Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if those who love winter have very robust mental health or very happy lives?

917 replies

Comedycook · 19/10/2023 19:07

So I was thinking about this after reading a thread about weather. Lots of posters saying how they loved winter...some even said they love the dark evenings and what really surprised me was the poster who said they loved dark, cold mornings. I assumed everyone hated these!

Now I'm not in a terrible place mentally and I'm not depressed but I do find the dark, rainy, cold days do affect my mood. When the evenings are warm and light I feel so much happier.

I'm really interested in how others don't feel that the winter brings them down and actually enjoy it. Are they naturally happier, more positive type people?

OP posts:
SpicedAppleAndFreshCider · 24/10/2023 22:27

I like the changes too and enjoy each season.

I love the different clothes & different activities.

LaLoba · 24/10/2023 22:09

EasternStandard · 19/10/2023 19:17

Give me seasons. Each one feels good but I don’t want to be stuck in any one

Same here. I like the changes. Looking at my recipe books to see what I’ll cook for different seasons, candles and baths (with gin and audiobooks) in winter, sitting in the garden till late drinking rose and barbecuing a lot in summer. Spring has the garden and the countryside really coming to life and for me, my healthiest, most energetic time. Autumn is when I start to recover from the heat fatigue of summer and can run further than a couple of miles.

I hesitate to say this as I’ll probably get people jumping down my throat, but maybe mental robustness does play a part. Being able to enjoy things you can’t change and find the joy. And no, I’m not judging those who can’t, for whatever reason.

cardibach · 24/10/2023 21:49

LusaBatoosa · 24/10/2023 18:40

I really don’t care if people dislike summer and like winter.

Cool, then I wasn’t talking about you and there’s no need for this exchange.

Maybe winter haters main more because we get approximately 10 months of cold/damp/dreary weather every year and only 2 (at best) or sunshine and warmth. We’ve got more to moan about.

Again, there is exactly nothing winter lovers can do about that. And you can moan as much as you like. I certainly don’t mind. However, if you’re going to moan, then complaining about other people moaning is a bit hypocritical.

Not only were you talking about me, this post is in reply to a post where you quoted me.

Delatron · 24/10/2023 20:59

Crikeyalmighty · 24/10/2023 17:29

@Delatron I'm in Los Angeles at the moment- every day around 27 degrees so far but cool in an evening - heaven to me!

Sounds simply wonderful!

LusaBatoosa · 24/10/2023 18:40

cardibach · 24/10/2023 14:48

@LusaBatoosa I really don’t care if people dislike summer and like winter. I don’t understand why, and their ‘reasons’ don’t make sense to me, but whatever floats your boat. I do object to people telling me I can just put a jumper on and I’ll be fine - you think I haven’t thought of that? Or one poster saying I’m being ridiculous to suggest being cold might affect my concentration (but being hot affects theirs).
Maybe winter haters main more because we get approximately 10 months of cold/damp/dreary weather every year and only 2 (at best) or sunshine and warmth. We’ve got more to moan about. But actually, have a look at mount hot weather threads as soon as the sun comes out in summer - it’s not just us.

Edited

I really don’t care if people dislike summer and like winter.

Cool, then I wasn’t talking about you and there’s no need for this exchange.

Maybe winter haters main more because we get approximately 10 months of cold/damp/dreary weather every year and only 2 (at best) or sunshine and warmth. We’ve got more to moan about.

Again, there is exactly nothing winter lovers can do about that. And you can moan as much as you like. I certainly don’t mind. However, if you’re going to moan, then complaining about other people moaning is a bit hypocritical.

phoenixrosehere · 24/10/2023 17:51

Overcooker · 24/10/2023 16:33

If you live somewhere where you only enjoy the weather for a few weeks per year (and for much of the rest of the year you actively dislike it), surely you should be considering moving?

I did only for people to be shocked how I love it in SE England because it’s supposedly always rains and it’s grey. Yet, every time I visited (NE & SE England) before I moved (winter and spring) it was sunny more often than not. Even having lived in this part of England over a decade, still think there is way more sunny days and not as bad compared to other parts of the country but I understand that’s due to dealing with extreme weather and temps and being equipped to handle them, but not dealing with them anymore.

Crikeyalmighty · 24/10/2023 17:29

@Delatron I'm in Los Angeles at the moment- every day around 27 degrees so far but cool in an evening - heaven to me!

Delatron · 24/10/2023 16:52

Ah yes so simple! I moved to the South from the North. That helped a bit.

One day I’ll definitely spend half the year in a different country.

Overcooker · 24/10/2023 16:33

If you live somewhere where you only enjoy the weather for a few weeks per year (and for much of the rest of the year you actively dislike it), surely you should be considering moving?

