonlightbythesea · 21/10/2023 07:09

MyDogCalledMax · 21/10/2023 06:50

@Moonlightbythesea there are a lot of reasons for using solicitors. I don’t know if I would agree that the judge would listen more just because a solicitor is involved. Usually, people representing themselves get A LOT more leeway because they’re not expected to know as much about the process. I have seen judges be pretty helpful in that regard, although that is largely down to the personality of the judge!!

I hope I get the right Judge!

OP posts:
Stringervest · 21/10/2023 07:03

Also a solicitor, but not a family lawyer.

Solicitors are NOT supposed to just write what their client tells them. They shouldn't make statements of fact that they do not know to be true / are not supported by evidence. Stating that someone is unstable without evidence is not professional in my view and would not be regarded well by a judge. I might write "my client believes that [ex] is unstable" but that is a very different thing.

However as pp have said, although the solicitor may be unprofessional, don't let it worry you as a judge won't pay any attention to a statement like that. It could even play in your favour. I once heard a speech from a High Court judge who said they checked the correspondence file at the outset of the trial to decide which party's lawyers they could trust.

Swipe left for the next trending thread