Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Visits to a smokers house

89 replies

Em9023 · 20/10/2023 10:46

I've never posted before so hope I'm doing this right!
My baby is 6 months old. My mother in law's partner is a smoker and smokes in his home. I don't let people who have recently had a cigarette hold my baby and so he has never held him as he's quite a heavy smoker. My son has also never been to their home because of the lingering smell of smoke.
My MIL keeps inviting us round and we have always dodged it, gone for walks instead, etc but now the weather has turned I'm struggling to find a polite way to say no. Her parter would go outside for a cigarette if we were actually in the house but it's the lingering smell of smoke that worries me. My husband supports me but I think he finds the whole situation quite awkward.
I go to my parents house at least once a week and so my husband wants the same for his family but this is such a barrier.
I'm just wondering if anyone thinks I'm being over the top? And how would anyone else approach this situation?
TIA for any advice, support, information on the dangers of second hand smoke in this way to empower my choices.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Zok · 29/01/2024 02:15

Why should she MIL come to their house ? She’ll bring the third hand smoke residue on her clothes and skin and contaminate the OP’s house

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 20/10/2023 16:09

They should probably come and visit you. If MIL really wants you there then she should side with you with regards to the smoking in the house. It’s quite normal to not want a baby to be in that environment.

would he compromise and say only smoke in the kitchen with the door to the rest of the house shut and the back door open? Allowing the rest of the house to carry less of the lingering smell.

tbh though my parents didn’t smoke we would stay for a week or two at a time with my grandparents who smoked liked chimneys in the house, even with us there. None of us have suffered any effects from it, but do understand not wanting a baby on that environment and tbh I’d probably feel the same.

TheGoddessFrigg · 20/10/2023 16:02

Londonscallingme · 20/10/2023 15:19

My Dad used to smoke in his house. When he died and I had to clear it out, everything was covered in a film of yellow nicotine. The place stunk. I wouldn't have taken my baby there, I could barely stand going in myself.

They need to come and visit you IMO.

I had the same experience. I bet if you wiped a cleaning wipe down one of the walls in the house, it would be filthy brown.

I used ti be a heavy smoker myself, but thinking about that gunk in my lungs made me give up almost immediately. It's a revolting habit, and an avoidable risk

Paynefully · 20/10/2023 15:41

We had this issue with our dad years ago. We ended up being straight about it and saying it’s not good for the kids, but we also hated coming home smelling of stale smoke. He was a bit ‘umph’ but he understood and tbh he couldn’t and wouldn’t argue about our children health. He ended up coming to us instead.

ThePaperTrail · 20/10/2023 15:37

I mean, it's up to you but...

Back in the 60s, 70s and even early 80s it was common for people to smoke everywhere, all the time. Chain smoking was rife. Children grew up in chain-smoking homes and were exposed to second-hand smoke day in and day out.

Yet the majority of people who grew up in those times are fine.

I don't disagree that second-hand smoke can be an issue, but my mum tells of the days when home and office furniture would have a layer of yellow nicotine stains on them because people would smoke so much.

Consequently, in the present situation, I do think there needs to be a level of perspective. Being exposed to second-hand smoke for a few hours every month isn't great, but the chances of it leading to SIDS or asthma are infinitesimally small. (It would be much higher in a home where the baby was exposed everyday, but even then most babies from a smoking home do not die from SIDS.)

Personally, I think this is a case where it's probably not worth upsetting an otherwise good relationship with the in-laws.

Londonscallingme · 20/10/2023 15:19

My Dad used to smoke in his house. When he died and I had to clear it out, everything was covered in a film of yellow nicotine. The place stunk. I wouldn't have taken my baby there, I could barely stand going in myself.

They need to come and visit you IMO.

Superscientist · 20/10/2023 15:15

Third hand smoke wasn't something I had much information on but I found this report that was interesting.
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=www.ashscotland.org.uk/media/6686/Third-hand%2520Smoke.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjx5eST5ISCAxWnU0EAHaUICHYQFnoECCYQAQ&usg=AOvVaw2TuAvZspdxJPKZI2JYOb4d

I hope it works, broadly more research is needed. On thing that stuck out for me was that nicotine doesn't come off surfaces with soap and water. There's also no safe levels of ingestion of nicotine. Chemicals can be detected in houses of former smokers after being vacant for 2 months

It would be prudent to ensure any babies and children in homes are kept an eye to reduce chewing on things from the home. Being realistic it WILL happen!

https://www.google.com/url?opi=89978449&rct=j&sa=t&source=web&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ashscotland.org.uk%2Fmedia%2F6686%2FThird-hand%2520Smoke.pdf&usg=AOvVaw2TuAvZspdxJPKZI2JYOb4d&ved=2ahUKEwjx5eST5ISCAxWnU0EAHaUICHYQFnoECCYQAQ

ActDottie · 20/10/2023 15:15

I think just saying you don’t want to be around smoke is fine. Can you invite them round to yours instead?

Dramatic · 20/10/2023 14:53

I feel like it's a bit extreme to never ever go for a visit, a couple of hours every month is really not going to do any harm.

Blondeshavemorefun · 20/10/2023 14:43

Your partner Ie their so. Needs to tell his parents why you aren't coming inside

ColleenDonaghy · 20/10/2023 14:43

Coldinscotland · 20/10/2023 14:28

Your dc developing asthma isn't a risk work taking..

But what is the risk of developing asthma from sitting in a smoker's house while they're not actually smoking from time to time? Do you know? I don't but I suspect it's not particularly high. Very different to second hand smoke or living with a smoker.

My DC were at risk of asthma as I have it, as does my only sibling and our father. All of us have eczema and hayfever, and my DH has those too. I can't imagine the occasional cuddle with granda would touch the sides of those genetic risks.

Ragwort · 20/10/2023 14:32

Just be honest ... and invite her to meet at your house. Why all the hand wringing?

Coldinscotland · 20/10/2023 14:28

Your dc developing asthma isn't a risk work taking..

ColleenDonaghy · 20/10/2023 14:01

tiggergoesbounce · 20/10/2023 13:56

Life isn't risk free and it can't be risk free

Absolutely but it's the OPs decisions on what "risks" she exposes her babies to. If this is one risk, which is avoidable, that she doesn't want to take, her in-laws, im sure, should understand.

Oh yes, absolutely.

tiggergoesbounce · 20/10/2023 13:56

Life isn't risk free and it can't be risk free

Absolutely but it's the OPs decisions on what "risks" she exposes her babies to. If this is one risk, which is avoidable, that she doesn't want to take, her in-laws, im sure, should understand.

Mrsmch123 · 20/10/2023 13:53

We don't visit my parents house as they smoke.they know this is the reason. Just be honest🤷🏻‍♀️

tiggergoesbounce · 20/10/2023 13:49

This is not new news, of course they shouldn't expect you to take your DC to be around their house, its well published about the harms of smoking and children.
My DM used to send her family out of the house 45 years ago.
YADNBU, When we were kids and no one held us who smoked, more so because my mum didn't want to force that stench on us and force us to smell it, common sense really.

Just be honest, it doesn't have to be an abrupt discussion or argument, just a simple because we want to protect our DCs health we can't bring them around.

Katypp · 20/10/2023 13:38

Phleghm · 20/10/2023 13:23

It's a sadder state of affairs when babies' health is seen as fair game. OP doesn't want to "control every situation and get the upper hand", she just wants for her baby not to come to any harm. Is it controlling to want your ILs to put a belt on your baby in the car, for example? I mean, chances are baby would be fine!
I'm shocked that so many people would be willing to take risks like this when it's not at all necessary.

What exactly are 'the risks' though? I don't know, do you?
Logic tells me that being in the home where someone has smoked (but is not doing it at the time) for an hour carries vanishingly small risks. I am happy to be corrected if you know differently.
Visiting smokers is one of those MN situations where the risks are totally overblown, along with eg never letting your baby out of your sight at home and using backward facing car seats until the child is at junior school.
Other risks - which I personally would not take - such as co-sleeping and BLW are just glossed.
You are never going to get many sensible replies on a thread about smoking. I am neither a grandparent or a smoker by the way.

Itwasamemoment · 20/10/2023 13:35

My mum was a smoker and smoked in her house but never when I was there with the children.I am a social outdoors smoker occasionally!
Yes the smell was horrible but the children had a fantastic relationship with their Grandma and putting up with the smell for a couple of hours a week was small change for the fond memories my children have of Grandma.

ColleenDonaghy · 20/10/2023 13:35

Phleghm · 20/10/2023 13:23

It's a sadder state of affairs when babies' health is seen as fair game. OP doesn't want to "control every situation and get the upper hand", she just wants for her baby not to come to any harm. Is it controlling to want your ILs to put a belt on your baby in the car, for example? I mean, chances are baby would be fine!
I'm shocked that so many people would be willing to take risks like this when it's not at all necessary.

I suspect the risk from sitting in a house where someone has smoke (not is currently smoking) is more akin to the risk of getting in the car with a correctly fitted seat, nowhere near the risk of not belting them in.

I'd also be curious to know (but far too lazy to google or calculate) the difference between sitting in a buggy going down the main street at a level close to car exhausts vs sitting in a smoker's living room.

Life isn't risk free and it can't be risk free.

Mumof2teens79 · 20/10/2023 13:31

Em9023 · 20/10/2023 10:46

I've never posted before so hope I'm doing this right!
My baby is 6 months old. My mother in law's partner is a smoker and smokes in his home. I don't let people who have recently had a cigarette hold my baby and so he has never held him as he's quite a heavy smoker. My son has also never been to their home because of the lingering smell of smoke.
My MIL keeps inviting us round and we have always dodged it, gone for walks instead, etc but now the weather has turned I'm struggling to find a polite way to say no. Her parter would go outside for a cigarette if we were actually in the house but it's the lingering smell of smoke that worries me. My husband supports me but I think he finds the whole situation quite awkward.
I go to my parents house at least once a week and so my husband wants the same for his family but this is such a barrier.
I'm just wondering if anyone thinks I'm being over the top? And how would anyone else approach this situation?
TIA for any advice, support, information on the dangers of second hand smoke in this way to empower my choices.

There is no easy solution to this. My mother smokes and when the children were babies she did go outside and we would open windows and doors, but it still felt smoky. It's not the smell so much as the residue.
As the kids got older she became less consistent about it, and would sometimes just stand in the doorway....it caused a few arguments.

Ultimately we did go round a couple of times a month for a few hours at a time....its important to maintain family relationships and she did help out with childcare. As the kids got older they did spend a bit more time there. I wasn't very happy but when I was a kid BOTH my parents smoked in that house, while I was in the same room, and while I am not saying that safe or advisable I am pretty much OK, as are lots of others.

So, I think occasional visits would be fine, but it's absolutely right that your OH should state very clearly that he is to smoke outside (10 steps from door) while you are there, and for at least 30 mins before, and they should air the house/rooms you will be using before you get there.

Also advise them airfresheners are not the same. My mum drowns the house in airfreshener thinking it disguises the smell but it just adds more chemicals to the mix!

I don't think it's reasonable or even effective to say to a smoke don't hold the baby, but take your own play mats, feeding stuff, toys etc, don't let him suck or chew on anything that has been in the house for more than a day.

You are a stronger person than me to have held out this long, I wish I had been more forthright, but I don't regret letting the kids go to their grandparents.

Eledamorena · 20/10/2023 13:30

I grew up in a house of smokers and most of my family still smoke.

I was lucky that my sister had children years before me and tackled the issue of smoking in the house with my mum. She just said, I can't bring the baby over if you smoke in the house... So my mum stopped smoking in the house. With small babies my mum also changed her clothes before holding them. It wasn't difficult, she was really understanding about it. She slacked off with the changing of clothes as they got older, but has never reverted to smoking indoors.

MIL, on the other hand, handed me back my 2 week old baby STINKING of cigarettes when we were at a family do. I'm pretty sure she didn't ACTUALLY smoke while holding her, but it definitely hadn't occurred to her that young babies shouldn't be exposed at all, really. Luckily we emigrated when my oldest was a few months old so I didn't have to tackle the 'no smoking in the house' rule with her, as there's no way my husband would have done it and there's no way I would have visited them in a house with a visible cloud of smoke hanging in every room.

I agree with previous posters suggesting honesty is the best policy. You can try to avoid confrontation by phrasing it nicely, commenting on how much things have changed in the past 30 years etc but that this is important to you. And if they won't agree, try to make an effort with suggesting regular visits to you or meeting elsewhere so as to maintain a good relationship.

WingingItSince1973 · 20/10/2023 13:30

I grew up with smokers as grandparents, really heavy and their house was the hub for the family so uncles and aunts smoked there too. On our visits there I would come out absolutely stinking and eyes stinging. We always knew after a visit it would be home to change clothes and have a shower to get rid of the smell. It was awful and I would never put my kids through that so we only ever visited for outside occasions like yourselves. I didn't regret it. My babies were more important than their hurt feelings. Do what's right for your baby. The smell of second hand smoke is revolting and your baby will be inhaling it and it stinking their clothes and skin.

TigerQueenie · 20/10/2023 13:30

I've said YABU because I don't understand why you can't just say you don't want the baby around cigarette smoke.

Coldinscotland · 20/10/2023 13:25

My ds has asthma.. Likely because me and dh have it. He has never been around a smoker. . Would you want to be holding an inhaler for your toddler choking because their loving dgps had been smokers? It's horrific even without the guilt.. Don't bow to it op.