Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Trackers on phones - weird or not?

206 replies

Judijudi · 21/10/2023 01:26

Someone I know their entire family uses a location tracker on their phones for everyone in the immediate family, husband, son, son’s girlfriend, sister, nieces, nephews, parents. They all have it. I don’t know how often the others use it but frequently this person will say, oh I see sister has come home early from her holiday, or son’s girlfriend- oh she must’ve got out of bed to go to the hairdressers, you get the jist.
I find this really really weird and a total invasion of privacy. It actually gives me the creeps! I can see how it would be handy if someone unexpectedly goes out of touch and their is an actual reason to want to know where they are like they’ve gone hillwalking and not returned when expected or if it is someone vulnerable etc.
What do you all think?
YABU this is perfectly normal behaviour to track the movements of your entire family
or
YANBU it is TOTALLY weird and an invasion of privacy verging on stalking behaviour

OP posts:
NoTouch · 21/10/2023 15:22

@CurlewKate again your words are imply things and maybe that reflects things in your own life/thoughts, but they are things that are not there for most people - "surveillance" is close observation to try to catch someone out doing something wrong.

That is not what is happening with most people it is just an easier way to do some things. If ds asks me to pick him up and I check where he is so I know where to go, just because it is easier, that isn't "surveillance". If dh or ds is driving to pick me up somewhere (or vice versa) and I have a look to see if he is nearly there yet that isn't "trying to catch someone out".

Most people feel there is nothing wrong with checking someone's location in those scenarios, and similar, or someone checking theirs, which is what most people would use it for and why the majority of people freely choose to have the option switched on.

Obviously a minority of people will use it as a means of control, or feel they may be being controlled - which is a much wider issue in that relationship than an otherwise harmless location finder, but those issues don't mean it is wrong for anyone else to use.

CurlewKate · 21/10/2023 14:51

@NoTouch ""tracking children" implies a parent watching their every move as a form of supervision, if they are that is not healthy for either the child or the parent, but in most cases I don't believe that is how it is used and it is wrong to assume it is."

I'm not assuming that. I don't think it's healthy however frequently or infrequently the surveillance happens.

converseandjeans · 21/10/2023 14:38

YANBU you can't go anywhere nowadays without being recorded by CCTV or someone's ring doorbell. I don't like it. I saw somewhere on FB a chat about this & there's an app where you can listen in to what is being said in background. So parents are listening into what teens are saying without their consent. I think it's a real invasion of privacy of friends of teen that grown ups are listening in covertly. It's just weird.

NoTouch · 21/10/2023 13:47

It is a tool that can be used harmlessly, but some people are closed to the very idea that it could be used for anything other than nefarious reasons. Someone in a relationship where is would be used negatively will have much bigger problems to focus on.

Some people prefer a quick location check to being annoyed by a text, or having to explain where they are so they can get a lift, or if someone is on their way to pick you up/visit and driving being able to check how far away they are - or many other reasons. Of course there are other ways to share this information, but if the tools are there to make life a little smoother and everyone is happy why not.

"tracking children" implies a parent watching their every move as a form of supervision, if they are that is not healthy for either the child or the parent, but in most cases I don't believe that is how it is used and it is wrong to assume it is.

CurlewKate · 21/10/2023 07:44

@WhiteArsenic "It’s very judgmental to be saying people shouldn’t do harmless things just because one doesn’t want to do them oneself."

I don't think parents tracking children is harmless.

barneythedino · 21/10/2023 07:40

I track my husband and he does me just for ease. Neither of us are glued to it, he often gets home from work and I'm not in so he will check where I am on the app and if I'm not driving he will text.

I track my mum (she can track me but has no idea how) mainly because she's forever losing her phone but also she has a lot of medical problems so if we ever can't get hold of her I can look for her and make sure she's ok

WhiteArsenic · 21/10/2023 07:39

We use apple’s location sharing within our family, including two adult DDs. It’s massively useful for seeing when people are going to arrive, for planning getting food ready for the right time. I know people can tell you when they’re on their way, but if they forget or the traffic/train has problems, that doesn’t work. I check it sometimes if someone is on a long journey, to see if they’ve arrived safely. And with one DD currently abroad, it’s nice to be able to see her phone on a map sometimes, makes me feel a connection without having to bother her or if there’s no way of contacting her at that moment because of the time difference.

The key thing here is consent, surely. If everyone knows and has agreed and there is no element of control or coercion , then there’s no problem. Generally speaking, if a group of people agree to do something that isn’t dangerous or illegal and has no downside for themselves or other people, then really I can’t see it’s anyone else’s business. Whether I’d fancy it myself is irrelevant. Other families do all sorts of such things that ours would find dull or odd, and why shouldn’t they?! It’s very judgmental to be saying people shouldn’t do harmless things just because one doesn’t want to do them oneself. I know it can be used for abusive control, but all sorts of other things, such as knives or alcohol, can be used harmlessly or in a problematic way. Doesn’t make them inherently bad for everyone all the time.

Sumlove · 21/10/2023 07:37

I use life 360 for my 14yo. She plays sport and is often at various locations and we share lifts, I like knowing she's arrived or on her way back so I can start dinner.
She's terrible with her phone and it does make it easy if I'm picking her up from somewhere I'm not familiar, as you just click the dot and it navigates you to them.
I'm not constantly glued to it tracking her. It pings when she leaves school so I can set off to get her. More of a convenience thing. But can be good to know if she's been in a car, how fast they drive! It also pings if she has a low battery. I think it is a good app, she can also see if I'm on my way etc. Not sure I'd want other people tracking me though, that would be weird.

McIntire · 21/10/2023 07:27

Is strange actually as his thread has made me think about it. DH and I sharing location actually gives me more space and freedom as I don’t feel the need to tell him what I’m up to or where I am. If he really wants to know he can look!

tiredandolderthanithought · 21/10/2023 07:24

@CurlewKate tracking very useful when my daughter needs collecting from netball but the game gets moved and she forgot to tell me. I knew where to pick her up!

We all have it (family of 4) and we find it useful but we aren't glued to it!

Perfect28 · 21/10/2023 07:23

My husband's family are like this. So odd.

MikeRafone · 21/10/2023 07:23

There have been a couple of cases where it would have been very useful and preserved life

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-64859195

the car was hidden from sight as it’d come of the road into deep shrubbery

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/young-dad-lay-dead-car-8772895. Another case, the wife knew he was missing but didn’t know where he was

Shane Loughlin, Eve Smith, Sophie Russon, Refal Jeanne, Darcy Ross

Cardiff car crash: Three of missing five found dead

The car was found in the early hours two days after the group went missing after a night out.

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-64859195

ginsparkles · 21/10/2023 07:22

ChipsAreLife · 21/10/2023 07:00

I can see why people use them but it creates a false sense of security. People aren't always with their phones. And if, worse case, they'd be taken the criminal would most likely dispose of the phone pretty rapidly.

I also wonder if it hinders basic communication and manners. People just stop messaging or calling to say they're running late etc.

We haven't found it hinders those communications. DD still texts to tell me she's got on the school bus, and when she's just arriving at school.
If any of us are running late we text if we can, but obviously if we are driving we can't so it's handy to be able to see.
The keeping in touch is still basic good manners, and we teach it to DD as she needs to know to do it to other people who aren't in our family circle.

McIntire · 21/10/2023 07:21

I’ve never heard of Life360.
That sounds like what the OPs family have.

I don’t want to track my kids but tbh, would probably be happier knowing where DS is. He’s in long term travel and keeps us updated but does travel alone, hitches lifts etc

McIntire · 21/10/2023 07:18

Although tbh @CurlewKate

We use it mostly for security with long distance sport or if I’m off on one of my nomadic wanderings 😂

sleepingpsycho · 21/10/2023 07:18

Yep totally weird, my DH Family have this. I accepted the invitation initially without knowing what it was, it soon got deleted when I found out!

