Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Poll. Did you stick to the high street or switch to out of town?

161 replies

IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 08:52

Not a taat but inspired by. Purely because I'm curious and polls make posters honest 😁

High streets are ghost towns now. When the alternatives that led to this happening first sprung up did you

YABU - I stuck to the high street 80%-100% of the time until the shops all closed and I had absolutely no alternative.

YANBU - I switched to the big supermarkets and the retail parks and home delivery etc 80% - 100% of the time

If you are too young to have had the choice please don't vote 😁

OP posts:
OldTinHat · 20/10/2023 12:48

I live in a town so tend to pop to the High Street shops and town centre supermarkets - but primarily because the High Street starts at the top of my road so I can walk instead of having to get in the car!

Sartre · 20/10/2023 12:47

Switched because it’s just more convenient and humans naturally like convenience.

user1497207191 · 20/10/2023 12:47

About 20 years ago, switched to out of town retail parks and supermarkets because the stupid council put in crazy one way systems, traffic calming, pedestrianisations, and insane car park charges to discourage people driving into town.

Well it worked.

The town centre soon became a ghost town and nearly all the chain stores have closed leaving just vape shops, betting shops, charity shops, coffee shops and loads of drugged up zombies wondering around. Meanwhile the out of town areas are absolutely heaving with people (who drive there because of free parking, no stupid traffic calming and pedestrianisations etc!).

KirstenBlest · 20/10/2023 12:46

Not all charity shop staff are volunteers. The brilliant one I go to is mainly staffed by employees. During a working day, they get donations and maybe a delivery. A donation might be a carrier bag-ful or 5 bin bags, A delivery could be something like 200 bin bags full of donations.
After they close the shop, they need to re-fill the rails, do the books, clean the shop.
I was shopping there one sunday and they were closing the shop because they only had 2 staff and a big delivery had come in. I insisted that I'd stay and help but they refused, but I helped anyway.
It was hard work even with 3 of us.

The shop is usually very busy. The rails are full of primark, boohoo, shein etc but they often have real finds. Yesterday, I got 5 things, decent condition, brands much-liked on S&B for £16.50.

Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 12:46

@muddyford but she probably meant on their own website. Why didn't you order from them rather than resorting to Amazon? "Online" doesn't just mean Amazon.

maddening · 20/10/2023 12:44

Ps I am northwest based so possible that regional impacts as well

muddyford · 20/10/2023 12:40

I went into a high street shop, last week, to buy a new toaster. I knew roughly what I wanted. Shop had twenty identical ones plus one the same brand I was interested in. I asked an assistant if that was it and was told there was a better selection online. So I went home, ordered it on Amazon and it was delivered, free of charge, within 24 hours.

Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 12:36

@Somewhatchallenging ironically there's probably plenty of people like students who could (and would like to) volunteer at charity shops in the evening.

bugaboo218 · 20/10/2023 12:33

My local town centre high street is dead! It used to be thriving when I was a child in the eighties.

The council charge extortionate car parking fees (2 hours £8 for example) and there are not enough car park spaces . Taking the bus to the bus station isn't great either because they are infrequent and it is a 10-15 min walk to the shops.

The high street used to have a good selection of chain and independent shops , but most have gone now. M and S, Next, Waterstones and Wilko and no post office.

Now all you have is a Sainsbury’s, Boots, Primark, one bank , coffee shops, bookmakers and nail bars.

None of which are of any interest to me. I prefer to shop in person, but like many other people I am busy - I work during the week, opening times on the high street are traditional and inflexible (09:00-17:00) not helpful if you work. At weekends I CBA to go shopping in the high street or at retail parks, so for me I buy 99% of stuff I need online including food shopping.

I would use the high street again if the shops sold what I wanted, customer service in shops was good, they had decent places to have a bite to eat or drink ( not over priced coffee shop food) and I could park.

Do not see that happening any time soon, so I will be sticking to online.shopping.

i have that choice, but I know a number of late middle age /elderly people, who never used computers in their jobs and refuse to learn how to use a computer/ the internet or shop online, they have no real choice but to use the high street for their shopping.

alloalloallo · 20/10/2023 12:32

Yes, our local town used to shut up shop bang on 5:00pm. It’s got much better the last couple of years and they have late night shopping nights, they open later in the summer and stuff like that now.

We are a very tourist town and quite often in the summer you’d mooch down for ice cream or something after dinner. The town would be absolutely rammed with people, but all the shops and stuff would be closed. We have 2 ice cream/dessert shops but they’d close at 4pm so everyone would resort to multi packs from Sainsbury’s.

We have a massive sailing event every year, thousands of people around with money to spend. Other than pubs/restaurants. Everything else is closed.

They then all moan about how it’s been a terrible summer season and the town is dying. It always seemed mad to me. They’re really not helping themselves.

It has got better the last few years I have to say, and some new shops have opened who are opening later.

maddening · 20/10/2023 12:29

I am 45 and was a young teen when I went to the cinema on a retail park and supermarkets were already a thing then so not sure if I am your demographic. Whilst I pretty much stuck to town as a teen and at Uni and in my 20s at some point online shopping became much easier and the choice in town was such that it became a pain - probably over the last 10 years. I only go to retail parks generally for specific shops eg b&q or Clarks outlet

IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 12:28

Oh god. All that's missing now is me telling you that it used to be all fields where the new shopping centre is 🤦

OP posts:
IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 12:27

Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 12:10

@NorthStarRising that is such a thing in many towns - it gets to 5 or 5.30pm and it's "Shutters Down Town Is CLOSED" 😂
They must lose so much potential trade.
More trade, more jobs (staff who work daytime plus different staff who work evenings)...I just don't understand it.
I went to go into a charity shop once and was told "sorry we are closing now". I said something like "Oh...why so early?" - the answer "well it is 4 o'clock" 😂

That takes me back again. Wednesday was half day closing. Shops had really short hours the rest of the week and we never thought anything of it.

OP posts:
Somewhatchallenging · 20/10/2023 12:24

Well, fair enough with the charity shops. They’re staffed by volunteers. If they can’t get the volunteers, they can’t open.

Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 12:10

@NorthStarRising that is such a thing in many towns - it gets to 5 or 5.30pm and it's "Shutters Down Town Is CLOSED" 😂
They must lose so much potential trade.
More trade, more jobs (staff who work daytime plus different staff who work evenings)...I just don't understand it.
I went to go into a charity shop once and was told "sorry we are closing now". I said something like "Oh...why so early?" - the answer "well it is 4 o'clock" 😂

NorthStarRising · 20/10/2023 11:57

I work.
So I’m out of the house by 7.30am and finish around 5pm, five days a week.
Most high st shops close at 5.30-6pm.
I’m not prepared to spend hours trudging around shops at the weekend looking for a specific item, coming home empty-handed and then spending 5 minutes online sitting with a coffee, locating exactly what I want.
So shopping on the high st tends to be me visiting Brighton or London every other month for a shopping experience.
Otherwise it’s supermarkets open til 10pm or online.

Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 11:41

@IncompleteSenten a lot of (older) people in many towns are set in their ways and go on and on about how the weekly market is gone or down to 5 stalls (yet they do all the food shopping at a giant Tesco Extra now because it's all under one roof) or the High Street is "dead" because M+S moved out (I do not understand the M+S obsession - it's fine for knickers but how often do you need new ones).
It's all very odd.

IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 11:32

Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 11:23

@IncompleteSenten yes going to the market and Littlewoods cafe was something I did with my mum too.
Although "going to the market" was more of a chore type shopping - ie getting food and not exactly exciting.
When I am in my hometown now visiting I love the town centre ("High Street") because it's full of charity shops, cafés, board game cafés etc. It has a more specialist farmers market and craft market now rather than an everyday grocery shop type market. There's street performers and a much more "cafe culture" environment.
But there seems to be a massive obsession in the town that because M+S etc has moved to "The Retail Park" it means the town centre is dying and dreadful. It's not. It's just evolved.

My son goes to board game cafes and cat cafes quite a lot. He loves them.

I'm not going to get on my soapbox about the issues I have with cat cafes 😁

Like I said earlier my own high street is fine, (mega tourist area) I keep reading about the dying high street and am curious.

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 11:23

@IncompleteSenten yes going to the market and Littlewoods cafe was something I did with my mum too.
Although "going to the market" was more of a chore type shopping - ie getting food and not exactly exciting.
When I am in my hometown now visiting I love the town centre ("High Street") because it's full of charity shops, cafés, board game cafés etc. It has a more specialist farmers market and craft market now rather than an everyday grocery shop type market. There's street performers and a much more "cafe culture" environment.
But there seems to be a massive obsession in the town that because M+S etc has moved to "The Retail Park" it means the town centre is dying and dreadful. It's not. It's just evolved.

PopSocksRock · 20/10/2023 11:22

My local high street is full of independent shops but the council are doing their best to destroy it with the parking charges
The next town had a Debenham that shut now the town more or less empty except for restaurants/cafes, nail bars and vape shops
It's very sad

ohtowinthelottery · 20/10/2023 11:12

High Streets still very much alive around here. Last time I went to the retail park (Next have closed in town and now only have OOT presence) it took me over 1 hour to get off the retail park on a midweek afternoon. I won't be going there again any time soon! Town centre shopping all the way for me.

CasperGutman · 20/10/2023 11:10

Most places I know with thriving high streets are local centres in large cities where the shops have a BIG population in easy walking distance and there are no "out of town" type developments nearby. Even there, the businesses are mostly either those you need to visit in person (salons, barbers, cafes, restaurants) or those which need to be nearby (hot food takeaways).

I do know a couple of places with thriving little town centres. They tend to be in affluent parts of the country and to have had a massive increase in the local population due to housing developments. So, while each person may be using the high street less, the number of potential customers has increased. I'm thinking of places like Bicester in Oxfordshire and Bishop's Cleeve in Gloucestershire. It strikes me that in both cases, there is also a pretty sizable supermarket - and thus lots of free car parking - close to the high street, which probably doesn't hurt!

nutbrownhare15 · 20/10/2023 11:09

About 33:67 high street:out of town retail for offline shopping but do a fair amount of online shopping as well. Maybe 20:40:40 for me.

TeresaCrowd · 20/10/2023 11:06

I’ve not voted as technically I think I fall into the too young camp, but I remember going ‘to town’ a lot as a young teen for ‘shopping’ etc but then as the retail parks popped up that was where mum would take us to buy more/bigger stuff. Kid spending pocket money was definitely the high street but needing to kit out an entire family PE kit was JJB (remember them…) on the retail park, likewise curry’s/comet etc for white goods. Plus the retail parks always had food and cinemas/bowling alleys etc in the early days round my way, and you could park the car. As kids we used to go to town on the bus. Even when I learned to drive, which was early 2000’s navigating the town centre and finding somewhere to park was crap compared to re out of town and that was before the mass introduction of ANPR car parks with a set of rules and regs you’d have overstayed your parking time in order to read.

I think there was a good 5-10yr crossover when both seemed to work in unison, and offered different things in that the high street still had a butcher and a couple of bakers but also independent music shops, sports shops etc. going back now it’s just bale shops and betting shops in the town, and even the retail parks are full of empty units as I guess it now mostly moves online.

Today I am quite jealous of people who can use a high street, but find they are quite inaccessible to the average working couple who do 8.30-5.30 with a commute. The cafes and independent food places especially do a roaring trade on a Saturday.

AIstolemylunch · 20/10/2023 11:00

Also these are the ones that had mainly chain stores and we have lost a lot of these that didn't keep up with changing shopping trends, didn't offer online ordering for collection in store, didn't offer free returns etc.

Contrast that with shops like Nike (only picking this because was recently shopping for trainers with DC). I was really impressed that you could go and browse and see what you wanted, try on etc, but at the till points you can login with your online id, get a discount for doing so if you buy in store or order the right size or colour they don't carry in store or whatever then and there for free delivery to store or home with free returns. They also offered in store only further discounts as an incentive to buy in store. H&M are going in the same direction. This is the kind of flexibility modern shops need if they want to exist in town centres I think.

And small independents need the local councils to do something about greedy commercial landlords who own whole swathes of properties in a town and force them out with ridiculous leases.