Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to deal with my 5 year old’s disappointment at not winning star of the week?

113 replies

Peachballoon · 20/10/2023 18:12

The child who wins star of the week gets to take home the class teddy for the weekend.
He started reception six weeks ago and two of the friends he plays with have won it, plus four others and he’s really gutted each Friday, in tears and angry, saying “why don’t I ever get it?!”

I do suspect he is ND, as he shows traits, but we haven’t had an official diagnosis as yet.

I’m just wondering how anyone else manages this kind of thing?

OP posts:
ImAMinion · 20/10/2023 20:00

It’s a shame the class Teddy is attached to Star of the Week - I have one for my reception class and it’s pulled out the pot so everyone sees it’s random - a bit like the daily class helper.

However - it’s not all sunshine and roses this way either! For the first couple of children who’s names were drawn, it was ages ago to their 4 year old minds and they sit there looking hopeful every Friday and get upset that their name hasn’t been drawn and basically haven’t grasped that if they do get a second go, it won’t be till towards Easter (I’m in a private school so a smaller class, but I’m still going to have to calculate if everyone can even have it twice).

And even this way doesn’t stop the parents requests. I’ve had emails each week asking for their child to be next for similar reasons as above (it’s making them sad), I’m getting requests for special events, people requesting it for the half term week because their child deserves it more……I’m going to be honest, I’m not taking any of it and politely reminding parents that’s it’s a random draw and remaining that way otherwise it’s just a never ending can of worms.

I agree with someone above - write a class list at home and get him to tick off so he can see that he isn’t alone. Now if people start getting it a second time before someone has it a first time, yes say something, but it won’t help him to request it because come next term or whatever he’s just going to get disappointed again and again when his turn has been done. Let him wait, it will be all the more exciting for him when he’s genuinely chosen. Do you really want him chosen because you complained or for him to be genuinely chosen and recognised for something good?

The truth behind the bear’s weekly allocation will be a combination of good behaviour, ticking off down a list, an incentive for good behaviour for certain children, as well as being used as a tool for less settled children (particularly the first few weeks to give them something exciting to associate with school) - and somewhere in there will be quiet children who just get on with it who get thrown in and then there’ll be the few who come up every week as a good possible but ultimately will be held till last because they will be deemed as sensible, patient, resilient, and always deserving so just kind of “held”.

The reward systems aren’t always easy. We don’t have star of the week thank god but we do have reward assemblies and yes I have a list and yes someone has to be last.

Give your son a big hug, his turn is coming, have a little rewards system at home for him and use it as a learning opportunity.

Smartiepants79 · 20/10/2023 19:55

EmmaDilemma5 · 20/10/2023 19:36

There's lots of things like this at our school and I don't like it either. One thing was school council. My 5yr old was very excited to get a badge, only to find out another child got the place. They're 5, they have zero concept of representing their class etc. All they see is wanting something and another child got it for no clear reason - it really isn't fair.

They also choose a child each week to be the "star" of various things. Again, not fair and not kind. Kids, especially those who are sensitive, often internalise these things as they're not good enough and it can cause long lasting confidence issues.

I wish they scrapped all of this crap. Surely a special sticker for each child each Friday for trying hard that week would be better. Praise for and value put on good behaviour, job done.

Then explain it to him. He’s not always going to get everything that he wants! At least he shouldn’t! At 5 I’d hope he’s already been taught by you that he’s can’t always have the things that he wants!??
Do you let him have ice cream for breakfast or stay up til 11pm or watch TV for hours??
Special stickers are not very special if everyone gets one every week no matter what. And not every child finds good behaviour or effort easy. Do they get the special sticker anyway to make sure it’s ‘fair’.

Stayeduptoolateagain · 20/10/2023 19:52

I absolutely hate everything about star of the week. It leaves 29 children feeling deflated at the end of each week. What's the point of a 'motivator' that will only work out for one child? I guarantee that every week there will be a good amount of kids who feel like they've put their all in and not been recognised for it. My experience as well is that the teachers don't make sure that everyone gets a turn! It's particularly bad for the 'middle learners' who consistently go under the radar.

Talapia · 20/10/2023 19:48

SmileyClare · 20/10/2023 19:02

I’d just reassure him he’ll get a turn and distract him with your weekend plans.

Remind him everyone who gets the award deserves it but that you all have to take turns.
Praise him for a few things he’s done in the week when you’re sat round the dinner table?

Its a good life lesson and won’t damage him Everyone is disappointed sometimes- it’s not actually helpful to sheild him from all negative feelings.

He won’t always be the winner at school, sports, games or life!

This.
It's not always the kids who need behavioural encouragement who get the.award.
Sometimes, it is given purely on merit for that week. On other occasions it may be because a child has shown courage or resilience in saturation which you know nothing about.

Each week many kids will be disappointed and that's part of life. Learning to manage this is part of life.
You won't be helping your child by rushing in and telling the teacher.That would indicate you want your child to be given it over another child. Help your child develop resilience

Snowonthebeachx · 20/10/2023 19:47

sunshineandskyscrapers · 20/10/2023 18:52

This was my son this time last year. I let his teacher know the effect it had on my son, which was significant enough that it was casting a dark cloud over our weekends. This didn't have much effect on the teacher until several other parents said the same, and then the teddy started coming home in register order for those who hadn't had him. The other thing I did, and I wish I'd done it earlier, was buy him a lovely teddy and give it to him when he came out one Friday.

One other thing you could do is buy a copy of the book Punished by Rewards and give it to the school. I didn't have the nerve for this, but I have pointed out when their strategies, like this one, don't align with their therapeutic behaviour policy.

By all means buy him a teddy but please don't do the book thing! Therapeutic thinking is a lovely idea in principal but terrible for behaviour management (having watched it across a school). Teachers have a hard job often with 30 children on their own and need some incentives! Also good preparation for life.

You need to manage your child's expectations and downplay the star of the week. It's very early in the year and there are 24 children who haven't had it.

Fireisland · 20/10/2023 19:47

I'd understand this if it were June, but it's only October!

You just remind him that there are 30 kids in the class and he'll get it eventually.

Whatever you do, don't have a word with the teacher!

SmileyClare · 20/10/2023 19:44

Life long confidence issues because they didn’t win Star of the week in reception?

They might not get picked for school choir, or selected for a drama production, they might not be Mary in the nativity.
Life isn’t always fair.

I think it’s far more damaging to shield children from any negative emotions-
there’s an unprecedented number of secondary school pupils who declare they have “anxiety” and can’t sit exams. Most are fine with encouragement and accept that feeling nervous is uncomfortable but normal.

Some level of competition amongst peers is also normal and healthy.

Redlorryyellowlorryblue · 20/10/2023 19:41

Absolutely right about school council. Same kid has held the position 3 years running. Give someone else a chance!

Redlorryyellowlorryblue · 20/10/2023 19:40

We had this for three years when my DD was in infants. I only sent an email when it was approaching Easter and 2 children had had the stuffed toy twice and she was getting upset. I was also sick of hearing about the damn thing every Friday.

EmmaDilemma5 · 20/10/2023 19:36

There's lots of things like this at our school and I don't like it either. One thing was school council. My 5yr old was very excited to get a badge, only to find out another child got the place. They're 5, they have zero concept of representing their class etc. All they see is wanting something and another child got it for no clear reason - it really isn't fair.

They also choose a child each week to be the "star" of various things. Again, not fair and not kind. Kids, especially those who are sensitive, often internalise these things as they're not good enough and it can cause long lasting confidence issues.

I wish they scrapped all of this crap. Surely a special sticker for each child each Friday for trying hard that week would be better. Praise for and value put on good behaviour, job done.

JustAMinutePleass · 20/10/2023 19:34

Tell the teacher he’s really upset about it and see what she says. It’s used as a behaviour management tool for the most difficult kids rather than merit so I’m sure she could squeeze in a turn at some point.

SmileyClare · 20/10/2023 19:34

sunshineandskyscrapers · 20/10/2023 18:52

This was my son this time last year. I let his teacher know the effect it had on my son, which was significant enough that it was casting a dark cloud over our weekends. This didn't have much effect on the teacher until several other parents said the same, and then the teddy started coming home in register order for those who hadn't had him. The other thing I did, and I wish I'd done it earlier, was buy him a lovely teddy and give it to him when he came out one Friday.

One other thing you could do is buy a copy of the book Punished by Rewards and give it to the school. I didn't have the nerve for this, but I have pointed out when their strategies, like this one, don't align with their therapeutic behaviour policy.

I’m not sure “nerve” is the right word for handing a school a book on child behavioural strategies and expecting them to read it!

Maybe “pomposity” or “self importance” or “blind belief that my child must never suffer disappointment in life”

WeWereInParis · 20/10/2023 19:33

I don’t agree with promoting sour grapes.

And Not really helpful if they win Star of week a few days after telling them that.

But that poster didn't tell her child, her child worked it out. You can't really stop a child working it out if that is indeed what happening.

In reception though, I'd imagine that any decent teacher would make sure that everyone got it once before anyone got it twice.

SahliJ · 20/10/2023 19:31

Can you show him visually.

Make a table with all class names on and get him to tick off each week. He can really see all of the others. It isn't just him that isn't getting a turn just yet.

A chance also to chat about it and build his patience and resilience.

HeyMicky · 20/10/2023 19:30

AvengedQuince · 20/10/2023 18:25

Trouble is you can't tell them it's usually the children who need the most encouragement who usually get it early on!

Of course you can. I've always been clear with my DDs that everyone gets a turn. And that if they are a pupil who are easy to "catch" doing the right thing, they'll either be early in the year while others are settling, or in the last few weeks because there will always be something to reward. We make a point of celebrating the specific language used and behaviour acknowledged so it doesn't diminish the value of the reward.

SmileyClare · 20/10/2023 19:29

CurlyhairedAssassin · 20/10/2023 19:14

Oh, and the more astute kids quickly realise that school rewards are essentially a way to get the naughty ones to behave (as others have said on this thread). I remember my eldest realising this and telling me and then the allure of Star of the Week lessened!

I don’t agree with promoting sour grapes.

And Not really helpful if they win Star of week a few days after telling them that. 🤣

PurpleElf · 20/10/2023 19:28

Let him known it’s ok and totally natural to be disappointed. Listen to how he feels. Don’t try to fix it. Don’t try to distract him or minimise his feelings. Let him have his feelings - they are normal. They will pass.

TravellingT · 20/10/2023 19:27

This is a great opportunity to teach him to be resilient

Explain every child will get their turn, and those who behave the best/do the best work/are kind or whatever get it

Flora56 · 20/10/2023 19:24

CurlyhairedAssassin · 20/10/2023 19:14

Oh, and the more astute kids quickly realise that school rewards are essentially a way to get the naughty ones to behave (as others have said on this thread). I remember my eldest realising this and telling me and then the allure of Star of the Week lessened!

I’d personally say that I give rewards to show the children I value them and their contribution. Verbal praise, stickers, points, stamps, certificates and notes home are all effective rewards.

I will be honest and say it’s also about behaviour management, because I have 30 children that I’m often teaching on my own and I need them to listen, contribute, engage and learn. It’s not just the ‘naughty ones’ that need managing, it’s all of them.

Good behaviour management is obviously based on a positive relationship in which pupils are confident and interested in engaging teaching, however teachers are humans, well meaning, but imperfect humans who sometimes use a sticker to get everyone to listen!!

AppleKatie · 20/10/2023 19:24

You’d hate my DCs school OP. My DS was told in week 1 this HT that star of the week is not an equal opportunities prize and they definitely aren’t guaranteed to get it, it goes on merit each week.

My DS has had it twice so far 😬😱
I’m not sure it’s helping him socially but he is delighted… at the moment.

Seriously the best thing you can do is play down the importance at home. It really isn’t a big deal and they do have to learn to let the small stuff go at school.

just to balance this post before I get accused of some mad bragging about primary school excellence, my other older DC has never had it.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 20/10/2023 19:17

Fifireee · 20/10/2023 18:58

Tell the teacher. Every child will get it. But if it’s causing anxiety tell the teacher and they will make sure your child is next.

Nah, you'd just get parents telling each other this "trick" and then they'll all be approaching the teacher claiming their kid has anxiety about it. Or that they think it's unfair.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 20/10/2023 19:14

Oh, and the more astute kids quickly realise that school rewards are essentially a way to get the naughty ones to behave (as others have said on this thread). I remember my eldest realising this and telling me and then the allure of Star of the Week lessened!

CurlyhairedAssassin · 20/10/2023 19:12

It's a really SHIT idea for the star of the week "prize" to be the teddy going home. There should be no connection between the two as a cuddly toy is too "emotional" an object to be a prize for behaviour. I think any teacher that thinks this is a good idea can't have much empathy with little ones. Star of the Week is one thing but Teddy going home should be picked out of a hat. Children love the whole "luck" thing of picking out of a hat and they can see that it's a fairer way to do things.

Star of the Week can be a thing. But the teacher (and you) should explain to the children that there can only be one a week and that everyone will get a turn and they must be patient as their turn will come. Teacher should also give out daily stickers to children for smaller behaviour and other achievements so that children feel recognised while "waiting for their turn" at Star of the Week.

How you approach that as a parent I don't know. With my kids I just tended to offer a brisk "Ah never mind, your turn will come. I'm sure you did lots of good things this week in school and the teacher will have noticed that but they can't give Star of the Week to everyone. You're MY Star of the Week EVERY week. So every Friday we can do something nice." And then discuss what their treat may consist of.

SmileyClare · 20/10/2023 19:07

Yeah don’t tell the teacher “he has anxiety and you want him to be next”. How embarrassing if you felt entitled to do that!

He’s a bit disappointed that’s all.

Flora56 · 20/10/2023 19:03

sunshineandskyscrapers · 20/10/2023 18:52

This was my son this time last year. I let his teacher know the effect it had on my son, which was significant enough that it was casting a dark cloud over our weekends. This didn't have much effect on the teacher until several other parents said the same, and then the teddy started coming home in register order for those who hadn't had him. The other thing I did, and I wish I'd done it earlier, was buy him a lovely teddy and give it to him when he came out one Friday.

One other thing you could do is buy a copy of the book Punished by Rewards and give it to the school. I didn't have the nerve for this, but I have pointed out when their strategies, like this one, don't align with their therapeutic behaviour policy.

That’s a nice idea. Maybe have a small treat, that you both decide on, for him to look forward to. Something positive to start the weekend that changes his focus.

Swipe left for the next trending thread