ElleCapitaine · 21/10/2023 07:17

We all share our location in FindMy - have done for years. It has always been voluntary and when we recently switched to another plan I offered my kids (17 and 15) the opportunity to stop sharing, but they both sent me a Share Location invitation. I don’t use it that much but I’ll use it for things like checking where my DD’s train home is, so I can pick her up from the station. They seem to check on me more! We’re a pretty chatty family anyway and don’t tend to keep secrets so I can’t imagine they would feel the need to hide their location, but I would fully respect their right to privacy if they chose to do so.

Tamuchly · 21/10/2023 07:14

We have Life360, my teens turn it off if they don’t want me to know where they are but I don’t sit watching it! It’s handy in that we can tell if phones have been lost or left at home, roughly where the kids are if we are going out and they aren’t home yet (they are twins and sometimes mess about not letting each other in the house 🙄). If they are out with friends I don’t call or text as I feel that’s an interruption but, as a pp said, knowing they are on their way home if it’s dark or pouring with rain is comforting without me smothering them. My husband didn’t want to be on it originally but, after watching how much fun the teens were having by tracking me to Sainsbury’s and ringing to ask for things 🙄, he soon joined in! He mainly uses it to gauge when to leave the sports club bar if I’m picking him up so I don’t have to hang around or text him to hurry up 😂. I’m sure it has more serious uses but thankfully we haven’t needed them yet.

McIntire · 21/10/2023 07:11

CurlewKate · 21/10/2023 07:04

@McIntire "Not everyone has set working hours.
Mne vary, as do DHs, or he may be travelling a long distance"

So, once again, why not a quick text "Hi-I'll be home at 8.30"
But hey, if adults choose to do this, and are really clear that it's not controlling, then fill your boots. DP and I track each other for fun. But kids? Nope. Well, I suppose there MIGHT be medical reasons. But otherwise, nope.

Because traffic varies and he may not necessarily be early or late etc or be aware I even need to know.

If I do need to know, I can just check and see so I know when to chuck the dinner in or whatever. Sometimes I’m out myself, so it gives me an idea when to head home.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 21/10/2023 07:09

ChipsAreLife · 21/10/2023 07:00

I can see why people use them but it creates a false sense of security. People aren't always with their phones. And if, worse case, they'd be taken the criminal would most likely dispose of the phone pretty rapidly.

I also wonder if it hinders basic communication and manners. People just stop messaging or calling to say they're running late etc.

Also I know devious teens get " burner phones". Absolutely not something I want to encourage.

CurlewKate · 21/10/2023 07:04

@McIntire "Not everyone has set working hours.
Mne vary, as do DHs, or he may be travelling a long distance"

So, once again, why not a quick text "Hi-I'll be home at 8.30"
But hey, if adults choose to do this, and are really clear that it's not controlling, then fill your boots. DP and I track each other for fun. But kids? Nope. Well, I suppose there MIGHT be medical reasons. But otherwise, nope.

ChipsAreLife · 21/10/2023 07:00

I can see why people use them but it creates a false sense of security. People aren't always with their phones. And if, worse case, they'd be taken the criminal would most likely dispose of the phone pretty rapidly.

I also wonder if it hinders basic communication and manners. People just stop messaging or calling to say they're running late etc.

McIntire · 21/10/2023 06:57

CurlewKate · 21/10/2023 06:42

@Collaborate "it’s also very handy to see when someone is due home from work."

Why would you need to know that? Surely if anyone's going to be late they send a quick text...

Not everyone has set working hours.
Mne vary, as do DHs, or he may be travelling a long distance

Beezknees · 21/10/2023 06:53

I did use one for DS when he was younger but now I don't (he's 15). If he ever wanted to use one then I would but I'd NEVER do it with a partner. I was in a controlling relationship for years where I had to justify my whereabouts all the time and now I will never ever consent to a partner knowing where I am at all times. It makes me uncomfortable.

Collaborate · 21/10/2023 06:53

@CurlewKate wife works long hours so we need to eat as soon as she gets home (by which time she’s tired and hungry). Try as I might she still doesn’t text me when she’s setting off as she always forgets. Again, she doesn’t have to share her whereabouts with me and it works the other way round if I’m late home from work.