Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if those who love winter have very robust mental health or very happy lives?

917 replies

Comedycook · 19/10/2023 19:07

So I was thinking about this after reading a thread about weather. Lots of posters saying how they loved winter...some even said they love the dark evenings and what really surprised me was the poster who said they loved dark, cold mornings. I assumed everyone hated these!

Now I'm not in a terrible place mentally and I'm not depressed but I do find the dark, rainy, cold days do affect my mood. When the evenings are warm and light I feel so much happier.

I'm really interested in how others don't feel that the winter brings them down and actually enjoy it. Are they naturally happier, more positive type people?

OP posts:
IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 20/10/2023 12:08

Comedycook · 20/10/2023 12:03

Forgot about NYE....I absolutely hate it. Enforced fun. Can't think of anything worse than going out on NYE in the cold and dark and unable to get a cab...whilst feeling pressured to celebrate. Hideous.

I'm a winter person (sorry!) but totally agree on this. We stay in. Film on, takeaway or something we really enjoy cooked, naughty snacks. Pre-DC we might have had a late walk to see the fireworks. Sometimes we invite family over, if we're feeling strangely sociable, but usually we just hunker down at home all cosy, in our little unit. Love it.

GCSister · 20/10/2023 12:06

I love NYE but that's because we have a house party with close friends and then walk home!

I think people would be much happier if they just did what they enjoyed rather than what was expected of them.

Comedycook · 20/10/2023 12:03

Forgot about NYE....I absolutely hate it. Enforced fun. Can't think of anything worse than going out on NYE in the cold and dark and unable to get a cab...whilst feeling pressured to celebrate. Hideous.

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 20/10/2023 11:45

I agree about snow. Some people get childishly excited about it but for people who have to try to get to work or school in it or who have disabilities or unsteady on their feet for any reason, or people who run businesses dependent on people getting to them, it’s a nightmare. And the shops sell out of essentials like milk and you can’t get any for love nor money.

ToWhitToWhoo · 20/10/2023 11:38

I don't like REALLY hot weather, and my skin doesn't like blaring sunshine, so the sort of summer they've had in much of Europe this year would have been a nightmare for me. But we don't get too much of it here. In fact, except for all the rain, I really like most aspects of British weather and feel lucky to have it- not a popular view, I know!

I don't really mind being cold as such, but I hate snow. I would like to sue snow under the Disability Discrimination Act! There is a myth (incorrect, in fact) that the languages of the native peoples of the Arctic have over 100 words for snow. I certainly have over 100 words for snow- but none of them are printable! Again. however, we don't get a lot of it in Britain, especially in the south.

The time of year that really depresses me is my birthday (not in the winter) and the day or two around it. But if no one reminds me of it, I can often forget its existence until it is over. I know people who are similarly depressed by New Year's Day, and that is harder to forget.

IDriveMySupernova · 20/10/2023 11:26

I’m very much a depressive, have PTSD and live alone but prefer Autumn and Winter. I don’t enjoy the heat combined with humidity of British summers. I can’t go for my usual walks because I get lightheaded and sweat. I feel dehydrated constantly. I feel pressure to be out doing stuff. There’s constant noise from neighbours and people outside. My city fills with tourists. It’s too bright, too loud. It’s basically a sensory nightmare.

In Autumn and Winter I like how the dark nights feel like a cocoon. I can shut my blinds and feel safe. No constant noise outside. I can go for walks without needing a shower as soon as I get home. I don’t feel guilty about not going out in the evenings. I can just be me.

Splishsplashsplooshsplosh · 20/10/2023 11:24

"I hate November and December...once we have the winter solstice though I start to feel hope as every day we get a little more daylight. I really don't mind January as Christmas is out of the way and I feel like spring is on the way."

I'm literally the opposite to this. I hate winter but November and December arent really winter. They're autumn. Autumn I love. There is so much going on it's almost as nice as summer. Halloween, bonfire night, Christmas stuff. People have lights up and it makes the darkness bareable. Then we have NYE and honestly I hate the NY celebrations. It's like the END of the good times and there is absolutely nothing to look forward to for the next 3 months or so. Cold, dark, drab, damp, muddy, depressing. Ugh.

Comedycook · 20/10/2023 11:18

My late mum used to say that it's light at 5 pm at the end of January, and boy, does that keep me going! The winter solstice (21st Dec) is a MASSIVE date for me - the day then the year turns and the days start to get longer

Yep me too. I hate November and December...once we have the winter solstice though I start to feel hope as every day we get a little more daylight. I really don't mind January as Christmas is out of the way and I feel like spring is on the way.

OP posts:
Objectionhearsayspeculation · 20/10/2023 11:13

AlwaysHeadingWest · 20/10/2023 10:48

I really struggle with the expectation that we should love summer and that you should be happy when it's a warm sunny day. When I've been feeling down that just makes it worse. It makes me feel really out of step with the rest of the world and is quite isolating.

I'm also quite sensitive to bright light but unfortunately live in a south-facing house - I had no idea when we bought it that it would bother me so much but I can't stand the bright sunlight coming into my house - I find it really oppressive and if I'm working from home I end up drawing all the blinds and sitting in the darkness.

I struggle with clothes as well - I feel much smarter and more put-together in winter. In hot weather I just feel a mess. I know that seems shallow but it has an effect on my self-confidence.

I actually enjoy the outdoors but much prefer to out in cooler weather as opposed to summer days - I like the freshness and as long as I'm warmly wrapped up I'm fine.

I feel a lot of similarities to you, especially with regards to the feeling out of step with everyone else's expectations of loving summer. I also much prefer being outdoors in the crisper weather, as the bright light makes my migraines worse.

Regarding the OPs question about the dark nights and mornings they improve my mental health hugely because I feel somehow more relaxed and secure, I don't mind the dark or doesn't bother me I associate it with happy times and more time together (farm so DH in more and Dds around more) and Dd1 is the same. DH and Dd2 though are the opposite and hate it much prefer the lighter nights and mornings.

CoffeeCantata · 20/10/2023 10:57

Just joined the thread so - sorry if this has been said many times!

I too used to love winter, but now I'm retired, not so much. Obviously it's the shortening days which can be depressing (esp when I was in work and didn't see my garden from weekend to weekend - due to darkness.

I think I'm OK as long is the sun is shining, so I don't mind cold, bright winters - just the sort where it rains for weeks on end and the sun never breaks through.

Now I prepare for this by getting together a 'winter box' with really tempting books, DVDs, possibly some needlework/art projects to keep me going until things start to get better - usually about late Feb.

My late mum used to say that it's light at 5 pm at the end of January, and boy, does that keep me going! The winter solstice (21st Dec) is a MASSIVE date for me - the day then the year turns and the days start to get longer. Conversely I get miserable at midsummer, when the days start to shorten after June 22nd. I can really identify with prehistoric people and their stone circles, designed to celebrate the winter solstice probably above all other astronomical events!!

AlwaysHeadingWest · 20/10/2023 10:48

I really struggle with the expectation that we should love summer and that you should be happy when it's a warm sunny day. When I've been feeling down that just makes it worse. It makes me feel really out of step with the rest of the world and is quite isolating.

I'm also quite sensitive to bright light but unfortunately live in a south-facing house - I had no idea when we bought it that it would bother me so much but I can't stand the bright sunlight coming into my house - I find it really oppressive and if I'm working from home I end up drawing all the blinds and sitting in the darkness.

I struggle with clothes as well - I feel much smarter and more put-together in winter. In hot weather I just feel a mess. I know that seems shallow but it has an effect on my self-confidence.

I actually enjoy the outdoors but much prefer to out in cooler weather as opposed to summer days - I like the freshness and as long as I'm warmly wrapped up I'm fine.

purpleyellowy · 20/10/2023 10:48

BlurredEdges · 20/10/2023 09:28

Why do people keep saying "stew" as if it's a good thing?

Agreed! I bloody hate stew! A well cooked Sunday roast in winter is a different matter

chunkyhunkyalmond · 20/10/2023 10:41

@HoldOnMiGenna don't agree at all. London is beautiful in autumn. Do you live somewhere very built up without any trees or parks? As can imagine that would make a difference.

User0000009 · 20/10/2023 10:39

Darker evenings mean no kids whacking balls outside and running around doing high-pitched screams both of which irritate the life out of me. Bring on the darker evenings. Candles lit. Peace and quiet

User0000009 · 20/10/2023 10:37

Fredthefrog · 19/10/2023 19:14

I like being cosy and indoors. I like the cool air and frost. I feel more comfortable in winter clothes and less hot a sweaty. I am a much more irritable person when hot so not necessarily more positive. I also like the festivals in winter halloween, bonfire night and Christmas. It does start to drag in February though...

Yes this

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 20/10/2023 10:35

When I lived in London I loved winter. It never got super cold, lots of cool Christmas-y stuff, all the lights. Now I live in the sticks in West Yorkshire and I don’t love it. It’s extraordinarily wet, very dark, very cold, and my stone house with high ceilings is everything I dreamt of 10 years ago when I was in London but bugger me, it gets cold and stays cold

Disturbia81 · 20/10/2023 10:32

garlicandsapphires · 20/10/2023 09:23

You see I am the opposite to most people and find Summer a bit depressing. Spring gives me anxiety. I'm not sure why. There's a bit of FOMO in Summer and the feeling that everyone except me is out having fun. I love Autumn, I really quite like getting up when it's dark and I absolutely love the cold. I am also a big fan of January!!!

Yeah too much light and the long days get to me. Not depressed but I feel happier when the nights start getting dark. Maybe I'm a vampire Grin

EasternStandard · 20/10/2023 10:14

HoldOnMiGenna · 20/10/2023 10:09

Two of my favourite dates in the whole calendar are December 21st whereafter the days get longer ( Winter Solstice) and March 21st where we have the first time of the year where the amount of daylight hours match the dark ( Equinox).
If not for these seasonal markers , Christmas, daffodils peaking through, green moss appearing on tree trunks and branches signifying life, and anticipation of at least eight hours of daylight by late January.....I would have brought forward my move to Jamaica at serious financial cost to me far sooner.
London Autumns and Winters have to be top ten of the ugliest things in nature. Damp, grey, lack of crispness and low winter sun, hardly any snow, frost on low roofs, much less pavements is anomalous by sunrise, but it's still cold....with none of the seasonal beauty or conditions.
I have to really cling to the nuances and a sense of being grateful for life in order not to get depressed.
I do get jealous of those who live in places in the UK where more than one of the seasons acts accordingly. As it is in London, we could guarantee Spring and Autumn....now we haven't even got Autumn acting right past mid October.

I’m in London I can’t relate to this.

HoldOnMiGenna · 20/10/2023 10:09

Two of my favourite dates in the whole calendar are December 21st whereafter the days get longer ( Winter Solstice) and March 21st where we have the first time of the year where the amount of daylight hours match the dark ( Equinox).
If not for these seasonal markers , Christmas, daffodils peaking through, green moss appearing on tree trunks and branches signifying life, and anticipation of at least eight hours of daylight by late January.....I would have brought forward my move to Jamaica at serious financial cost to me far sooner.
London Autumns and Winters have to be top ten of the ugliest things in nature. Damp, grey, lack of crispness and low winter sun, hardly any snow, frost on low roofs, much less pavements is anomalous by sunrise, but it's still cold....with none of the seasonal beauty or conditions.
I have to really cling to the nuances and a sense of being grateful for life in order not to get depressed.
I do get jealous of those who live in places in the UK where more than one of the seasons acts accordingly. As it is in London, we could guarantee Spring and Autumn....now we haven't even got Autumn acting right past mid October.

LifeofBrienne · 20/10/2023 09:55

MotherOfCatBoy · 20/10/2023 09:12

I hate winter. And I say that as someone who gets outdoors a lot, I’m active, and I like the changing of the seasons. But I live in Wales and our typical winter weather is exactly as it is today - grey, wet, raining, no light, miserable.
I am a light driven creature and I find the dark mornings very hard to get up. The shortened day length is horrible. The outdoor landscape is peeled of colour; even the houses have grey slate roofs (because of all the rain). I find myself wondering why we don’t all paint our houses bright colours like they do in the Far North - I’d love to see red and yellow to brighten things up! (Pink front door here!).
A light box helps. A dose of that every morning stops me dipping further than I otherwise would.

What you say about houses, I feel about winter coats. I was looking round a crowd of people on a grey day in London recently and imagining if their coats weren’t 60% black, with almost all the rest grey/khaki/navy, if there wasn’t apparently a rule that men are only allowed to have black umbrellas - wouldn’t it all be less depressing?
I actually started a thread once about this and got absolutely slated. Apparently you can’t say that a crowd of people all dressed in gloomy colours is depressing as it’s massive privilege to have a coloured winter coat even if it’s old or second hand. Because if you can’t afford more than one coat it has to not show dirt and be suitable if you need to go a funeral in winter.
On a different topic, I do understand that feeling that everyone else is enjoying themselves, that some people get in summer - I get it not in summer but in the run up to Christmas. Much prefer January to December!

KimberleyClark · 20/10/2023 09:47

Sugaristheenemy · 20/10/2023 09:05

Possibly when people say this they're just lonely, and feel it more in summer when they can see people out having fun more. In winter people are indoors, even while socialising, so the perception is that others aren't out and about, so being lonely doesn't feel so unusual

I wouldn’t go that far but there probably is more FOMO in the summer. You feel you should be doing something.

Plus if you are not tanned people assume you have been actively avoiding the sun, which is not necessarily the case. I just don’t tan.

EasternStandard · 20/10/2023 09:40

minipie · 20/10/2023 09:32

The plants would outvote us

Too right

minipie · 20/10/2023 09:32

EasternStandard · 20/10/2023 09:29

Maybe if we all liked the same one the seasons would listen ;

The plants would outvote us

WoollyBat · 20/10/2023 09:31

Mmmmmmm stew! Because it’s warming and feels wintery and cosy!

EasternStandard · 20/10/2023 09:29

LusaBatoosa · 20/10/2023 08:40

Some of you seem genuinely angry that other people like seasons you don’t like. What’s up with that? It’s a very strange attitude.

Maybe if we all liked the same one the seasons would listen ;