Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Poll. Did you stick to the high street or switch to out of town?

161 replies

IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 08:52

Not a taat but inspired by. Purely because I'm curious and polls make posters honest 😁

High streets are ghost towns now. When the alternatives that led to this happening first sprung up did you

YABU - I stuck to the high street 80%-100% of the time until the shops all closed and I had absolutely no alternative.

YANBU - I switched to the big supermarkets and the retail parks and home delivery etc 80% - 100% of the time

If you are too young to have had the choice please don't vote 😁

OP posts:
shockeditellyou · 20/10/2023 09:38

I would say that 90% of my shopping is on line. My local big town is only 7 miles away but traffic is horrendous and public transport non existent. If it's just me I'll cycle in but if I need to bring the kids with me it's a bit of an expedition - parking is also extortionate.

We also don't really have much in the way of out-of-town near us - we'd have to drive 30mins or so and at that point I'd rather buy stuff on line.

AIstolemylunch · 20/10/2023 09:35

Ah yes, if no discussion allowed and we have to accept the OP premises then I am old enough to remember high streets of the 80s, even 70s as a small child and yes, I happily switched to the alternatives as soon as they became available - online travel agents, online banking, Amazon and online ordering of clothes, roughly in that order.

LauraFlex · 20/10/2023 09:33

@IncompleteSenten you know this is an open forum right?

Your posts trying to gate keep who responds are a bit weird

Coffeerum · 20/10/2023 09:32

IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 09:19

Also can I just repeat I said
"When the alternatives that led to this happening first sprung up did you"

im not talking about now where really there's not much choice. I wanted to know when the alternatives were first built and you could still get everything on the high street did you carry on using it, therefore contributing to its survival or did you switch, taking your money to the alternatives and contributing to it being the way it is now.

I'm not judging btw! I did that latter and voted yanbu myself.

I'm just curious.

This isn't really a logical question though. You're saying that everyone could always get what they wanted all of the time on the highstreet but that is just incorrect. Larger shops or supermarkets found a gap and tailored their supply to demand. If it was easier or more convenient for some people to shop in town centres then they wouldn't shop in retail parks, but clearly due to the rise of them many people found them preferable in some way.

AIstolemylunch · 20/10/2023 09:32

I also disagree that high streets are dead ghost towns. Most of the chain shops and banks have gone, agreed, largely due to what PP have said, their own greed and inflexibility and unwillingness to change. Everyone else has adapted and evolved, or are starting to. So now High Streets (if they are controlled by clever and more forward thinking people) have become/are becoming experience destinations. You can't buy a relaxing coffee with friends online, or a nice meal, or a drink in a pub, or get a haircut, or a tattoo, or take a class.

So for me, I'm more than happy to buy virtualy everything I need online in terms of physical things - it has long worked better for people who work full-time.I do my banking and savings in apps - way easier to control and move your money (I accept this is not great for the generation or 2 before me but everyone else is ok with it I think). I abandoned high street travel agents decades ago, long before the 'death of the high street' because they were never competitively priced. I then use supermarkets for food shopping in person (and these are in town where I lived though it wouldn't bother me if they were out of town) and out of town place when I want to actually look at things before I buy them, IKEA, B&Q etc.

But then I spend many happy hours a week in one of the 3 or 4 local high streets near where I live. I work from home so I often go to one of the local cafes and coffee shops that have sprung up in place of the shops. We use the pubs, restaurants and hairdressers. I use the small gyms that have taken over some of the premises. There are regular food markets and street events with bands and stalls. The high street pubs are busy and thriving. There's a walk in repair cafe, drop in centre for older people on their own. It's generally become a more sociable experience I think.

I personally think 'death of the high street' is over exaggerated. It's is (or should) just evolve to meet the way people live now, my generation and down anyway (again, I accept that older people might need some assistance with the transition).

Taylorswiftserastour · 20/10/2023 09:31

Our nearest high street is pretty busy - few cafes and restaurants, supermarket, b&m, superdrug, a book and gift shop, lots of charity shops too. No post office, only one bank left. No where to buy clothes either. I do pop in for essentials a couple of times a week but I can easily walk there because otherwise you have to pay to park.

Big retail park is about 15 minute drive away and free to park so go there for clothes shopping or to collect orders. DS mostly wears m&s and next as they're both on the retail park!

I very rarely go shopping in our closest city centre now, lots of brands have left so not as much choice, it's expensive to park, expensive if you get public transport there, and it's really busy at the weekends (and full of stag & hen dos).

8ahwe · 20/10/2023 09:27

i prefer high streets as they are more interesting places than retail parks

HollisMann · 20/10/2023 09:27

Our high st is OK, but if you need an example of what out of town shopping has done to the high st, Bangor (Wales not N.I) is an absolute shocker. Nice place but the high st is derelict. Was really shocked when I visited after many years away.

I do a mixture of both. Parking on the high st is only free for an hr and it's not long enough to have lunch/coffee plus have a good wander. Plus it's a job finding a space. Otherwise it's expensive parking.
We don't have a mall here, but I have to admit the one thing I like about places like the Trafford Centre is not having to wear bulky clothes in winter or the on/off of the coat when you go in and out of shops, even worse when it's raining.

Toddlerteaplease · 20/10/2023 09:24

I only live a 20 minute walk from the city centre. So town for me. However with the fridge of Wilko there is nowhere to buy good quality household stuff in town. No B&M or Home bargins.

IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 09:21

It's also why I asked those of you too young to remember the traditional high street please not vote. 😁

OP posts:
IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 09:19

Also can I just repeat I said
"When the alternatives that led to this happening first sprung up did you"

im not talking about now where really there's not much choice. I wanted to know when the alternatives were first built and you could still get everything on the high street did you carry on using it, therefore contributing to its survival or did you switch, taking your money to the alternatives and contributing to it being the way it is now.

I'm not judging btw! I did that latter and voted yanbu myself.

I'm just curious.

OP posts:
YourNameGoesHere · 20/10/2023 09:19

I've tried to use the high street several times in the past few weeks to buy bog standard items e.g a kids white shirt, a pair of toddler gloves and some craft tape and each time they've not had what I needed and have more than once directed me to order online.

I've all but given up and if I had to visit physical stores I'd rather use a retail park or super market at least then I wouldn't have to pay for parking.

Graciebobcat · 20/10/2023 09:18

I have limited sympathy for the whole demise of the high street thing. Most town councils/landlords/retailers in ghost high streets were greedy, short sighted and/or resistant to change so only have themselves to blame.

Exactly. Plus the dull chain stores is what killed retail. Homogenity and lack of consumer choice. Plus opening 9-5 while loads of people are at work - duh.

Acornsoup · 20/10/2023 09:15

Combination but mostly retail park and supermarkets. A big chain near me as a private company operating their car park and that has put most people after fines for being too long or the machine being ooo and getting a fine anyway. Parking and convenience are the biggest factor IMO.

LauraFlex · 20/10/2023 09:15

Neither

i do 99% of my shopping online

CalistoNoSolo · 20/10/2023 09:14

I stopped using the high street shops years ago due to really poor choice and inflated prices. When dd was little (mid to late 2000's) there was no way to buy her clothes other than online or travelling 45mins for crap parking and crap choice. I have limited sympathy for the whole demise of the high street thing. Most town councils/landlords/retailers in ghost high streets were greedy, short sighted and/or resistant to change so only have themselves to blame.

IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 09:13

SM4713 · 20/10/2023 09:04

What is a taat and what type of shopping are you asking about? Clothes, homewares, food shopping or something else?

My high street is far from a ghost town!

Thread about a thread.

Traditional high street where you would buy your food every week (or few days. If you had to get the bus or walk you'd only carry a few bags), get yourself some new clothes and a pair of shoes when needed, pop into the electronics shop to get your toaster fixed once in a blue moon, go to the bank to draw out some money or cash a cheque, get a paper and a comic from the newsagents etc. That sort of thing. When I was a kid that's what we did. Also visited the sweet shop far too often.

OP posts:
KirstenBlest · 20/10/2023 09:13

High street - about 10 minutes walk.
Out of town - car or bus journey. The stores there aren't very appealing. Traffic is quite bad a lot of the time. Not many parking spaces.

Graciebobcat · 20/10/2023 09:12

I was an early adopter of online shopping. I always hated traipsing round the shops looking for things and don't do and never did shopping as a hobby. I like mooching around high street independent shops and browsing bookshops when I don't have anything particular to buy.

CatOnTheCarpet · 20/10/2023 09:09

High street is booming where I live.

PuttingDownRoots · 20/10/2023 09:08

Do I
A) travel 20 minutes to town centre, pay £5 to park, for less shops
Or B)
Travel 30 minutes to out of town shopping centre, with free parking and more shops?

I rarely go shopping... but its more likely to be B.

KirstenBlest · 20/10/2023 09:08

@SM4713 , TAAT - thread about a thread

@IncompleteSenten , I've always stuck to the high street

Mummy08m · 20/10/2023 09:08

Omg I was thinking of starting a thread just to rant about my recent experience.

Went to a big high street shopping area a 20min train ride away to get some winter maternity clothes. (Because I'm starting my third trimester but all my maternity stuff from prev pregnancy is summer stuff).

Let me tell you, I am not fussy. Just anything that vaguely fits and is warm and not too scratchy and I'm basically willing to pay whatever. Any style, any colour. But I'd rather not buy online as I'd rather try stuff on

I tried:
M+S
Next
Tkmaxx
New Look
River island
H+M - temporarily closed
Debenham - permanently closed

And every SINGLE one (except the ones that were closed altogether) said their maternity range was online only. Bearing in mind a) this isn't clear when you look up their "store finder". Also b) I have PGP so hauling my huge person from shop to shop took me ages and got painful.

The ONLY shop with maternity in-store was Primark (I could have hugged the sales assistant who told me), although it was a small section but I almost cried with relief by that point - and I saw they had some fabulous maternity jogger bottoms. Fab, I think! They're reduced from like £15 to £5...er...this is almost too good? Because the entire rail was only XS and XXL. The XS was creepy small like for a pregnant child. The XXL wouldn't have stayed up. I would have accepted S, M or L and made do. I did buy two t shirts.

The high street deserves to die. The rare time I actually need to try stuff on is when my body has changed.

SM4713 · 20/10/2023 09:04

What is a taat and what type of shopping are you asking about? Clothes, homewares, food shopping or something else?

My high street is far from a ghost town!

IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 09:03

My village has the traditional small shops plus coffee shops etc . It's a massive tourist village in a national park and the tourists keep them going. Us locals mostly drive out or have home delivery. I read other posters not in tourist areas talk about how their high streets are mostly closed shops or pound shops. So my own high street exists (no banks or clothing shops though)

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread