Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Trackers on phones - weird or not?

206 replies

Judijudi · 21/10/2023 01:26

Someone I know their entire family uses a location tracker on their phones for everyone in the immediate family, husband, son, son’s girlfriend, sister, nieces, nephews, parents. They all have it. I don’t know how often the others use it but frequently this person will say, oh I see sister has come home early from her holiday, or son’s girlfriend- oh she must’ve got out of bed to go to the hairdressers, you get the jist.
I find this really really weird and a total invasion of privacy. It actually gives me the creeps! I can see how it would be handy if someone unexpectedly goes out of touch and their is an actual reason to want to know where they are like they’ve gone hillwalking and not returned when expected or if it is someone vulnerable etc.
What do you all think?
YABU this is perfectly normal behaviour to track the movements of your entire family
or
YANBU it is TOTALLY weird and an invasion of privacy verging on stalking behaviour

OP posts:
Snugglemonkey · 21/10/2023 17:38

I hate the idea. I find it weird that so many people do not seem to see privacy as precious.

WilmaWonka · 21/10/2023 17:38

Hbh17 · 21/10/2023 17:03

Weird and intrusive (w exception of special needs etc). Honestly, if a family member suggested it to me, it would be the end of the relationship. Nobody needs to know where I am, nor me them.

Bit of an overreaction! So if your DH or DC suggested you all know each other’s whereabouts if the situation arose that someone couldn’t be contacted in a emergency, you’d divorce/cut them off 🤔!

We all do via Find My Iphone. We don’t control our DC, they go where they want and we rarely check but if there was an instance where they didn’t come home, they were driving and came off the road or ended up in a bush for any reason, it gives peace of mind that we’d be able to see their last position if they went missing, which could be followed up by CCTV.

If you see all the missing people on TikTok for many years, some of those may have been found if this tech was available.

Similarly a fairly recent horrific car crash where 5 young people ended up in the middle of a large roundabout, car obscured by trees, people were searching for them but they were there for 2 days with cars driving past them. 3 of them died and one of the rear passengers was wedged seriously injured between her dead friends for 2 days. May have been found quicker if one of their phones had a tracker. Food for thought and I doubt any of them thought their night out would end like that.

JaceLancs · 21/10/2023 17:36

I share location with adult DC and they choose to share with me
TBH I can’t remember when I last used it - I use it more for find my device

CurlewKate · 21/10/2023 17:34

@NoTouch I knew surveillance was the wrong word-but I couldn't think of a better one.

If one of my kids wanted to be picked up, they sent me the address. If I wanted to know they were home safely, I asked them to send me a text. It's all about expecting them to take responsibility for their impact on other people, and teaching them to keep their wits about them and to look after themselves. There were occasions where we did turn the tracker on-dd used to like going on long rides by herself, and it would have been useful to be able to find her if she fell off and hurt herself. But it was turned off as soon as she got home. It's important, particularly for girls, although for boys too, not normalising being under surveillance (and that is the appropriate use of the word.)

Stomacharmeleon · 21/10/2023 17:27

It wouldn't even occur to me tbh. I can understand the theory behind small kids/ medical issues etc though.
I do think the university Student tracking is weird. I know my boys are out late and up to all sorts but isn't that the point? They don't want their mother tracking their every move.

whiteroseredrose · 21/10/2023 17:16

As a family we use FindMy now that we all have iPhones. DC are 23 and 20 and are the ones that set it up.

When they were younger they had something on my phone so that they could tell where I was and if it was worth asking for a lift 😂.

We've never been intrusive parents or dictated what they can and can't do or where they can go, so nobody has a problem with it.

supersonicginandtonic · 21/10/2023 17:15

I track my order 16, 15 and 14 year olds. We use life 360. Not an issue

MrsPinkSky · 21/10/2023 17:14

gooddayruby · 21/10/2023 17:01

We do it and it just feels kind of normal to us. If anyone turned it off, there wouldn't even be a discussion about it, it would be absolutely fine. It can be handy tool and a comfort, but no one's pressured to do it.

Are you honestly saying that if your DP randomly turned his tracker off and refused to turn it on again, you wouldn't even ask him why?

Hbh17 · 21/10/2023 17:03

Weird and intrusive (w exception of special needs etc). Honestly, if a family member suggested it to me, it would be the end of the relationship. Nobody needs to know where I am, nor me them.

gooddayruby · 21/10/2023 17:01

We do it and it just feels kind of normal to us. If anyone turned it off, there wouldn't even be a discussion about it, it would be absolutely fine. It can be handy tool and a comfort, but no one's pressured to do it.

Tiredmum100 · 21/10/2023 16:58

I think it's strange. We do have a tracker on ds phone, but he's 11. He's just started comp and gets the bus back and for on his own, so it's more just to check he's ok, as we're in work when he comes home. For other family members, no.

Finestreason · 21/10/2023 16:58

I don’t think it’s perfectly notmal because circumstances probably vary widely among those who share their locations with others.

But I also don’t think it’s inherently stalkerish. Like most technology, it can be used to improve lives but can also have severe downsides.

We use it as it suits us but I really wouldn’t want to be bothered with seeing information about too many relatives locations.

DuplicateUserName · 21/10/2023 16:52

NoTouch · 21/10/2023 16:50

You are just making things up now. Where is the MNetter on this thread who has "insisted" on it when their dh wasn't happy with it too?

I didn't mention this thread, did I?

There has been tonnes of threads like this.

Personally I worry we'll get to a point where jealous, abusive partners will think their DP has something to hide if they don't agree to being tracked but I appreciate that's a whole other thread.

Have a look through AS and you'll see how many have insisted on it.

