Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if those who love winter have very robust mental health or very happy lives?

917 replies

Comedycook · 19/10/2023 19:07

So I was thinking about this after reading a thread about weather. Lots of posters saying how they loved winter...some even said they love the dark evenings and what really surprised me was the poster who said they loved dark, cold mornings. I assumed everyone hated these!

Now I'm not in a terrible place mentally and I'm not depressed but I do find the dark, rainy, cold days do affect my mood. When the evenings are warm and light I feel so much happier.

I'm really interested in how others don't feel that the winter brings them down and actually enjoy it. Are they naturally happier, more positive type people?

OP posts:
HelinaHandcart · 21/10/2023 21:12

Redhead living in Canada. I hate the long, hot summers. I burn very easily and am susceptible to heat stroke. Socializing in summer is difficult, as is even being at home or at work - I can’t focus well when temperatures are in the high 30s or 40s. Sleeping is very difficult due to the heat (even with air conditioning) and the light (even with blackout curtains).

I love the cold and the snow. Long stretches of rain can be gloomy but I’ll take that over summer.

LadyTrunchbull · 21/10/2023 21:08

Working outside a lot has seemingly left me with an iron constitution whereby I just don't seem to feel the cold anymore. It's hell for me being in friend's houses when the heating is cloyingly hot.

That said, I was working last summer on the day when it was 34°C and the a/c was broken in my truck. When stationary the temp was 44°C in the cab as it's right over the engine. I think it was just pure stubbornness that kept me going as I'd rather be a bit warm than sit at home and sacrifice £200 pay.

CleverLilViper · 21/10/2023 21:05

I love winter which is odd as I do/have suffered with seasonal affective depression in the past quite badly.

i love the cold. I love dark mornings and evenings. I think because of my SAD I’ve found methods that help me cope such as making my home really bright and cosy, focusing on Christmas etc.

I’ve found especially with Christmas, it’s helped me so much to just be completely focused on it- decorating, all the bright and twinkly lights, presents, music, movies etc and the foods has given me something positive to draw away from the feelings that sometimes bother me.

BitOutOfPractice · 21/10/2023 21:04

I agree @Comedycook the people who say they love winter describe it like every day is bright and crisp. The reality is grey, mizzle, low clouds, damp, dreary days when it never seems to get light.

also, an an extrovert, I’m feeling a bit fed up of explaining that yes, I do like being out and about and that doesn’t make me a monster.

cardibach · 21/10/2023 21:01

Kat1981111 · 20/10/2023 03:09

I love winter lover. At least when we are cold we can wrap up love the cosy winter evenings. Its a very homely feel.

Wrapping up doesn’t make me warm. Just uncomfortable. It’s neither cosy nor homely to be uncomfortable and cold. In summer I wear linens, keep in the shade, close curtains appropriately in the day and always have the option of a fan. Much more comfy and homely.

TrashedSofa · 21/10/2023 20:57

Delatron · 21/10/2023 19:29

Yes that was exactly it.

I don't know anyone who liked the weather this summer just gone. It was alternated between pissing it down and muggy damp spells inbetween. Too wet for everyone, not cool enough for the summer sceptics and not warm enough for the heat fans. With the added bonus that indoor places were much fuller than usual, so even the people who don't care much about the weather and stay inside got irritated too!

TrashedSofa · 21/10/2023 20:54

givemeasunnyday · 21/10/2023 19:54

Not all the summer lovers on here live in the UK. As I said, I can understand people not liking heat, but not liking the sun is just plain odd.

Autumn is actually my favourite season, but autumns where I live are generally sunny and warm - just not as hot as summer.

It's true not everyone on here lives in the UK or a place with similar climate. But the OP evidently does, and if there's one thing that's pretty clear about this thread it's that she's located this discussion very firmly within her own experiences! And there's such a lot of seasonal variation globally.

Also, not liking the sun certainly isn't plain odd if you burn easily.

BatshitCrazyWoman · 21/10/2023 20:47

givemeasunnyday · 21/10/2023 19:42

I agree that looking outside and seeing rain and grey clouds and having your mood boosted is odd. Maybe it's a UK thing (or perhaps a MN thing?). I've heard numerous people say their mood instantly improves when the sun shines - whatever the season - but I've never heard anyone say they prefer dull days. One rainy day now and again is nice, low cloud at any time is horrible. I can understand people not liking heat, but sunshine??? Never irl have I heard anyone say they don't like sunshine.

I don't much like the sun. A cool, grey day is lovely 😍 We're all different.

ToWhitToWhoo · 21/10/2023 20:23

Comedycook · 20/10/2023 12:03

Forgot about NYE....I absolutely hate it. Enforced fun. Can't think of anything worse than going out on NYE in the cold and dark and unable to get a cab...whilst feeling pressured to celebrate. Hideous.

In the case of my friends, it's not really the actual celebrations that bother them, as they don't feel under pressure to go out and party in any case. Just that it's another milestone to mark time passing; and that depresses them.

I don't really feel like that about NYE (though I don't party for it) but I do feel like that about my new age day, aka birthday, and no one is allowed to remind me of it.

LadyTrunchbull · 21/10/2023 20:21

The sun can defo boost my mood but I think the crux is that the weather isn't really a huge factor in determining my happiness.

I will admit though that I was standing outside the other day when it was cold but sunny, enjoying the sun on my face. I actually thought for a second 'ah, spring's on its way' before remembering that actually winter's on its way and it's going to get much colder and grimmer for a good few months. 😭😭😭

phoenixrosehere · 21/10/2023 20:08

Halfemptyhalfling · 21/10/2023 18:58

I like wearing coats as they have pockets so don't always have to carry a bag. Also not having to think about suncream is a plus. I like being in a normal work/school routine whereas in the summer holidays everything gets a bit messy. The wet at the moment feels abit relentless but we have rainy patches all times of year in the UK. For people who now can't afford heating winter must be really miserable.

Also not having to think about suncream is a plus.

Sunscreen is recommended to be worn year-round even in overcast weather.

ExperiencedTeacher · 21/10/2023 20:01

There’s lots I love about all of the seasons. I’m quite “outdoorsy” so get out with the kids in most weathers. Obviously don’t put us at risk by being out in floods but a bit of rain/snow/wind etc doesn’t stop us having fun. I’m not a big fan of dark mornings but they are so short lived it never bothers me that much.

givemeasunnyday · 21/10/2023 19:54

TrashedSofa · 21/10/2023 16:23

It's weird how many people keep coming back to the rain thing as though we don't live in a climate with rain all year round. There's a bit more of it in winter, but the UK is not a country with a consistently dry summer. Yet none of the summer lovers have been telling us how much they enjoy it when it's pissing it down but too warm to wear waterproofs without boiling.

Not all the summer lovers on here live in the UK. As I said, I can understand people not liking heat, but not liking the sun is just plain odd.

Autumn is actually my favourite season, but autumns where I live are generally sunny and warm - just not as hot as summer.

Womencanlift · 21/10/2023 19:51

You seem to have a very fixed mindset OP. You have said many times you assume that everyone hates winter mornings when many people have given you reasons why they don’t

I love summer and I love winter. It’s actually this time of year that I don’t like. At least in winter it’s festive with Christmas. Yes I wouldn’t open my curtains and smile at a rainy day, but a crisp morning, absolutely

While I don’t think everyone that suffers from depression prefers winter (that’s quite a generalisation) it could be that there is more pressure on people to do stuff in the summer whereas staying in is more socially acceptable in the winter which may give people an “out” when needed

Oakbeam · 21/10/2023 19:46

Never irl have I heard anyone say they don't like sunshine.

Vampires?

givemeasunnyday · 21/10/2023 19:42

Comedycook · 21/10/2023 11:47

I'm not offended...but irl I've never known anyone open the curtains, see it's raining and grey and found its boosted their mood.

I agree that looking outside and seeing rain and grey clouds and having your mood boosted is odd. Maybe it's a UK thing (or perhaps a MN thing?). I've heard numerous people say their mood instantly improves when the sun shines - whatever the season - but I've never heard anyone say they prefer dull days. One rainy day now and again is nice, low cloud at any time is horrible. I can understand people not liking heat, but sunshine??? Never irl have I heard anyone say they don't like sunshine.

Delatron · 21/10/2023 19:29

EasternStandard · 21/10/2023 19:28

Ime June was nice and really dry, July bad, August had one good week and September too

It wasn’t the best summer if you like heat

Yes that was exactly it.

EasternStandard · 21/10/2023 19:28

Ime June was nice and really dry, July bad, August had one good week and September too

It wasn’t the best summer if you like heat

Delatron · 21/10/2023 19:23

IDriveMySupernova · 21/10/2023 19:09

The south east is quite a big place.

Yeah I’d love to know where in the SE had a nice summer in July and August??!

IDriveMySupernova · 21/10/2023 19:09

Delatron · 21/10/2023 18:31

Once summer got going? What you mean that week in September? July and August were a complete wash out. People do have short memories. I live in the S.E. I struggle to sleep in the heat. I have an air con unit. I didn’t turn it on for the whole of July or August…

The south east is quite a big place.

Halfemptyhalfling · 21/10/2023 18:58

I like wearing coats as they have pockets so don't always have to carry a bag. Also not having to think about suncream is a plus. I like being in a normal work/school routine whereas in the summer holidays everything gets a bit messy. The wet at the moment feels abit relentless but we have rainy patches all times of year in the UK. For people who now can't afford heating winter must be really miserable.

LadyTrunchbull · 21/10/2023 18:35

Well, I was diagnosed with major depressive disorder at 16yo and like winter (although I also love when it starts getting warmer again).

Tbf, though, I'm pretty content with life atm. I struggled for years in office jobs, which I think was probs down to my ADHD but I'm now in the construction sector driving trucks and managing one of our big aggregate contracts. Well paid, low stress, and I enjoy it.

I like that crisp wintery feel that makes you feel sharp and alive. It's the exact opposite of the lethargic chilled feeling I get on warm balmy summer days.

Spending a lot of time outside I've probs got more reason than most to hate the rain (get bloody soaked!) but I also manage to get out in the sunlight a lot even in the winter. When I was in the office I hated driving to and from work in the dark and being inside all day long.

I also ensure I'm not deficient in Vit D which I think is a big factor. Also think it's not great for humans to spend all day every day inside, especially not stuck in the same room like many office workers are. I love being at multiple sites a day. It stops me feeling stagnant in a weird way.

Delatron · 21/10/2023 18:31

IDriveMySupernova · 21/10/2023 16:30

I live in the South East and the hot summer days really do feel relentless. This year summer was slow to get going, but once it started here it didn't stop. Yes there were a few days of cloud where it was a few degrees cooler, but it still felt very hot and humid. As for the year before... well, I just hope I never have to endure a repeat of that.

I do think it helps if you have a garden or you're the sort of person who likes to be out and about wild swimming or whatever.

I don't have a garden to enjoy summer in. If I want to get out then I have to go to the park which will be full of people, big groups having BBQs or picnics and playing music. Nothing wrong with that of course, I just don't find it enjoyable to be around.

I could drive out to the countryside but a lot of other people have the same idea which creates big traffic jams. My car's aircon is broken so it's really unpleasant to be in (and gets v hot as my parking space is in full sun all day), especially when stuck in traffic.

My flat is modern and energy efficient so it traps heat. During the summer it can get up to 30 C and stays there. I have big floor fans running but it doesn't help much. I just end up useless, feeling sick and unable to sleep. I have to keep my blinds closed until the sun goes down which is depressing.

If I lived in the countryside, in a house that doesn't trap the heat so much, with a big garden then no doubt I'd enjoy summer. I'd be out there all the time, under a parasol or canopy with a G&T and a book.

Once summer got going? What you mean that week in September? July and August were a complete wash out. People do have short memories. I live in the S.E. I struggle to sleep in the heat. I have an air con unit. I didn’t turn it on for the whole of July or August…

FuzzyPenguin · 21/10/2023 18:31

I prefer the Autumn/ Winter, for some reason it feels like a reset and a fresh start. (Much more than the actual new year) it sounds daft but I feel myself come alive inside as the nights draw in.
I am an introvert and find summer draining with the expectations of doing something while the weather is nice. And I hate being hot.

Absolutelymassesofcourgettes · 21/10/2023 18:29

I do like summer, but for me summer comes with expectations. "Get out there and make the most of it" was constantly being thrown at me as a child. I still feel enormous guilt if I stay inside on a sunny day.

The long nights of winter come with no expectations. Stay in, watch shit TV, no one will judge that's how you spent your weekend when it's throwing it down outside and dark at 4pm.

I think the answer is to look for the joy in all seasons rather than wishing half the year away from October to March. Life is far too short for that.