Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Poll. Did you stick to the high street or switch to out of town?

161 replies

IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 08:52

Not a taat but inspired by. Purely because I'm curious and polls make posters honest 😁

High streets are ghost towns now. When the alternatives that led to this happening first sprung up did you

YABU - I stuck to the high street 80%-100% of the time until the shops all closed and I had absolutely no alternative.

YANBU - I switched to the big supermarkets and the retail parks and home delivery etc 80% - 100% of the time

If you are too young to have had the choice please don't vote 😁

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 14:48

@KirstenBlest excuse me - did you mean to be so rude?
I was just giving an opinion based on 2 decades of retail work. We had customers banging on the shutters at 7 in the evening because they wanted to shop. We often would have stayed open but we were within a shopping centre that wanted to shut up for the day. My manager had many meetings with the shopping centre management about trading longer hours.
I was also just giving my opinion on experiences of being turned away from shops/cafes because they are closing what I consider early - not just me. I see other people trying the doors of places and saying "oh they are closed".
Oh by the way - I don't drive so paying for parking is irrelevant to me. I frequently WALK to many shops.
I have been involved in surveys and community groups that have tried to improve town centres.
I am slightly baffled why you decided to have a go at me.

muddyford · 20/10/2023 14:43

Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 12:46

@muddyford but she probably meant on their own website. Why didn't you order from them rather than resorting to Amazon? "Online" doesn't just mean Amazon.

I have had an Amazon account for 25 years. I don't have an account for the shop. I would have bought it in the shop if they had had it there. But they didn't.

daisypond · 20/10/2023 14:31

My high street is doing ok. Lots of people use it and there are no empty units or shops. No one really drives and there’s little parking, but you could park at the high street supermarket if you want to. The high street, about a minute from my front door, has cafes, several restaurants, a couple of nightclubs, a few bars, one big supermarket and a few smaller ones, like Iceland and mini Waitrose/Sainsbury’s. There are hairdresser’s and barbers, a printer’s, three optician’s, a bookie’s, main post office, WH Smith, Boots, several chemist’s, carpet shop, a few good-quality charity shops, dentist’s, doctor’s, library, butcher’s, deli, grocer’s/whole food shop, a fix-your-phone shop, health food shop, a running shop, a couple of gyms, a couple of sell-anything shops, a big DIY shop, two bike shops, one motorbike shop, a few gift-type shops, two or three fashion and furniture shops, like Oliver Bonas, shoe repairer/key cutter, dry cleaner’s, a beauty salon. I’ve probably missed some out. It doesn’t have a shoe shop or a dedicated furniture shop, but walk five minutes the other direction there’s a bed shop. No big high street chains like Next or M&S. Just off the high street is the leisure centre with pool and gym.

DuesToTheDirt · 20/10/2023 14:30

I always buy in person if I can, even if it's slightly more expensive (I'm lucky that I don't needn't to watch every pound). I appreciate having shops and try to help keep them going. My main exception to this is books, which I generally buy for Kindle these days - though I've now discovered a gorgeous bookshop near me...

However, it's becoming more difficult.

White goods - rarely available in shops now. I do like to see what I'm getting, even if it's a washing machine.

Clothes - fewer shops, less stock, much seems aimed at teenagers. And it's so infuriating to be told there's a greater selection on the website. I tried to buy a top at John Lewis a little while ago. My size wasn't in the shop, which was listed as having 2 in stock, but staff couldn't find them. I'd have had to pay extra to do click and collect, so I didn't bother. And if I want anything particular, it's so much easier to find online, e.g. far more choice of colours. I recently bought a green fake leather jacket online - I tried several in the shops, but they weren't quite right in fit, and every single one was black.

Supermarkets - I've used supermarkets rather than small food shops for years as we don't have a great selection nearby, though I do use our corner shop. For speciality things like miso I still use small shops.

As for retail parks, if I'm out in the car and want something from Boots, say, it's easier and cheaper to stop off and pick it up at a retail park than to drive or take the bus into town. I do walk into town for a shopping expedition, but not just to get some shampoo.

DH is the opposite and probably contributes a huge percentage of Amazon's profits.

KirstenBlest · 20/10/2023 14:01

Tell you what, @Needmorelego , why don't you contact the head offices of the charities and tell them. While you're at it, do the same with Boots, Superdrug....

You probably still wouldn't shop there even if they were open 24/7 because you'd not bother to check if you need to pay for parking and it would be too much hassle to park a few 100 yards away.

Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 13:52

@KirstenBlest another person up thread pointed out they are at work in the daytime so can't go to the shops then. People finish work and want to shop after work - but the shops are closed. If all the shops were open until at least 7pm (including charity shops) then it wouldn't be so much as "nipping to the charity shop" - it would be just "going to the shops".
But they are all closed so people go to the out of town supermarkets and retail parks (who seem to have no problems with employing evening staff).
That's one reason why the High Street is "dying".

Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 13:48

@user1497207191 well yes that is the other problem - no public transport in the evenings/Sundays/Bank holidays.
It's a vicious circle.... people want to shop - the shop isn't open when they can get there. Buses don't run because there's not enough users. But the user's don't use the bus because the shops aren't open......

KirstenBlest · 20/10/2023 13:46

@Needmorelego , it wouldn't cross my mind to nip out to the charity shop at 6 p.m. The other shops would be closed other than Iceland and the 'ethnic' shops.

user1497207191 · 20/10/2023 13:34

There's also the problem that some places don't have buses that run as late as 7pm (or more likely 7.30 once cashed up, closed down and walked to the bus stop). I know some people won't be able to identify with that, but it's the reality of crap public transport in lots of places outside the big cities. Yes, often the major routes have later services, but the more rural routes don't have evening services nor any Sunday services at all! Volunteers or minimum wage shop workers aren't going to be keen to work late and then have to pay for a taxi to get home!

Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 13:27

@user1497207191 I find the opposite. People want to work (or volunteer) evenings. People want to be able to work around daytime caring for children etc or being at university/college in the daytime.
@KirstenBlest if a particular charity shop is doing a good trade at 9am then that makes sense but I find many "High Streets" are quiet before 10/11am.
In many places people can't use the Freedom passes on buses until after 9.30. Anyone doing a school drop off is unlikely to be in town before 10.
Obviously this will vary from town to town - but being turned away from charity shops (and cafes) at 4 in the afternoon because they are closing is just daft. So much potential trade lost.

Ginmonkeyagain · 20/10/2023 13:24

I live in London and don't have a car so am unsure where my nearest "out of town" retail park would be - Bluewater perhaps? Either way I'm not going. I can get easily to Stratford Westfield on the train but the place is a fucking hell mouth. It's awful.

I bank online and buy large items online but most of my shopping is done in person.

For clothes shopping I tend to go to the West End or Covent Garden.

My local high st (5 mins walk) is great for very functional stuff - Superdrug, post office, hairdressers, dry cleaners, medium Sainsbury's, butchers, shoe repairers, Post Office as well as a few cafes and pubs

About 25 mins walk away (or a 10 min bus journey) there is a bigger and fancier high st where I spend more time - there are gift shops, independent clothes and household shops, bakeries, fishmonger, butcher, library, ironmongers, haberdashers, greengrocery, bookshops a weekly market, plant shop etc.. etc.. as well as restaurants, pubs and coffee shops.

I also shop in person at a larger Sainsbury's that is a little bit removed from the main high st.

posturn · 20/10/2023 13:23

Our local high street is thriving, as it's in a touristy part of London and a popular place to visit, a busy market, music venues, street food. I don't use it too often except to collect parcels from Amazon lockers and from the Argos for ebay deliveries. I get all groceries delivered and don't do top up shops. I do like the buzz of being out in a busy environment. I'd hate to live in a dead little town with nowhere to go.

Out of town shopping is too difficult to get to on public transport so it's not very popular here.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 20/10/2023 13:21

I go high street (I am lucky enough to live somewhere where its still thriving) between those two choices.

However I get most of my stuff online. I think this has decimated the high street more than out of town, which has been an option foryears, i remember studying it at school 20 years ago

One of the things that puts me off a lot of high street though is quality and material- I don't want to wear acrylic and polyester which seems to be in most shops

MonumentalLentil · 20/10/2023 13:17

I stuck with High St. until it became impossible to find anything to buy, or to go into a shop without either being harrassed and followed about by a sales person trying to make a sale, or impossible to actually get served because no-one was about, or they were all off chatting.

So, moved on to supermarkets and sometimes a department store, aside from there being no shops to go to where I was living.

Supermarkets became crappy with self checkouts and no staff so now use online with the occasional forage around a store. The High St. is one of the reasons we moved here but the banks have all gone and the useful shops have gone, like DIY, craft supplies, pet stuff, and it is now a street of nail bars and facial fiddling, cafes, cafes, cafes, and coffee, overpriced supermarkets and one dump of an Iceland that looks as if someone opened the stock room door and slung the stuff out of it, then shut the door and went home.

Lucky to have a Post Office to return online purchases so that's it. I miss the shops, but there aren't any.

user1497207191 · 20/10/2023 13:12

Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 12:50

@KirstenBlest so why don't the charity shops do the sorting, putting out stock in the morning and open the shop later? So rather than opening at - say 9.30am when there will be little trade - open at 12 and stay open until 7pm?

It's harder to find staff, paid or volunteers, to work unsocial hours to say 7pm. People want to enjoy their evenings.

Cumbrianlife · 20/10/2023 13:07

I'm a blue badge holder and have to park too far away to be able to manage to shop on my local high street. I love M&S food but only go when DH is with me because there's no car park and I can't carry it.
There is an extortionate multi story car park but even the disabled spaces are difficult to park in, let alone get the doors wide enough open to get out and I'm tiny.
There's also the fact that even the largest shops on my high street don't stock my size. I've been into the town centre once this year. It was full of pigeon shit, chuggers and beggers actively harassing and intimidating passers by.

motherofawhirlwind · 20/10/2023 13:03

Depends. For lunch / coffee I go into town and will have a rummage around the independents and charity shops whilst there. For kids clothes shops, home wares and Boots, out of town. For adult clothes, to the next city.

0palFruits · 20/10/2023 13:02

Brighton is still rammed. No empty shops

IDidntKnowMyOwnStrength · 20/10/2023 13:01

I don't know why people are so surprised when things change, the supermarkets were classed as the enemy to small independent stores, and now they are changing direction and heavily pushing the online side, where they take more money than through the tills.
I personally much prefer shopping online The shops in the high street are poorly stocked and all selll the same over priced rubbish, plus customer service is poor.
It's so much easier shopping online and so much choice, I rarely go to any shops in person if l can help it.

alloalloallo · 20/10/2023 13:01

user14699084663 · 20/10/2023 12:48

It sounds ridiculous, but what puts me off is paying for parking…I know it’s only a few ££ but the days of just putting your money in and getting a ticket are long gone! Download an app, recall your car reg, the machines are always at such an odd level that I have to stoop, (although thinking about it, they’re probably low for wheelchair users) the keypad is always laid out in a odd way, it all just puts me in a rage before I’ve got there, so if i can buy online or from out of town where you don’t have to pay to park I will!

Shopping is no longer a fun outing - 9/10 when you’re looking for something in particular it’s not in store but only online. I used to love a mooch round the shops!

Yes!! It’s a pain in the arse.

We do have parking machines still, that accept card payments, but they never work.

I’ve got 3 parking apps on my phone for all the various car parks round here. You’ve got to remember the code off the machine make sure you pick the right car to park (we’ve got 2 between us), they don’t use apple pay or remember your card details so I have to plug that in every time, and 9 times out of 10 I’ve got no bloody phone service. Plus, they charge an 50p in processing fees on top of the already extortionate £6 for 2 hours parking charges.

If I go into the main/big town, we’ve got all that palaver, I can park for a max of 2 hours so it doesn’t really encourage me to stop off for a nice leisurely lunch and go for a wander round the shops, or anything like that. Not that there are any shops I want to go into anyway. I only go when I absolutely need to (hairdressers appointment).

I can walk down to my town centre, have a mooch, spend as long as I like, have lunch, maybe a cocktail, wander round a local artist’s little gallery or something and then walk home.

Meniscus · 20/10/2023 13:00

I haven’t switched at all, and won’t (apart from furniture/DIY etc stuff that is pretty much always in retail parks). If I buy clothes in person it’s at a high street department store that has a lot of different concessions or a couple of independent shops, i buy shoes from a city centre shoe shop, I won’t buy books on Amazon, I support the local bookshops, and, while I get bulk stuff (cleaning products, pulses, tinned tomatoes, toilet paper) delivered, I shop for vegetables at the Saturday farmers market in the city centre and in the covered market which is open 8 to 6 Mon to Sat.

There is a giant retail park that a lot of shops have relocated to, but it’s a depressing, generic place. It’s about 20 years since I was there.

KirstenBlest · 20/10/2023 12:54

I don't know, but the shop is busy at 9 a,m,
i can't see them getting much footfall after 5.30 because the other shops would be shut.

fiftyval · 20/10/2023 12:53

Councils do not set business rates - they are set by the government. In my area the district council gets to keep less than 6% of what they collect . They get the blame for rents too even though they don't own any of the premises. County council are responsible for pavements and have woefully let down the town.
Parking charges are down to them though but there are cheaper car parks within 5 minutes walk.

Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 12:50

@KirstenBlest so why don't the charity shops do the sorting, putting out stock in the morning and open the shop later? So rather than opening at - say 9.30am when there will be little trade - open at 12 and stay open until 7pm?

user14699084663 · 20/10/2023 12:48

It sounds ridiculous, but what puts me off is paying for parking…I know it’s only a few ££ but the days of just putting your money in and getting a ticket are long gone! Download an app, recall your car reg, the machines are always at such an odd level that I have to stoop, (although thinking about it, they’re probably low for wheelchair users) the keypad is always laid out in a odd way, it all just puts me in a rage before I’ve got there, so if i can buy online or from out of town where you don’t have to pay to park I will!

Shopping is no longer a fun outing - 9/10 when you’re looking for something in particular it’s not in store but only online. I used to love a mooch round the shops!