NoTouch · 21/10/2023 16:50

DuplicateUserName · 21/10/2023 16:38

It's totally weird and I would not be in a relationship with anyone who insisted on tracking me.

Yet so many MNetters insist it's so they can 'put the kettle on when their husband's are nearly home'. Yeah righto 🙄😂

You are just making things up now. Where is the MNetter on this thread who has "insisted" on it when their dh wasn't happy with it too?

TheaBrandt · 21/10/2023 16:42

Saves me pestering Dd eg after school Friday can see she’s at friends house - all good. She has hundreds of friends has been useful when I go to pick up to click directions and phone takes me to their random country houses.

Dd14 is not naughty and we do trust her and have good communication but she is out and about a lot and very social so it’s reassuring to keep a handle on her whereabouts. She travels from party to party on some nights. If she was very sensible/older or a home bird I probably wouldn’t bother.

ordinarybarbie · 21/10/2023 16:42

I've got my DH, children, siblings and parents all on Findmy.

We don't check up on each other but made a mutual agreement to give everyone access after someone we knew was in a car crash and the car wasn't found for almost 3 days so no one could find them to help and possibly save their life. They were known to be missing within about 8 hours of the crash so if they'd had the tracker would have been found and possibly saved much sooner. Just felt like a no brainier after this.

DuplicateUserName · 21/10/2023 16:38

It's totally weird and I would not be in a relationship with anyone who insisted on tracking me.

Yet so many MNetters insist it's so they can 'put the kettle on when their husband's are nearly home'. Yeah righto 🙄😂

TheaBrandt · 21/10/2023 16:35

Depends if you are parenting a slightly wayward out and about early to mid teenage child or not.

My family all think it’s outrageous and awful my local friends who all have teens and ourselves all do it and find it invaluable.

NoTouch · 21/10/2023 16:16

Neurodiversitydoctor · 21/10/2023 16:03

The question is when does "checking the 11yo gets home ok" morph into " making sure the 14yo is at the mates house she said she was" and if her parents do this unashamedly then how does she know her partner doesn't have an unassailable right to know her whereabouts at all times. Slippery slope easier not to normalise it.

That's were trust comes in, if you can't trust yourself not to abuse others privacy or your can't trust your nearest and dearest not to abuse yours, again, you have bigger issues.

What is to stop me going right now into dhs wallet sitting in the kitchen and having a snoop, or into my dcs room and his belongings? Nothing. It is no different with location finding.

It is as important to teach your teens (and yourself) that trust is easy lost and harder to restore.

2jacqi · 21/10/2023 16:04

did she not need the families mobiles to install this programme?? pretty sure the sons girlfriend wont know she is being tracked!!

Neurodiversitydoctor · 21/10/2023 16:03

NoTouch · 21/10/2023 15:47

Texting won't work great if you leave your phone at home either 🤣

I didn't say using it as means to keep "an eye on teens" ok. I think I was pretty clear saying using if was "surveillance" and "tracking" is not healthy, but that doesn't mean all the other people using it as a useful tool for other reasons that they are happy with is an issue.

The question is when does "checking the 11yo gets home ok" morph into " making sure the 14yo is at the mates house she said she was" and if her parents do this unashamedly then how does she know her partner doesn't have an unassailable right to know her whereabouts at all times. Slippery slope easier not to normalise it.

NoTouch · 21/10/2023 15:50

Neurodiversitydoctor · 21/10/2023 15:30

and TBH as a teen I would have quickly worked out how to use it as a decoy to get up to even more mischief, which I know Dd's mates have. So actually fasly reasuring and counterproductive.

TBH as a teen I would have just switched it off if I didn't want to use it and my parents would have been fine with that. I would also be fine with it if ds did the same. I don't use it often and he knows the types of scenarios I would use it for and would rather I did that than text/phone.

NoTouch · 21/10/2023 15:47

Neurodiversitydoctor · 21/10/2023 15:29

2 consenting adults, well fair enough, but obviously won't work if you left your phone at home or something. As a means of keeping an eye on teens, I think it is wholly inappropriate. It doesn't teach trust or responsibility, with older teens I would ask myself do I really need or want to know where DS 19 spends his time ?

Texting won't work great if you leave your phone at home either 🤣

I didn't say using it as means to keep "an eye on teens" ok. I think I was pretty clear saying using if was "surveillance" and "tracking" is not healthy, but that doesn't mean all the other people using it as a useful tool for other reasons that they are happy with is an issue.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 21/10/2023 15:30

and TBH as a teen I would have quickly worked out how to use it as a decoy to get up to even more mischief, which I know Dd's mates have. So actually fasly reasuring and counterproductive.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 21/10/2023 15:29

NoTouch · 21/10/2023 15:22

@CurlewKate again your words are imply things and maybe that reflects things in your own life/thoughts, but they are things that are not there for most people - "surveillance" is close observation to try to catch someone out doing something wrong.

That is not what is happening with most people it is just an easier way to do some things. If ds asks me to pick him up and I check where he is so I know where to go, just because it is easier, that isn't "surveillance". If dh or ds is driving to pick me up somewhere (or vice versa) and I have a look to see if he is nearly there yet that isn't "trying to catch someone out".

Most people feel there is nothing wrong with checking someone's location in those scenarios, and similar, or someone checking theirs, which is what most people would use it for and why the majority of people freely choose to have the option switched on.

Obviously a minority of people will use it as a means of control, or feel they may be being controlled - which is a much wider issue in that relationship than an otherwise harmless location finder, but those issues don't mean it is wrong for anyone else to use.

2 consenting adults, well fair enough, but obviously won't work if you left your phone at home or something. As a means of keeping an eye on teens, I think it is wholly inappropriate. It doesn't teach trust or responsibility, with older teens I would ask myself do I really need or want to know where DS 19 spends his time ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread