Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Poll. Did you stick to the high street or switch to out of town?

161 replies

IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 08:52

Not a taat but inspired by. Purely because I'm curious and polls make posters honest 😁

High streets are ghost towns now. When the alternatives that led to this happening first sprung up did you

YABU - I stuck to the high street 80%-100% of the time until the shops all closed and I had absolutely no alternative.

YANBU - I switched to the big supermarkets and the retail parks and home delivery etc 80% - 100% of the time

If you are too young to have had the choice please don't vote 😁

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Pinceywincey · 23/10/2023 12:51

I didn’t really get a choice in the matter - I’m plus size and the vast majority of high street retailers have moved their plus size ranges to online only, so there’s literally nothing for me in the shops so I have to shop online. Anything else I would have bought while I was on the high street I can now get from the supermarket or on a retail park, so I’d rather go there and park for free than pay to park in town.

KirstenBlest · 23/10/2023 12:07

I think you mean dominated not domineered. The town centre here is having some retail buildings turned into flats.

user1497207191 · 23/10/2023 11:18

The ironic thing is that town centres used to be places where you'd live, work, shop, etc - they weren't domineered by retail. It all went wrong in the 70s and 80s when the big chain stores took over town centres and forced out the small independent shops, along with the demise of "industry", i.e. the town centre warehouses, small manufacturing, breweries, printers, garages, etc - all turned into shops or shopping centres. "Big" retail pushed everything else out of town centres. Now that "big" retail has moved out of town (mostly due to anti-car councils) it's left one hell of a vacuum, and online retail is the final nail in the coffin as can be seen by the empty big units in many retail parks!

If we want town centres to be thriving again, councils need to change their plans to include a lot more housing in and around the town centres, more employment opportunities for people to work in town centres (maybe smaller office units), which will involve some pretty major town planning, demolishing older/unsuitable premises and rebuilding, etc. AND less car-hate with more opportunities for people living, working and shopping in town centres to be able to park!

hallana · 23/10/2023 11:09

I shop either online or on my local high street and independent shops. I never liked those out of town places, or even the big malls like the Trafford Centre. I'm lucky that my little high street has everything I want - butchers, bakeries, grocers, gifts/galleries, opticians, chemist, hardware, paint and decorating, antiques, an indoor market, and a few clothes shops - I do have to go three miles up the road for shoe shops. I live in a small, working class market town in the north but we don't seem to have the high street problem here. (We have no chains either.)

SamW98 · 23/10/2023 11:02

Both.

I shop mostly online these days but use both my local high street and Lakeside

user1497207191 · 23/10/2023 10:56

@nettie434

i also think that a lot of councils believed people wanted pedestrianised centres when they didn't, especially in the evenings when they are empty and feel unsafe.

Nail on the head.

But I don't even think councils believed it was what people wanted. It has always seemed to be motivated more by other factors, such as political and other beliefs of the council (councillors and officers). More of the patronising "we know best" attitude. And, of course, by the time the damage has been done, the councillors/officers pushing for the changes have either retired or moved onto other jobs, so just leave the damage behind them, no accountability, etc.

IvorTheEngineDriver · 22/10/2023 21:16

I use whichever is the most convenient.

Samlewis96 · 22/10/2023 20:56

AIstolemylunch · 20/10/2023 09:32

I also disagree that high streets are dead ghost towns. Most of the chain shops and banks have gone, agreed, largely due to what PP have said, their own greed and inflexibility and unwillingness to change. Everyone else has adapted and evolved, or are starting to. So now High Streets (if they are controlled by clever and more forward thinking people) have become/are becoming experience destinations. You can't buy a relaxing coffee with friends online, or a nice meal, or a drink in a pub, or get a haircut, or a tattoo, or take a class.

So for me, I'm more than happy to buy virtualy everything I need online in terms of physical things - it has long worked better for people who work full-time.I do my banking and savings in apps - way easier to control and move your money (I accept this is not great for the generation or 2 before me but everyone else is ok with it I think). I abandoned high street travel agents decades ago, long before the 'death of the high street' because they were never competitively priced. I then use supermarkets for food shopping in person (and these are in town where I lived though it wouldn't bother me if they were out of town) and out of town place when I want to actually look at things before I buy them, IKEA, B&Q etc.

But then I spend many happy hours a week in one of the 3 or 4 local high streets near where I live. I work from home so I often go to one of the local cafes and coffee shops that have sprung up in place of the shops. We use the pubs, restaurants and hairdressers. I use the small gyms that have taken over some of the premises. There are regular food markets and street events with bands and stalls. The high street pubs are busy and thriving. There's a walk in repair cafe, drop in centre for older people on their own. It's generally become a more sociable experience I think.

I personally think 'death of the high street' is over exaggerated. It's is (or should) just evolve to meet the way people live now, my generation and down anyway (again, I accept that older people might need some assistance with the transition).

This is a pretty apt description of our high street

AfterWeights · 22/10/2023 12:48

I've been shopping mainly online for years. I never enjoyed "shopping" itself am experience, I buy the things i need, so online achieves what I need.

What i want most from my local area are the things you can't so easily get online. Hair dressers, garden centres, vets, doctors, chemists, cafes & restaurants, leisure facilities. I'd use a butcher or fishmonger if it was reasonably priced - my mother uses a good one where she lives but in my area these sorts of things tend to target the luxury/premium end of the market, they are unbelievably expensive (£9 for 8 rashers of bacon) and the owners make a killing - not something I'd use regularly.

Things that take up half the town centre where i live that i never use:

  • estate agents
  • charity shops
  • random independent gift/tat shops that are always overpriced
maddening · 22/10/2023 12:46

Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 13:27

@user1497207191 I find the opposite. People want to work (or volunteer) evenings. People want to be able to work around daytime caring for children etc or being at university/college in the daytime.
@KirstenBlest if a particular charity shop is doing a good trade at 9am then that makes sense but I find many "High Streets" are quiet before 10/11am.
In many places people can't use the Freedom passes on buses until after 9.30. Anyone doing a school drop off is unlikely to be in town before 10.
Obviously this will vary from town to town - but being turned away from charity shops (and cafes) at 4 in the afternoon because they are closing is just daft. So much potential trade lost.

I agree with this, when I am free and not working the shops in town are shut, and Sunday afternoon more than half are shut.

KimberleyClark · 22/10/2023 12:38

I use a mixture. My city centre has lost Debenhams plus two independent department stores and even the John Lewis is under threat. It’s all very depressing.

whiteroseredrose · 22/10/2023 12:34

I go to the Trafford Centre or out of town for the free parking.

I drive to a nearby town for a supermarket shop rather than the local equivalent because of not enough parking and the parking costs.

Back in the day I used to shop in central Manchester when parking was free after 1pm on a Saturday but that was years ago.

About 10 years ago the council started 2 hours free parking in our local village and it thrived. A couple of friends had shops there and it was great. But now the charges are back, a big car park has had flats built on it and shops are closing again. Very cycle friendly though.

StoatofDisarray · 22/10/2023 12:23

I shop local, but I am lucky to have good fresh food markets close by as well as metro versions of the supermarkets.

tiglit · 22/10/2023 12:10

Mostly stick to out of town because they're easier to get to and free parking, ours also have the shops I want unlike our high street (we are a town though as opposed to a city).

PokeyLaFarge · 22/10/2023 12:07

I live in a small town

Its fine, if you want your hair done, or a curry, or to buy the type of gifty tat you can buy anywhere...not so good of you need food, clothes, housewares, books...

So I do 95% of my shopping online

Fionaville · 22/10/2023 12:04

Small town, we've got the same high street we've always had (Co-op, pharmacy, butchers, bakers, greengrocer, off licence and a hardware store) So I still use it often, but go to big retail parks and online for most things. Whereas years ago, I'd go into the nearest big city.

Britneyfan · 20/10/2023 22:21

@Mummy08m I love this idea, I’ve been thinking something similar myself for a while now!

I don’t drive but used to make the effort for take the bus to the local mall (which serves as our local high street really). But like others have said the clothes shops pretty much never have what I’m looking for, I’m a size 18-20 and although the shops I’m looking at do do that size they hardly ever have it in store and helpfully tell me I can order it online. When I want to try it on, see how the fabric feels etc. I’m also crap at returning stuff and I know it so I generally like to make sure I’m going to like something enough to keep it before buying it online. I could have ordered it online without leaving my house so it’s super frustrating when shop assistants say that like they’re being “helpful”.

Even when I went looking for my teenage son I got “oh yeah our age 10-14 boy range is all online only” from Next (a HUGE Next store coming down with girls clothes in those sizes I hasten to add). Sometimes it’s not size it’s “oh that dress you’re looking for that you liked the look of on our website is an online only range”.

I kind of agree with some sentiment that the high street has done this to themselves.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 20/10/2023 22:06

Voted YANBU, but my shopping habits don't entirely fit with your voting options. I never go to a big retail park. I buy my weekly grocery shop in person from Aldi and I do most of my other shopping online.

Pleaseme · 20/10/2023 18:59

I once spent a whole day failing to buy the dc wellies in October. Some shops didn’t have the right sizes. Some didn’t have wellies in stock yet. Lots of buy them on the website from sales assistants.

I’ve never gone shopping in town again and just get stuff online. I live ages away (45 minutes) so it seems like a waste of petrol. Much more efficient for everything to be delivered to local corner store( still 15 minutes away but I pass it on the way to work).

AlviarinAesSedai · 20/10/2023 18:53

I use a mixture, small village and farm shop. High street and retail parks.
Online Etsy and sometimes Amazon, but not that often because don’t have prime.

IncompleteSenten · 20/10/2023 18:38

I think I felt I had to prove it. Which is daft when I think about it because I could have always been lying. 😂
Anyway, I was just explaining why I asked a clarifying question and saying that it was a genuine question not a snarky dig or trying to start a row or something.

OP posts:
SM4713 · 20/10/2023 18:01

If you advance search me you'll read I have talked about the fact I'm autistic more than once.

How would I advance search you? Is that to read your other threads? Sorry, I don't know how to do that, nor would I have the time nor inclination to check each and every, single persons other posts!

MrsMoastyToasty · 20/10/2023 17:51

It costs me £9 to travel into my nearest city (Bristol) because I drive an old diesel car which I can't afford to replace. Then there's parking at a minimum of £2.30 for the first hour and the actual cost of fuel.

To be honest I hardly ever go into the city since M&S closed their central Bristol store and Debenhams closed down. House of Fraser and Harvey Nicks are generally out of my price range.

I tend to go to a small retail park on the edge of Bristol, the local high street in my own town or The Mall at Cribbs Causeway.

MumofSpud · 20/10/2023 17:36

My v local high street is now a ghost town with tumbleweed.
There are more closed shops than open ones.
There is still a Smiths (it has a PO in it) but isn't a proper Smiths as it has all clearance stuff.
There is a Boots but the top floor closed years ago.
Even one of the pound shops shut!
The giant Tesco's has also boarded up some sections.
Recently half the shopping centre has been closed to be redeveloped changed into flats.
Where people are supposed to shop....

My other local 'naice' high street has alot of independent shops as well as chains but even that has a lot of shops closing.

Needmorelego · 20/10/2023 17:12

@Mummy08m I use a "granny" shopping trolley but mine broke. I was looking at new ones (ironically on Amazon....🙄) and they have one with a flip down seat attached. I am very tempted by it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread