Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask - Which living generation do you think has had it the hardest?

207 replies

catsinpinkhats · 19/10/2023 18:16

• Silent Generation: Born 1925-1945.
• Baby Boomers: Born 1946-1964.
• Generation X: Born 1965-1980.
• Millennials: Born 1981-1996.
• Generation Z: Born 1997-2012.
• Generation Alpha: Born 2013-2025.

I think each generation has had varying degrees of things that are hard, socially, financially, politically etc.

My grandparents were of the silent generation and there's no doubt their childhood and young adulthood was hard during and after the war. Plus many men still did national service.

I am a millennial and most of my generation is old enough to remember life pre-internet but also young enough to embrace it. Things are hard for my generation and younger due to house prices etc, but society is more open generally with more possibilities.

We all think our generation has it harder, but what do you think if being objective?

OP posts:
PriOn1 · 20/10/2023 05:42

Any graph I’ve ever seen which reports on “the age at which people are happiest” has dipped down on my generation (X). When I was young, I thought I’d only have to wait a few years and then things would be easier, when I was in my forties or fifties or whatever. But the charts kept coming and the dip moved with my generation.

I think it might be because we were brought up when expectations were high, over life being improved by technology and perhaps, for women at least, the expectation that women would have equality at some point in our lives.

I haven’t seen one of those charts recently, but I also feel my younger children’s generation have it quite hard, because of social media and the incredible toll it seems to have on young people’s mental health.

So I absolutely get what people are saying about living through the war, but those people also got to live through (and perhaps benefit from) the stable period after the war, when jobs for those who survived, were easier to find and housing was cheaper and many people’s lives went from not great, to being better. My parents and my ex husband’s parents were in that generation and both rose up from their working class roots to having a very comfortable existence. They got to retire much earlier than I’m going to - it wasn’t uncommon then to retire at 55.

Ormonde · 20/10/2023 05:23

I think we can all agree that the Silent Generation who fought in WW2 had it worst. And obviously the Boomers who lived through the longest period of peace and economic prosperity in recorded history had it best.

My generation is late Gen X / early Millennial, and our main problem has been lack of jobs and high house prices. We were all pushed to go to university at great expense, only to discover there were no graduate jobs for many of us. This led to widespread depression and feelings of failure. Add on the fact that house prices shot up so we couldn’t afford our own roofs over our heads, which meant we had to delay things like marriage and kids. We are visibly worse off than our parents were and it’s just been a constant struggle to pay bills and survive.

givemeasunnyday · 20/10/2023 03:32

WhiteHorseSpirit · 19/10/2023 23:10

Were your family at risk of being bombed while you were away for instance?
This is kind of a dumb question because my entire life I’ve been at risk of being bombed. From birth to 1989- Cold War- so many close calls of nuclear bombs dropping. You just accepted it could all end in a flash of light. Even after the USSR fell apart, hundreds of nuclear warheads went missing and were in the hands of terrorists who threatened to use them..so the danger amped up and then oh wow, here comes Iraq invading Kuwait and Iraq with its “WMD” (we didn’t know it was lies) then ethnic cleansing in Bosnia.

The world wasn’t a safe or stable place.

Oh dear heaven. Being at risk of bombing is nothing like actually being bombed. My question isn't nearly as dumb as your answer. I suggest maybe you read a few history books. (knocks head against table in despair!!!)

givemeasunnyday · 20/10/2023 03:30

WhiteHorseSpirit · 19/10/2023 22:47

Well if I had not, I’d likely be dead as a gang was out to kill me. So it was an escape from certain death to possible death.

Life wasn’t rosy for the Falklands British held hostage either…

Plus, think of the civil war of the Troubles in NI for those of my generation- which only marginally affected me but would have had a profound effect on all Gen X in NI. All at risk of bombs, shootings…

On the others, the U.K. was bombed 7/7 ring a bell? My going prevented more bombs like that.

