Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to deal with my 5 year old’s disappointment at not winning star of the week?

113 replies

Peachballoon · 20/10/2023 18:12

The child who wins star of the week gets to take home the class teddy for the weekend.
He started reception six weeks ago and two of the friends he plays with have won it, plus four others and he’s really gutted each Friday, in tears and angry, saying “why don’t I ever get it?!”

I do suspect he is ND, as he shows traits, but we haven’t had an official diagnosis as yet.

I’m just wondering how anyone else manages this kind of thing?

OP posts:
Storynanny1 · 20/10/2023 21:12

Tortugaa · 20/10/2023 20:54

Give him a cuddle, a biscuit and put some tv on so he can have a rest and calm down after a long week of school. Maybe buy him a special new teddy to cuddle with a star on it and give it to him and tell him no matter what he’s your star and he has his own star bear to cuddle on a Friday.

I love it! Exactly what I’d have done with mine if they’d been at school with all of this teddy/star of the day/week nonsense.

Mariposista · 20/10/2023 21:07

If it was Easter and he still hadn't had his turn, it would be more understandable. But 6 weeks? You need to kindly but firmly say your time will come if you keep doing and behaving well. Then swiftly change the subject.

Alopeciabop · 20/10/2023 21:02

sunshineandskyscrapers · 20/10/2023 18:52

This was my son this time last year. I let his teacher know the effect it had on my son, which was significant enough that it was casting a dark cloud over our weekends. This didn't have much effect on the teacher until several other parents said the same, and then the teddy started coming home in register order for those who hadn't had him. The other thing I did, and I wish I'd done it earlier, was buy him a lovely teddy and give it to him when he came out one Friday.

One other thing you could do is buy a copy of the book Punished by Rewards and give it to the school. I didn't have the nerve for this, but I have pointed out when their strategies, like this one, don't align with their therapeutic behaviour policy.

Haven’t heard of this book. Will definitely look into it though. No matter which kid you are, the high achiever or low achiever, these rewards don’t help. They just detract from everything.

Tortugaa · 20/10/2023 20:54

Give him a cuddle, a biscuit and put some tv on so he can have a rest and calm down after a long week of school. Maybe buy him a special new teddy to cuddle with a star on it and give it to him and tell him no matter what he’s your star and he has his own star bear to cuddle on a Friday.

AvengedQuince · 20/10/2023 20:52

bossybloss · 20/10/2023 18:58

You can, kind of . My daughter was slightly older but I eventually told her that she was self motivated but other children need a bit of a helping hand to achieve or be good! It worked x

I doubt I would have managed to phrase it right and then DS would have repeated what I said at school. He figured it out fairly early anyway but it didn't matter if he said something then as long as it didn't sound like it had come from me. He was the youngest and the most cynical little child on his own without my help.

SmileyClare · 20/10/2023 20:39

I’ve 3 children and it feels like the upset at not winning the bear is exaggerated a bit here.

I mean yes they were a bit disappointed when they didn’t get it but at 5 years old that lasted about 10 minutes and they bounced back. They certainly weren’t depressed or sobbing all evening.

Id say it was on a level with not winning when we played a game with them at home or not being invited to a party.

Theyre all adults now and completely unscathed by their SOTW experiences 20 years ago.

WeWereInParis · 20/10/2023 20:39

Hedgehogtunnel · 20/10/2023 20:36

I always pointed out to my children that it's the children who aren't doing so well or aren't behaving well who get the stars, because they're to encourage them. Children who're already doing their best and working hard don't need them. (Then I'd get them a small gift or even print out a certificate for them to show they're appreciated!)

Is that not slightly risky? You tell them it's for children not doing well or who don't behave, and then what happens if they get it the next week?

Paintedtoenail · 20/10/2023 20:38

BoohooWoohoo · 20/10/2023 18:29

His turn will come but 💐 to your son for having to endure this practice which is 💩 for most. How many boys are in the class? If there are 6 boys who haven't won it yet then hopefully your son will get his turn by Christmas.

Ideally their turn will come. We had a bitch of a teacher last year ( not reception though) and one who clearly hates boys. She really was not pleasant and my son hated going to class with her. It was common knowledge she loathed boys. Unbelievable in this day and age.

My son never got a star of the week for the whole year yet other children got it multiple times. She really is that horrible.

PeggyPiglet · 20/10/2023 20:37

There's no wonder we have a 'snowflake society' reading this thread.

Hedgehogtunnel · 20/10/2023 20:36

I always pointed out to my children that it's the children who aren't doing so well or aren't behaving well who get the stars, because they're to encourage them. Children who're already doing their best and working hard don't need them. (Then I'd get them a small gift or even print out a certificate for them to show they're appreciated!)

ImAMinion · 20/10/2023 20:34

WillowCraft · 20/10/2023 20:15

Why bother with the teddy if it's just random and causes upset? I really don't see the point!

Star of the week is about recognising something that a child has achieved that week, it's nice for every child to get their turn, they will all do something special at some point I am sure. Our school has 3 stars at once 4x a term.

I don’t actually disagree with you - but it’s a tradition I inherited and the other class in the year has one and…..yeah we have to do it. It is quite sweet to have a class mascot and the kids love it, and it’s generally only a few that properly kick up about it.

We have similar, we have reward assemblies but don’t call it Star of The Week - normally a couple of children in a class a week and something specific will be mentioned on there certificate that they’ve done amazingly, be it a piece of work, a personal challenge, effort….so not pulled out as best of the week of you get me, but for something they’ve done well.

Storynanny1 · 20/10/2023 20:30

I’m disappointed to hear, on this thread, that there are teachers of very young children who don’t realise how upsetting this sort of thing is for 4/5 year olds.
Plenty of time and opportunities later on in the infants to start teaching about resilience.
Give them a Friday treat at home for a week of trying their best at school.

SmileyClare · 20/10/2023 20:30

I think that’s a great approach @notanotherclairebear Responding positively at home, giving your own rewards and encouragement at home is key.

It’s not ideal to reward your dc crying and stamping their feet and saying “Not fair” by going to the teacher and crying and stamping your feet and saying “Not fair” 😂

If you ask the teacher to let your dc be next (because they’re sad) how is that “fair” for the others?

buttercupcake · 20/10/2023 20:29

I’ve tried to teach my children to not seek external validation, that they should try hard and be kind to others because it makes them feel good, it doesn’t matter if the teacher notices or not.

If you keep saying, ‘try harder and your time will come’ you could be setting him up for more disappointment.

MuffyRogers · 20/10/2023 20:28

The first adventure the class teddy had at our house when he stayed for the weekend was have a ride in my washing machine! 🤣

Unithorn · 20/10/2023 20:26

Ds' school was really good I think in reception, they had a star of the day and instead of taking a toy home or whatever they got to sit on a special chair the next day. Sounds rubbish to us but the children loved it! They all won a few times as well and the reasons werent always having to be something super amazing but something that was important and impressive to them. I'd just explain that there are a lot of children in the class and although you understand he's disappointed it doesn't mean he hasn't had a good week etc.

notanotherclairebear · 20/10/2023 20:22

I think it's ok for them to feel sadness and disappointment, and it's ok that you don't want him feeling those things! We have star of the week but also a headteachers award - they go to the headteachers office and get a hot chocolate and a biscuit! My son didn't get one all the way through YR and was sad about it, so one Friday just before Christmas in Y1 I gave him a 'mummy's award' and told him all the kind things I'd noticed him doing that week. We had a biscuit and he never mentioned the headteacher's award again. Now my daughter has started YR he's been reminding her he didn't get one for the whole of YR but that it's ok. She did get star of the week this week, so must be behaving terribly according to PPs 🤣🥴

SmileyClare · 20/10/2023 20:20

I’m sure some reception classes might use SOTW as a behavioural management technique but i never thought it was unfair at my dc’s (or any of the dc in my wider family’s) school.

They all had a turn at some point and had usually worked out who was going to get it by the end of term by a process of elimination.

”It’s a reward for the naughty kids” is always trotted out on these threads.

How about explaining to your child why some dc might struggle at school and need more encouragement than others ? Rather than teaching your child to resent “naughty” children.

Procrastinatiostation · 20/10/2023 20:15

My daughter had this in Reception and I did bring it up at Parents evening, but it was April by this point without her having received it. She'd never mentioned it until after Christmas but then had started to notice lots of other children had got it but she hadn't. Then every Friday, she was upset and saying she had tried really hard to be good and didn't understand. Some children had received it 2nd time round by this point.

