Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask - Which living generation do you think has had it the hardest?

207 replies

catsinpinkhats · 19/10/2023 18:16

• Silent Generation: Born 1925-1945.
• Baby Boomers: Born 1946-1964.
• Generation X: Born 1965-1980.
• Millennials: Born 1981-1996.
• Generation Z: Born 1997-2012.
• Generation Alpha: Born 2013-2025.

I think each generation has had varying degrees of things that are hard, socially, financially, politically etc.

My grandparents were of the silent generation and there's no doubt their childhood and young adulthood was hard during and after the war. Plus many men still did national service.

I am a millennial and most of my generation is old enough to remember life pre-internet but also young enough to embrace it. Things are hard for my generation and younger due to house prices etc, but society is more open generally with more possibilities.

We all think our generation has it harder, but what do you think if being objective?

OP posts:
SarahAndQuack · 19/10/2023 22:47

ElizaMulvil · 19/10/2023 22:41

The poverty in inner cities was dreadful for the Boomer generation. I remember the hovels/ back to backs of Manchester, Oldham, Salford, Sheffield, Macclesfield etc. Slum clearances through 50-60s. Housing terribly short after the bombing of WW2. Rationing of food etc until the late 50s.

Class sizes horrendous. 56 in my class in Didsbury the most favoured suburb of Manchester. Some schools in Salford could barely get teachers at all. My cousin, working as an uncertificated teacher in 1957 before going to Uni was in charge of 90 ( the legal ruling was half a class for an uncertificated teacher!)
Most children 80%?+ left school at 15. Comprehensive education was decades off for most.

Women teachers were on 3/4 of men's pay. Some male teachers broke away from the NUT who were campaigning for equal pay to found the National Association of School Masters NAS, to campaign against equal pay( no women allowed of course! ) ie sexism was rife. Girls were discriminated against in so many ways - a restricted syllabus, often fewer places in Grammar schools despite girls generally doing better than boys in 11+, quotas for medicine eg, not a tenth of men's places for women at Oxbridge.

Rape legal in marriage, birth control unreliable, forced adoption of babies born outside marriage. Women couldn't get loans, mortgages ( Teachers' Building Society was founded to remedy this).

Banks were still sacking women who got married. Racism horrendous v Blacks, Irish etc.

The NHS only came in in 1948 so many people had very poor health. Asian flu in 50s.

The difference was that after the Labour Atlee victory in 1945 people had hope that things would get better. Legal Aid, NHS, Council Housing, Sickness/ unemployment benefits, retirement benefits etc. all came in then.

We have the extraordinary 'ordinary' people of the Silent Generation who campaigned for these things in the army, navy, RAF, factories, mines all through the WW2 to thank.

Rape was legal in marriage, in England and Wales, until 1991. It is shocking.

WhiteHorseSpirit · 19/10/2023 22:47

givemeasunnyday · 19/10/2023 22:35

Surely you can understand that a world war (in other words affecting multiple countries), where people had to go to fight is quite different from those who join the armed forces of their particular country, knowing that going to war could well happen. People, especially men, of the silent generation didn't have a choice. Hmm No-one actually forced you to take on your career.

Also. it's not just those away at war who suffered during the world wars, life wasn't exactly rosy for those at home. Were your family at risk of being bombed while you were away for instance?

Edited

Well if I had not, I’d likely be dead as a gang was out to kill me. So it was an escape from certain death to possible death.

Life wasn’t rosy for the Falklands British held hostage either…

Plus, think of the civil war of the Troubles in NI for those of my generation- which only marginally affected me but would have had a profound effect on all Gen X in NI. All at risk of bombs, shootings…

On the others, the U.K. was bombed 7/7 ring a bell? My going prevented more bombs like that.

freetheunicorn1 · 19/10/2023 22:47

I don't think any generation as a whole had it harder but it comes down to circumstances.

My parents were/are silent generation, they were rural and born to farming families so sheltered from WWII and no families at war, not comparable to living somewhere with air raids, losing loved ones etc.

A PP mentioned being GenX in NI, not comparable to me being GenX in rural Scotland.

I do think younger people have additional challenges with SM but then will have less challenges in other aspects in life than older people had.

HamBone · 19/10/2023 22:46

@ElizaMulvil Yes, think of the poverty depicted in “Call the Midwife,” that was inner city poverty in the late 1950’s/early 1960’s. ☹️

ElizaMulvil · 19/10/2023 22:41

The poverty in inner cities was dreadful for the Boomer generation. I remember the hovels/ back to backs of Manchester, Oldham, Salford, Sheffield, Macclesfield etc. Slum clearances through 50-60s. Housing terribly short after the bombing of WW2. Rationing of food etc until the late 50s.

Class sizes horrendous. 56 in my class in Didsbury the most favoured suburb of Manchester. Some schools in Salford could barely get teachers at all. My cousin, working as an uncertificated teacher in 1957 before going to Uni was in charge of 90 ( the legal ruling was half a class for an uncertificated teacher!)
Most children 80%?+ left school at 15. Comprehensive education was decades off for most.

Women teachers were on 3/4 of men's pay. Some male teachers broke away from the NUT who were campaigning for equal pay to found the National Association of School Masters NAS, to campaign against equal pay( no women allowed of course! ) ie sexism was rife. Girls were discriminated against in so many ways - a restricted syllabus, often fewer places in Grammar schools despite girls generally doing better than boys in 11+, quotas for medicine eg, not a tenth of men's places for women at Oxbridge.

Rape legal in marriage, birth control unreliable, forced adoption of babies born outside marriage. Women couldn't get loans, mortgages ( Teachers' Building Society was founded to remedy this).

Banks were still sacking women who got married. Racism horrendous v Blacks, Irish etc.

The NHS only came in in 1948 so many people had very poor health. Asian flu in 50s.

The difference was that after the Labour Atlee victory in 1945 people had hope that things would get better. Legal Aid, NHS, Council Housing, Sickness/ unemployment benefits, retirement benefits etc. all came in then.

We have the extraordinary 'ordinary' people of the Silent Generation who campaigned for these things in the army, navy, RAF, factories, mines all through the WW2 to thank.

givemeasunnyday · 19/10/2023 22:35

WhiteHorseSpirit · 19/10/2023 19:20

I don’t get the war stuff meaning silent generation that was in WWII had it the worst, as I’ve lived through/served in more years of war than they did as a Gen Xer.

Who was sent to the Falklands?
Who was sent to Iraq?
Who was sent to Bosnia?
Who was sent to Iraq a second time?
Who was sent to Afghanistan?

?..

WWII lasted six years.

Surely you can understand that a world war (in other words affecting multiple countries), where people had to go to fight is quite different from those who join the armed forces of their particular country, knowing that going to war could well happen. People, especially men, of the silent generation didn't have a choice. Hmm No-one actually forced you to take on your career.

Also. it's not just those away at war who suffered during the world wars, life wasn't exactly rosy for those at home. Were your family at risk of being bombed while you were away for instance?

JayAlfredPrufrock · 19/10/2023 22:08

I agree. I think the boomer generation covers too wide a span. My DH was born in 1946 and had nothing like my experience born in 1959.

ruby1957 · 19/10/2023 22:06

Onthelongroad · 19/10/2023 21:11

I think Boomers have had a harder time than people give them credit for. Yes, you could afford a house on a single salary -if you quite middle class, a lot of families had to have two working adults. But this was very often not a choice - opportunities for women were dire and many were sacked when they got married. Yes, university was free and you got a grant, but very few young people had the opportunity to go to university. Social mobility was bad and many people were stuck in the environment they grew up in.

Some boomers - especially those with some element of wealth - got really lucky, but things were much harder for loads of them than for most people today.

I agree with this,
I was born in 1947 - just out by 1 year from the silent generation - so allocating circumstances to a span of 18 years is a bit meaningless.
As a child - rationing was still in operation as was national service. We had the scourge of diseases like polio and usual childhood illnesses that had no vaccinations. Life was hard - No television, no electricity, outside toilets, no central heating!
There were no foreign holidays a day trip if you were lucky, children could leave school without exams and go straight to work
University was only for the 10%
We lived through the cold war and dangerous nuclear proliferation (Cuban missile crisis)

There were few benefits when I was working and a single parent in the 1970s except child benefit. No equality for women.

It is disengenius to attribute the same conditions to someone who was born at the end of the generation with those who were in it at the beginning. This applies to all generations.

Pipsquiggle · 19/10/2023 22:06

The silent generation - the war, sexism, basic medical care although some people came out relatively unscathed.
Everyone younger than Gen X due to uni fees and housing prices

JayAlfredPrufrock · 19/10/2023 22:02

@coffeorbust Hell yes I’m fine thanks. I’m living off my inheritance from my dad. Typical Boomer😉

TitInATrance · 19/10/2023 21:58

Silent generation. The others have all had their own challenges.

I’m a boomer. Personally impacted by: sex discrimination in education and employment, the harassment culture, falling house prices decreasing paid-for equity, losing a friend to AIDS and the fear that created. In general: WASPI. High unemployment, winter of discontent. The impact of strikes and civil unrest on strikers, families, police.

Contraception, equal pay, no-fault divorce and the introduction of computers (to a generation who didn’t even have calculators) made me feel very lucky, especially in comparison to those only slightly older than I am.

Purplebunnie · 19/10/2023 21:52

Whattheflipflap · 19/10/2023 18:22

Silent generation - because of the war
then millennials - especially older millennials - no Compiter literacy taught, but all jobs expecting computers - housing crisis. Lived in rentals unable to buy yada yada

Boomer and Gen X didn't have computer literacy taught either and still have the same expectations job wise of computer literacy

DeliahSmilah · 19/10/2023 21:51

Some silent generation - my Dad is 85, been retired for 30 years on a ridiculous nhs full pension mortgage has been paid off since then and still gets a normal pension and winter fuel etc help. He's had a computer since the 80s and has no problem navigating his smart phone/banking apps. Vs DP's boomer parents who can't even work their tv and rely on us to complete any sort of paperwork. FIL works in a manual job pushing 70. He'll never be able to retire due financial constraints.

I have gen alpha, gen Z and millennial children and can't really see a lot of difference between them.

Gen z are the last generation to have it relatively easy.

givemeasunnyday · 19/10/2023 21:51

Nevermind31 · 19/10/2023 18:18

I don’t think anything can be harder than being born and living through a war.

I agree with this.

SarahAndQuack · 19/10/2023 21:45

You can't generalise about a generation. There will always be some who had it easy and some who had it hard.

My grandmother was the generation who were absolutely, joyously liberated by WWII. Of course they were aware it was a war, and it was terrible - but her whole life changed because suddenly, women were allowed to do all sorts of things that would never have happened before. It is really striking when you compare to other women slightly older or younger in her village - she even lived ten years more than the average, because she got out. She was born in 1926; she was the daughter of a Welsh miner and purely because she was not yet married when war broke out - but wasn't a young child - she had huge opportunities that changed her whole life. Importantly, she also had family who were hugely proud of her and happy for the way her life had changed.

My dad is a boomer. He had it very easy in terms of what you can calculate on a spreadsheet. Passed his 11-plus, straight into a very prestigious public school, closed scholarship to Oxford, funded postgraduate. Minor wobble in the 80s where he had to change career, but it's a tiny bump in the road. But, he's absolutely emotionally crippled by having a father who was traumatised by the war, and he's a sad, angry man.

My mum is also a boomer - also got lots of 'opportunities,' free ride to university, great start into an excellent career out-earning her husband ... but she's really miserable and emotionally a mess.

I would not want to be a boomer if it meant the 'advantages' my parents had came with the emotional struggles.

thegreylady · 19/10/2023 21:35

I was born in 1944 on the cusp between the Silent Generation and Baby Boomers. I grew up in a council house in a NE pit village and my dad was invalided from when I was 11. Mum had 3 jobs, a factory canteen, a market stall and a cake icing side line. I was an only child. I had a wonderful extended family, a grammar school education and a fully paid college course. I don’t feel I was in anyway deprived of the things that matter.

coffeorbust · 19/10/2023 21:23

JayAlfredPrufrock · 19/10/2023 20:58

My Dad went to work on a building site at 14 as his dad had died.

They taught him to piss on his bleeding cracked hands to harden them up. He gave his mum his wage at the end of the week and she gave him a hapenny back which he spent on sweets.

Sounds awful. You're poor dad. Are you ok

HamBone · 19/10/2023 21:22

As PP’s have pointed out, it’s also difficult to make general statements about generations, because life can be so different depending on personal circumstances.

For example, the pandemic. My Gen. Z seem to have got through it pretty well academically and socially, but we know other teens who have been far more affected. 🤷

CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 19/10/2023 21:18

i once heard warren buffet say that financially the silent generation had the greatest potential for strong financial gains.
but i know it takes money to make money.

i will have to agree that living in poverty regardless of what generation you fall in is the horrible.

Sartre · 19/10/2023 21:14

Silent gen but the ones I know never complain about it. DH’s Grandad is just so bloody stoic, I feel like you could stand throwing literal rocks at him and he wouldn’t even budge.

flutterby1 · 19/10/2023 21:14

Silent

Onthelongroad · 19/10/2023 21:11

I think Boomers have had a harder time than people give them credit for. Yes, you could afford a house on a single salary -if you quite middle class, a lot of families had to have two working adults. But this was very often not a choice - opportunities for women were dire and many were sacked when they got married. Yes, university was free and you got a grant, but very few young people had the opportunity to go to university. Social mobility was bad and many people were stuck in the environment they grew up in.

Some boomers - especially those with some element of wealth - got really lucky, but things were much harder for loads of them than for most people today.

Phonedown · 19/10/2023 21:09

I agree with those who say anyone living in poverty in all generations.

Wars didn't end with the silent generation and my gen X family member still suffers from all of the horrific things he did/saw in the late 80s and 90s... Northern Ireland, Lockerbie, Bosnia and the Gulf War. But poor boys from my area signed up.

My mum and her siblings are boomers. They often suffered at the hands of their war- traumatised parents, had to deal with year long hospital stays because of TB, had no protections in terms of racist or sexist policies.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 19/10/2023 21:07

Mytholmroyd · 19/10/2023 21:02

I was absolutely haunted by the idea of nuclear war when I was young and I know my DM worried about it a lot in the context of the potential impact on her children’s future.

@Greatbigfluffytrousers Oh god this! I remember reading a story in Jackie magazine about a young farm girl left alone in some miraculously unaffected valley when her parents died from the radiation fallout and a strange man arriving one day. I have never forgot it. It scarred me for life. I then set about learning things like how to ride a horse/milk a cow/start a fire because I was convinced we would be returning to a pre-electric state before very long!

Z for Zachariah ?
Read it in year 5, same year as Chernobyl.
Not sure if I was more terrified of nuclear holocaust or AIDS when I was 10...

Chypre · 19/10/2023 21:03

Living during the plague must've been hard....