Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if those who love winter have very robust mental health or very happy lives?

917 replies

Comedycook · 19/10/2023 19:07

So I was thinking about this after reading a thread about weather. Lots of posters saying how they loved winter...some even said they love the dark evenings and what really surprised me was the poster who said they loved dark, cold mornings. I assumed everyone hated these!

Now I'm not in a terrible place mentally and I'm not depressed but I do find the dark, rainy, cold days do affect my mood. When the evenings are warm and light I feel so much happier.

I'm really interested in how others don't feel that the winter brings them down and actually enjoy it. Are they naturally happier, more positive type people?

OP posts:
Delatron · 21/10/2023 18:27

My point is - proportionally, according to the weather in the UK and not the calendar. ‘Winter’ ie cold and mainly murky/damp weather lasts a lot longer than ‘summer’ if we actually get a summer which is not a given.

We most certainly do not get 3 months of lovely warm weather guaranteed every year.

So if you like winter you’re doing a bit better than if you like summer and warm weather. In this country at least.

AInightingale · 21/10/2023 18:22

Surely most of March is winter? Winter is 20 December to 20 March - astronomical seasons.

Comedycook · 21/10/2023 18:19

My ds birthday is in march...it's a weird month. One year we had a bbq in the garden on his birthday and another year there was heavy snow. But I don't really mind the cold in march and April as the days are longer and I know summer is on its way.

OP posts:
Delatron · 21/10/2023 18:07

KimberleyClark · 21/10/2023 08:27

Winter is 3 months. December, January, February.

It was colder in April than Jan this year. It’s more likely to snow at Easter than at Christmas. March often does not resemble anything spring like… so yes the cold and damp goes on for a lot longer than 3 months..

TrashedSofa · 21/10/2023 17:48

RampantIvy · 21/10/2023 17:16

@TrashedSofa the one I bought isn't available any more. I had got caught in a torrential downpour that even my "waterproof" jacket couldn't cope with. They will probably bring out something similar next year. I am pleased with it as it is properly waterproof (and non sweat making).

They probably should. The way our climate is going, clothes that can deal well with rain in hot weather are going to be increasingly popular.

Cornflakes44 · 21/10/2023 17:31

I feel the pressure to be happy and cheery in the summer sometimes too much. I like the gloom as it feels appropriate. And like it can only get better from there.

AgentJohnson · 21/10/2023 17:24

I don’t like the dark per de but I do like the change from one season to the other. I went backpacking around Asia many moons ago and the constant sunshine did start to annoy me.

For me winter is: hot chocolate, not feeling I have to be out and about because it’s still light at 21:00, Christmas being around the corner, stews and stodgy comfort food etc. Come February I’m over it and can’t wait for Spring.

Excessive sun and being so dam hot that I can barely function, now that makes me depressed.

RampantIvy · 21/10/2023 17:16

@TrashedSofa the one I bought isn't available any more. I had got caught in a torrential downpour that even my "waterproof" jacket couldn't cope with. They will probably bring out something similar next year. I am pleased with it as it is properly waterproof (and non sweat making).

phoenixrosehere · 21/10/2023 17:15

I feel hot, uncomfortable in the heat. I also get incredibly faint and dizzy in the heat - no idea why, but whenever I'm on holiday with friends I get heat stroke before everyone else.

For me, it’s my blood pressure being on the lower end of healthy. I was having fainting spells in childhood and it took me fainting at 30 after leaving the doctors for a check-up (everything was fine) less than 20 minutes earlier and an ambulance called to be told my blood pressure dropped too low.

I'm not offended...but irl I've never known anyone open the curtains, see it's raining and grey and found its boosted their mood.

I do. I actually prefer to work in the garden when it’s grey and there’s a bit of wetness and chill in the air otherwise I’m burning up in my coat and gloves.

IDriveMySupernova · 21/10/2023 17:02

@RampantIvy I'm from North Yorkshire and I remember feeling lucky if we had a few days above 20C. Although even my family (still there) suffered last year. I've always preferred the 'dark nights' for the cocooned/safe feeling it brings for me but didn't mind summer so much in the north. In the SE, especially in my touristy location, summer has well and truly become something I dread now.

TrashedSofa · 21/10/2023 16:56

I can answer that one @TrashedSofa. When it rains in Yorkshire where I live it is never warm rain. I have a very light Seasalt raincoat that I bought this summer. It is as light as a cagoule, but lined and isn't sweaty. Basically I don't get hot and sweaty in Yorkshire rain because it isn't warm enough to generate sweat.

It's not really warm rain where I am either- also north. But the rain itself isn't cool enough to make it not warm when the temperature is high.

Might have a look at the Seasalt raincoats though...

headcheffer · 21/10/2023 16:51

I like it cold rather than hot so prefer winter. But I always welcome the lighter brighter days come spring, and do find it gives me a happiness lift.

RampantIvy · 21/10/2023 16:49

Yet none of the summer lovers have been telling us how much they enjoy it when it's pissing it down but too warm to wear waterproofs without boiling.

I can answer that one @TrashedSofa. When it rains in Yorkshire where I live it is never warm rain. I have a very light Seasalt raincoat that I bought this summer. It is as light as a cagoule, but lined and isn't sweaty. Basically I don't get hot and sweaty in Yorkshire rain because it isn't warm enough to generate sweat.

You have demonstrated very clearly that it depends very much on where you live @IDriveMySupernova. Here in South Yorkshire we had two weeks of nice weather in June, the wettest July for 40 years, a few warm days in August and a hot week in September. Our reservoirs are overflowing. No relentless hot days for weeks on end this year.

And yes, I live in a house with a garden on a hill in a village on the edge of the Pennines, so where you live will be considerably warmer.

IDriveMySupernova · 21/10/2023 16:30

RampantIvy · 21/10/2023 15:29

I also hate hate hate summer

Apart from the odd very hot day (which I completely get that heat haters struggle with), what do you hate about summer @MsCactus? It isn't as if we get the relentless heat over a long period of time that the Med does. Our hot days tend to be interspersed with cooler, cloudy or wet days.

Like the OP I do struggle to understand why people prefer to sit in artificial light instead of natural daylight. It doesn't have to be sunny, just not dark.

And like others I'm not keen on summer clothes as I lack confidence in them.

Summer clothes does not equal skimpy clothes though. I mean this kindly, but if you think you look fat in summer clothes, you won't look any less fat in winter clothes. Clothes that skim rather than clothes that cling look better on every body shape, summer and winter alike.

I live in the South East and the hot summer days really do feel relentless. This year summer was slow to get going, but once it started here it didn't stop. Yes there were a few days of cloud where it was a few degrees cooler, but it still felt very hot and humid. As for the year before... well, I just hope I never have to endure a repeat of that.

I do think it helps if you have a garden or you're the sort of person who likes to be out and about wild swimming or whatever.

I don't have a garden to enjoy summer in. If I want to get out then I have to go to the park which will be full of people, big groups having BBQs or picnics and playing music. Nothing wrong with that of course, I just don't find it enjoyable to be around.

I could drive out to the countryside but a lot of other people have the same idea which creates big traffic jams. My car's aircon is broken so it's really unpleasant to be in (and gets v hot as my parking space is in full sun all day), especially when stuck in traffic.

My flat is modern and energy efficient so it traps heat. During the summer it can get up to 30 C and stays there. I have big floor fans running but it doesn't help much. I just end up useless, feeling sick and unable to sleep. I have to keep my blinds closed until the sun goes down which is depressing.

If I lived in the countryside, in a house that doesn't trap the heat so much, with a big garden then no doubt I'd enjoy summer. I'd be out there all the time, under a parasol or canopy with a G&T and a book.

TrashedSofa · 21/10/2023 16:23

Comedycook · 21/10/2023 11:47

I'm not offended...but irl I've never known anyone open the curtains, see it's raining and grey and found its boosted their mood.

It's weird how many people keep coming back to the rain thing as though we don't live in a climate with rain all year round. There's a bit more of it in winter, but the UK is not a country with a consistently dry summer. Yet none of the summer lovers have been telling us how much they enjoy it when it's pissing it down but too warm to wear waterproofs without boiling.

RampantIvy · 21/10/2023 16:16

Dressing for work in the winter can be a problem because offices are so overheated that you can’t actually wear jumpers.

Not true in my case. The aircon where I work is too fierce. I have no idea why it is on most of the time. We have windows that open. It's such a monumental waste of resources.

MsCactus · 21/10/2023 16:06

RampantIvy · 21/10/2023 15:29

I also hate hate hate summer

Apart from the odd very hot day (which I completely get that heat haters struggle with), what do you hate about summer @MsCactus? It isn't as if we get the relentless heat over a long period of time that the Med does. Our hot days tend to be interspersed with cooler, cloudy or wet days.

Like the OP I do struggle to understand why people prefer to sit in artificial light instead of natural daylight. It doesn't have to be sunny, just not dark.

And like others I'm not keen on summer clothes as I lack confidence in them.

Summer clothes does not equal skimpy clothes though. I mean this kindly, but if you think you look fat in summer clothes, you won't look any less fat in winter clothes. Clothes that skim rather than clothes that cling look better on every body shape, summer and winter alike.

I feel hot, uncomfortable in the heat. I also get incredibly faint and dizzy in the heat - no idea why, but whenever I'm on holiday with friends I get heat stroke before everyone else.

Even when it's not hot enough to make me ill (I start feeling ill around 27 degrees, so fairly low hot temperatures) I just hate the feeling of sun on my skin. I didn't actually realise that people liked it for ages - thought it was something people "put up with" in the summer.

I quite like lounging by the pool on holiday, but only under some shade, the hot sun genuinely feels horrible to me. It's hot, it's warm, it's sweaty, it's grim.

Have felt like this since I was a child 🤷‍♀️

KimberleyClark · 21/10/2023 16:00

Comedycook · 21/10/2023 15:42

@RampantIvy agree especially with regards to clothes. I'm overweight but prefer summer clothes. I have about 8 summer dresses which I wear in rotation with various flip flops and sandals. I hate getting dressed on a winter morning. I never know what to wear. Leggings can look too casual. I find jeans uncomfortable. I like wearing dresses but in winter you have to wear with tights which is a faff. I actually think summer clothing can be more flattering as you're not bulking yourself out with layers upon layers.

Dressing for work in the winter can be a problem because offices are so overheated that you can’t actually wear jumpers.

RampantIvy · 21/10/2023 15:58

I have more clothes for colder weather than warm weather as it is usually not warm.

So do I, for the same reasons.

I'm not skinny either BTW.

aSofaNearYou · 21/10/2023 15:49

RampantIvy · 21/10/2023 15:29

I also hate hate hate summer

Apart from the odd very hot day (which I completely get that heat haters struggle with), what do you hate about summer @MsCactus? It isn't as if we get the relentless heat over a long period of time that the Med does. Our hot days tend to be interspersed with cooler, cloudy or wet days.

Like the OP I do struggle to understand why people prefer to sit in artificial light instead of natural daylight. It doesn't have to be sunny, just not dark.

And like others I'm not keen on summer clothes as I lack confidence in them.

Summer clothes does not equal skimpy clothes though. I mean this kindly, but if you think you look fat in summer clothes, you won't look any less fat in winter clothes. Clothes that skim rather than clothes that cling look better on every body shape, summer and winter alike.

