Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to deal with my 5 year old’s disappointment at not winning star of the week?

113 replies

Peachballoon · 20/10/2023 18:12

The child who wins star of the week gets to take home the class teddy for the weekend.
He started reception six weeks ago and two of the friends he plays with have won it, plus four others and he’s really gutted each Friday, in tears and angry, saying “why don’t I ever get it?!”

I do suspect he is ND, as he shows traits, but we haven’t had an official diagnosis as yet.

I’m just wondering how anyone else manages this kind of thing?

OP posts:
Storynanny1 · 20/10/2023 22:33

Absolutely. My children have never suffered from not bringing home a star of the week teddy.
In the 90’s when they were taking GCSE’s there started a thing amongst some of their friends where parents were offering an amount of money per “A” grade they got. I didn’t engage in this at all ( didn’t have spare cash anyway in those days) and my children were still motivated. And happy to just enjoy a celebratory family meal on results day.

FunnysInLaJardin · 20/10/2023 22:32

God, I hate primary for this kind of shit. it does untold damage to the quiet well behaved kids

So glad my kids are at secondary and beyond now!

WillowCraft · 20/10/2023 22:27

There's research showing that exterbnal rewards inhibit learners' self motivation as they only want the reward and stop seeing the inherent value and satisfaction in completing the work.

Seems pretty obvious really, a teddy will work in reception when they care about that sort of thing, but most children that age are really keen anyway. By the time they are a bit older they are thoroughly disillusioned by all these meaningless rewards and they no longer work, but a proportion of children have also lost the love of learning and it's progressively harder to motivate them.

Fewer external rewards in the early years would probably be better in the long run

Storynanny1 · 20/10/2023 22:26

DrBlackbird · 20/10/2023 22:18

i wish every infant school teacher would read the book Punished by Rewards. Stickers and teddies etc are not tools used to model and reward good behaviour or extra effort etc, They are means to control children and train them to compete rather than collaborate and they create significant negative and unintended long-term consequences. Someone upthread admitted to being cognisant of using them this way, but it’s depressing reading many of the replies. Every single piece of research highlights the harms they do, but tragically they will never stop being used.

They could all read it and most likely agree with it, but management will be telling them what they have to do.

SmileyClare · 20/10/2023 22:25

What are the long term harmful consequences of rewarding children with stickers etc that studies have proven?

I’m sceptical. I mean this has been a thing for decades for every child in the land at primary school. I’m not convinced it’s a tragedy.

DrBlackbird · 20/10/2023 22:18

i wish every infant school teacher would read the book Punished by Rewards. Stickers and teddies etc are not tools used to model and reward good behaviour or extra effort etc, They are means to control children and train them to compete rather than collaborate and they create significant negative and unintended long-term consequences. Someone upthread admitted to being cognisant of using them this way, but it’s depressing reading many of the replies. Every single piece of research highlights the harms they do, but tragically they will never stop being used.

SmileyClare · 20/10/2023 22:17

I hate..attendance awards

I agree with you there. Bad enough when you’re ill as a kid without the realisation you’ve missed out on an award as well.

caringcarer · 20/10/2023 22:16

I used to teach secondary aged kids. For fun I used to have a chocolate advent calendar for my tutor group. Only one kid could open it each day. I was astonished how competitive the kids were to open the day and get the tiny little chocolate. Most of the kids probably had a whole chocolate advent calendar at home to themselves anyway.

Prometheus · 20/10/2023 22:14

Agree with all the other advice but a word of caution - I had similar when my DS was in reception. It got to July (end of school year) and he still hadn’t had the class teddy. As he was quiet and well behaved the teacher had totally overlooked him for a year. He didn’t understand why the disruptive kids had taken the teddy home multiple times. I had to write a note in his homework diary and he finally brought the teddy home in the second to last week of term 😢

Crispautumn · 20/10/2023 22:09

It really isn’t always the naughty ones who get it first. I have two DS, one with ADHD who pushed all the boundaries at school and questions the teachers, and another people pleaser who loves the class environment, loves to learn and concentrates well. Which do you think has already got star of the week this term, and which do you think routinely gets it in the spring/summer term (he’s never been last, thankfully, but one year he was last but one to get it!).

At my DC’s school, the kids who get it early are the best behaved (they announce it for every year each week on the school’s tapestry).

caringcarer · 20/10/2023 22:04

Every kid in the class will win the Star Award by the end of the year. They don't actually give it to the child producing the best work because then the same kids would win it every week. Its just given for inclusivity to get all kids trying.

Snowinjulyy · 20/10/2023 22:04

I'd mention to the teacher that he really wanted the teddy. You'd hope that people who teach 4/5 year olds would be empathetic.
I'd say "I hope you don't think this is cheeky of me but I just wanted to let you know that x really wants that teddy"
there will be other children in the class who aren't bothered.

EcoCustard · 20/10/2023 22:03

I hate star of the week, attendance awards, school council/popularity contest etc it’s rubbish. Dc4 has got more irritated each week as he has hasn’t won’ it yet, although he did get an effort award for being the only child able to name vegetables. Dc2 is solid, performs well, achieves above her age & peers, good, kind kid. She went through the whole of yr1 without receiving any star of the week, or effort awards. She is rarely recognised for anything, and it stings. Today star of the week in Dc3’s class went to the kid who threw a chair at the table of their classmates, Dd being on that table on Monday. But they ‘had worked really hard at applying different vocabulary this week’. Absolute farce along with attendance certificates that reward either the ‘lucky’ that don’t ever catch anything or the selfish parents who insist on sending sick kids & spread it to everyone else. Don’t ever reward prioritising health or following the ‘rules’.

SmileyClare · 20/10/2023 22:00

Storynanny1 · 20/10/2023 21:52

Haha! Yes one of my little granddaughters loves getting the “I hurt myself” stickers and excitedly waves the parents note about the injury around at me when I pick her up.

Haha It’s just getting the sticker that’s important. I don’t want to say my niece is faking injuries but she gets those stickers very regularly 🤣

Knivesandforks · 20/10/2023 21:59

Redlorryyellowlorryblue · 20/10/2023 19:41

Absolutely right about school council. Same kid has held the position 3 years running. Give someone else a chance!

Oh same here! My dd tries every year and it really means a lot. She really wants the star of week, readers award etc too- never gets them. My ds not in the least interested gets them.... says alot about both of their behaviour!!

Storynanny1 · 20/10/2023 21:53

Honestly, I couldn’t still be a teacher in this climate, I’d have to buy a class set of teddies and just give them all one!

Storynanny1 · 20/10/2023 21:52

SmileyClare · 20/10/2023 21:46

Yes I see your point about singling one child out.

My niece is 6 and they seem to hand out lots of stickers and rewards as well as the Star of the week.

She likes getting the “II hurt myself today” sticker and proudly tells me when I collect her about VERY minor scrapes in the playground that have won her a sticker. Hmm

Haha! Yes one of my little granddaughters loves getting the “I hurt myself” stickers and excitedly waves the parents note about the injury around at me when I pick her up.

YellowRibbon710 · 20/10/2023 21:51

Fifireee · 20/10/2023 18:58

Tell the teacher. Every child will get it. But if it’s causing anxiety tell the teacher and they will make sure your child is next.

Terrible advice.

Try and teach him some resilience and that his turn will come. It's a really optimal age for him to learn this.

Otherwise he will find it hard to deal with small setbacks and disruptions in his life.
Take it from an (exasperated) employer of lots of Gen Z staff.

SmileyClare · 20/10/2023 21:46

Yes I see your point about singling one child out.

My niece is 6 and they seem to hand out lots of stickers and rewards as well as the Star of the week.

She likes getting the “II hurt myself today” sticker and proudly tells me when I collect her about VERY minor scrapes in the playground that have won her a sticker. Hmm

Frasers · 20/10/2023 21:43

It’s not used specifically as a tool for managing naughty kids, it’s a tool used to model and reward good behaviour or extra effort etc, and yes sometimes that’s the naughty kids, although I don’t even align on such a phrase or thing at this age.

if he’s in a large class then you need to sit down and talk to him and try ro explain in words he will understand that there are many children and all need to get a chance and what it’s awarded on. Do not say it’s for the naughty kids, it’s a ludicrous sentiment that will lead him into trouble if he repeats it to the kifd who are awarded it.

its important you do this because he can’t learn if he cries he gets his way. You can also speak to the teacher to ask what he needs to do to help him het awarded.

bossybloss · 20/10/2023 21:41

AvengedQuince · 20/10/2023 20:52

I doubt I would have managed to phrase it right and then DS would have repeated what I said at school. He figured it out fairly early anyway but it didn't matter if he said something then as long as it didn't sound like it had come from me. He was the youngest and the most cynical little child on his own without my help.

Yeah, that’s true ! My child was older and to be honest I am not sure if she actually did say anything at school. She may have sounded like a little prima donna if she had !😂

Storynanny1 · 20/10/2023 21:36

SmileyClare · 20/10/2023 21:29

Oh right fair enough @Storynanny1 !

There must have been some sort of equivalent praise/reward thing? There used to be Top of the class didn’t there?
Or end of term awards, House points ?

When I was at school I remember End of term certificates handed out for various achievements. I got one for “kindness to others” when I was about 5 and my mum put it on the kitchen wall 😂

I do recall them often coming home with stickers - being helpful at lunchtime, being kind , doing an amazing something or other in PE, that sort of thing. But never one child singled out, teachers used to give out lots of stickers every day!

SmileyClare · 20/10/2023 21:29

Oh right fair enough @Storynanny1 !

There must have been some sort of equivalent praise/reward thing? There used to be Top of the class didn’t there?
Or end of term awards, House points ?

When I was at school I remember End of term certificates handed out for various achievements. I got one for “kindness to others” when I was about 5 and my mum put it on the kitchen wall 😂

Storynanny1 · 20/10/2023 21:22

Yes, about the last 20/25 years. Mine are all in their 40’s and late 30’s so didn’t experience any of that.

SmileyClare · 20/10/2023 21:17

I agree with giving him a cuddle and reassuring him. I don’t think anyone is suggesting saying “Unlucky mate, man up”

Mine all had Star of the Week in reception over 23 years ago. I don’t think it’s a new thing?

Swipe left for the next trending thread