Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I want to move to countryside but DH not sure

219 replies

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 13:34

I'm fed up of city life and want to move to somewhere more rural, not to a really remote location but definitely to a place where I am not woken by car doors slamming, neighbour's children screaming from all sides, excessive traffic noise etc. DH is a city boy through and through and thinks we'll hate country living. I've been studying the online property websites and have found three houses to look at this weekend. He says he might be 'too busy' to come with me. So AIBU if I go and look by myself and try to persuade DH to at least consider moving? There's nothing keeping us here really because we both WFH and can work anywhere and have no dependent children or family nearby. Has anyone else moved to the countryside during Covid or any other time and did you love it or hate it? Obviously, I'd like some 'good news' stories to tell DH but perhaps I need the realistic ones to stop myself going off on a romantic quest for something that won't actually make me happier?

OP posts:
MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 16:18

Eve223 · 20/10/2023 16:08

Fair enough. Presumably the EAs have qualified you to check that you won't be wasting anyone's time.

What will happen if you fall in love with a house you view?

No problem with the EAs. I did have to show one of them proof that we had money in the bank but the other one took me at my word. Maybe I will end up wasting someone's time, but how will I know unless I view the houses? It's not the sort of thing you can choose without seeing it. It's a bit like buying a horse, some people think you're a time waster if you don't buy their horse but if you don't like it, why on earth would you buy it? Admittedly, a house is unlikely to injure me by bucking me into the middle of next week but I don't want to buy a house sight unseen either.

If I fall in love with one of the houses DH will have to be on board too, unless I fall very deeply in love and am willing to ditch him for my Prince Charming of a house?!!

OP posts:
Forgotmylogindetails · 20/10/2023 16:15

I moved to the countryside …

moved back.

I hated it too quiet for me x

ChimChimeny · 20/10/2023 16:15

My dad & his partner moved to a village a few years ago, she doesn't drive so they deliberately chose some Where with a shop (only a small costcutter type place) and a regular bus service in case he can't drive anymore or does first.
Definitely think about the future, you don't want to be old and isolated.
When we drive through small villages or see remote houses we always ask 'where would you buy milk if you needed it ' 😂
We have the best of both worlds, edge of a city with a great but service but can walk for 15 mins and be in a field

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 16:14

Birch101 · 20/10/2023 16:05

From what you've said you've been the one to uproot your life for him several times so I don't think there is anything wrong with assessing what you would like your future life to look like and then come together to work out a fair solution. Maybe just start at researching villages/market towns you would like and even do some long weekends away to see if you could see yourself actually living somewhere similar.

E.g. as much as I like the idea of no neighbour's I like that I can walk to a local shop and a couple of takeaways, but would want water near me so either a reservoir/decent lake/canals etc
Do you want to be withing a decent train station of any large city e.g. London, Bristol so having dinner and theater can still be an achievabe thing

Just don't be that person who buys a house in the country and then complains about the farmers/fisherman etc 🤣

You have my word that I won't complain about the farmers 😉Some of my best friends are farmers, ha ha. I think I might enjoy living more rurally than DH but I'm keeping an open mind until I've got the feel for the places and properties available. I think my horse will be delighted if we find somewhere with land ... if we can afford it, which remains to be seen. Prices vary so much when you are looking in a wide search area.

OP posts:
YellowRibbon710 · 20/10/2023 16:11

Yeah we would find it very dull. Does he meet with friends after work or on the weekens to go for a drink or dinner? Does he like going to the theatre or restaurants? Unless he already stays home most of the time, he's probably worried about being isolated and not having the buzz of the city around him.

Maybe I'm projecting because I'd go mad living rurally (but visiting is lovely!)

Turfwars · 20/10/2023 16:11

Another thing to consider is what he likes to do in his downtime and see what similar amenities are around in areas you are looking in. You know that with your horse what criteria you are looking for but for example he likes cycling/ hill walking/ fine dining/ golf then find potential places that have some proximity to those attractions as well.

He might be more open to the idea if he can see his own hobbies fitting in well with the location.

Teatimeisanytime · 20/10/2023 16:08

I lived in the rural countryside as a child i hated it 8 miles to the nearest shop no bus`s nothing it was dead for miles.
We was so pleased to leave it.
Years later as an adult i did move to a village not so rural as above it lasted 9 months hated it a few over priced shops bus every hour from 9am till 6pm.
none on weekends 7 miles to the nearest town.
Nice walks but did get told off a few times with GET OF MY LAND it was a public path i pointed at the sign to one woman that wanted to call the police on me.
Best thing i done that year was leave.
Country life It works for some but not for me

Now I live in a big-ish town where i can walk to shops and train station etc.
i like to be in walking distance to things .
And a bus every 20 mins blissful.

Eve223 · 20/10/2023 16:08

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 15:53

No worries on that front because this house is rented so we've no ties. Sold the last house a while back and intended to rent until the next job move but DH says he's happy to stick with current remote working for next few years. I feel the same. Current job isn't very exciting but it pays me enough to keep the horse in snazzy turnout rugs 😝

Fair enough. Presumably the EAs have qualified you to check that you won't be wasting anyone's time.

What will happen if you fall in love with a house you view?

Birch101 · 20/10/2023 16:05

From what you've said you've been the one to uproot your life for him several times so I don't think there is anything wrong with assessing what you would like your future life to look like and then come together to work out a fair solution. Maybe just start at researching villages/market towns you would like and even do some long weekends away to see if you could see yourself actually living somewhere similar.

E.g. as much as I like the idea of no neighbour's I like that I can walk to a local shop and a couple of takeaways, but would want water near me so either a reservoir/decent lake/canals etc
Do you want to be withing a decent train station of any large city e.g. London, Bristol so having dinner and theater can still be an achievabe thing

Just don't be that person who buys a house in the country and then complains about the farmers/fisherman etc 🤣

Fupoffyagrasshole · 20/10/2023 16:03

find a new house less rural thats quieter as a compromise - i live on a really busy street in zone 2 London - but the house is back of the road with a huge driveway - got really good windows that keep the noise out - bedrooms are at the back - massive long back garden - aren't bothered by any noise from outside at all - yet have all the benefits of the city - not needing a car, tube walking distance, shops easy to get to, choice of airports

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 16:01

Marblessolveeverything · 20/10/2023 15:59

Unless he is enthusiastic I wouldn't. It can be challenging moving at the best of times when fully onboard but if he has key doubts then I wouldn't.

The enthusiasm makes the bumpy bits tolerable.

I agree but, honestly, we've lived in so many places and I swear he's not even noticed because he's been so career focussed his whole adult life. We lived in a lovely European city and I really enjoyed it there and would return if possible and if the countryside move doesn't work out but DH was never there. He saw more of the airport than our apartment 🙄

OP posts:
JaneyGee · 20/10/2023 16:00

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 15:19

That sounds pretty grim and I'm sorry for you 😬I must try to figure out if there is going to be a lot of building going on in the places I'm visiting. I'm pretty sure that there is a new build estate close to one of them from looking at the satellite view actually so thanks for the warning.

If you buy a nice little place near a field, or woodland, be double sure they aren't going to build on it. I feel SO sorry for the people at the other end of my village. It used to be quiet (a meadow, a few trees...kind of idyllic), and I'm sure that for many it was their dream home. Those houses have now been engulfed by the new estates. Houses and flats are being built behind them, next door to them, and even across the road. I just cannot believe no one compensates them.

People need to remember that these massive new developments ruin lives. Instead of dismissing complainers as 'NIMBYs', there ought to be more understanding. Those on the left seem to think it's only the rich who suffer. It isn't. I know so many people whose lives have been affected by the endless new estates. None of them are rich. They're just ordinary people who've worked hard and saved up to buy a little semi-detached place in the country.

When those new estates are finished, I shudder to think how bad the traffic will be. It is unbearable NOW, so god knows what it will be like when all those new houses and flats are occupied.

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 15:59

sipsqueak · 20/10/2023 15:51

Yes we were life-long city dwellers but left central London about 8 years ago and moved to a quiet corner of the Home Counties. Our house is in a remote location but on the doorstep of a busy town with lots of amenity and with an easy commute to London. It's a perfect balance for us. Our DC have a clean & safe environment, and for me and DH we've found it to be much easier making friends out here in the 'burbs than it ever was in London - more of a community vibe here.

I won't lie it can be boring/sleepy and obviously none of the bars, restaurants or cultural activities come close to London quality. But that's why being close to London was key for us.

I think I am sort of 'over' London now. Used to live there a few years back and have sort of circled round it (Berks, Bucks, Surrey) but I'm ready for a change. I haven't mentioned it yet but my other option is moving abroad and DH thinks this might be possible depending on his employer.

OP posts:
Marblessolveeverything · 20/10/2023 15:59

Unless he is enthusiastic I wouldn't. It can be challenging moving at the best of times when fully onboard but if he has key doubts then I wouldn't.

The enthusiasm makes the bumpy bits tolerable.

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 15:56

senua · 20/10/2023 15:51

I'm looking in two other counties that we've holidayed in but never lived in.
You know that you have to name them, don't you. MN rules.
Is one of them Gloucestershire? - that's very equestrian.

Ha ha, no, but I wouldn't rule out Glos if we could afford it. I'm looking in Hampshire and Dorset first. Not got my heart set on any particular county yet so I'm determined to visit a few places before making my decision. Oh and DH's decision too, assuming I give him chance to express a view 😋

OP posts:
Londonscallingme · 20/10/2023 15:55

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 15:47

All sensible advice, thank you :) I tend to be a bit of a hot head when it comes to decision making I admit. Friends also call me ditzy but I don't think I am. I can be serious and I'm happy to take responsibility for my own decisions rather than blaming other people.

We're living in Surrey currently with easy access to London. We can't afford the Surrey countryside prices, unfortunately so I'm looking in two other counties that we've holidayed in but never lived in.

I think press ahead with your research and then chat to him about options when you know more. Given you are currently in Surrey, not central London, I am sure there must be a good compromise out there for you both. Good luck!!

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 15:53

Eve223 · 20/10/2023 15:50

Not RTFT but you're unlikely to be able to view any houses if yours isn't at least on the market and under offer....

No worries on that front because this house is rented so we've no ties. Sold the last house a while back and intended to rent until the next job move but DH says he's happy to stick with current remote working for next few years. I feel the same. Current job isn't very exciting but it pays me enough to keep the horse in snazzy turnout rugs 😝

OP posts:
senua · 20/10/2023 15:51

I'm looking in two other counties that we've holidayed in but never lived in.
You know that you have to name them, don't you. MN rules.
Is one of them Gloucestershire? - that's very equestrian.

sipsqueak · 20/10/2023 15:51

Yes we were life-long city dwellers but left central London about 8 years ago and moved to a quiet corner of the Home Counties. Our house is in a remote location but on the doorstep of a busy town with lots of amenity and with an easy commute to London. It's a perfect balance for us. Our DC have a clean & safe environment, and for me and DH we've found it to be much easier making friends out here in the 'burbs than it ever was in London - more of a community vibe here.

I won't lie it can be boring/sleepy and obviously none of the bars, restaurants or cultural activities come close to London quality. But that's why being close to London was key for us.

Eve223 · 20/10/2023 15:50

Not RTFT but you're unlikely to be able to view any houses if yours isn't at least on the market and under offer....

KnittedCardi · 20/10/2023 15:49

I'm semi rural, within 10 mins of a large town, but surrounded by fields. We are in a village, so we do have some neighbours, but at the moment I am in my study looking out at sheep, red kites, and tree covered hills. DH loves that he can just pop out for a half hour walk in the countryside at lunchtime.

We do have a train station, but not many trains, often cancelled for bad weather etc. You do need a car. We have good wifi. We do have power cuts as overheads get damaged. We do get stuck when it snows. We are in SE though, so that's not often.

We are very glad we moved out of town.

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 15:47

Londonscallingme · 20/10/2023 15:44

MN - the home of stark choices!! (One of them invariably being to LTB, no matter how minor the complaint)

I think the context that you have 'followed him' for the last 20 years with your horse is important but I think the key thing might be to try and find a reasonable compromise rather than going from one extreme to the other. I currently live in a very rural location and I hate it; I mainly hate not being able to walk anywhere, but that's by-the-by. This shouldn't be about whether it's better to live in the country vs a City.

Could you look at small towns with good access to the countryside? But still enough 'life' to make your OH happy? For me there is a massive difference between being able to walk to a decent coffee shop and a nice pub / restaurant and literally having nothing but fields around.

Where are you currently?

All sensible advice, thank you :) I tend to be a bit of a hot head when it comes to decision making I admit. Friends also call me ditzy but I don't think I am. I can be serious and I'm happy to take responsibility for my own decisions rather than blaming other people.

We're living in Surrey currently with easy access to London. We can't afford the Surrey countryside prices, unfortunately so I'm looking in two other counties that we've holidayed in but never lived in.

OP posts:
Londonscallingme · 20/10/2023 15:44

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 14:06

Only one really positive story so far. Perhaps I am BU and I should cancel the viewings? Or forge ahead and divorce DH if he digs in his heels? Stark choices!

MN - the home of stark choices!! (One of them invariably being to LTB, no matter how minor the complaint)

I think the context that you have 'followed him' for the last 20 years with your horse is important but I think the key thing might be to try and find a reasonable compromise rather than going from one extreme to the other. I currently live in a very rural location and I hate it; I mainly hate not being able to walk anywhere, but that's by-the-by. This shouldn't be about whether it's better to live in the country vs a City.

Could you look at small towns with good access to the countryside? But still enough 'life' to make your OH happy? For me there is a massive difference between being able to walk to a decent coffee shop and a nice pub / restaurant and literally having nothing but fields around.

Where are you currently?

Findapath · 20/10/2023 15:42

You sound fun and funny ( srsly, I know that sounds sarcastic) Encouraging DH to mix it up a bit and have a look at options does not make you evil! And viewing in a storm might actually give a realistic idea of what it can be like! I’m in a small rural village , wind is howling at the mo. It’s good and bad - and honestly even though I’m in the rural north , the bright lights of London are 2.5 hrs and Mancs 50 mins. It’s not the moon. I even have super fast community broadband (B4RN) apparently some of the fastest in the country! Rural communities are changing, people are moving around more. Give it a whirl! I love cities and sometimes think I want to move, but then I come home to quiet and nature…

MaybeRural · 20/10/2023 15:41

Aprilx · 20/10/2023 15:29

Do you know how patronising that sounds? He is already pretty sure he will hate it. If he forced you to make those other moves then yes maybe it is your turn to force him to move where you want to, although personally I couldn’t be in a relationship like that. You need to both be on board for a move and booking viewings is frankly out of order at this point.

As an aside, I am somebody that has made the move from city (Wimbledon to be precise) to a rural location. It is quieter and we have more space here. But the mobile network is patchy, the wifi speed is slow, there is no public transport, nearest shop is seven miles away, Uber / Lyft don’t operate, it is even hard to get a taxi, can’t get a takeaway food delivery, the roads are badly maintained and do not get gritted in bad weather.

Overall, swings and roundabouts. I am neither happier or less happy here versus being in the city. I tend to think my happiness is more from the within, wherever you go, there you are and all that.

Edited

Thanks for your input. I think you are taking me too seriously though. My DH is happy to try new things really but he has to put up a token protest. Oops! There I go being patronising to the poor chap again. Like I said, if this is a deal breaker for him (although the previous twenty moves at his instigation weren't) then he is perfectly free to head to the nearest divorce lawyer. Heck, I'll even take out a Plenty of Fish subscription for him to make my departure for pastures new (pun intended) a more seamless experience!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread