Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People not saying "please"

83 replies

amiboverd · 20/10/2023 09:27

AIBU to think people should say please when asking for something?

Maybe I'm just old fashioned but I find it grating when someone asks for something and don't say please.

Example - someone I don't know on a Facebook group asking me to pick something up form as shop and post it to them (after I had offered to do this for someone else) and they said something like "if you see one you could get another and I could pay?"

It also happens at work. People send me things like "Article below for feedback".

I must sound like a such a bore but AIBU? Would you say please in these circumstances and would be be annoyed if someone didn't?

OP posts:
Ffsmakeitstop · 20/10/2023 13:58

I agree with you op. So many people don't use manners. I work in a shop and it's awful the way we are spoken to sometimes. My favourite was a young man who came in every day and just said "bag" I stood it for so long and eventually I snapped "please" at him. Only took a couple of days and he got it. Result shame it's not always that easy.

MidnightOnceMore · 20/10/2023 13:45

amiboverd · 20/10/2023 09:42

@PriOn1 Because they were asking me to review it for them. If I was sending something to someone senior and asking for them to check it or asking them for feedback I'd say please eg Please can you review this and let me know if you have any feedback?

I know what you're saying and in my house people didn't say thank you each other as they did in DH's for example but I'd asking a stranger to go get you something from a shop, package and post it for you a "please" would come naturally.

I think neurodiversity is used as an excuse for anything. That could apply to anyone. Should we not have social standards any more because of this? Genuine question. I know not everyone will agree with me.

This neurodiversity is used as an excuse for anything is offensive.

Neurodiversity is not being used as an 'excuse', sometimes it is an explanation.

You've lost me now - being so dismissive of neurodiversity is way worse than forggeti g to add please to a routine work email!

amiboverd · 20/10/2023 13:30

@Mamma2017 I definitely think there is a general sense of entitlement and this could be linked.

@pippapipps Exactly this sort of thing too or when you're driving and stop to let someone through. You're right in a way to keep doing it and it's occurred to me that stopping to let someone out of a junction, for example, and they don't say thanks makes me not want to do it again but if we all did this then the world would become less kind and considerate and so it's better to keep being kind to make the world a better place rather than a worse one.

OP posts:
mewkins · 20/10/2023 13:28

I'm with you OP and I do think it reflects the character of a person if they can't muster a please or thank you. I work remotely so a lot of my communication is by email and the people are work with are all polite and take time to say please/thanks. It's important to express gratitude and it definitely fosters good working relationships. If anyone issued orders it wouldn't be well received by anyone, regardless of seniority.

However I do think some people have to train themselves to do this - I worked in a shop in another part of the UK when I was at university and my co-workers used to laugh at how polite I sounded. It was very busy and they'd below at the customers to come forward- it was a completely normal thing and not considered rude.

amiboverd · 20/10/2023 13:27

@rocknrollaa I understand neurodiversity and cultural differences but do often on Mumsnet I see neurodiversity as a possible reason for things but at what stage do we just assume eveyrone is different and therefore can we not have an opinion about anything? You don't know anything about me, where I'm from or my neurodiversity.

I'm happy to discuss but this is intended to be lighthearted and you're a bit aggressive tbh.

@BloodyHellKen There are definitely cultural differences I'm aware of (half my family is from a different country) and it's interesting what counts as good manners in different countries. You often know when it's a cultural thing though and I'm thinking of situations when it doesn't seem to be ie people who were born and raised here.

@Abitofalark i haven't noticed this but I'm sure I will now!

OP posts:
pippapipps · 20/10/2023 13:13

YANBU I'm always holding doors open for people in shops etc and rarely do I get even a smile!! Really pisses me off so rude to not even achknowledge with a smile grrrrrrr
Yet I keep holding doors open for these people because I'd feel ignorant not too😳

Mamma2017 · 20/10/2023 13:09

People too entitled to feel they should use basic manners these days. No one has any patience either.

AgnesX · 20/10/2023 13:06

In the example you gave, it sounded more like question without the question mark.

You're not wrong though. Basic good manners seem to be thin on the ground especially online sometimes.

Blossomandblooms · 20/10/2023 13:04

Totally NBU. I HATE it when people take something / ask for something without the obligatory "please" and "thank you". My DC are well mannered and always mind their Ps and Qs - anyone who says otherwise is likely just rude and obviously doesn't realise it (obviously excluding people who are ND).

Abitofalark · 20/10/2023 13:01

In shops it has changed a lot. When staff say 'five pounds fifty', it feels as if there's something missing. There's a space where 'please' should be. When they ask me if I want a bag, I say 'No, thank you', or a receipt 'Yes, please.' It would be blunt and would feel rude to say just 'No' or 'Yes'. When they give you your change, in most cases they don't say how much they are giving you, which used to be standard. And at the end of the transaction when you say 'Thank you', they don't. Sometimes they do say 'You're welcome' but the concept of thanking you for your custom or signing off with a polite expression of general thanks on completion of the transaction has been lost.

BloodyHellKen · 20/10/2023 12:38

YANBU I really dislike it when people don't use basic manners and forget to use please and thank you. I've brought all our children up to be polite but I still hear them not thanking people unfortunately.

I've also worked with lots of people from all over and noticed that some cultures don't seem to bother with please and thank you and are generally so much more direct with each other - Scandinavians, I'm looking at you 😂

rocknrollaa · 20/10/2023 12:25

@amiboverd I am annoyed that you picked out neurodiversity from several things I listed in my post, and claimed that too many people use it as an 'excuse'. You obviously lack understanding and I am interested that you did not make the same claim about cultural differences.

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 20/10/2023 12:03

ButteryNuts · 20/10/2023 09:45

I say please because it's expected and seen as polite, but don't actually care if people use it or not.

I find 'please' quite rude personally and feel uncomfortable saying it, even though I do. It reminds me of a begging kid going PLEASE MUM PLEEEEEEEEEASE to get what they want. If I ask 'Can you do this?' is a genuine question and request. 'Can you do this please?' feels like a manipulation to try make them do it and like there's less of a choice?

Definitely the odd one out with this, but no, i don't care if someone says please as long as they're polite and say thank you.

I've never thought of it like that before. Strange

amiboverd · 20/10/2023 11:09

@rocknrollaa It's not like I like I let it ruin my day or anything but I notice! I definitely don't think I'm right and everyone else is wrong and I wasn't picking on anything in your post. This is just a discussion. I was interested in what people thought. You sound a bit annoyed!

@ButteryNuts That's an interesting take and I know what you mean actually.

@Trisolaris No standalone email just assuming I can do it and not really even asking.

@LuckySantangelo35 Haha I wondered too!

OP posts:
LuckySantangelo35 · 20/10/2023 10:20

LauraFlex · 20/10/2023 09:29

Yabu

@LauraFlex

is she? Why?

Catza · 20/10/2023 10:10

Doesn't bother me in the slightest. I get a lot of work emails with requests and it never even occurred to me to scan them for inclusion of please and thank you. They usually come in a format of "If you have time, would you mind looking at X and giving me some feedback" or "any chance you have a cancellation and can see this person before the 20th of November" which are perfectly polite requests even though they don't contain buzz words. Also if I had a conversation with someone on the phone or in person and they mentioned wanting me something to review an email follow up with "here is the thing for feedback" is perfectly fine.
I was also brought up in a different culture and what I find amusing having lived in Britain for 25 years is how wonderfully polite you guys are in person and then judge people in the privacy of your own home or anonymously on the internet. My friends gasp if I tell a server the meal was cold when they ask me if everything was alright. How impolite! But, apparently, perfectly polite to tell them everything was fine and then tell strangers online that they had the worst meal in their life and to never set foot in the establishment.

Trisolaris · 20/10/2023 09:57

@rocknrollaa

Similarly to this one I notice a lot culturally is that in English whilst we say ‘you’re welcome’ sometimes as a response to ‘Thank you’ it isn’t required whereas other languages e.g Italian it’s rude not to respond.

rocknrollaa · 20/10/2023 09:52

@amiboverd Also - neurodiversity is just one of many reasons someone might behave differently to the way you would expect them to. I'm not sure why you just picked that out of my post. Some cultures don't even have a word for please and don't put as much emphasis on it. Some people had different backgrounds/ upbringings/ expectations. Some people just think a bit differently to you.

I just think it's completely pointless to project your own (ultimately fairly random) cultural expectations onto other people.

Just accept people as they are unless they are actually being rude to you.

Trisolaris · 20/10/2023 09:51

I find work emails are an interesting one as too many ‘pleases’ in an email looks repetitive but if I’m asking someone to do something I think it should include a please and a thank you.

In the example you have given ‘article below for feedback’ I would presume that either a please is included earlier in the email (if there is more detail you haven’t mentioned) or if that was the entire email that you were asked in earlier emails/calls to feedback on the article and that a please had already been given at that time. It seems like a short follow up email when I would not expect a please.

ButteryNuts · 20/10/2023 09:45

I say please because it's expected and seen as polite, but don't actually care if people use it or not.

I find 'please' quite rude personally and feel uncomfortable saying it, even though I do. It reminds me of a begging kid going PLEASE MUM PLEEEEEEEEEASE to get what they want. If I ask 'Can you do this?' is a genuine question and request. 'Can you do this please?' feels like a manipulation to try make them do it and like there's less of a choice?

Definitely the odd one out with this, but no, i don't care if someone says please as long as they're polite and say thank you.

rocknrollaa · 20/10/2023 09:45

@amiboverd Well at the end of the day you're the only person who you're bothering with this sort of reaction? So what's the point? Other people will behave this way so you can accept it or not, but if you don't it's only you who gets upset.

It seems to me like there is no rude intention in either of these examples so I think you are just getting annoyed about nothing tbh. No one is being actively rude to you.

bennyonthedispatch · 20/10/2023 09:44

This drives me barmy.

I speak on a police radio all day at work and always say please when tasking cops, even though its their job. My colleagues take the piss out of me and task without the 'please' and 'thank you' but I am naturally very polite and think manners cost nothing. And it helps me build up good working relationships.

My kids have good manners, I may not have done much else right but I am incredibly proud of their manners.

rainbowsparkle28 · 20/10/2023 09:44

YANBU. It takes one extra word to say please and is basic manners.

amiboverd · 20/10/2023 09:43

Sorry the second part of that response was to @rocknrollaa

OP posts:
amiboverd · 20/10/2023 09:42

@PriOn1 Because they were asking me to review it for them. If I was sending something to someone senior and asking for them to check it or asking them for feedback I'd say please eg Please can you review this and let me know if you have any feedback?

I know what you're saying and in my house people didn't say thank you each other as they did in DH's for example but I'd asking a stranger to go get you something from a shop, package and post it for you a "please" would come naturally.

I think neurodiversity is used as an excuse for anything. That could apply to anyone. Should we not have social standards any more because of this? Genuine question. I know not everyone will agree with me.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread