Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In-laws should be more sensitive about 11+

105 replies

OnlyFrog · 21/10/2023 05:55

I’ll start by acknowledging this is definitely a first world problem.

So, back in their day my husband and his parents all passed the 11+ and went to grammar schools. All very bright and successful in their academic careers.

I did not pass the 11+, which was a painful blow for years, but I went to the local comprehensive, got As and A GCSEs, 4As and A level (no A *available back then), got a first in a science degree at Oxford, PhD, then did graduate medicine and now working as a doctor.

We currently live in a non-grammar school area but DH said we could consider moving over the county boundary to an area with grammar schools.

We were chatting about this with his parents who are pro moving and say there are lots of benefits to grammar schools. I said I didn’t want the kids to go through the 11+ as i think it does a lot of emotional harm if you don’t pass. MIL said the kids are bright so no reason why they shouldn’t pass!

I was annoyed by this as it seems to imply that not passing means you’re not bright.

DH thinks I’m being too sensitive to take it that way. I just felt insulated and annoyed that they can’t see the harm in selecting on a single test. I also don’t like the way they put down comprehensives as being for less bright kids. I am so grateful to my teachers for all their support.

AIBU to be pissed off and think they should be more sensitive?

OP posts:
HannahDefoesTrenchcoat · 21/10/2023 07:29

My 75 year old aunty was the only one of 5 siblings not to pass 11+. She still feels it now.

My dyslexic DH remembers results day like it was yesterday. His best friends at primary went to grammar and he went to comp. He hardky saw them again. He ran a very successful business and has retired first. He still feels a failure too.

shockeditellyou · 21/10/2023 07:26

As someone who sailed through the 11+ and thrived in a grammar school, I am very glad indeed we live in a comp area! Secondary transition is bad enough round here without the added pressure of performance based entry. I’d far rather move to the catchment of a large, well performing comprehensive.

CurlewKate · 21/10/2023 07:24

Is it possible she didn't know/had forgotten that you didn't pass? Or it didn't cross her mind that,
considering your success, you might still mind.

However, it's obvious, not least from posters on here, that people don't understand that failing the 11+ can have a profound and long lasting impact. Which is one of the main reasons the vile, inequitable system needs to go.

RoyalImpatience · 21/10/2023 07:19

But we also have to remember our dc are not us and may feel differently to op

Danascully2 · 21/10/2023 07:19

I think people who passed some time ago (or their children did) don't always have an accurate view of the 11+. We are in an 11+ area and I think grammar school would suit my child but I absolutely hate having to battle with him to do the work for it at home. Maybe if you can afford private primary it's a bit different as then at least they cover the topics they need in school before the exam. I am not a fan personally of the system even though I do think my child has a fair chance of passing.

RoyalImpatience · 21/10/2023 07:18

She's also now apparently performing very high in the cohort and so far looks on course for 6 x 9 rest 8.

Op I would also push back that you don't feel 11 plus is good test of intelligence or want to go on about it.

My in laws are obsessed with numbers and showing off. We don't talk about it to them

whittingtonmum · 21/10/2023 07:16

I think you are right being pissed off. You know the struggle of not passing the exam so why inflict it on your children. Your PILs don't get a say in this so I would not discuss the matter with them further. In fact I would tell them in no uncertain terms to not discuss the issue in front of your children ever. They might have an opinion but it's none of their business so off they trott. Then I would sit DH down and have a very serious conversation on why you are putting your foot down on moving and grammar schools. I would ask him to validate your struggles, experience and achievements rather than labelling kids - such as yourself - who don't pass the exam as 'not bright' - given all the evidence to the contrary.

RoyalImpatience · 21/10/2023 07:16

You don't need tutoring my dc passed albeit without the proper maths, looking back I should have got her a maths tutor to teach her what she didn't know but she just passed.

If your child is working at greater depth they don't need it. It's a huge con...

PuttingDownRoots · 21/10/2023 07:14

Its not the same as 20 years ago. I scrapped an 11+ pass with no tutoring... nowadays even bright children need it so their exam technique is on par with the other bright children. Children start tutoring in yr3 or yr4... its a lot of pressure on them.

We moved into an area with a good all round school and love it. DD is top set for Maths and Sciences, then gets extra help in English (dyslexia). Its perfect for her.

RoyalImpatience · 21/10/2023 07:12

Did you push back?

" mil I'm not sure that 11 plus is a good measure of intelligence? I didn't pass but Oxford accepted me with my 4 as"..

Maray1967 · 21/10/2023 07:12

OnlyFrog · 21/10/2023 06:36

Thank you for the range of views.
it’s true this has touched a nerve. To answer one of the questions, my in-laws know full well that I did not pass and that it knocked my confidence for years.

Edited

But they can forget - probably just didn’t think. In my case the comment was about how first time mums would naturally want to spend more time with their own mums than their in laws, knowing full well that my mum had died years before.

Everydayimhuffling · 21/10/2023 07:12

If you go to a comprehensive, you are much better off at one in a non-grammar area where it's truly comprehensive. Also the levels of tutoring have exploded so it's a completely different situation to when his parents got in at least. Everyone loves grammars when they assume their DC will get in.

I would focus on making a reasoned argument rather than the emotion of whether they should have said it to you.

Haveyouseenthemuffinman · 21/10/2023 07:10

Yanbu to have an issue with your inlaws’ obsession with grammar schools.

yabu to let an exam you took at 10 to define how successful you feel - if anything, you prove how crazy a system is to discount children at a certain age. It’s not quite the same, because it was based on choice, but after my 11-16 comp, most of my friends went to a grammar school sixth form. I went to a fully comp, large sixth form college in a tough area, and was looked down for my choice. Guess which one of us got 5As…

yogasaurus · 21/10/2023 07:07

OnlyFrog · 21/10/2023 06:36

Thank you for the range of views.
it’s true this has touched a nerve. To answer one of the questions, my in-laws know full well that I did not pass and that it knocked my confidence for years.

Edited

Your reaction to it seems to have been very extreme if it knocked your confidence for years, and you’re still getting upset by it.

MsJuniper · 21/10/2023 07:05

Do you think they felt defensive as it may have seemed you were implying they didn't care about the risk to their children's emotional wellbeing? I know that wasn't your intention but their reply could also be implying they didn't believe there was a risk therefore justifying their decision at that time.

Kittenkitty · 21/10/2023 07:03

I changed my vote after reading this. I think they’re unreasonable to speak like this if they know you failed. I moved for better schools but not to a grammar area. In my experience Doctors usually live in areas with good catchment schools anyway. And have the attitude to education and the access to extra curricular activities etc that help their children to thrive regardless.

WandaWonder · 21/10/2023 06:48

OnlyFrog · 21/10/2023 06:36

Thank you for the range of views.
it’s true this has touched a nerve. To answer one of the questions, my in-laws know full well that I did not pass and that it knocked my confidence for years.

Edited

Then it would benefit you to work on this does it really matter in the whole of your life? Seriously?

Mumof2teens79 · 21/10/2023 06:44

I think they are idiots
Moving into a grammar school area is very risky.
I know a few who have done it, plus paid a fortune for 2-3yrs of 11+ tutoring and not got in.
Then they go to a comprehensive....but it's not truly a comprehensive because so many of the higher achieving kids go to grammars.

In grammar school areas competition for places means it's harder than ever to get in. Just passing or being bright isn't enough. It's hours of tutoring and then comes down to practice and maturity.

You are proof that you don't need a grammar school education to be academic or successful.

SaracensMavericks · 21/10/2023 06:44

I think it's a bit of both - it was tactless of them to say this (assuming they know that you failed?) but you are also a bit over sensitive on the subject because of your own experience.

My kids are bright and are doing well at a comprehensive school so I agree with you. We're not in a grammar school area though.

OnlyFrog · 21/10/2023 06:36

Thank you for the range of views.
it’s true this has touched a nerve. To answer one of the questions, my in-laws know full well that I did not pass and that it knocked my confidence for years.

OP posts:
Fluffycloudsfloatinginthesky · 21/10/2023 06:25

@Zanatdy not sure what school your daughter went to see but we are that area and my daughters friend has moved from grammar to non grammar for 6th form. My daughter also viewed grammar but decided to stay at existing school. She heard mixed reviews on girls grammar 6th form from a couple of pupils (not friends just girls it came up in conversation with)

JupiterJan · 21/10/2023 06:25

MrsPatrickDempsey · 21/10/2023 06:20

I don't agree with @JupiterJan.
My daughter was at a super selective and did not have a good experience. Whilst emphasising the academic achievements sadly emotional health can often be. neglected by grammars.
My non grammar attending son was very supported in his learning by us and had a better schooling experience. Horses for courses.

hence I said often, not always

MrsPatrickDempsey · 21/10/2023 06:20

I don't agree with @JupiterJan.
My daughter was at a super selective and did not have a good experience. Whilst emphasising the academic achievements sadly emotional health can often be. neglected by grammars.
My non grammar attending son was very supported in his learning by us and had a better schooling experience. Horses for courses.

MikeRafone · 21/10/2023 06:20

I think you have your argument not to move - bright children will do well regardless & im proof of that.

SapphireOpal · 21/10/2023 06:20

Do they know you didn't pass?

Swipe left for the next trending thread