I don't like it when it's light until late. I find I stay in "daytime mode" rather than settling down to enjoy myself and then suddenly it's bedtime. And I don't sit there with the full light on - I associate dim lighting/darkness with excitement, festivities, magic etc. I don't think there's ever been a time in my life when I've done more exciting things in summer than winter due to the various festivals in winter, which is probably why I associate darkness with fun and excitement.

And I don't need to be told that I look fat in all clothes, but I personally find it more comfortable to throw on a pair of leggings than wear a dress, or go through all of my summer clothes from the previous year to discover that they don't fit me any more and struggle to find anything suitable to wear. I have more clothes for colder weather than warm weather as it is usually not warm.

Nagado · 21/10/2023 15:48

I hate summer; it makes me utterly miserable. I live in a sweatbox flat with small windows and no usable outside space, not even a balcony. It’s unbearably hot in the summer and I can go for months without sleeping properly. And when I do eventually get off to sleep, the light mornings and noisy birds wake me up too early. My neighbours are normally outside their houses playing loud music, smoking weed and letting their kids run riot until well after dark. There are wasps and buzzy things all over the place and god forbid you open your window while your lights are on. You get out of a tepid shower and need another within a hour. You never feel fresh or totally clean. The buses and trains are full of sweaty people and everyone seems to be irritable and generally harassed.

I feel completely energised in autumn and winter and my mental health is always improved. I love the colours of the trees. I like walking in heavy rain. I love walking through snow when it’s dark and it’s really quiet and peaceful. I really enjoy going down to the beach when it’s cold and blustery and going home feeling wide awake and like all the cobwebs have been blown away. I feel more alert at work. I can control my body temperature. I can sleep properly. I can enjoy my favourite foods without worrying about my kitchen spontaneously combusting because I’ve had the oven on for 20 minutes. All my favourite things happen in the winter (Christmas, a family holiday etc).

I totally understand that we all like different things but for someone to say they like dark mornings and rain is like someone saying to me, oh I absolutely love it when I find mouldy food in fridge… You do sound like you’re struggling with the concept that anyone might feel about summer the way you feel about winter.

Comedycook · 21/10/2023 15:42

@RampantIvy agree especially with regards to clothes. I'm overweight but prefer summer clothes. I have about 8 summer dresses which I wear in rotation with various flip flops and sandals. I hate getting dressed on a winter morning. I never know what to wear. Leggings can look too casual. I find jeans uncomfortable. I like wearing dresses but in winter you have to wear with tights which is a faff. I actually think summer clothing can be more flattering as you're not bulking yourself out with layers upon layers.

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 21/10/2023 15:29

I also hate hate hate summer

Apart from the odd very hot day (which I completely get that heat haters struggle with), what do you hate about summer @MsCactus? It isn't as if we get the relentless heat over a long period of time that the Med does. Our hot days tend to be interspersed with cooler, cloudy or wet days.

Like the OP I do struggle to understand why people prefer to sit in artificial light instead of natural daylight. It doesn't have to be sunny, just not dark.

And like others I'm not keen on summer clothes as I lack confidence in them.

Summer clothes does not equal skimpy clothes though. I mean this kindly, but if you think you look fat in summer clothes, you won't look any less fat in winter clothes. Clothes that skim rather than clothes that cling look better on every body shape, summer and winter alike.

Dweetfidilove · 21/10/2023 14:44

My preference is anything between 21 - 24 degrees, but I still find I enjoy winter.

Everyone knows I’m not coming out in the cold so I’m free of expectations/outings.

The cold requires hot brews, so the place always smells of ginger, oranges and cinnamon leaves or whatever else I can find to boil.

Soups, stews, heating, electric blanket and copious amounts of long baths and candles 🥰. I really go overboard on candles, but yeah, winter is cosy season and I love it (inside).

Oakbeam · 21/10/2023 14:32

Do those who love 30 degrees+ temperatures have aircon in their homes?

No. For short journeys I tend not to it in use in the car in those temperatures either because the huge contrast when you get in and out.