Turns out it was for behavioural encouragement for some of the more rowdy kids. DD won it the following week😳, but her teacher did it well, told her about mid-week point she thought she was in with a chance of getting it and if DD managed to do x, y, z by Friday she would win it. She was so thrilled when I picked her up, I didn't care if I looked like an arse bringing it up to the teacher. I'm actually glad I did, the teacher seemed a bit surprised it might be having a negative impact on the children that weren't getting it 🤔

WillowCraft · 20/10/2023 20:15

ImAMinion · 20/10/2023 20:00

It’s a shame the class Teddy is attached to Star of the Week - I have one for my reception class and it’s pulled out the pot so everyone sees it’s random - a bit like the daily class helper.

However - it’s not all sunshine and roses this way either! For the first couple of children who’s names were drawn, it was ages ago to their 4 year old minds and they sit there looking hopeful every Friday and get upset that their name hasn’t been drawn and basically haven’t grasped that if they do get a second go, it won’t be till towards Easter (I’m in a private school so a smaller class, but I’m still going to have to calculate if everyone can even have it twice).

And even this way doesn’t stop the parents requests. I’ve had emails each week asking for their child to be next for similar reasons as above (it’s making them sad), I’m getting requests for special events, people requesting it for the half term week because their child deserves it more……I’m going to be honest, I’m not taking any of it and politely reminding parents that’s it’s a random draw and remaining that way otherwise it’s just a never ending can of worms.

I agree with someone above - write a class list at home and get him to tick off so he can see that he isn’t alone. Now if people start getting it a second time before someone has it a first time, yes say something, but it won’t help him to request it because come next term or whatever he’s just going to get disappointed again and again when his turn has been done. Let him wait, it will be all the more exciting for him when he’s genuinely chosen. Do you really want him chosen because you complained or for him to be genuinely chosen and recognised for something good?

The truth behind the bear’s weekly allocation will be a combination of good behaviour, ticking off down a list, an incentive for good behaviour for certain children, as well as being used as a tool for less settled children (particularly the first few weeks to give them something exciting to associate with school) - and somewhere in there will be quiet children who just get on with it who get thrown in and then there’ll be the few who come up every week as a good possible but ultimately will be held till last because they will be deemed as sensible, patient, resilient, and always deserving so just kind of “held”.

The reward systems aren’t always easy. We don’t have star of the week thank god but we do have reward assemblies and yes I have a list and yes someone has to be last.

Give your son a big hug, his turn is coming, have a little rewards system at home for him and use it as a learning opportunity.

Edited

Why bother with the teddy if it's just random and causes upset? I really don't see the point!

Star of the week is about recognising something that a child has achieved that week, it's nice for every child to get their turn, they will all do something special at some point I am sure. Our school has 3 stars at once 4x a term.

MsJuniper · 20/10/2023 20:11

I think it's quite a good thing for children to learn to applaud and feel happy for others.

If you can learn that, you'll be a lot happier in life.

Storynanny1 · 20/10/2023 20:02

I taught infants for nearly 40 years and absolutely hated this kind of thing. I got round it by secretly tweaking it! I had about 6 “ teddies” so the maximum time anyone had to wait was 5 weeks.
One year a little boy in reception had to wait all year to be in birthday assembly as he wasn’t 5 until August. He cried every Friday wanting it to be his turn. I gave him a sticker every Friday just because I could. I wish teachers would break the “ rules”! It’s hard to be resilient when you are barely 5.

ChocolateIsntTheSameAnymore · 20/10/2023 20:01

Ours is names out of a hat. So they all get a turn

Smartiepants79 · 20/10/2023 20:01

When did we decide that our children should never have to deal with disappointment or feeling sad or being nervous or any kind of negative emotions at all.
Life involves all these things. They need to develop ways of handling them.
Mummy can’t always make it better.

SmileyClare · 20/10/2023 20:01

Op it all sounds very fair and measured with regards to the rewards in his class.

He regularly gets stickers and is one off from completing his chart/ getting a prize?

He received Worker of the Week?

Sounds like he’s getting plenty of recognition and praise.

Dont reward him making a fuss about not winning the teddy this time.
You could encourage him to feel happy for his friend that got it this week.

Swipe left for the next trending thread