Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you find this inappropriate

211 replies

Mooshamoo · 19/10/2023 21:54

I recently went to my male doctor. He sent me a letter to go in and see him. I had gone in about stomach pain a couple of weeks before.

I was saying to him that I had really painful periods. And I asked to get a stronger painkiller as over the counter I was weren't working.

He said "do you have children" I said "no and I won't be having any". I'm 39.

He looked shocked and said " why wont you be having children?".

None of his business. But I said an answer

I said "eh because I'm quite Independent".

He said "so what are you doing to stop having children".

I said "eh I'm not currently having relationships or being with men "

He then said "have you ever had sex?".

At this point , I was like eh why is he asking
that, it's a bit of a strange question. I was starting to feel uncomfortable. I mumbled something like "yes but not since my last boyfriend". He sensed the awkwardness in the room so he said at that point "I'm only asking that because I can't put you on one of these contraceptives (the coil) if you've never had sex.

I hadn't gone in to get a cobtraceptive, I had gone in to get a painkiller. Ksaid 'i dont want to be put on a contraceptive, I want to get a painkiller" . He then did give me a painkiller.

I went out feeling a bit uncomfortable . What do you think. I know he wasn't extremely extremely inappropriate, but he was a bit inappropriate I think.

OP posts:
LusaBatoosa · 20/10/2023 09:00

Mooshamoo · 20/10/2023 01:43

With the greatest of respect. Not almost everyone here has disagreed with me.

And saying "why don't you want children" is not appropriate for a doctor to say.

Got it's late. It's nearly 2. I'd better go to bed.

At time of writing, 74% have voted YABU. That’s very much the majority.

You're being massively weird.

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 20/10/2023 07:53

Mooshamoo · 19/10/2023 23:41

Yes but why would you ask a 40 year old woman has she ever had sex. It's a bizarre question to ask. Of course she has had sex. Do you know any forty year old women that haven't had sex.

Anyway there are several doctors at the practice. I'll ask for a female doctor next time

I'm sure there are some that haven't had sex. You might be asexual or a lesbian who's never had sex with a man. If he's considering the coil to help with painful periods it's relevant. Not sure if it's the same now but they used to only fit coils for women who've had children.

Lightningrain · 20/10/2023 07:51

I’ve had a doctor ask whether I have children in relation to contraception because there are some coils they don’t like to fit in women that haven’t given birth. Maybe it’s the same idea with penetrative sex.

They do suggest contraceptives as a remedy for painful periods as I’ve had the pill for that reason (and the coil was suggested also). I suspect the intentions were there regarding pain relief but he didn’t explain himself very well.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 20/10/2023 07:44

Frances0911 · 20/10/2023 00:52

When my doctor told me that blood tests confirmed I'd had the menopause, the first thing he asked was if I wanted to go on HRT, and the second question he asked was, are you finding having sex uncomfortable. I was absolutely mortified, especially as I was divorced and not even in a relationship at the time.

Good doctor, there.

That question saves many women from the pain of vaginal atrophy, as a yes can result in an additional prescription for oestrogen pessaries. And there's potential for somebody to describe symptoms of prolapse.

Canisaysomething · 20/10/2023 07:27

If you want to know what over the counter painkiller is best for periods, a pharmacist can help you with that.

Proseccoismyfriend · 20/10/2023 07:08

I don't think it's appropriate to justask women "have you ever had sex" when they go in for a painkiller though.

It wasn't relevant to what I was asking for, and I didnt want to talk to him about my sex life.

Now that I think of it -, I've seen at least 3 other female doctors about my painful periods over the last couple of years, and not one of them ever asked me "have I ever had sex. "

Because you have been in a few times with the same issue over a couple of years, chances are he's hoping to find a better solution than painkillers so unfortunately he needs to ask appropriate but uncomfortable questions. You've made up your mind, he makes you feel uncomfortable so just book with someone else in future and move on.

sammylady37 · 20/10/2023 07:05

Interesting how the op has upped the drama with some details, going from how he makes her mother uncomfortable and She said he stands really really close to her when she is sitting down. Uncomfortably close to her so his crotch is nearly in her face

to

he stuck his crotch right into my 75 year old mother’s face. She said that he was standing so close to her that he was nearly on top of her. And that she felt scared of him

And the neighbour gets added in as well.

Almost as if the op is adding to the story when posters are telling her she’s being unreasonable.

VisionsOfSplendour · 20/10/2023 06:52

Mooshamoo · 20/10/2023 03:29

He stuck his crotch right into my 75 year old mother's face. She said he was standing so close to her, that he was nearly on top of her. And that she felt scared of him.

Yet he's the lucky one according to you.

Right..

I think we are the lucky ones , not to have to see him ever again.

The last time I came out of his office, I rang my mother and I said to her "that is the last time I am ever seeing him"

So you said you weren't going to see him again then went to see him again?

Your whole manner seems very contradictory, youre even trying to deny you posted things that we can all see you literally said

sammylady37 · 20/10/2023 06:46

A doctor is not a shop-keeper, it’s not a matter of going in asking for something and being given it without question. It sounds like the doctor was being thorough in his questioning to ascertain what was causing your pain, rule out more serious causes rather than just attribute it to painful periods and come up with reasonable solutions rather than just doling out analgesia to mask the symptoms.

BusyMum47 · 20/10/2023 06:44

@Mooshamoo I don't know why you're even asking if you're being unreasonable when you quite clearly & very strongly don't believe you are?!

Hibiscrubbed · 20/10/2023 06:43

Mooshamoo · 19/10/2023 23:33

Do you not think asking a 39 year old woman "have you ever had sex" is a bit strange in itself? Like of course I've had sex.

If I was a doctor, I wouldn't say to a 40 year old woman "have you ever had sex". It's just weird.

Do you not think asking a 39 year old woman "have you ever had sex" is a bit strange in itself? Like of course I've had sex

There’s no ‘of course’ about it.

Your answers previously about being ‘independent’ May have suggested loud never had a relationship, and therefore never had sex. These questions were relevant for a multitude of diagnostic reasons, another being the likelihood of HPV and cervical changes.

HikingforScenery · 20/10/2023 06:35

OP, as you’ve mentioned previously, just ask for a different doctor next time. He made you uncomfortable and there’s no denying that.

GnomeDePlume · 20/10/2023 06:29

YANBU

If he is asking questions he should explain why he is asking them.

eg 'The contraceptive coil has been effective for some women in treating period pain but isnt suitable for women who havent had penetrative sex, would you consider that?'

OP can then say 'I don't need/want contraception and have heard a lot of negative opinions about the coil'

Just diving into questions about sex without explanation is at best inept.

Does your GP practice have a manager? If so, give feedback. It doesnt have to be a complaint in the sense that he needs punishment but he does need to reflect on how he is communicating with patients.

HikingforScenery · 20/10/2023 06:28

aif you felt uncomfortable, that’s what matters.

However, I do know women i! their early 40s, who have never had sex. Just saying they exist. It’s unusual but not strange and being a doctor, he must come across a whole range of of patients.

Gnomegnomegnome · 20/10/2023 06:11

I’m sorry that you felt uncomfortable although It’s a gynae problem, of course he asked about sex and children. He wouldn’t be doing his job properly if he wasn’t exploring what was causing it.

It is your right to not see him again but don’t be discussing his creepiness with the neighbours. That’s not fair.

autiebooklover · 20/10/2023 05:58

I think the way generally doctors speak to women about contraception/periods/menopause is appalling.

I chose to have the mirena fitted and developed crippling anxiety. I read up on links to mirena and anxiety and decided after it had been in a year to have it removed (I was 39). I was spoken too like I was a irresponsible child. Questioned repeatedly, told that it would be my fault if I got pregnant and put my self at risk with a geriatric pregnancy. And when I explained my husband and I intended to use condoms was told they are not as reliable as the coil. Which may be true but they are reliable enough to be considered an effective method.

When I reached mid forties and started having heavy periods (as in having to change moon cup hourly for the first 2 days) I went to GP and was told I needed the coil fitting. I said I didn't want it and was told there was nothing else they could do.

I agree op, the doctor should have said "I could prescribe a contraceptive " at which point you could have told him you don't want a artificial hormone in your body and would prefer a painkiller.

Cherryberrypie · 20/10/2023 05:48

Please don’t complain about him OP. It doesn’t sound like he has done anything wrong.

the reason I say this is because having suffered from a chronic illness for a very long time, I finally found a really lovely GP who actually listened to me, and yes he asked a lot of questions, all necessary in order to get to the right treatment.

Within 6 months of me finding this wonderful doctor, a female patient made a complaint about him and he got suspended.

I live in a country town in Australia where good doctors a very hard to come by. This poor doctor was distraught and he was not even told the nature of the complaint or who complained.

the consequences of this, is that all the patients on his list have been unable to see a doctor for the past 18 months. The best we can get is a Tele appointment with the practice nurse or visit the emergency dept at the town hospital for an emergency.

Nobody knows, obviously, what the complaint was, but if it was a frivolous thing because someone felt offended or a bit funny about personal questions then the amount of fallout has been tragic for everyone including the doctor and his other patients.

MissTrip82 · 20/10/2023 05:22

Mooshamoo · 19/10/2023 23:33

Do you not think asking a 39 year old woman "have you ever had sex" is a bit strange in itself? Like of course I've had sex.

If I was a doctor, I wouldn't say to a 40 year old woman "have you ever had sex". It's just weird.

I wouldn’t get far in medicine if I were this judgmental!

It’s not at all unheard of for people in their 30s and much much older to not have had sex. I’d never assume that someone had.

ComeOutSun · 20/10/2023 05:03

Mooshamoo · 20/10/2023 00:02

I didn't say that I assumed that every 39 year old woman has had sex.

I said it was rude and inappropriate for him to ask me have I ever had sex.

I had not gone in to get contraception. I had gone in to get a painkiller.

Going into a doctor with painful periods does not mean that a woman wants to be put on contraception.

I specifically said to him that I wanted a painkiller.

So he had no business at all asking me about my sex life.

Yes, you said to him that you wanted a painkiller. It would be remiss of him not to think of solutions that would address your pain and offer you all options rather than just write a script. That seems more thorough.

I aren't aware of any 40 year old women virgins but I do know a couple of men who are that age and virgins. Even older than 40.

In the end, you don't feel comfortable with this doctor, so see a different one.

ComeOutSun · 20/10/2023 04:59

Mooshamoo · 19/10/2023 23:33

Do you not think asking a 39 year old woman "have you ever had sex" is a bit strange in itself? Like of course I've had sex.

If I was a doctor, I wouldn't say to a 40 year old woman "have you ever had sex". It's just weird.

Most people in this line of work would have learned it's best not to assume. For all he knows you've only been with other women all your life too, so may never have had penetrative sex.

5128gap · 20/10/2023 04:56

Not wanting to see a female doctor because she's 'silly' is not in any way comparable to not wanting to see a male doctor who makes you feel uncomfortable @HoppingPavlova
The prejudice against women in medicine who were fully qualified and capable, just the same as the men, was baseless sexism.
The OP is speaking of feeling uncomfortable due to her experience with a man and feeling sexually vulnerable. You nor anyone else know if she has grounds or not as we weren't there to witness his tone and manner, so have no idea if it's baseless. She hasn't decided he's silly or incapable on the basis of his sex, so it's an entirely false equivalence.

5128gap · 20/10/2023 04:47

I'm sorry you have had experiences that have caused you to see men as inappropriate and creepy. Unfortunately because some are, we can sometimes have a heightened level of caution around them all. Especially where we have to interact with them on quite a personal level like our doctors.
The subjects he discussed with you seem OK as sex/reproduction is part of your overall health. But I'm not going to disbelieve you about his manner if you say he was creepy.
If I were you I'd request a chaperone for future visits. A nurse at the practice maybe? It may give you peace of mind to have a woman present.

IsThereABarUpThere · 20/10/2023 04:46

@Mooshamoo exactly. You're drip feeding.

You've now added your neighbour. Who next, the local vicar?

ForfarBridie · 20/10/2023 04:43

He wasn’t inappropriate and you’re way overthinking your appointment.

The Spanish Dr wasn’t being inappropriate either. He was in an English lesson and it was his way of telling you he liked his job.

i think it would be better all round if you stick to female Drs from now on as you do seem determined to find fault with a male Dr where there’s none.

Breezy1985 · 20/10/2023 04:11

Poster - AIBU
Everyone - yes
Poster - drip, drip, drip. Added in the mother and now the neighbour.

Honestly the dr did or said nothing wrong for the issue you went in for, now if you had gone in with an ear infection then yes those questions would have been inappropriate, for a gynae issue - absolutely not.