You really don't get it do you? There is no arguing with someone like you. Interesting that the majority of people on this thread agree that the silent generation had it the worst, but of course you know better.

Kat1981111 · 20/10/2023 03:14

I think the earlier man kind was born it was harder.yes war years were hardest for sure. But thinking ahead I can't imagine life without TV, kettle, microwaves, duvets, coomers, radiators. We take things way to much for granted these days.

lavenderlou · 20/10/2023 03:09

I am Gen X and was discussing this with my Mum (Baby Boomer) recently. Her generation generally had a much poorer childhood than either my own or my DCs. Swings and roundabouts with mid-life - much easier to get on the housing ladder, most families could get by on a single wage but there were periods of unrest and high interest rates. Not so many opportunities for women. They have almost certainly had the golden age of retirement with many being able to retire in the early 60s on a generous pension with increased likelihood of good health into their 70s and 80s.

As Gen X I feel most of us had better childhoods than our parents and benefited from the last years of free university (although education in the 79s and 80s was generally crap). Getting on the housing ladder was achievable more easily than now. I don't think we'll have the same retirement experiences as our parents' generation.

Feel sorry for my Gen Z/Alpha DC. Materially they've had a pretty good childhood - although not noticeably that different to mine other than technology-wise. I think employment/housing/having children will be much harder for them especially with things like AI and climate change to worry about.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 20/10/2023 02:55

Mytholmroyd · 19/10/2023 23:04

@Neurodiversitydoctor Could be - I can't remember the title - so long ago. I must have read it in the 70s. But maybe they re-published after Chernobyl happened and traumatised the next generation!

It was- themes, nuclear aniliation, murder, rape.Obvious choice for pre-teen girls...

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z_for_Zachariah

Z for Zachariah - Wikipedia

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z_for_Zachariah

LemonyTicket · 20/10/2023 01:27

Silent generation.

But I feel deeply for younger generations dealing with housing prices, tuition fees, wage stagnation. It's very tough.

Certainly boomers and my generation (X) had things easier.

Overcooker · 20/10/2023 01:03

It obviously varies with geography but, for most of Britain at least, it has to be the silent generation. I’d say it’s been diminishing returns since the Baby Boomers.

MariaLuna · 20/10/2023 00:51

Well, my parents went through WWII. In Europe.

But Palestine/Israel is pretty awful now....... (pretty being an understatement...)

ConsuelaHammock · 20/10/2023 00:41

The silent generation. War, rationing, no contraception, large families, cold houses without proper bathroom facilities. Living on the very basics. No welfare state. I’m generation X. We’ve had it pretty good.

Greycheck · 19/10/2023 23:44

I'm an older millennial and think I've had it relatively OK compared to my parents and my gen Z children. I was a teen before social media really took off, by 21 had two children and a mortgage (2005), very generous child and working tax credits, never had a problem getting work without a degree etc.

My 20 and 18 year olds have had a pandemic and social media to contend with and are struggling to find work. A mortgage is a distant thought etc.

Blueystolemyinsanity · 19/10/2023 23:37

I don’t get the millennials computer thing either.
we started doing IT in primary and done it as GCSE in secondary.
I actually think we were in the mist of the technology bloom and sort of grew with it.
from me starting secondary school to leaving secondary - we had gone from no camera phones / internet etc to full on internet phones and big bulky computers with dial up to flat screens and Wi-Fi.
we were at the start of “ social networking to “ we went from bebo - my space / msn to Facebook by the time I left.

Gwendimarco · 19/10/2023 23:37

@Daphnis156
”People of any age let down by the NHS and local authorities.
People who cannot afford food or heat”

You mean people let down by the Tory government?

Let’s not blame our public servants, it’s not their fault the country’s a shambles.

velvetandsatin · 19/10/2023 23:32

The Silent Generation, of coursse.

But American and Australian Boomers were drafted into the Vietnam war. Many died, and many were left with severe PTSD.

Pretty well every sexual transgression brought up by the Me, Too movement was part of many Boomer women's daily lives. Too frequent to mention, and hardly something anyone went to the cops about.

Boomer women fought for all sorts of rights and priviliges that following generations take for granted, and are now in the process of throwing away.

Too say Millenials have it hard is laughable.

Ilikeyourdecor · 19/10/2023 23:32

AllegroConMoto · 19/10/2023 18:28

Another one voting for the Silent Generation (particularly the earlier end of that), followed by late Gen X / early Millennial - I think some people are actually now calling that a separate micro-generation.

I think the people who have had it easiest are probably late Boomers / early Gen X, so the ones who became adults in the late 70s and 80s.

I also vote silent generation, but I'm amazed that people are voting for late Gen X/Early Millenial after that! I am that generation and think I've had it easy and was born in a great era! Parents weren't rich either.

Much better imo than current generation with covid / house prices / Brexit restrictions / social media / environment issues / outrageous uni fees.

Blueystolemyinsanity · 19/10/2023 23:29

So strange how many people say millennials I am ( 1991 ) and would have expected we would have been seen as the least disadvantaged.

Gwendimarco · 19/10/2023 23:24

Generation Alpha, easily.

Mytholmroyd · 19/10/2023 23:22

Sexism was rife when I was a teenager but you just lived with it.

I tried to join the RAF at 16 in the 70s - the recruiting officer refused to accept my application because he said I was too pretty and would be married and pregnant within a couple of years and it would be a waste of good training.

At the factory I was working at at the time, a boy the same age asked me how much I was earning, I told him, and he went and complained to the owner and I got my wage reduced by about a third. My fault apparently for telling someone how much I earned!

Just normal shit.

NumberFortyNorhamGardens · 19/10/2023 23:18

I do, like others on this thread, find the divisions of the generations a bit artificial. My PILs are technically Boomers but MIL’s life was far more Silent Generation. She was brought up as one of 5 surviving children (all the boys died, most at birth, suggesting some sort of undiagnosed sex-linked genetic condition) against a backdrop of horrendous DV and neglect, with an alcoholic gambler for a father and a disengaged and (understandably) constantly unfaithful mother. She and FIL never earned much, but did benefit hugely from property ownership.

WhiteHorseSpirit · 19/10/2023 23:10

Were your family at risk of being bombed while you were away for instance?
This is kind of a dumb question because my entire life I’ve been at risk of being bombed. From birth to 1989- Cold War- so many close calls of nuclear bombs dropping. You just accepted it could all end in a flash of light. Even after the USSR fell apart, hundreds of nuclear warheads went missing and were in the hands of terrorists who threatened to use them..so the danger amped up and then oh wow, here comes Iraq invading Kuwait and Iraq with its “WMD” (we didn’t know it was lies) then ethnic cleansing in Bosnia.

The world wasn’t a safe or stable place.

Mytholmroyd · 19/10/2023 23:04

@Neurodiversitydoctor Could be - I can't remember the title - so long ago. I must have read it in the 70s. But maybe they re-published after Chernobyl happened and traumatised the next generation!

Butterkist8 · 19/10/2023 23:04

Silent , without a doubt.

Anonymouseposter · 19/10/2023 23:01

I would say the silent generation had the most challenges. Poverty in childhood, WW2 and more.
People born in the 1980s are having a difficult time.
The boomer generation were fortunate in many ways but didn't escape all challenges. Women were expected to tollerate abuse and there was little child care provision. Maternity leave didn't start until 1979 and women found it difficult to be considered for mortgages etc.
With generations born after the 1980s it's too early to say yet. Many of them aren't off to an easy start.
Just considering what I wrote above, in all generations some people are born into much more advantage than others and hardship is more connected to Social class than generation. For a little while, after the War there was a bit more Social mobility and opportunity. We're putting a stop to that!

Vintagecreamandcottagepie · 19/10/2023 22:53

Load of old crap. I'm very end of gen x but far more in common with someone born 1986 that 1965.

Really stupid and divisive way to look at things.