Delatron · 24/10/2023 16:16

There are so many more threads on here that moan the minute it goes above 18 degrees. That’s what we all take umbrage with. This thread is actually unusual…I have been given a short thrift on many a ‘oh it’s toooo hot’ thread. I’ve never seen one discussing how shit and long winter is before.

cardibach · 24/10/2023 14:48

@LusaBatoosa I really don’t care if people dislike summer and like winter. I don’t understand why, and their ‘reasons’ don’t make sense to me, but whatever floats your boat. I do object to people telling me I can just put a jumper on and I’ll be fine - you think I haven’t thought of that? Or one poster saying I’m being ridiculous to suggest being cold might affect my concentration (but being hot affects theirs).
Maybe winter haters main more because we get approximately 10 months of cold/damp/dreary weather every year and only 2 (at best) or sunshine and warmth. We’ve got more to moan about. But actually, have a look at mount hot weather threads as soon as the sun comes out in summer - it’s not just us.

LusaBatoosa · 24/10/2023 14:27

cardibach · 22/10/2023 11:12

Not cross about your preferences. Cross that there’s a load of you moaning as soon as the weather goes over 18 for 5 mins about how hot and bright it is with no recognition that it’s a teeny bit of the year.
Also the unrealistic nature of the raptures about autumn/winter which go on about crisp sunny days - this isn’t a regular feature of the darker months in most of the UK. It’s nonsense, and those people don’t actually like the weather in the country in which they live any more than people who like weather over 25 do.
Edit: I’m not fully in the winter hating group. I’m ok as long as it’s not raining or grim with a load of slush everywhere. I prefer longer hours of daylight because it’s easier to do stuff. I don’t feel pressure to go out either in summer or at Christmas. I do what I want to do and what makes me happy. Also I’m lucky enough not to have to worry too much about paying for heating - but a season which doesn’t cost me money to just stay warm is always going to be higher up my list of likes than one that costs me a fortune (yes, I have an oodie. It’s on).

Edited

You just described being cross about other people’s preferences while claiming not to be cross about other people’s preferences. This is a strange thread.

Again, what do you want us to do about this? And why are other people’s ‘unrealistic raptures’ a problem? Also, the winter hating group is considerably moanier than the summer hating group - as illustrated by this thread. To the extent that they take umbrage at anyone not hating winter with them.

ManateeFair · 24/10/2023 13:52

IDriveMySupernova · 24/10/2023 12:44

How did your parents feel about autumn and winter?

My mum used to make a big song and dance of how ‘the nights are drawing in’ from August onwards and how it’s ‘nothing but doom and gloom for the next four months’ as if it was the most depressing thing in the world. It definitely instilled in me this sense of panic and dread around the ‘dark nights’. I didn’t really overcome it until I was in my late 20s when I developed PTSD, when suddenly I equated the blanket of darkness and relative quiet with safety and self care.

It's interesting because my mum really hates winter and it definitely seems to affect her mental health; she always used to openly dread it when I was a kid. But somehow I never picked that up from her. My dad never moaned about winter but he definitely much prefers summer, and so does my brother. My sister just likes the change of seasons in general I think. But I've always found winter weirdly exciting. For me, it's just much more mysterious and atmospheric. I loved the spookiness of dark evenings when I was a kid and I still do. My favourite weather is basically a freezing winter mist that smells damp in the air!

ManateeFair · 24/10/2023 13:34

Comedycook · 19/10/2023 19:12

But lots of people do find winter depressing...it's why seasonal affective disorder is a thing. I'm interested in how some people can actively enjoy something that makes others so miserable?

There are millions of things that some people enjoy that make others actively miserable, though. It's not limited to the seasons. Some people feel incredibly lonely and depressed if they spend most of their time alone, while others are much happier that way. Some people are absolutely terrified of heights while others feel exhilarated by looking at the view from the tallest building they can find. Some people cannot bear the feeling of being in deep water while others are miserable without their daily swim. Everyone's different.

For me personally, I prefer autumn and winter to summer. I tend to feel quite relieved when the clocks change. I like colder weather, I like winter fashion more than summer stuff, and I prefer dark evenings. And no, that doesn't mean I want an excuse to sit and watch telly under a blanket - I'm much more active in winter than summer! One of my favourite things to do on a dark winter evening is to go for a run, and I love a long walk on a cold day too.

I do like the fact that we have seasonal changes, and I don't hate summer or anything, but I hate being too warm and I tend to sweat a lot which I find embarrassing and unpleasant. I'm also very pale so I burn very easily and have to wear sunscreen all the time which I find sticky and messy. I'm also very allergic to most insect bites and am prone to prickly heat, so generally just not really built for summer. I don't mind warm weather on holiday, in countries that are kitted out for that (ie where everywhere has air-con and houses are designed to keep you cool with tiled floors etc) and where I don't have to go to work and do chores and so on, but if they were the only two weeks of hot weather I ever experienced I'd be fine with that. And even then I'd still prefer it to be dark by 7pm at the latest. I'd never go on a Mediterranean holiday in summer, only in autumn/winter.

To answer the OP's original question - no, I'm not a cheery and positive person with stable mental health! I'm an introvert with a history of clinical depression and anxiety. I'm not outwardly emotional or prone to sudden mood swings or anything like that (I'm generally a very contained kind of person) but I've had periods of mental illness from childhood onwards and I take medication every day.

RampantIvy · 24/10/2023 13:12

but I don't go around telling people who love it how much it sucks.

Loads of people on MN do. As soon as we get a couple if days of temperatures at 21 degrees there are loads of threads complaining about the "heatwave".

There are far more "I hate summer" threads than winter hating threads.

JaneGainsborough · 24/10/2023 13:07

aSofaNearYou · 24/10/2023 12:54

I’m not totally anti-winter. But still as far as I can see the people who love it actually love the things they do to avoid it - blankets, hiding indoors from rain, heavy clothes. Seems odd to me

You could say that about a lot of things, though. People swim in summer to cool down, but could still say they love swimming in summer. Same with ice creams and cold drinks. People go on holidays to get away from the mundanity of their lives, but could still say they love holidays.

It doesn't really make a difference why we like the things we do in winter, we still like them.

Precisely. I have to say I am annoyed by the winter bashing. Well, not the winter bashing in itself, people like what they like. But why do people who hate winter find it so hard to understand that not everyone feels the same? I'm not the biggest fan of summer, but I don't go around telling people who love it how much it sucks. If I were to take the approach to summer that the winter haters do, I would say things like 'well how often is it actually SUNNY, rather than raining and miserable (I find that endless grey skies are worse when sunset is much later because you then have grey instead of dark). It doesn't make sense.

aSofaNearYou · 24/10/2023 12:54

I’m not totally anti-winter. But still as far as I can see the people who love it actually love the things they do to avoid it - blankets, hiding indoors from rain, heavy clothes. Seems odd to me

You could say that about a lot of things, though. People swim in summer to cool down, but could still say they love swimming in summer. Same with ice creams and cold drinks. People go on holidays to get away from the mundanity of their lives, but could still say they love holidays.

It doesn't really make a difference why we like the things we do in winter, we still like them.

IDriveMySupernova · 24/10/2023 12:47

RampantIvy · 24/10/2023 12:40

I’m not totally anti-winter. But still as far as I can see the people who love it actually love the things they do to avoid it - blankets, hiding indoors from rain, heavy clothes. Seems odd to me

I agree.
I also wonder how many lovers of our actual reality of winter drive to and from work in the dark on motorways in driving rain or sleet.

This is definitely true in my case. I WFH atm but I will be commuting and working outdoors next year. I hate driving in the dark (thanks astigmatism) so I suspect my feelings will change somewhat!

IDriveMySupernova · 24/10/2023 12:44

Comedycook · 24/10/2023 10:45

No not that I don't think. Although I detested lockdown! I actually remember feeling this way from childhood. Even then I used to get the sense of doom as the evenings drew in.

How did your parents feel about autumn and winter?

My mum used to make a big song and dance of how ‘the nights are drawing in’ from August onwards and how it’s ‘nothing but doom and gloom for the next four months’ as if it was the most depressing thing in the world. It definitely instilled in me this sense of panic and dread around the ‘dark nights’. I didn’t really overcome it until I was in my late 20s when I developed PTSD, when suddenly I equated the blanket of darkness and relative quiet with safety and self care.

RampantIvy · 24/10/2023 12:40

I’m not totally anti-winter. But still as far as I can see the people who love it actually love the things they do to avoid it - blankets, hiding indoors from rain, heavy clothes. Seems odd to me

I agree.
I also wonder how many lovers of our actual reality of winter drive to and from work in the dark on motorways in driving rain or sleet.

Delatron · 24/10/2023 12:34

Light reflected on snow 😂. I mean how often does that happen in this country? (I’ll understand if you’re the poster from Canada). I actually like snow. If it snowed more maybe I’d enjoy winter more. It’s the never ending dreary cold with not much sun I don’t like. And often all my favourite dog walks by the river flood so I can’t even get joy there.

SpicedAppleAndFreshCider · 24/10/2023 11:50

duchiebun · 24/10/2023 11:02

Halloween, fireworks are in Autumn. I love Christmas but find the rest of Winter (Jan & Feb) pretty depressing.

I'm the same, love all the festivities. After New Year I look forward to Spring & Summer. We're booking festivals already for next year.

cardibach · 24/10/2023 11:46

KimberleyClark · 24/10/2023 11:42

@cardibach have you had your thyroid checked? Feeling constantly cold can be a symptom of underactive thyroid.

I have an under active thyroid, well treated and at a set thyroxine level for over 20 years. It’s probably not helping, I agree. I was the same as a child though (thyroid under active post pregnancy), and I don’t think everyone who feels like this has an under active thyroid. Again, schools have a lower permitted temperature but not higher. Being cold is well understood to be uncomfortable and to stop people concentrating.

KimberleyClark · 24/10/2023 11:42

@cardibach have you had your thyroid checked? Feeling constantly cold can be a symptom of underactive thyroid.

Justme10 · 24/10/2023 11:38

I love winter. I like the dark mornings and nights and I don't mind the rain either. I'm not a fan of strong winds though.
And I love all the nice things that go along with it as well.

I like summer as well but there's more things I dislike about it than winter.

Swipe left for the next trending thread