Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In-laws should be more sensitive about 11+

105 replies

OnlyFrog · 21/10/2023 05:55

I’ll start by acknowledging this is definitely a first world problem.

So, back in their day my husband and his parents all passed the 11+ and went to grammar schools. All very bright and successful in their academic careers.

I did not pass the 11+, which was a painful blow for years, but I went to the local comprehensive, got As and A GCSEs, 4As and A level (no A *available back then), got a first in a science degree at Oxford, PhD, then did graduate medicine and now working as a doctor.

We currently live in a non-grammar school area but DH said we could consider moving over the county boundary to an area with grammar schools.

We were chatting about this with his parents who are pro moving and say there are lots of benefits to grammar schools. I said I didn’t want the kids to go through the 11+ as i think it does a lot of emotional harm if you don’t pass. MIL said the kids are bright so no reason why they shouldn’t pass!

I was annoyed by this as it seems to imply that not passing means you’re not bright.

DH thinks I’m being too sensitive to take it that way. I just felt insulated and annoyed that they can’t see the harm in selecting on a single test. I also don’t like the way they put down comprehensives as being for less bright kids. I am so grateful to my teachers for all their support.

AIBU to be pissed off and think they should be more sensitive?

OP posts:
FloraClover · 21/10/2023 08:12

Hollyhead · 21/10/2023 08:02

I voted yanbu, but wanted to say that if you live in an area with good comprehensives do not put yourself through the hassle of moving to a grammar area! We’re in an area with good comps and having read threads in here I’m so grateful we never had to go through any of the grammar hassle and expense!

I would agree. And I say that as someone with 2 kids in super selective grammars.

We are very happy with the school and they are excelling. However, as PP said unthread, it’s not the destination, it’s the journey. Now luckily, our journey was ok, and destination great, but it could’ve been so different. My second child put so much pressure on themselves as their sibling was already at the super selective, and as much as we said it didn’t matter, DC2 felt enormous pressure to get in too. I felt enormous stress in case I had to give the news that “they weren’t good enough” even though I didn’t believe that.

If I’d known about the system earlier, I’d have never moved here. It has worked out well for us, but it was a stressful journey and not one I’d wish on anyone.

yikesanotherbooboo · 21/10/2023 08:10

Where I live the grammar school entrance means tutoring through year 5 with extra work sheets etc. Many DC are doing this in year 3 and 4 also.Failing to get a place means a blow for the child and an awful feeling of futility for everyone. The 'comprehensives' are not comprehensive in intake and , of course, the presence of grammars pushing up house prices means that there are many financially comfortable parents who then send their children to independent senior schools reducing the diversity of the ' comprehensive' schools even further.It is an awful system . Stick to your guns .In the end we all have to make the choices based on what is available to us at the time and what is best for our DC but moving , as you know, carries risks.

usernother · 21/10/2023 08:02

I think you're being over sensitive. Why do you care what they think?

Hollyhead · 21/10/2023 08:02

I voted yanbu, but wanted to say that if you live in an area with good comprehensives do not put yourself through the hassle of moving to a grammar area! We’re in an area with good comps and having read threads in here I’m so grateful we never had to go through any of the grammar hassle and expense!

ScaryHellscape · 21/10/2023 07:57

The adult judgment is very likely to come from DHs parents as well. We had this with my DC and the grandparents - the “bright” one that “smashed” it and went to a superselective and the other one that failed but got into grammar “are they coping ok there?” questions for years.

The other one has better results but shattered confidence. They picked up on all of it over the years, no matter the job we did as parents reassuring them.

SunshineAutumnday · 21/10/2023 07:55

I think it depends on the child and how they cope with exams. How they would repsond emotionally to failure if that happens.

This decision is yours and your children. Your ILs is just an opinion.

Edwardandtubbs · 21/10/2023 07:52

AmandasFleckerl · 21/10/2023 07:48

It’s parents that create the judgment though. Like any exam we need to encourage our children to do their best but also let them know that there are other options if they don’t get the result they need. Too many parents put far too much pressure on their children.

There aren't other options though. Not good ones. You end up in a terrible school with horrible behaviour problems and the worst teachers in the country. Any 'normal' child just flounders. I was a governor at a school where they were absolutely delighted that ONE child in the entire sixth form cohort got ONE A at A level (and it was in drama). That was an outstanding year for them. There's a reason the 'worst school in the country' is in a grammar county.

The whole thing should be abolished. Sorry to hi-jack the thread OP! I'll retreat now.

MintJulia · 21/10/2023 07:51

@shockeditellyou we must have been lucky. Ds did four taster days. I did four parents evenings. We both chose the same school.

Shoxfordian · 21/10/2023 07:51

I failed my 11+, have a great career, a lovely life and I’m not dwelling on something that happened over 20 years ago- maybe try that

ScaryHellscape · 21/10/2023 07:50

AmandasFleckerl · 21/10/2023 07:48

It’s parents that create the judgment though. Like any exam we need to encourage our children to do their best but also let them know that there are other options if they don’t get the result they need. Too many parents put far too much pressure on their children.

It’s irrelevant where the judgment comes from - and in many ways it’s worse coming from adults that should know better.

A 10 year old knows what different looks mean - tilty head, pretend sad eyes etc.

Why risk subjecting a DC to that?

SparklyStone · 21/10/2023 07:49

I failed my 11+ too. I’ve got a degree and a Masters now, like you I’ve never felt smart enough. I totally understand the damage it can do x

Electrictache · 21/10/2023 07:49

There's two issues here. I think expecting people to remember and understand how you felt not passing an exam when you were 10/11 is a bit unreasonable. Especially as although it dented your confidence it clearly didn't impact your education.

I don't think you're wrong to prioritising your children's well-being over the pressure of the test though. Kids don't need to go to grammar to succeed and you're the proof of that.

AmandasFleckerl · 21/10/2023 07:48

ScaryHellscape · 21/10/2023 07:38

There’s a lot of ignorance on this thread from people that just don’t get it.

I wonder if any of them experienced such public failure & judgment at the age of 10?

It’s parents that create the judgment though. Like any exam we need to encourage our children to do their best but also let them know that there are other options if they don’t get the result they need. Too many parents put far too much pressure on their children.

shockeditellyou · 21/10/2023 07:46

I love the idea that schools are just waiting for roll out taster days for kids. Round here they don’t even do school tours - it’s open evening or nothing.

And what do you do if your kid takes a shine to an amazing super selective grammar they have no hope of getting into?

Edwardandtubbs · 21/10/2023 07:45

It sounds like a throwaway comment that was meant to be reassuring but was ill, if at all thought through.

I assume you are talking about moving to Kent? We have just moved out of Kent partly to save DD9 from the 11+. She would have either failed or we'd have withdrawn her, and the route for those who fail it is awful.

I worked with schools there and the non-grammars, with a few exceptions are hideous places. Children don't go on to do well there. So there's no way I would take the chance of the children failing the exam and ending up in a sink school.

I think moving into a grammar system county, for the schools, is absolutely bananas.

MintJulia · 21/10/2023 07:44

@CurlewKate Why not? That's what I did with ds, five years ago. Worked for us. Or is the system in London very different?

CurlewKate · 21/10/2023 07:41

"Rather than take sides, it would be far better to let your child do taster days at each possible school, see which they prefer"
Good idea-but not something that could happen.

Parakeetamol · 21/10/2023 07:41

We are in 11+ area and dd is year4 the competition is insane. Parents boasting about the hours of tutoring and coaching they're doing. We are tempted to move away so my dd gets a childhood!

MintJulia · 21/10/2023 07:38

It's clearly touched a nerve with you, but they aren't talking about you or the system 20 years ago.

The senior school system now is different, There are more problems, more behavioural difficulties and less funding. Your ILs are being pragmatic and suggesting what they believe to be the best route, that's all.

Rather than take sides, it would be far better to let your child do taster days at each possible school, see which they prefer and ask them if they want to try for the 11+.

Encourage but don't push.

ScaryHellscape · 21/10/2023 07:38

There’s a lot of ignorance on this thread from people that just don’t get it.

I wonder if any of them experienced such public failure & judgment at the age of 10?

themothergoose · 21/10/2023 07:37

AmandasFleckerl · 21/10/2023 07:34

Why are you focusing on one exam that you were presumably 11 when you took it? It’s not like you’re someone who has then gone onto academic failure. You were a young child, you’re now an extremely well educated woman. Focus on the things you have achieved rather than one failure. Not passing your 11+ was the making of you.

Exactly this!

themothergoose · 21/10/2023 07:36

For someone who is a doctor who made into a very competitive course and university, then went on to do one of the most competitive courses to get into (graduate medicine) + has a PhD . . . you seem a bit soft OP. In the nicest way possible. So what if you didn't pass 11+, what bearing does that have on your career now?

People fail in medical school and have to retake exams. I am sure you have seen this. You get up and keep going. Are you still affected by not passing 11+ after everything you have achieved?

It sounds to me like you are projecting your fears onto your children. DD did well without tutoring. Start early - to remove the pressure / stress. Do a little everyday or every other day. Choose schools your child will most likely get into. Don't pick competitive and academically rigorous schools if your child isn't smart. I have seen a few children without places because parents have high expectations.

I would suggest moving house if you love the house and if it works school-wise. Don't move only for the school. What if your child doesn't get in?

AmandasFleckerl · 21/10/2023 07:34

OnlyFrog · 21/10/2023 06:36

Thank you for the range of views.
it’s true this has touched a nerve. To answer one of the questions, my in-laws know full well that I did not pass and that it knocked my confidence for years.

Edited

Why are you focusing on one exam that you were presumably 11 when you took it? It’s not like you’re someone who has then gone onto academic failure. You were a young child, you’re now an extremely well educated woman. Focus on the things you have achieved rather than one failure. Not passing your 11+ was the making of you.

ScaryHellscape · 21/10/2023 07:33

“You did well without it what difference does it make?”

It makes a massive difference. It’s not the destination, it’s the journey. One of my DC failed the 11+, got in to grammar on appeal and is predicted 3 As at A level. So destination tick.

Journey not so much. The impact of telling a child they aren’t good enough at age 10 shouldn’t be underestimated.