Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In-laws should be more sensitive about 11+

105 replies

OnlyFrog · 21/10/2023 05:55

I’ll start by acknowledging this is definitely a first world problem.

So, back in their day my husband and his parents all passed the 11+ and went to grammar schools. All very bright and successful in their academic careers.

I did not pass the 11+, which was a painful blow for years, but I went to the local comprehensive, got As and A GCSEs, 4As and A level (no A *available back then), got a first in a science degree at Oxford, PhD, then did graduate medicine and now working as a doctor.

We currently live in a non-grammar school area but DH said we could consider moving over the county boundary to an area with grammar schools.

We were chatting about this with his parents who are pro moving and say there are lots of benefits to grammar schools. I said I didn’t want the kids to go through the 11+ as i think it does a lot of emotional harm if you don’t pass. MIL said the kids are bright so no reason why they shouldn’t pass!

I was annoyed by this as it seems to imply that not passing means you’re not bright.

DH thinks I’m being too sensitive to take it that way. I just felt insulated and annoyed that they can’t see the harm in selecting on a single test. I also don’t like the way they put down comprehensives as being for less bright kids. I am so grateful to my teachers for all their support.

AIBU to be pissed off and think they should be more sensitive?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HowdidImanagetohavetwoaccountaandthenloseboth · 24/10/2023 09:40

I do think that supporters of grammar schools, particularly if their own children attend them, have to turn a blind eye to the huge negatives of the system for the majority of children

This 100%

The trouble is the perception and reality of other schools in areas where there are grammar schools . They are generally poor ,seem to fail often and have poor reputations. All because of the grammar school system. So the parents and DH are basing their perception on their own experience . They assume as many do in grammar school areas, that their offspring will get in and don’t give a fudge about the other schools and have a jaded view on what comprehensive means which in their eyes = poor school.

I went to a grammar school and I hate that system . My siblings didn’t . One got into a fee paying school, the other who looking back had SEN , didn’t and was failed by the school system . Growing up for me , immersed in that system, I know I was completely jaded . It was only when I met my husband who went to a truly comprehensive school I learnt that actual proper comprehensives do exist ! And I know many people who still live in a GS area who think that way still!

Frankly I am shocked at the voting on here ( 60/40) . Mumsnet must be so pro grammar schools yet the system stinks for those many who don’t make it . I was so grateful that my children grew up in an area where there are no grammars and so the comprehensive schools are truly comprehensive .

Stick to your guns OP , you are right!

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 24/10/2023 09:20

It’s worth mentioning that passing the 11-plus may well have been easier a few decades ago, before the Greenwich Ruling, which meant that out-of-borough children were equally entitled to sit the exam and attend the grammars. (Just two here, a boys’ and a girls’).

There was an undertaking that (for a while at least) anyone whose child would have passed before the Greenwich Ruling, but failed to afterwards, would be informed of this.

Here, the ruling came in in between dds sitting the 11 plus. Dd1 was awarded a place straight away, but when it came to dd2, she was put on the waiting list, and we were told that under the old system she would have got a place straight away.
She was in fact offered a place quite quickly, but I couldn’t help wondering about anyone who wasn’t - how would they feel to have salt rubbed into the wound, so to speak.

NalafromtheLionKing · 21/10/2023 17:41

I would say they were just trying to be reassuring. You’re clearly extremely bright so should try just to forget about your experience with the 11+ (either you had a bad day or the examiner did, but it certainly didn’t disadvantage you in the long run).

CurlewKate · 21/10/2023 17:37

I do think that supporters of grammar schools, particularly if their own children attend them, have to turn a blind eye to the huge negatives of the system for the majority of children.

ScaryHellscape · 21/10/2023 17:00

whiteroseredrose · 21/10/2023 16:19

I'd want the most appropriate school for my DC, regardless of my own history. Schools have changed a lot in the past 20 years.

In the OP's shoes I'd want to have a look at what the different schools have to offer and get a feel for them. Most will have open days every year. Which would suit the DC best? Are they strong on the arts, languages or science?

That might help with the decision as to whether the Grammars would be worth moving for.

If there is a great school that would really suit your DC, but they need to take an exam, would you say no because they may or may not pass?

That only really works if there is a great secondary modern in catchment as well, as if the DC don’t pass then that’s where they will be going. And you won’t know that until October of Y6.

whiteroseredrose · 21/10/2023 16:19

I'd want the most appropriate school for my DC, regardless of my own history. Schools have changed a lot in the past 20 years.

In the OP's shoes I'd want to have a look at what the different schools have to offer and get a feel for them. Most will have open days every year. Which would suit the DC best? Are they strong on the arts, languages or science?

That might help with the decision as to whether the Grammars would be worth moving for.

If there is a great school that would really suit your DC, but they need to take an exam, would you say no because they may or may not pass?

JupiterJan · 21/10/2023 15:42

Bluevelvetsofa · 21/10/2023 09:49

@JupiterJan I think it’s unfair to say that the parents of children in a grammar school care about their education, inferring that parents of children at comprehensive schools don’t. Surely most parents care about their children’s education, whether grammar, comprehensive or independent.

I’m sure there are experiences as a child that are carried through to adulthood, good or bad. The OP is clearly academically successful, but didn’t feel so at the time of 11+ and it has stayed with her. Maybe the in-laws spoke without thinking and were insensitive.

A lot of parents really dont care at all, and of course in the average comp many parents will, you will also get many who won't - but in a grammar all parents will

Mumof2teens79 · 21/10/2023 15:08

Paradeofrain · 21/10/2023 11:08

Would you say the same about the Sat's If you hadn't done well in them?

If someone said your kids would do well in the Sat's because they were bright would you feel they were calling you not bright?

I agree that it seems like you've massively over valued a passing discussion about one of many exams primary kids might take

Its not one of many exams primary kids might take though is it?
It's one of two, the other being SATS which don't the determine which school.you go to for the next 5 years I order to take your main school leaving qualifications...your GCSEs

SATs pressure is bad enough, let alone 11+

ScaryHellscape · 21/10/2023 15:00

CurlewKate · 21/10/2023 14:15

"I don't think there's any assumption that a kid in a comp uniform has "failed" anything"

I suppose it depends on the circumstances. Where I live, all the kids who go to state school go to either the grammar or the secondary modern (no comprehensive). And yes, people do notice uniforms. It's a small town, and kids in grammar uniforms get congratulated by people on the check out in Tesco on the first day of term!

Where I am too. There’s a huge amount of judgment and to pretend there isn’t is not helpful.

CurlewKate · 21/10/2023 14:38

@Nevermind31 "simply because they will be with peers whose parents care."

As opposed to the kids in secondary moderns whose parents don't care? Right.

Nevermind31 · 21/10/2023 14:32

I think it is important to try to go to a grammar school in an area why they have them - simply because they will be with peers whose parents care.
however, in a non grammar area all the brightest and those whose parents do care will go to the good comprehensives

ScaryHellscape · 21/10/2023 14:24

Paradeofrain · 21/10/2023 14:13

No but your point was that people would know your score by your uniform and judge you when at least 2/3 of kids are in non grammar schools (due to both not passing and the significant number who abstain) and several of the grammar schools are within another school so have the same uniform.

I’m not aware of any grammar schools within other schools. I am aware there are a few that have a top stream that they call a grammar stream, but it’s not a separate school.

CurlewKate · 21/10/2023 14:15

"I don't think there's any assumption that a kid in a comp uniform has "failed" anything"

I suppose it depends on the circumstances. Where I live, all the kids who go to state school go to either the grammar or the secondary modern (no comprehensive). And yes, people do notice uniforms. It's a small town, and kids in grammar uniforms get congratulated by people on the check out in Tesco on the first day of term!

Paradeofrain · 21/10/2023 14:13

ScaryHellscape · 21/10/2023 14:03

“I don't think there's any assumption that a kid in a comp uniform has "failed" anything”

  1. that’s a bit naive at best
  2. comps don’t exist in fully grammar areas. Comp meaning comprehensive, including all abilities. The “top” 25% go to grammar so aren’t present in the other schools. These are essentially secondary moderns but have euphemistic names instead now like academy etc. Those that don’t sit the 11+ but are very capable are few & far between.

No but your point was that people would know your score by your uniform and judge you when at least 2/3 of kids are in non grammar schools (due to both not passing and the significant number who abstain) and several of the grammar schools are within another school so have the same uniform.

YouJustDoYou · 21/10/2023 14:07

I know a few people who went to grammars - parents spent a ton on tutors etc, then there was the cost of expensive school activities, clothes, outings etc. Not one of them, as adults, are in careers that needed a grammar education. One friends loves to boast about she was in a grammar, and "how smart she is", but it was all just a waste of time. I wouldn't force a kid to do it if they're not academically gifted.

ScaryHellscape · 21/10/2023 14:03

“I don't think there's any assumption that a kid in a comp uniform has "failed" anything”

  1. that’s a bit naive at best
  2. comps don’t exist in fully grammar areas. Comp meaning comprehensive, including all abilities. The “top” 25% go to grammar so aren’t present in the other schools. These are essentially secondary moderns but have euphemistic names instead now like academy etc. Those that don’t sit the 11+ but are very capable are few & far between.
Paradeofrain · 21/10/2023 13:59

ScaryHellscape · 21/10/2023 11:26

This is a typical example of knowing absolutely nothing about the impact of living in a grammar area. Comparing SATs to the 11+ is actually hilarious.

Because the SATs aren’t visible to anyone. Everyone you go to school with knows you failed the 11+, and each day you go to your secondary modern in your uniform all the kids on public transport know too.

Yeah I live in a grammar area, went to a grammar and have a dc who sat out the exam and one who took it.

Many kids don't take it

I don't think there's any assumption that a kid in a comp uniform has "failed" anything

Some of the comps have grammar streams with the same uniform, lots of kids don't take it and there's a big emphasis on it being no a particularly accurate representation of anything

Citrusandginger · 21/10/2023 13:05

It's true that bright children can do well anywhere. It's also true that your children's peers will have a stronger effect on their behaviour and wellbeing once they become teens and that this too can affect outcomes.

It's hard to admit that you want your children to have friends whose parents have similar values to you. But good schools tend to have self-selecting parents and it's OK to acknowledge that's generally a positive thing.

ActDottie · 21/10/2023 11:33

Yanbu grammar school isn’t the be Allen’s end all.

I grew up in a non grammar area and have achieved similar grades to you academically.

My dad went to grammar and he did well. My mum failed the 11+ so went to non grammar and she’s done just as well in terms of getting into a good uni etc.

ScaryHellscape · 21/10/2023 11:26

Paradeofrain · 21/10/2023 11:08

Would you say the same about the Sat's If you hadn't done well in them?

If someone said your kids would do well in the Sat's because they were bright would you feel they were calling you not bright?

I agree that it seems like you've massively over valued a passing discussion about one of many exams primary kids might take

This is a typical example of knowing absolutely nothing about the impact of living in a grammar area. Comparing SATs to the 11+ is actually hilarious.

Because the SATs aren’t visible to anyone. Everyone you go to school with knows you failed the 11+, and each day you go to your secondary modern in your uniform all the kids on public transport know too.

ScaryHellscape · 21/10/2023 11:22

Tbh many replies on this thread show why the PILs are unaware of how crass they are being - it’s seems that unless you have been through it, the ramifications of it are hard to understand.

Paradeofrain · 21/10/2023 11:08

Would you say the same about the Sat's If you hadn't done well in them?

If someone said your kids would do well in the Sat's because they were bright would you feel they were calling you not bright?

I agree that it seems like you've massively over valued a passing discussion about one of many exams primary kids might take

HannahDefoesTrenchcoat · 21/10/2023 10:55

Even if the kids get their attitudes from their parents, the attitudes still exist.

Kids aren't daft and soon work out what Sparrow Table or Green readers mean.

mugboat · 21/10/2023 10:31

rather disingenuous post by those saying "why do you care". most people care what others think about them... and most people consider the opinions of others...

Aldicrispsareshit · 21/10/2023 10:31

I think you're being a bit oversensitive. That said I can see the merit in the Essex grammars for very bright children and would consider moving there if my kids had the ability but I wouldn't purposely move to Kent or similar for their system.

Swipe left for the next trending thread