Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think that more intelligent people…

118 replies

ellencan · 20/10/2023 07:32

are generally of lower mood, depressive tendencies etc?

OP posts:
CesareBorgia · 20/10/2023 12:24

Fahbeep · 20/10/2023 11:13

How do you grade intelligence? Is it innate or a product of education? And is a skills proficiency an equal indicator of intelligence as academic achievement? Just flagging as the premise of the question is flawed. If you wanted to study this seriously, how would you identify your test populations of intelligent/non intelligent? How would you do that without introducing bias and error? For example, would you base this on people with high ranking tertiary qualifications? If so, all your study would tell you is whether low mood is under, averagely or over represented within that tiny microcosm. It would not be safe to extrapolate to the general population.

Hypothetically, it would make more sense to take a random selection of people who were identified as being depressed and then apply your chosen measure of intelligence to that sample. The measure of intelligence is the tricky one - education level wouldn't identify people who are very bright but through choice or circumstance didn't go onto tertiary education. The only way would be to bolt on some kind of IQ test to the sample - but are people suffering from depression going to perform at their best in such a test? (This leaves aside various arguments that have been made about the accuracy of IQ tests).

Pollyputhekettleon · 20/10/2023 11:16

Intelligence is measured using IQ tests. They're a pretty good though not perfect measure. It's highly genetically heritable although environment contributes to a lesser degree.

Fahbeep · 20/10/2023 11:13

ellencan · 20/10/2023 07:32

are generally of lower mood, depressive tendencies etc?

How do you grade intelligence? Is it innate or a product of education? And is a skills proficiency an equal indicator of intelligence as academic achievement? Just flagging as the premise of the question is flawed. If you wanted to study this seriously, how would you identify your test populations of intelligent/non intelligent? How would you do that without introducing bias and error? For example, would you base this on people with high ranking tertiary qualifications? If so, all your study would tell you is whether low mood is under, averagely or over represented within that tiny microcosm. It would not be safe to extrapolate to the general population.

BestMeds · 20/10/2023 09:33

I don’t know. But I have never met anyone with anxiety who wasn’t also very bright. Especially kids. It’s just anecdata though.

Oversharingnamechanged · 20/10/2023 09:03

This is really long, sorry, I've tried to explain though about my own depression because I think your question is very important but answering it is so loaded and complex, so I've tried to cover the bases. I'm very interested to read others opinions on this.

I have clinical depression, was diagnosed in my early teens and was given prozac at 13 (I'm 30s now, still on the sunny Ds, just a different kind) but I doubt it my life had been less horrific than it was I'd have perhaps not had clinical and just shit life syndrome, however because of my bizarre upbringing I don't think my brain is wired properly which is why I have depression now even though my life is, besides being a skint from time to time, fucking peachy!
I have a irritatingly positive outlook etc but I can still find things to wind myself up over to the point I struggle getting out of bed.
I am poorly educated, no SAT'S let alone GCSEs but I'd have perhaps been quite academic in other circumstances. I am what was known as street smart which just is a fancier term for neglected estate kid in my case.
I do think that depression can be caused by feeling sadness from others.
Say those parents on press conferences of missing children, seeing the news of the Palestine/Israel drama, I think depression can be secondary almost.
So your life can be as rosy as Kate Winslets cheers in titanic and if you're someone who feels hurt on the back of world injustice or sadness, depression will worm its way into your mind and make itself very comfortable, like a squatter with an oodie. And be just as hard to shift.
I think people who are susceptible to feeling pain of others, regardless of their academic abilities are the ones more likely to experience depression.
Because even when things are going great for you, it's hard to witness the world around and it not cause despair.
I know for myself personally and I speak only for me here, but I can be having the most wonderful day, the things that fill me with joy can be surrounding me and yet I'll see something that is categorically not my fault, my problem or my business, eg homeless person and I can't shake the guilt and sadness then that they're living such a poor life when mine is going swell.
It can lead to manic episodes then, so I'll have to buy homeless people selection boxes and hot drinks and I can spend my last ten quid doing it and it won't help, I'll just feel despair that I haven't done enough. So often my depression can just spiral. I never ever let anyone outside see that, I have it well hidden, I'm as present as a mum, partner, friend I can be, but inside it takes so little to send me into crushing sadness and I know logically that it's an illness, that probably the homeless wouldn't want me crying in bed about them (I've been homeless so it's a massive trigger) but it's harder to pull myself out of the mindset than I admit.
I'm not really bright, not really dim, so I'm not sure if it makes a difference, I agree with what CurlewKate said. But I'm still not sure if ultimately intelligence is a factor, but I think you'll be judged on your depression with your social economic status.

KimberleyClark · 20/10/2023 09:03

My DB is the academically successful one of our family but has always had worse mental health than me. But it may just be genetic luck - my mother was a lifelong depressive and perhaps he takes after her more than I do.

muggart · 20/10/2023 09:02

No, but I have heard that said before. I suspect it is just another way of glorifying depression.

I also heard someone suggest the opposite too, she said that being intelligent really helped her overcome her trauma after a horrific incident because she was able to work through her feelings and contextualise what happened by herself as a teenager without any outside support. It struck me as an odd way of looking at the situation but I could see her point.

MammaTo · 20/10/2023 09:01

No but I do think “ignorance is bliss” sometimes. I have friends who pay no attention to current events and they live a much happier life.

Annoyingfly · 20/10/2023 08:57

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 20/10/2023 07:40

It's relevant to the thread. There are probably higher concentrations of very intelligent people in both Oxford and Cambridge than there are in most places. If the OP's theory is correct, they should be utterly miserable places. They are not.

One thing you can't admit to around here, though. Earning over six figures? A-OK. Being clever? Anathema.

Biasquia · 20/10/2023 08:54

GreyGreyGrey · 20/10/2023 08:50

I think people of low socioeconomic status suffer the most. They have the least and are the least supported.

That said, I have had a ring side seat to watch extremely intelligent people be miserable despite outer privilege. Minds that get into loops and cannot stop analysing themselves.

I think the key to happiness is focussing on the world outside yourself, rather than always thinking about yourself.

I agree with this to a point. I know that most people I’ve spoken to who had significant childhood trauma have come to a point where they eventually ground to a halt with this as their coping mechanism. Something triggers it, usually having a child of their own that they dote on.

sorry I meant to quote only the last paragraph.

VisionsOfSplendour · 20/10/2023 08:53

No, why do you ask?

GreyGreyGrey · 20/10/2023 08:50

I think people of low socioeconomic status suffer the most. They have the least and are the least supported.

That said, I have had a ring side seat to watch extremely intelligent people be miserable despite outer privilege. Minds that get into loops and cannot stop analysing themselves.

I think the key to happiness is focussing on the world outside yourself, rather than always thinking about yourself.

Biasquia · 20/10/2023 08:50

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 20/10/2023 08:41

It can affect anyone, but it's less like to affect those of higher socioeconomic status. SES in turn of course correlates with intelligence

Just an anecdote but I have heard people suggest that the more intelligent people within lower SES groups are more prone to depression.

I used to work with a fantastic guy. Ex mining engineer. NUM official through the strikes and subsequent deindustrialisation of the 1980s. Later a Welfare Rights advisor, which is where I met him.
So, he really had a front row seat for the economic destruction of his community and the heroin crisis that followed.

He told me that the first generation of junkies were the intelligent, sensitive kids.

Guys who, in his generation, would have been shop stewards. Maybe gone on to higher education at Ruskin College. Maybe become a big shout in local politics. Obviously, he recognised something of himself in them.

The way he put it was "We lost a generation of leaders" He said it was because they were too sensitive to what was going on around them and they couldn't cope with it.

I was very struck by that because it was the first time anyone had made me think about addicted people in such a positive light.

I don't know if it's specific to that particular set of (quite extreme) circumstances or if it's generally true.

That is very insightful.

EmmaDilemma5 · 20/10/2023 08:49

Ignorance is bliss is something I truly stand by. The more simple the life and thoughts, the better.

EmmaDilemma5 · 20/10/2023 08:48

Yes I think there's probably a weak correlation. Obviously there's be plenty of people in each camp with and without depression.

But I do think knowledge is both power and a burden.

I think "overthinking" and not switching off is probably a big one. But that's just my thinking, no idea really.

Floogal · 20/10/2023 08:46

Also, if you're unintelligent, you're more likely to be unemployed or be stuck in a low paid job. Or be bullied at school, college or work. Also (especially men) are less likely to find romantic partners if they are average intelligence or bellow.

Floogal · 20/10/2023 08:43

I don't really buy into the 'Lisa Simpson' stereotype of having more intelligence meaning being more miserable. For starters, knowing you're not as smart as other people is very likely to affect your self esteem overall.

Lumins · 20/10/2023 08:42

KissTheRains · 20/10/2023 08:35

Based on pure anecdotal evidence of people I've known, lived with, worked with etc.

The old adage of ignorance is bliss seems true.

Massively generalising and speaking VERY broadly:

The 'intelligent' people kept up with the news, politics, inflation, interest rates etc. They'd be able to tell you about what country had attacked whom and what the BOE had set interest at and what it meant for affording food.

The 'not as intelligent' didn't know anything of what was happening in the world or anything of politics or price rises etc but they could tell you who was voted out of the latest singing show or who was number 1 in the charts or the latest footy scores.

I wouldn't say the intelligent were depressed or sad or down, I'd say they were more realists and possibly a little more cynical and wary of what's coming.

The 'not so intelligent' seemed overall just happier, more upbeat and shrugged things off a lot easier and lived a bit more in the 'now'

But, obviously that's not true for everyone, just speaking in broad terms of people I've known etc.

I've noticed this too. Ignorance is bliss.

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 20/10/2023 08:41

It can affect anyone, but it's less like to affect those of higher socioeconomic status. SES in turn of course correlates with intelligence

Just an anecdote but I have heard people suggest that the more intelligent people within lower SES groups are more prone to depression.

I used to work with a fantastic guy. Ex mining engineer. NUM official through the strikes and subsequent deindustrialisation of the 1980s. Later a Welfare Rights advisor, which is where I met him.
So, he really had a front row seat for the economic destruction of his community and the heroin crisis that followed.

He told me that the first generation of junkies were the intelligent, sensitive kids.

Guys who, in his generation, would have been shop stewards. Maybe gone on to higher education at Ruskin College. Maybe become a big shout in local politics. Obviously, he recognised something of himself in them.

The way he put it was "We lost a generation of leaders" He said it was because they were too sensitive to what was going on around them and they couldn't cope with it.

I was very struck by that because it was the first time anyone had made me think about addicted people in such a positive light.

I don't know if it's specific to that particular set of (quite extreme) circumstances or if it's generally true.

Lumins · 20/10/2023 08:41

I'm not particularly intelligent but I overthink. For example, there's 100 billion stars in the Milky Way, 200 billion galaxies in the observable universe. Where did it come from, why is it here, what else is going on out there. Is there anything at the bottom of a black hole? When did consciousness come to be, at what point did it spark? We can only see a fraction of what is going on around us. What happens when we die? etc etc etc

I drive myself to depressive thinking because everything seems so pointless. Plus I'll likely never get an answer to any of my questions, I find that depressing. I'm not clinically depressed.

Biasquia · 20/10/2023 08:41

Somebody upthread wrote about shit life syndrome. Sinead O’Connor spoke widely about this, she had a shit early life and then mostly unworkable relationships after, her responses were absolutely normal for what she had experienced and learned from those experiences, that is to say that most people would experience significantly negative emotions around those kinds of experiences. To me that is different from an existential depression at least.

Dymaxion · 20/10/2023 08:39

I mean lower moods, quite bleak outlook etc.

So intelligent people are more likely to be pessimists, is that what you mean ?

KissTheRains · 20/10/2023 08:35

Based on pure anecdotal evidence of people I've known, lived with, worked with etc.

The old adage of ignorance is bliss seems true.

Massively generalising and speaking VERY broadly:

The 'intelligent' people kept up with the news, politics, inflation, interest rates etc. They'd be able to tell you about what country had attacked whom and what the BOE had set interest at and what it meant for affording food.

The 'not as intelligent' didn't know anything of what was happening in the world or anything of politics or price rises etc but they could tell you who was voted out of the latest singing show or who was number 1 in the charts or the latest footy scores.

I wouldn't say the intelligent were depressed or sad or down, I'd say they were more realists and possibly a little more cynical and wary of what's coming.

The 'not so intelligent' seemed overall just happier, more upbeat and shrugged things off a lot easier and lived a bit more in the 'now'

But, obviously that's not true for everyone, just speaking in broad terms of people I've known etc.

Dymaxion · 20/10/2023 08:30

How are you defining 'more intelligent' ?

NunsKnickers · 20/10/2023 08:26

No

I'm very intelligent and very happy.

😁