Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I want to move to countryside but DH not sure

219 replies

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 13:34

I'm fed up of city life and want to move to somewhere more rural, not to a really remote location but definitely to a place where I am not woken by car doors slamming, neighbour's children screaming from all sides, excessive traffic noise etc. DH is a city boy through and through and thinks we'll hate country living. I've been studying the online property websites and have found three houses to look at this weekend. He says he might be 'too busy' to come with me. So AIBU if I go and look by myself and try to persuade DH to at least consider moving? There's nothing keeping us here really because we both WFH and can work anywhere and have no dependent children or family nearby. Has anyone else moved to the countryside during Covid or any other time and did you love it or hate it? Obviously, I'd like some 'good news' stories to tell DH but perhaps I need the realistic ones to stop myself going off on a romantic quest for something that won't actually make me happier?

OP posts:
Dontknowwhyidoit · 20/10/2023 15:37

It all depends on the type of lifestyle you want. I moved from big city to tiny rural village 14 years ago for love and I didn't realise the sacrifices that would be made. There are pros and cons to every where, if you like eating out or take aways then rural life is not good, if you like more solitude and wide open spaces then it's good. I have struggled with the distance from things I miss such as nightlife, choices to eat out and leisure activities such as swimming, gym, cinema etc . However my younger children have not experienced the elbows out attitude you have in city schools. Kids are less judgemental and they don't grow up as fast so there are good points as well.

anxiousatnight · 20/10/2023 15:32

I live very rurally. I still get woken up, but instead of car doors slamming its foxes or the collie dogs barking from across the valley.

I think you ought to go for the edge of a decent sized market town, which is near enough to access countryside but also close enough to amenities.

I love living here, but I'm a farmer's daughter so this is normal for me and I felt out of place in the small town we bought our first house in. The WiFi is crap, as is he mobile signal. It's muddy all winter and the neighbouring farmer spread slurry during the heatwave last year. We have to drive everywhere and my kids can't 'play out' with other kids, not will they be able to cycle to friend's houses when they're older.

That said, we live a different lifestyle to friends in the local town and it's wonderful. My kids play outside heaps, they can be as loud as they like and no one hears them. They also have a sense of independence because they have so much space. They don't have iPads or watch much TV. The house, gardens and views and beautiful and I never get bored here. There is always something to do. We love being close to nature and all the activity it brings. We are closer to our neighbours here than we ever were when we lived in town, despite the fact that we were in a row of houses before and now our nearest neighbours are a couple of fields away.

Think very carefully if one of you isn't keen. I don't know that it's something you can convince someone to like.

SarahLKelp · 20/10/2023 15:31

I understand the desire to live rurally. We moved out of London to the countryside but in the Home Counties so DH can commute. I can't function in a city, I need to live in nature or I feel drained and unwell.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 20/10/2023 15:30

A lot of the Airbnb / country cottages are keen to have long lets in the winter, and you can do some surprisingly good deals.

Aprilx · 20/10/2023 15:29

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 13:59

Hmm, not sounding too positive so far! I'm not forcing DH to do anything by the way, just exploring options that might make life better for both of us, even if he can't see it yet! We've lived in numerous towns and cities over the last twenty years because he's had to move with quite a bit for his career and I've always uprooted myself (and my horse) to go with him, even when I've been settled and happy so I'm wondering if it's my turn to find a property in a location that I might like after years of trailing after him? Nothing set in stone yet, but I want to at least look at some rural houses. Who knows, I may hate them myself but I won't know until I go and view. I promise I won't apply thumbscrews to the poor chap if he really hates the idea of rural life!

Do you know how patronising that sounds? He is already pretty sure he will hate it. If he forced you to make those other moves then yes maybe it is your turn to force him to move where you want to, although personally I couldn’t be in a relationship like that. You need to both be on board for a move and booking viewings is frankly out of order at this point.

As an aside, I am somebody that has made the move from city (Wimbledon to be precise) to a rural location. It is quieter and we have more space here. But the mobile network is patchy, the wifi speed is slow, there is no public transport, nearest shop is seven miles away, Uber / Lyft don’t operate, it is even hard to get a taxi, can’t get a takeaway food delivery, the roads are badly maintained and do not get gritted in bad weather.

Overall, swings and roundabouts. I am neither happier or less happy here versus being in the city. I tend to think my happiness is more from the within, wherever you go, there you are and all that.

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 15:21

Right, got to get ready for meeting now. Thanks everyone for all the positive and negative countryside tales. I appreciate them all 😀

OP posts:
MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 15:19

JaneyGee · 20/10/2023 15:16

Think carefully before you do. I've lived in the country all my life (Essex/Suffolk border) and it has changed profoundly. Frankly, I find life in an Essex village more stressful than life in a city. I'm near Colchester, and the traffic on the outskirts of the town, and in the local villages, is awful. In fact, it's so bad I increasingly feel like a prisoner in my own home. Most of the villages round here have been ruined by developers. Half my local woods have been hacked down to make way for a new estate, and at the other end of the village a massive new estate is being built that looks more like a new town. They squeeze houses and flats onto every bit of available land – and it's never enough. No matter how many they build, we need more, more, more. I lived in London for a bit, and looking back it often seemed quieter there than it does here.

That sounds pretty grim and I'm sorry for you 😬I must try to figure out if there is going to be a lot of building going on in the places I'm visiting. I'm pretty sure that there is a new build estate close to one of them from looking at the satellite view actually so thanks for the warning.

OP posts:
assignedferretatbirth · 20/10/2023 15:18

MidnightOnceMore · 20/10/2023 14:05

Oh, and I moved out - hated it - moved back.

Same!

We're in the process of looking to move back to the city.

We're in a tiny village in the countryside and we hate it. We're bored and lonely, not a pub or coffee in walking distance, 7 miles to a supermarket. I hate it.

PinkLemons99 · 20/10/2023 15:17

I live very rurally with empty fields for neighbours. I love the peace and quiet and pitch black skies at night.

DH grew up in Glasgow and I've also lived in cities and neither of us miss the noise and bustle and with online shopping, we've got all we need.

As I get older, I might want to move into a village or small town but that's not going to be for some time yet.

The only advice I strongly recommend is to rent somewhere for at least 6 months during Winter/Spring rather than risk everything buying, to see if you really really like it.

We sold our house and put everything into storage and rented a 3 bed furnished house in a village to try it out. We rented for about 10 months before our house purchase went through and during that time really got to know all the surrounding towns and villages.

Cananyonehelpplease · 20/10/2023 15:17

I live in a very rural village. Its lovely in the summer..in the winter floods/ice/snow makes things very very hard. If you cant get to supermarkets due to snow etc, the supermarket vans cant deliver to you when you order online! A lot more electricity cuts resulting in no heating/cooking/Internet etc as we have no natural gas only electricity in our village, and NO roads get gritted. The bad winter weather closes roads so it means I cant go into work and kids cant get into school. Pipes freeze regularly due to being rural. Winter is really rough!

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 15:16

Lizzieregina · 20/10/2023 15:06

I grew up in a big city and moved to a rural location as a teenager. I loved it! However, for life opportunities, I moved again to an even bigger city (another country) in my 20s and if I won the lottery tomorrow, I’d be winging my way back to my rural countryside.

I think country life isn’t for everyone, but nothing makes me happier than the quiet surroundings and chatting to the cows and horses along the country lanes!

In your case, I’d try and see if the DH would be amenable to trying it out for a few months.

He's coming home soon so I'll see if he's had time to get used to the idea. I'm pretty sure he'll agree to give it a whirl for six months or so. Fingers crossed!

OP posts:
JaneyGee · 20/10/2023 15:16

Think carefully before you do. I've lived in the country all my life (Essex/Suffolk border) and it has changed profoundly. Frankly, I find life in an Essex village more stressful than life in a city. I'm near Colchester, and the traffic on the outskirts of the town, and in the local villages, is awful. In fact, it's so bad I increasingly feel like a prisoner in my own home. Most of the villages round here have been ruined by developers. Half my local woods have been hacked down to make way for a new estate, and at the other end of the village a massive new estate is being built that looks more like a new town. They squeeze houses and flats onto every bit of available land – and it's never enough. No matter how many they build, we need more, more, more. I lived in London for a bit, and looking back it often seemed quieter there than it does here.

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 15:14

Brokendaughter · 20/10/2023 15:09

If you thought the suburbs were too far from amenities & nobody to be friends with, why do you think you'd be okay when even further from amenities with even less people to be friends with?

If you found the suburbs isolating & boring, I don't think you'll settle in a more rural location.

Excellent point and shows my lack of logic somewhat. As long as I have my horse (and DH if he deigns to come with us) I think I'll be fine. I didn't have the horse when I lived in the suburbs so I was really lonely. Livery yards are good for making friends though even if all else fails and the locals are hostile!

OP posts:
MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 15:12

Dontcallmescarface · 20/10/2023 15:04

I'm happy to listen to tractors

That's what a lot of people who don't live rurally say......until haymaking/harvest time when the tractors are still going well into the night, then it's a different story. 😂

Ok, more disclosure - I come from a farming background. Tractors moving are tractors making money! It's the ones in the barn being worked on that my family never liked. No longer got the family farm but I have met plenty of tractors I promise you, even the mighty caterpillar tracked beasts that take half the tarmac off the road with them on a sunny day.

OP posts:
MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 15:09

SecondUsername4me · 20/10/2023 14:56

Why are you being so patronising towards your dh? "He just can't see it yet"

Fuck off.

You want to live in the countryside? Then go! But why should he be forced to come along too against his will?

I'll pass on your good wishes to DH 🙄Honestly, no-one's ever had his best interests at heart more than they have today. If he wants to divorce me so be it. Bet he doesn't though!

OP posts:
AuraBora · 20/10/2023 15:09

Dh and I moved after 15 or so years in London to a lovely market town in a national park. We absolutely love it here. Beautiful countryside right on our doorstep, never feels too crowded anywhere even on a busy Saturday in town,loads of beautiful places to walk and 15-20 mins from the sea and a couple of cities for culture, better shopping and choice of restaurants etc.

One of the things we loved when we first moved here were the dark skies and smell of the air. Also people just more relaxed and less stressed.
We are enjoying bringing up two small children here.

It's fairly quiet where we live although sometimes a bit of noise from guys in their 20s next door having gatherings. Unless you're detached you don't really know what you'll get noise-wise from your neighbours..but compared to the city flat we were in before it's pretty quiet!

I second the idea of trying somewhere out before making any decisions.. maybe your DH could be persuaded.. but it sounds like full on rural wouldn't be a wise idea.

Brokendaughter · 20/10/2023 15:09

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 14:22

I'm an all or nothing type person so the suburbs are not for me I'm afraid. Tried it once when we lived in Berkshire and I hated it with a passion. Too far from amenities but no-one to be friends with as it was a dormitory town and I was looking for a job for ages and felt very isolated and bored without even work colleagues to chat to. Was glad when we moved back into the city.

If you thought the suburbs were too far from amenities & nobody to be friends with, why do you think you'd be okay when even further from amenities with even less people to be friends with?

If you found the suburbs isolating & boring, I don't think you'll settle in a more rural location.

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 15:07

senua · 20/10/2023 14:49

I second the market town idea - rural but not too rural, best of both worlds.

If you want to convince your DH to move to the country, I'm not sure that dragging him out in the middle of Storm Babet is a good strategy. Choose better weather, maybe leave it until Spring!

That's actually a very good point!! I keep thinking the storm will have blown over by tomorrow but maybe I am being over optimistic?

OP posts:
MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 15:06

Turfwars · 20/10/2023 14:49

The countryside can be noisy too.

A few weeks ago we had two bulls keeping us up all night as they were yelling at each other from different fields presumably to tell the other to not even think about having notions about his girls. Grin

Pheasants and foxes can scare the shit out of you with their yelling and lambs and sheep getting separated cry all night long sometimes.

But then you see frogs, bats, lizards & newts, swans, squirrels, pheasant, foxes, pine martins, badgers,birds and butterflies. You can see the stars properly and sip a beer watching a stunning sunset. And then it doesn't matter that Dominos won't deliver that far away or that Fortnite is lagging. Well, mostly!

I used to have my horse at livery on a farm with some very imposing looking bulls in one of the fields. One of them tried to get to know me and my horse better by leaning on a stone wall until it collapsed. We scarpered because it was a toss up who was more scared, me or the horse 😂

OP posts:
Lizzieregina · 20/10/2023 15:06

I grew up in a big city and moved to a rural location as a teenager. I loved it! However, for life opportunities, I moved again to an even bigger city (another country) in my 20s and if I won the lottery tomorrow, I’d be winging my way back to my rural countryside.

I think country life isn’t for everyone, but nothing makes me happier than the quiet surroundings and chatting to the cows and horses along the country lanes!

In your case, I’d try and see if the DH would be amenable to trying it out for a few months.

Dontcallmescarface · 20/10/2023 15:04

I'm happy to listen to tractors

That's what a lot of people who don't live rurally say......until haymaking/harvest time when the tractors are still going well into the night, then it's a different story. 😂

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 15:04

EmmaStone · 20/10/2023 14:47

Have you ever lived rurally? DH and I grew up in villages, so knew what to expect. Where we live now is very rural, but only 10-15 miles from a few cities (we both work in one of the cities, and our children went to school in one as well). I think it's important to think carefully about what you like and dislike most about city life and same about country life. I loved my time in London, and adore going back (which I do very regularly, for work, to see friends and as a tourist), but I was completely done with the battle of life there. With rural living, I think it's super important to become involved in the community - whether it be running some kind of activity or charitable endeavour or similar. There's much more importance on making something happen if it's what you want.

Full disclosure - I am country born and bred but left to live in a town when I was a teenager. DH city born and bred and thinks the countryside is for 'posh people', or at least that's what he's telling me. I have promised not to look at the Cotswold chocolate box type properties and have lined up a cottage, small holding and more modern sort of house to view. I'm sure he'll come with me, even if he grumbles, because he'll be too curious to stay at home wondering what I'm up to.

OP posts:
Photographsandmemories · 20/10/2023 15:01

I hate town life here. No good having ballet and opera and so on if the tickets are too expensive to take your family. We are looking at moving away. A field with a shed would be great. And some sheep to frighten the dog.

Universalsnail · 20/10/2023 14:57

Tbh. Don't make him move to the countryside. I moved to the countryside for my DH. I hate it and me wanting to move back to the city as come up a few times because tbh I have wanted to move back to the city for years.

SecondUsername4me · 20/10/2023 14:56

Why are you being so patronising towards your dh? "He just can't see it yet"

Fuck off.

You want to live in the countryside? Then go! But why should he be forced to come along too against his will?