Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"You didn't really expect food to be ready at 4pm did you?"

215 replies

123bumblebee · 19/10/2023 20:36

Said to me by my mother recently when, after driving 2.5 hours with a toddler and planning our meals around this, dinner didn't appear until 6.30pm. We were staying in a hotel so imminently had to leave to get our 18 month old settled for the evening- we're not precious parents who are rigid about bedtimes, it's just she loses her shit with tiredness past 7pm and it's not fair on her. She won't sleep out and about in a pram, never has.

It got me thinking. I've had another recent family fallout where I hosted my brother for lunch at midday and he turned up 2.5 hours later claiming the time he said he was arrive was 11.30 "ish" so therefore we were obviously supposed to know that he was going to be so late.

Am I naive to expect people to serve meals or turn up for meals at the time stated? My mother laughed at me being so naive to expect a 4pm meal to be served....around 4pm. Obviously I understand things crop up and it sometimes takes longer than expected but this was a BBQ and the host didn't even light the BBQ until gone 5pm.

If so, how the frick am I supposed to plan my life if this is an unspoken rule that I have never been informed of?

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 20/10/2023 13:42

Cammac · 20/10/2023 13:36

spitefulandbadgrammar · Today 11:44

@Cammac Light tea and snack are two different things. “HTH”!

If you don’t know the difference between a meal and a snack there is no point engaging with you. Have a good day

Is a scotch egg a meal or a snack?

🙃

Cammac · 20/10/2023 13:36

spitefulandbadgrammar · Today 11:44

@Cammac Light tea and snack are two different things. “HTH”!

If you don’t know the difference between a meal and a snack there is no point engaging with you. Have a good day

WeMustGetOffTheMountain · 20/10/2023 12:16

It sounds like a miscommunication. My friend recently invited me for a bbq and said "turn up at 4 for food", what he actually meant was "turn up at 4, there will be food served not just drinks so don't plan tea". Since the OP has said she suggests ASD, she has just interpreted it wrong. Easily done, ASD or not.

OP, I would suggest in future saying "what time will food be out as I could do with knowing whether to bring something for LO to nibble while he waits". Or just take some food for LO anyway in case the same thing happens again. You were not being unreasonable to expect the food at 4, as that is how you had interpreted the offer. However, an easy fix would have been to just fix LO something to eat and take it as a learning curve for next time.

stylishnot · 20/10/2023 12:02

I'm so lucky to know the people I do, friends and family. We always cater for kids - and by that I mean have something ready early because kids work on different time. 4pm is early for adults but may not be for kids. I have never, ever been invited to anyone's home that didn't have anything ready for kids to eat. If it was my mum and it was being hosted in a family members home, my mum would have made something before hand just not only for my kids but anyone else's whose kids are there. Yanbu, your mum was so ugly to mock you over something that's perfectly normal.

MargotBamborough · 20/10/2023 11:58

spitefulandbadgrammar · 20/10/2023 11:55

The takeaway is that you appear to have missed that OP suspects ASD, she struggles with unspoken rules and last-minute changes, and may well not be capable of this.

Of course what I expect/do doesn’t tally with everyone in the world, but I’m very glad my friends and family communicate clearly instead of this weird game of “let’s do this at 4pm! But not really!”

That's why it's useful for her to have started this thread and got a range of responses.

It will allow her to change her expectations, which is the only thing that is within her control. Other people's behaviour isn't, whether it is reasonable or not.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 20/10/2023 11:55

MargotBamborough · 20/10/2023 11:49

So the takeaway from this thread is that what you would expect and what you would do is not necessarily the same as what other people would expect or do.

OP is capable of saying, "Toddler is hungry, can she have something to eat?" at 4pm whether the host has said anything or not.

The takeaway is that you appear to have missed that OP suspects ASD, she struggles with unspoken rules and last-minute changes, and may well not be capable of this.

Of course what I expect/do doesn’t tally with everyone in the world, but I’m very glad my friends and family communicate clearly instead of this weird game of “let’s do this at 4pm! But not really!”

spitefulandbadgrammar · 20/10/2023 11:49

@HoppingPavlova But why on earth not say what you mean? I don’t know anyone who does this. If my friends want us there for 4pm but food is later, they’ll say to come at 4pm to hang out and we’ll have food later. I can see why OP is baffled, I am too, and I’m coming at it from a NT perspective.

MargotBamborough · 20/10/2023 11:49

spitefulandbadgrammar · 20/10/2023 11:47

@MargotBamborough As host I’d certainly expect to communicate clearly to my guests if the plan changed: “no one’s hungry yet, right? Shall we fire the barbecue up later and eat at 7? Everyone OK for a drink?” And then the onus is on OP to say “Actually toddler is hungry, have you got some cheese/soup/toast she can have as we’ll need her in bed by the time you’re eating.” It just sounds like no one actually communicated, which makes it harder for OP to speak up.

So the takeaway from this thread is that what you would expect and what you would do is not necessarily the same as what other people would expect or do.

OP is capable of saying, "Toddler is hungry, can she have something to eat?" at 4pm whether the host has said anything or not.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 20/10/2023 11:47

@MargotBamborough As host I’d certainly expect to communicate clearly to my guests if the plan changed: “no one’s hungry yet, right? Shall we fire the barbecue up later and eat at 7? Everyone OK for a drink?” And then the onus is on OP to say “Actually toddler is hungry, have you got some cheese/soup/toast she can have as we’ll need her in bed by the time you’re eating.” It just sounds like no one actually communicated, which makes it harder for OP to speak up.

HoppingPavlova · 20/10/2023 11:45

But then why would anyone say “food at 4pm”?

Again, because none would comprehend that. I’d say ‘yep, food at 4pm’, meaning, come at 4pm with the intent you will subsequently be fed food (as opposed to just coming over for drinks), but it wouldn’t mean food served at 4pm.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 20/10/2023 11:44

@Cammac Light tea and snack are two different things. “HTH”!

MargotBamborough · 20/10/2023 11:44

spitefulandbadgrammar · 20/10/2023 11:41

But then why would anyone say “food at 4pm”? I’m NT and generally if someone says something is happening at X time I expect it to happen at that time, regardless of my personal mealtime preference – especially since these can clearly be so varied. My MIL eats her dinner at 5pm, my European housemates were always 9 or 10pm, my preference is 7.30pm, small children schedules are the Wild West.

I don't know, maybe they didn't think their statements were contractually binding?

Maybe they thought they'd serve food at 4pm but none of their other guests were actually hungry at that time because they'd eaten lunch three hours earlier. You really want them to cook 20 burgers at 4pm when no one else is hungry just because the parents of a toddler want everything to happen exactly as planned?

Real life is less rigid than this.

Most toddlers' schedules are actually less rigid than this.

Cammac · 20/10/2023 11:43

@spitefulandbadgrammar

I have no idea who feeds their child what when they leave nursery. Mine always had a snack - Half a sandwich, veg sticks or whatever at 4pm as toddlers or when they came home from school. We all ate together at dinner.

You think your child is fine with a snack or “light tea” aka snack at 4pm and a yogurt before bed. You know your D.C. Op knows her D.C. she is upset that the host didn’t feed her dc at a time that suits D.C. and OP. Ultimately OP is responsible for making sure her child’s basic needs are met. Nobody else!

HoppingPavlova · 20/10/2023 11:42

I would assume there must be a miscommunication as ansolutely no one has dinner at 4pm. Maybe be you interpreted this as dinner served but they interpreted it as turn up, I know if someone said to me ‘4pm for dinner’, I’d say ‘yes, 4pm’, thinking they would turn up around 4pm, time for greeting, chat, drinks, nibbles and the BBQ would be fired up 6/6.30ish.

I’ve had kids so understand their eating patterns but no child, be it toddler, young child, older child I’ve had or known has eaten dinner at 4pm.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 20/10/2023 11:41

MargotBamborough · 20/10/2023 11:35

Yes but this is the point, isn't it?

There are lots of people who wouldn't expect food at 4pm, regardless of what had been said beforehand. So what OP thinks is reasonable is not what a lot of other people think is reasonable.

If I invited people over at 2pm I'd expect them to have just had lunch and not be hungry at 4pm.

But then why would anyone say “food at 4pm”? I’m NT and generally if someone says something is happening at X time I expect it to happen at that time, regardless of my personal mealtime preference – especially since these can clearly be so varied. My MIL eats her dinner at 5pm, my European housemates were always 9 or 10pm, my preference is 7.30pm, small children schedules are the Wild West.

dutysuite · 20/10/2023 11:36

My inlaws invite us to a BBQ and we turn up at the given time they’ve already started or finished eating. 🤣

MargotBamborough · 20/10/2023 11:35

spitefulandbadgrammar · 20/10/2023 11:33

@MargotBamborough I think we can conclude “children are different”. At two mine was in bed at 6.30! I actually think that 4pm is a red herring: it could have been any time, the point is she was told food at Xpm but there was no food at Xpm. Doesn’t matter that your kid has pasta at 6 and mine has yoghurt at half five: OP was still not served food when she could have reasonably expected it.

Yes but this is the point, isn't it?

There are lots of people who wouldn't expect food at 4pm, regardless of what had been said beforehand. So what OP thinks is reasonable is not what a lot of other people think is reasonable.

If I invited people over at 2pm I'd expect them to have just had lunch and not be hungry at 4pm.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 20/10/2023 11:33

@MargotBamborough I think we can conclude “children are different”. At two mine was in bed at 6.30! I actually think that 4pm is a red herring: it could have been any time, the point is she was told food at Xpm but there was no food at Xpm. Doesn’t matter that your kid has pasta at 6 and mine has yoghurt at half five: OP was still not served food when she could have reasonably expected it.

MargotBamborough · 20/10/2023 11:29

spitefulandbadgrammar · 20/10/2023 11:22

@MargotBamborough She’ll have some Greek yoghurt or something at home but she’s not hungry for more. Used to have a cup of milk in the bath but doesn’t want that any more. Sleeps through till 7am then gets up and wants to play rather than demanding breakfast. It’s less about the time without food, I think, as the overall quantity of calories over 24 hours and over the week – lots of studies show that if you increase a child’s calories at breakfast they’ll self-regulate to eat less throughout the day; the “stuff them full before bed so they’ll sleep” is a myth. Adults don’t neck their dinner right before bed, we need and want time to digest and unwind; same for kids.

Right, but adults go to bed a lot later than kids do so they don't have so long to wait until breakfast.

My two year old has a large lunch at about 12, then a snack at 4pm which is usually bread, jam and fruit compote, or sometimes cake if a child has a birthday, then he comes home and eats something like pasta or rice with vegetables and some fruit between 6pm and 6:30, which is usually about an hour and a half before he falls asleep. By 7am he is hungry and demanding his breakfast.

I really wouldn't want to move that whole schedule forward by two hours, or even one hour.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 20/10/2023 11:22

@MargotBamborough She’ll have some Greek yoghurt or something at home but she’s not hungry for more. Used to have a cup of milk in the bath but doesn’t want that any more. Sleeps through till 7am then gets up and wants to play rather than demanding breakfast. It’s less about the time without food, I think, as the overall quantity of calories over 24 hours and over the week – lots of studies show that if you increase a child’s calories at breakfast they’ll self-regulate to eat less throughout the day; the “stuff them full before bed so they’ll sleep” is a myth. Adults don’t neck their dinner right before bed, we need and want time to digest and unwind; same for kids.

ManyATrueWord · 20/10/2023 11:22

MargotBamborough · 20/10/2023 10:34

They're not "lying". They just don't realise that the sky will fall in if the schedule slips a bit.

Saying that you will do something and then not doing it makes you a liar. Just because it's normal doesn't mean it's right. And I don't believe they really believe what they say because if they had the intention of making food for when they said it would be, they would have to start earlier.

IdaPolly · 20/10/2023 11:21

spitefulandbadgrammar · 20/10/2023 11:15

@Cammac So first it’s nurseries serve a snack at 4pm, now you concede it’s actually tea, and that as I said, snack is actually earlier – and smaller than the tea (one might go so far as to say snack-sized!). “Puzzling.” How do you know most kids “have” dinner with their families after their “nursery” meal, have you “done” a survey? Most nurseries do their main meal at lunch “and” a lighter meal at teatime. Some kids will eat more later, some “won’t”. Tea is often a sandwich with side elements “such” as vegetable sticks, therefore it is a meal. (Makes as much “sense” as your arbitrary declaration of what a meal isn’t.) Thank “you” too! Hope I got the passagg inverted commas right!

MargotBamborough · 20/10/2023 11:17

spitefulandbadgrammar · 20/10/2023 11:15

@Cammac So first it’s nurseries serve a snack at 4pm, now you concede it’s actually tea, and that as I said, snack is actually earlier – and smaller than the tea (one might go so far as to say snack-sized!). “Puzzling.” How do you know most kids “have” dinner with their families after their “nursery” meal, have you “done” a survey? Most nurseries do their main meal at lunch “and” a lighter meal at teatime. Some kids will eat more later, some “won’t”. Tea is often a sandwich with side elements “such” as vegetable sticks, therefore it is a meal. (Makes as much “sense” as your arbitrary declaration of what a meal isn’t.) Thank “you” too! Hope I got the passagg inverted commas right!

I'm curious about this. If your toddler has their evening meal at 4pm are they really expected to manage without food until the next morning, i.e. about 15 hours?

spitefulandbadgrammar · 20/10/2023 11:15

@Cammac So first it’s nurseries serve a snack at 4pm, now you concede it’s actually tea, and that as I said, snack is actually earlier – and smaller than the tea (one might go so far as to say snack-sized!). “Puzzling.” How do you know most kids “have” dinner with their families after their “nursery” meal, have you “done” a survey? Most nurseries do their main meal at lunch “and” a lighter meal at teatime. Some kids will eat more later, some “won’t”. Tea is often a sandwich with side elements “such” as vegetable sticks, therefore it is a meal. (Makes as much “sense” as your arbitrary declaration of what a meal isn’t.) Thank “you” too! Hope I got the passagg inverted commas right!

MargotBamborough · 20/10/2023 11:14

aSofaNearYou · 20/10/2023 10:48

@MargotBamborough It's usually that we are planning on eating together and they just keep pushing it back to a later and later time because to them it isn't a problem. With my family it's usually that they aren't ready in time for lunch, with my DPs it's usually that they want us to hang around for dinner later than is convenient, and then we live an hour away so there's the inevitable danger nap in the car. Yes we could leave early and suit ourselves. but that would be cancelling the whole point of meeting. They do know the sorts of time we like to do things as we've spoken about it so many times. They just don't seem to think.

I'm not saying they're doing anything massively wrong, it's just one of those things in life that you put up with but that is quite annoying.

In your case I think I would bring everything you need for your child's lunch and just say, "If lunch is on the table at the time DC needs to eat, they can eat with us, otherwise we'll just sort DC out at their usual time and the adults can eat whenever lunch is ready," and I would refuse dinner invitations altogether.