Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Poll. Did you stick to the high street or switch to out of town?

161 replies

IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 08:52

Not a taat but inspired by. Purely because I'm curious and polls make posters honest 😁

High streets are ghost towns now. When the alternatives that led to this happening first sprung up did you

YABU - I stuck to the high street 80%-100% of the time until the shops all closed and I had absolutely no alternative.

YANBU - I switched to the big supermarkets and the retail parks and home delivery etc 80% - 100% of the time

If you are too young to have had the choice please don't vote 😁

OP posts:
AIstolemylunch · 20/10/2023 10:54

alloalloallo · 20/10/2023 10:23

A combination mostly

I use supermarkets mostly for food shopping. We do have a fab butchers and greengrocers in my local town that I use if I’m feeling a bit flush - they’re quite a bit more expensive than the supermarkets unfortunately.

Clothes, etc, usually online shopping - where I live, there are fuck all clothes shops. Either online or I’ll go to the city nearby.

My local, small, nice town the high street is flourishing tbh. We’ve got a good variety of small independent shops and the town is busy all year round these days. It used to be very seasonal - I live in a holiday area. I can wander down, have a mooch, nice lunch and wander back home.

Our main town is dying on its arse. Even H&M shipped out. Nearly every other shop is empty. The council is putting various ‘hubs’ into the empty shops, which is great on one hand, but we need actual shops. Not helped by £6 for 2 hour parking charges.

Edited

I think this poster raises an interesting point. This is close to what I see around where I live too (southeast/Greater London). Very local high streets i.e the one most people can walk to are the ones that are in better shape with cafes, bars, independent shops. The actual 'nearest town' ones are the ones that are looking like ghost towns sometimes. i.e the county/bigger towns that serve lots of local communities. I guess these are the ones that suffer more from the fact that local government has consistently failed to maintain decent bus routes to get to them and have overseen the extortionate parking charges. Really I see this as a failure of local government over the last few decades.

IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 10:52

What on earth makes you think I'm being patronising?

OP posts:
Mummy08m · 20/10/2023 10:47

IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 09:19

Also can I just repeat I said
"When the alternatives that led to this happening first sprung up did you"

im not talking about now where really there's not much choice. I wanted to know when the alternatives were first built and you could still get everything on the high street did you carry on using it, therefore contributing to its survival or did you switch, taking your money to the alternatives and contributing to it being the way it is now.

I'm not judging btw! I did that latter and voted yanbu myself.

I'm just curious.

It is simply not in the power of the individual consumer to contribute meaningfully to the survival (or demise) of the high street.

I am "old enough to remember" the high street, yes, no need to be patronising though. It used to sell things I needed. It no longer sells things I need. It's that simple.

As soon as it goes back to selling the things I need, I will use it.

I do use the high street for:

  • Independent shops selling miscellaneous hardware goods eg when I need a drain plug of a specific size
  • Shonky phone repair shops, you know type - they've been a godsend at times
  • Key cutting and shoe cobbling
  • Independent cheap housekeeping shops that sell buckets, plastic stools, nylon bags, peg octopuses, etc

Clothes? No. Read my anecdote upthread. Clothes shops on the high street are not fit for purpose.

PinkRoses1245 · 20/10/2023 10:34

Coffeerum · 20/10/2023 08:54

High streets are ghost towns now.

Really not my experience at all.

not my experience either, we have a great high street in my town, and also great shops in nearby city. Saying that I do shop online quite a bit to save time as I dislike shopping

DonnaGiovanna · 20/10/2023 10:30

I'm sitting in a coffee shop in my mid-sized town high street watching a steady stream of people saunter past. It's not dead yet but unreasonable landlords and chain store management are doing their best (we have the last high street M&S in the county but it's just announced plans to move to the new retail park).

IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 10:29

Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 10:21

@IncompleteSenten to be honest in my 1980s childhood hometown (medium size Midlands market town) there was a busy "High Street" and large market twice a week but when it came to a big clothes shop or a special purchase we went to Birmingham or Milton Keynes because that's where the department stores (BHS, C+A in them days) were.
Now that town has large out of town shopping areas - and actually has the shops we could only dream of in the 80s (obviously 21st century versions).
It doesn't matter to me if those shops are in the "Town Centre" or on the edge of town. I still have to take a bus to get there. Doesn't make a difference to me if I am getting a bus from A-B or A-C.

We used to go once a year to C&A in the nearest city . It was really exciting I remember. I used to look forward to that more than the school holidays. We'd sometimes go into town on market day. Half an hour by bus. We'd have lunch in Littlewoods cafe and look round all the market stalls.

I feel about a hundred years old right now 😂

OP posts:
ApolloandDaphne · 20/10/2023 10:29

We have a very vibrant town centre with lots of shops which I use a lot. I also use the supermarket on the edge of town as it's the only decent sized one locally. There is an Aldi and an M&S foodhall in the vicinity of the supermarket to give choice.

Oreosareawful · 20/10/2023 10:24

I switched.

High street shops are more expensive and less convenient. I would much sooner drive out to a retail park with free parking.

I only use the high street a couple of times during the week as I can walk from my office. But theres very little choice out there.

Torganer · 20/10/2023 10:24

My nearest JL etc., is Oxford Circus. I try and avoid that as much as possible and it’s manic and more difficult now with a toddler and trying to carry shopping. We sometimes drive to Stratford Westfield as we can more easily park. We mostly shop online now as it’s more convenient (prefer do more fun things on the weekend than shop). We are fortunate to have an excellent fishmonger and grocer 5m walk from our house so I often pop out at lunch to get fish and vegetables for dinner. Heavy and bulky items are done online.

alloalloallo · 20/10/2023 10:23

A combination mostly

I use supermarkets mostly for food shopping. We do have a fab butchers and greengrocers in my local town that I use if I’m feeling a bit flush - they’re quite a bit more expensive than the supermarkets unfortunately.

Clothes, etc, usually online shopping - where I live, there are fuck all clothes shops. Either online or I’ll go to the city nearby.

My local, small, nice town the high street is flourishing tbh. We’ve got a good variety of small independent shops and the town is busy all year round these days. It used to be very seasonal - I live in a holiday area. I can wander down, have a mooch, nice lunch and wander back home.

Our main town is dying on its arse. Even H&M shipped out. Nearly every other shop is empty. The council is putting various ‘hubs’ into the empty shops, which is great on one hand, but we need actual shops. Not helped by £6 for 2 hour parking charges.

Pourmeanotherwine · 20/10/2023 10:22

Used to be a city centre shopper, as it's a 30 min nice walk round the docks and I like to try things on. However now M&S have left our city centre and Debenhams closed, there are not many shops I like. Also my walking route is now a main road one due to a pedestrian bridge being closed for repairs for 2 years. So may have to drive to the out of town one instead.
We do most of the food shop in a supermarket, but sometimes get bits from the greengrocers.

Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 10:21

@IncompleteSenten to be honest in my 1980s childhood hometown (medium size Midlands market town) there was a busy "High Street" and large market twice a week but when it came to a big clothes shop or a special purchase we went to Birmingham or Milton Keynes because that's where the department stores (BHS, C+A in them days) were.
Now that town has large out of town shopping areas - and actually has the shops we could only dream of in the 80s (obviously 21st century versions).
It doesn't matter to me if those shops are in the "Town Centre" or on the edge of town. I still have to take a bus to get there. Doesn't make a difference to me if I am getting a bus from A-B or A-C.

Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 10:11

Big food shop I do as home delivery because I have no car.
Anything else I go where the shop I want is. I shop at retailers that have branches in both "High Streets", shopping centres and "out of town" retail parks. I am not especially loyal to one shopping area. Often my decision is made by which bus turns up first.

Mountainhowl · 20/10/2023 10:10

I mostly shop online and have for years, it's a lot easier for me to:

  • Keep track of how much I've spent
  • Not get distracted in shops and forget what I'm there for
  • actually find what I need without spending hours going in and out of different shops

I enjoyed the high street as a teen, and still go in occasionally (usually to get the kids feet measured & try on shoes), but online is so much more convenient

IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 10:07

Trying to think now what shops we had in the high street when I was a kid.

our high street had 2 banks, 2 greengrocers, a bakery, a cafe, a pharmacy, a sweet shop, a newsagent, a couple of clothes shops, a shoe shop, a hardware shop, a pet shop, umpteen pubs, a travel agent, electronics shop where you could buy new, rent a TV or get appliances repaired, council office where you'd go to pay your rent and report repairs, general food shops, hair dresser, barber, doctor, dentist, petrol pumps - run by the hardware/DIY supplies shop I seem to recall.

Trying to think what else. Newsagent & tobacconist, florist, chip shop, garage oh we had a little branch of English furnishing stores. Jewellery shop. Baby clothes and stuff shop. A shop that sold all manner of random stuff. Im sure I've forgotten some. Optician.

You could get everything you needed. You might not have had a lot of choice but you wouldn't be missing anything vital.

OP posts:
RedPony1 · 20/10/2023 10:07

I havent used the town centre here for many many years. i only use OOT places where parking is free

Bluevelvetsofa · 20/10/2023 10:05

I used to regularly visit the high street, when we first lived here nine years ago. Within a short time, one or two shops closed, but after March 2020, it’s been a rapid decline. There’s no point in trying to shop for clothes, because the only clothes shops left are Oliver Bonas, Mint Velvet and Phase 8.

There are plenty of coffee shops, restaurants and hairdressers and the beautiful building that housed House of Fraser has been empty since 2019.

The only thing to do is to shop online and get things delivered to a hub.

AlwaysPrettyOnTheInside · 20/10/2023 10:02

I voted YABU. The council make it so difficult to access the high street, people were forced onto retail parks.

  • One way streets surrounding the high street corralling everyone onto the same route causing ridiculous traffic.
  • Red routes.
  • No parking spaces.
  • Ridiculous fees to park.
  • Then the invention of fucking apps that never work, to pay for parking.
  • Huge pedestrianised areas making it difficult for people with mobility issues.

Blame the councils for killing the high street, not shoppers.

TigerRag · 20/10/2023 09:59

Switched. We have so many shops that are similar but different brands. (charity shops, coffee shops, etc)

randomsabreuse · 20/10/2023 09:56

Demise of the high street is very much self inflicted/caused by council greed tbh.

Council issues
Rubbish local bus networks meaning getting into town by bus takes a long time and is expensive
Expensive poor quality parking.
Business rates pushing stores away.

Retailer issues
Limited range in store with "see our wider range online" plastered all over it
Poor quality, if the fabrics are all shite no point feeling them
Poor trying on options.

I'd happily pay more to get what I want on the high street, I won't pay more to get something a bit like what I want but not really...

TizerorFizz · 20/10/2023 09:52

On line for most clothes. Occasionally go to out of town John Lewis but use supermarkets in towns. Parking is free for 1 hour or 1.5 hours. I have a very decent choice of 4 towns with supermarkets. So after shopping at the supermarket, I visit the High Street. They are all decent where I go so it’s a good combo. I don’t go to any retail parks, except Bicester Village!

IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 09:51

LauraFlex · 20/10/2023 09:33

@IncompleteSenten you know this is an open forum right?

Your posts trying to gate keep who responds are a bit weird

I'm not. Anyone can reply. And are doing. I'm not in charge of that. I don't think I am. It simply appeared that people were answering a question I hadn't asked so I wanted to make sure my actual question was clear. Is that gatekeeping?

I put a poll out of curiosity. I wanted people wIth a specific experience to answer that poll. That's not unreasonable is it?

If I put a poll asking if you've been swimming in the sea did you like it
Yanbu I liked it, yabu I didn't and people posted yabu I've never swum in the sea and I said actually I was asking for the experiences of people who have swum in the sea would that be gatekeeping? Would responses saying I've never swum in the sea be answering my question?

OP posts:
BeckhamSeven · 20/10/2023 09:49

My high street is absolutely packed. I actively avoid it on a Friday as its just so busy 😂 The only high streets I know that have gone downhill are the pedestrianised ones. I used to go twice a week shopping to another nearby town, but I just don't have the time or energy any more. You've got to park 1/2 a mile away to get to it, the whole experience is really draining especially with kids in tow, and most shops aren't accessible.

PurBal · 20/10/2023 09:44

Every time I try the high street they don’t stock what I want (despite it being available online) or the size I need and then tell me to order online anyway. I live rurally so have to drive around anyway and it’s not fuel efficient when I can get stuff delivered, often for free.

Last week I went to buy some coordinating items, you don’t need both items but many people would get both (think matching top and trousers or pillow cases and sheets). They only stocked one half of the coordinating items (not sold out, just didn’t stock in that particular store) and I either had to drive 30 miles to the nearest store that stocked the other half or pay for delivery. I’d already driven 8 miles to go to this shop.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 20/10/2023 09:43

My High street is a 10 minute walk away. I tend to do online food shops especially for bigger, heavier items. The high street is good for certain items like clothes, vintage, specialist shops like picture framers and has recently got a fishmongers and one of the cafes also sells baked bread (expensive though). What I don’t like about some high streets now is you tend to get as in our area a plethora of cafes, restaurants and nail bars. In some nearby high streets there are butchers, fishmongers and more variety but not always the case.

High street is good for some things but as PP says sometimes they don’t have what you need so you end up ordering online or going to a retail park.