Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if those who love winter have very robust mental health or very happy lives?

917 replies

Comedycook · 19/10/2023 19:07

So I was thinking about this after reading a thread about weather. Lots of posters saying how they loved winter...some even said they love the dark evenings and what really surprised me was the poster who said they loved dark, cold mornings. I assumed everyone hated these!

Now I'm not in a terrible place mentally and I'm not depressed but I do find the dark, rainy, cold days do affect my mood. When the evenings are warm and light I feel so much happier.

I'm really interested in how others don't feel that the winter brings them down and actually enjoy it. Are they naturally happier, more positive type people?

OP posts:
Cozytoesandtoast00 · 19/10/2023 21:02

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 19/10/2023 20:01

You could say that about anything. I find Eastenders depressing but other people love it. I find wearing all black depressing but some people love it. I enjoy spending long periods by myself with no loneliness, other people might find that depressing.
I'm not a winter person, I prefer the light and the warmth of summer, I just kind of try and make the best of winter and force myself to see some positives in it.
I am heavily considering investing in a sunlight lamp though.

I honestly think the purchase of my SAD lamp has changed winters for me.
Without fail, I sit every morning with it fairly close to my face, with all the other lights on for 20-30 minutes. You can do this with your morning cuppa. Give it a few weeks and see how you feel.
I have not had winter depression for at least six years now!

3ormoredogs · 19/10/2023 21:02

I love winter.

I especially love when it’s raining and getting dark…I tend to wrap up with a torch, grab the dog and go for a lovely long walk where I see nobody at all because everyone else prefers fair weather.

I am an introvert clearly!

Blinky21 · 19/10/2023 21:01

I love the hunkering down feeling in the evenings, the coziness, not having any pressure to go out if I don't want to, no neighbours being noisy in gardens and winter clothes are much nicer and more stylish in my opinion. Also so many festivities in autumn and winter to enjoy

Comedycook · 19/10/2023 21:01

Ertriscia · 19/10/2023 20:58

But lots of people do find winter depressing...it's why seasonal affective disorder is a thing. I'm interested in how some people can actively enjoy something that makes others so miserable?

When look at what people are listing they enjoy, they are talking about what they do.

So, they enjoy fairy lights and socks or whatever. But these are things they do to combat the cold and winter.

Nobody has actually said "yes, I enjoy leaving the office to faceful of sleet that makes my cheekbones hurt and I love sliding around on ice and crashing into Belisha beacons because I've lost control of my car, that's when I know autumn has arrived".

Every single thing that people have talked about on here as being positive are things that they do to stop themselves going doollaly/getting frostbite.

So actually people enjoy the coping mechanisms and rituals associated with being cold.

If they were relentlessly exposed to the elements in the cold, with no cashmere socks, so catch up drinks, no lovely steaming mugs of hot chocolate, they would be unhappy.

Yes that's a great point

OP posts:
BrightYellowDaffodil · 19/10/2023 21:01

I love all the seasons, there is magic in them all. I don’t live in a beautiful rectory in the Cotswolds but I still love my little flat - in winter I have candles and incense, nice blankets etc. I love the change from one season to another and crisp mornings, my horse’s breath rising when I ride out, Christmas and even the duvet days in bad weather when it’s OK to spend the whole day reading a book have their charm.

I try to live to the seasons, especially with food, but also the season’s energy. Winter is a quiet time and, for me, it’s a time of hunkering down and enjoying comfort.

That’s not to say there aren’t bits I don’t like - freezing mornings don’t always seem beautiful when I have to lift chunks of ice out of my horse’s trough with my bare hands, and the endless mud come January and February is a pain. My house is not always the warmest, much as my fuel bill suggests I’m running a blast furnace.

But, as with so many things, it’s what you make it.

Tumbleweed101 · 19/10/2023 21:01

I'm not really a winter person, I prefer spring and autumn before it gets properly cold and dark. However I do like the slower pace of the winter days where it is quiet and the dark means you have a reason not to get outdoor jobs done but stay inside and do house jobs. I tend to neglect the house in the summer to do stuff outside.

Donein2023 · 19/10/2023 21:01

I hate summer, find any heat truly oppressive. Winter we wrap up and spend it outside as much as possible. Autistic kids much prefer the cold and wild weather too

totallyteutonic · 19/10/2023 21:00

Have poor mental health that summer makes worse, I hate bright light, being hot, summer clothes, hayfever etc. I would very happily live in perpetual autumn / winter. I like the dark, I like layers, I just like the vibe!

Firebird83 · 19/10/2023 21:00

I have SAD so fucking hate late autumn and winter.

MrsTerryPratchett · 19/10/2023 20:59

FUCKING WASPS.

That is all.

Ertriscia · 19/10/2023 20:58

But lots of people do find winter depressing...it's why seasonal affective disorder is a thing. I'm interested in how some people can actively enjoy something that makes others so miserable?

When look at what people are listing they enjoy, they are talking about what they do.

So, they enjoy fairy lights and socks or whatever. But these are things they do to combat the cold and winter.

Nobody has actually said "yes, I enjoy leaving the office to faceful of sleet that makes my cheekbones hurt and I love sliding around on ice and crashing into Belisha beacons because I've lost control of my car, that's when I know autumn has arrived".

Every single thing that people have talked about on here as being positive are things that they do to stop themselves going doollaly/getting frostbite.

So actually people enjoy the coping mechanisms and rituals associated with being cold.

If they were relentlessly exposed to the elements in the cold, with no cashmere socks, so catch up drinks, no lovely steaming mugs of hot chocolate, they would be unhappy.

1990thatsme · 19/10/2023 20:58

I love all the seasons and really appreciate the changes.

Yes, I do have an Aga, and open fireplaces, but tbh I don’t go in for tramping through the woods much. I just love the hygge of blankets, cushions, apple crumble and custard. All snuggled up on the sofa together.

I love summer too, am lucky enough to live near the beach and it makes the summer holidays much easier with three young DC.

What I absolutely hate with a passion is the rain. It really does make me miserable.

@Delatron, you know you can ferry your DC around wearing pyjamas, right? I do feel for you though. Glad mine don’t do outdoor winter sports, it must be intolerable.

BeverForget · 19/10/2023 20:58

I hate flat grey days, but I love winter. Clear skies, freezing nights, bright stars, warm fires, good books, dog curled up with/next to/on me.

spuddel · 19/10/2023 20:58

I love all the seasons for different reasons but yes, winter is fabulous for all the cosy opportunities, wardrobe options and Christmas! I am a glass half full person for sure though.

KimberleyClark · 19/10/2023 20:58

I quite like winter. The times I have had SAD were when I wasn’t feeling happy generally - struggling with infertility, in a job I hated etc. Now I am retired and really happy, I like the dark mornings and the dark evenings and I can enjoy what daylight there is because I’m not stuck in an office all day. And enjoy cosy evenings listening to podcasts or reading.

cowgirl42 · 19/10/2023 20:56

I like winter. I feel
less compelled to be busy like in summer. The children are in a better bedtime routine and I just feel less exhausted as we all seem to settle down for the evening earlier. I do however get outside whenever I can.

Would say I am generally a positive person. OH on the other hand hates it and suffers with SAD but I think he is generally not so positive and is extremely busy during the summer months and he finds it difficult to wind down.

Fionaville · 19/10/2023 20:56

In some ways I think it's down to being either optimistic or pessimistic. So it's easier to look forward to the 'coziness' of winter and the feeling of getting home into the warmth after being out in the cold. And wintery walks.
I love all the seasons, because I can see the good in them all and wouldn't really want to live full time in a country that didn't have 'proper' seasons like we do.
Winter should be a time when we rest more. When we spend more time indoors, keeping warm when its dark and being connected to our families and letting ourselves slow down (I know this isn't always possible in the modern world of work) So when we say we look forward to winter, we actually mean we are looking forward to the slower pace and rest.
Then in the spring, we are reawakened, like nature. Ready to make the most of being outside more.
The optimistic can see the good things about winter. It must be hard hating the dark and cold, yet living in the UK.

theysaiditgetseasier · 19/10/2023 20:56

43ontherocksporfavor · 19/10/2023 20:47

I don’t get the pressure people are saying they feel to socialise more in summer. If anything I’d rather go out in the colder months.

Because in my case the vast majority of family & friends are summer lovers, they people the winter they hate going out they moan it's too cold and once they're indoors they want to stay indoors.

Hayliebells · 19/10/2023 20:56

I'm always way more comfortable in winter than summer, so if I had to have a preference, it's winter all the way. Something about being too hot really affects me, I just can't do anything. I love walking but find that impossible when too hot, work is harder, sleep is harder, everything is just harder. With the right clothes I'm fine in winter, so I appreciate that it's not hot.

Delatron · 19/10/2023 20:56

MuckyPlucky · 19/10/2023 20:09

I wonder if the winter-lovers (all tucked up under blankets eating stews & hot chocs) and the summer lovers (can get out & about later / early morning wood runs, long evening bike rides etc) can be split into those who are naturally less active/sporty and those who need to do outdoor activity most days (running, gardening, cycling, outdoor swimming, hiking, climbing etc)

I can’t imagine anyone in the latter group saying they just love only getting 8hrs of daylight per day, and the prospect of rain storms, sleet, etc.

Yes I suggested this on another thread about this. I can’t imagine wanting to lie on a sofa under a blanket most evenings for 6 months..

I like the light evenings because I can go for a run, walk the dog along the river and sit outside a pub and have a drink, go to the lake and swim etc etc.

I find the dark claustrophobic and it means I can’t do as many things.

Also, those coming home from work and getting in to PJs mustn’t have children to ferry around to various sporting activities. This is also far worse in the dark and rain. I am not snuggling under a blanket in front of the fire, I’m standing in the rain and dark by a football pitch.

It feels awful and unnatural to me to get up in the dark. Our body clocks are designed to wake with light.

IdaPolly · 19/10/2023 20:54

MsCactus · 19/10/2023 20:50

I mentioned my skin too in my response - I'm very, very pale skinned and I absolutely love the winter.

Both my mum and brother are very tanned and both hate the winter, love the summer.

My mum tans easily too. She's got brown eyes and olive skin. I'm pale like my Scottish grandmother. I was freckly when younger.

Disturbia81 · 19/10/2023 20:54

I love winter, cold, dark nights. I'm a positive person, never get depressed. I don't drive and I work in city centre so I'm out in all weathers.
I just feel alive on cool dark dry nights or gloomy grey clouds. I get energy. Summer saps it out of me, I can't stand it being so light all day. I love having blankets and fires. I love closing the world out. I love fashion for cold weather. I love wearing coats and boots. Love the peace on the streets.
I'd say it's 50/50 judging from here

Thundercnut · 19/10/2023 20:53

There are not enough words to describe how much I hate winter (and Autumn, if it comes to it). I loathe it. I detest dark evenings and mornings, and I despise "snuggling" and blankets and "hot choc" and all the other revolting shit that people come out with about winter. Christmas can fuck off, too. I have to be out and doing things and in the light the whole time - if someone wanted to torture me, they would make me stay at home.

I'm a pale blonde person so maybe I should love winter, but I love boiling hot summers. I had all my children in summer because I hate winter so much that I didn't want to lumber children with winter birthdays (mine is also July).

Nothing personal about those who like winter, obviously, but I'm not one of those people.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 19/10/2023 20:53

Lolaandbehold · 19/10/2023 20:13

I wouldn’t say I love winter per se, but I do love being indoors in winter: fire lighting, nice lighting, a good tv show or book. Even better if it’s raining beating against the veluxes. I think I just love being cosy.
equally I love a crisp winter’s day with blue sky and a nice bracing walk, all wrapped up warm.
I can’t say I love getting up in the dark when it’s wet though.

Yes me too

MrsTerryPratchett · 19/10/2023 20:52

These posters who describe their winter evenings seem to have idyllic lives. Happy families walking through the woods coming home to their big warm house with a casserole in the aga and the log fire going. Cracking open the red wine and having a hot chocolate whilst playing board games. Getting the bus home in an inner city area in the pissing down rain and cold just doesn't seem as cosy and lovely.

You're writing a script for other people's lives. I live in a nice place with a nice family now. But I still preferred winter when I lived in a shit flat, alone in South London.

I hate sandals (my feet hurt and I get stubbed toes), I like winter hats (I look all Anna Karenina rather than a curried tomato face in summer), I don't tan I burn (which means shade and sunscreen, which I'm allergic to), I have sensitive eyes so wear sunglasses all year and it's not enough in summer, I CANNOT STAND lobster red shirtless men everywhere sweating at me, drunk Brits in public places (urg), endless shit BBQ food, I'd rather be cold than hot and love blankets, I like all the winter foods, I LOVE Halloween, Christmas, Hanukkah and Solstice, I like the smell of fires, leaves, rain and Christmas more than coconut and sweat.

Stop assuming why people like it or not. You don't. Great. But lots of us do, regardless of income, mood or MH.