Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People not saying "please"

83 replies

amiboverd · 20/10/2023 09:27

AIBU to think people should say please when asking for something?

Maybe I'm just old fashioned but I find it grating when someone asks for something and don't say please.

Example - someone I don't know on a Facebook group asking me to pick something up form as shop and post it to them (after I had offered to do this for someone else) and they said something like "if you see one you could get another and I could pay?"

It also happens at work. People send me things like "Article below for feedback".

I must sound like a such a bore but AIBU? Would you say please in these circumstances and would be be annoyed if someone didn't?

OP posts:
HercuIesMorse · 22/10/2023 14:21

ButteryNuts · 20/10/2023 09:45

I say please because it's expected and seen as polite, but don't actually care if people use it or not.

I find 'please' quite rude personally and feel uncomfortable saying it, even though I do. It reminds me of a begging kid going PLEASE MUM PLEEEEEEEEEASE to get what they want. If I ask 'Can you do this?' is a genuine question and request. 'Can you do this please?' feels like a manipulation to try make them do it and like there's less of a choice?

Definitely the odd one out with this, but no, i don't care if someone says please as long as they're polite and say thank you.

Agree.

If someone was directly given something/had something done and refused to say thank you, I would find that much more rude.

As long as the tone is polite and there's a thank you, please is not needed. As you said? It can almost feel presumptive/manipulative to say please.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/10/2023 14:18

Tone and attitude of the conversation is far more important than the actual words used

While I agree with this, please and thank you are shorthand for so much and for me it's not so much "why use them?" as "why not"

It really doesn't take any extra effort, and even if it did what's the harm in trying to be pleasant?

salamithumbs · 22/10/2023 13:49

I think it's rude not to say thanks, but I don't think please is really necessary if the tone is polite, ie 'would you mind doing xyz,' or 'could you pass me the x'.. in fact I think please sounds vaguely passive aggressive somehow! Maybe because I only really hear people using please when they're already annoyed ie 'would you please just stop that'

Tlolljs · 22/10/2023 13:22

I always say please and thank you. So do my children and grandchildren.
If I’m in a shop and the worker just asks for the money I will stand there until they ask properly.

Rummikub · 22/10/2023 13:19

i don’t routinely say please.

Never brought up to day it. Not even a word for it in my parents language.

I’ve tried to remember to do it but it feels alien to
me and also a bit fake.

Agree with pp of depends on tone.

Thank you or showing appreciation is more important imo.

ChlorrOfTheMask · 22/10/2023 13:11

rocknrollaa · 20/10/2023 12:25

@amiboverd I am annoyed that you picked out neurodiversity from several things I listed in my post, and claimed that too many people use it as an 'excuse'. You obviously lack understanding and I am interested that you did not make the same claim about cultural differences.

Yup. Finally find out at 34 that I'm not an oversensitive, lazy, rubbish failure as I'd thought all my life but an auDHD person trying to live up to neurotypical expectations unsupported, then bam! Along come the "everyone's neurodivergent these days it's just an excuse" crew to knock me down again because I don't deserve self acceptance or self esteem. Cheers folks.

theduchessofspork · 22/10/2023 13:01

Defaultsettings · 20/10/2023 14:58

So “Get me that document by 5pm please” is better than “The deadline for that document is 6pm, so it would great if I could have it by 5pm so we’re on track to deliver”?

Tone and attitude of the conversation is far more important than the actual words used.

The first is actually better, because it gives the key info first. The below would be even better, because the recipient also understands why. I am being picky obviously, but people are crap at absorbing emails and get far too many, so cutting all the fluff is a good thing.

— ‘get it to me by 5, so I can review and send for the 6pm deadline. Thanks.’

ChlorrOfTheMask · 22/10/2023 12:57

To me "please may I" would sound strange and come across icily formal, maybe even passive aggressive.. but then in the area I grew up in nobody ever said "please may I" even 30 years ago. We always said "can I get a whatever please." I say please and thank you but it doesn't bother me when others don't. Tone affects me more; if someone is warm, kind and friendly I feel safe and reassured in that social interaction, no matter what wording they use, but if someone is coldly polite I feel anxious and upset, wondering what I did to annoy them/make them dislike me. Again where I'm from people often swear and call one another names while being friendly. Warmth over manners for me, definitely.

JudgeJ · 22/10/2023 12:56

pippapipps · 20/10/2023 13:13

YANBU I'm always holding doors open for people in shops etc and rarely do I get even a smile!! Really pisses me off so rude to not even achknowledge with a smile grrrrrrr
Yet I keep holding doors open for these people because I'd feel ignorant not too😳

Even before I escaped teaching 18 years ago manners were seen by a certain type to be a joke, if I said Excuse me to try and get by pupils crowding the corridor there were always a few smart arses who would reply Why, wotcherdun? It was no surprise that the majority of these were in the lower sets.

theduchessofspork · 22/10/2023 12:55

The first one it’s cheeky to ask at all, but yes a please would help

The second email one I think is fine. I am a big please and thank you person, but if it’s a standard task on an email it isn’t necessary. In Britain we can sometimes overdo the floweryness in work correspondence and it doesn’t help people get to the point.

Annio82 · 22/10/2023 12:50

thaisweetchill · 20/10/2023 15:32

Yep, hate it. Even more so since becoming a mother, if my son asks for anything I won't do it until he says please. A family member has the MOST terrible manners and I find myself ending his requests with 'please?' sarcastically, I can't help myself.

Do you realise that actually that makes you the rude one?

This whole concept of specific words being the difference between polite and ill mannered boggles my mind a bit. I’d be more offended by someone who was impolite but ended with a please or thank you than I would if someone was polite but didn’t use please/thanks

HundredMilesAnHour · 22/10/2023 12:02

Always using please and thank you was drummed in to me by my parents when I was a small child and I don't think I could actually stop using them even if I tried. I even catch myself saying "no thank you" to Alexa😂

I find people without manners very irritating. If they want something from me, they need to use please or quite simply they will get nowhere. I'm polite but firm.

Kwasi · 22/10/2023 11:51

As someone with a strong English background, I would typically use please for requests, not questions. In the case of the person on Facebook, they’re asking you a question rather than making a request; at least that’s my interpretation.

As for the email you mentioned, I see no reason to add please. The sender is stating a fact/providing you with information. I think you’re being very anal there.

maddiemookins16mum · 22/10/2023 11:09

I had an office day last week, usually I WFH, another colleague messaged me on Teams the day before with this….

’Can you pick me up tomorrow?”

I ignored it.

DRS1970 · 22/10/2023 10:40

I agree they should really say please, or at the very least say thanks.

DragonDoor · 22/10/2023 10:39

Defaultsettings · 20/10/2023 14:58

So “Get me that document by 5pm please” is better than “The deadline for that document is 6pm, so it would great if I could have it by 5pm so we’re on track to deliver”?

Tone and attitude of the conversation is far more important than the actual words used.

I agree.

I also share the view with some pp’s that adding please and thankyou to a request in a email can make it sound quite presumptuous.

It depends on the power dynamic between who is communicating with whom.

E.g. From someone’s manager , a message along the lines of

’Please can you do X Y Z . Thanks.’

Would be fine. But if that request came from the staff member to the manager, or to a colleague, it could read as a bit cheeky imho.

SoShallINever · 22/10/2023 10:39

YANBU but it would be helpful if you'd enabled voting.

Clarebabes · 22/10/2023 10:31

Re: neurodiversity, my son is on the spectrum, would be diagnosed with Asperger’s syndrome if it still was a thing, but he always uses please and thank you! It’s about teaching basic manners. He is always getting house points at school for good manners and that makes me so proud.

I have friends with kids who don’t say please and thank you and I have to catch myself saying, ‘what comes next?’ 🤣

Rufusroo · 22/10/2023 10:10

I sent my niece a really expensive dressing gown for her 14th birthday (it was what she had asked for). I didn’t hear anything back - not even that it had arrived. Eventually I asked her mum if she’d liked it. You could hear the shrug in her voice as she replied “Well, she’s wearing it”.
Never sent anything ever again

Normalweirdo · 22/10/2023 09:23

I had an acquaintance point out that my husband and I don't say please but do say thank you and how she thought that very rude. I found her pointing it out quite rude. She also swears like a trooper regardless of company or surroundings and will at length discuss personal matters, politics and money in lose social groups haha so I guess her rude and my rude are different.

thaisweetchill · 20/10/2023 15:32

Yep, hate it. Even more so since becoming a mother, if my son asks for anything I won't do it until he says please. A family member has the MOST terrible manners and I find myself ending his requests with 'please?' sarcastically, I can't help myself.

AGoodDayForSomebodyElseToDie · 20/10/2023 15:11

I wouldn’t stick a please on the end of either of the examples in the OP, as to my mind that wouldn’t make either more polite. “Please” on the end of a request can sound quite shitty and presumptuous in some circumstances. I would, however, rework the sentences to make the requests more open / easier to refuse, and include some indicator of gratitude.

But then, I also don’t thank people who let me out at junctions either, unless it’s actually a sensible and safe decision (and often, it isn’t).

coxesorangepippin · 20/10/2023 15:01

I've noticed people don't say thanks

Which really gets my goat

Defaultsettings · 20/10/2023 14:58

So “Get me that document by 5pm please” is better than “The deadline for that document is 6pm, so it would great if I could have it by 5pm so we’re on track to deliver”?

Tone and attitude of the conversation is far more important than the actual words used.

rocknrollaa · 20/10/2023 14:36

I'm happy to discuss but this is intended to be lighthearted and you're a bit aggressive tbh.

Saying that neurodiversity is used as an excuse is not lighthearted. It's ignorant and deserves to be called out.