Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it is dangerous to buy/or support buying alcohol for under 16s

162 replies

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 19/10/2023 16:08

“It is illegal to buy alcohol for someone under 18 in a licensed premises, the only exception is for 16 or 17 year-olds who are allowed to drink beer, wine or cider with food if with an adult (but they may not buy the alcohol themselves).”

However, I hear of more and more ‘adults’ justifying buying alcohol for children. It makes me question how safe children are?. Particularly when we find ourselves in a largely split parent/coparenting demographic in the UK. It makes enforcing parental boundaries and measures to keep our children safe, all the more difficult.

OP posts:
Theemeperorsnewclothes · 19/10/2023 17:19

jannier · Today 17:07

In most of Europe there is a more relaxed attitude to alcohol with meals and less of a problem with alcohol so I think this shows our approach to alcohol is wrong.
Split parenting is an irrelevant prejudice

It is not an “irrelevant prejudice” I am highlighting the point that different parents/households have different approaches/attitudes to underage drinking, further disadvantaging children/parents/main care givers (over 90% mothers) in this situation, as they do not have the legal power to protect their children. It is a very valid point. Even if it is not your direct experience.

OP posts:
Caipirovska · 19/10/2023 17:15

I didn't sneak alcohol nor my siblings - don't think my teens have - DH was positively encouraged to drink by his parents. So we've basically followed how I was introduced to alcohol though my DC had much less overall as we didn't do wine with Sunday lunch once a week like I was raised.

I've never drunk much but IL were a fucking menace when I met them at 18 - trying to insist I drank and putting alcohol in soft drink to "hide" it from me. IL have vastly reduced amount they drink over time and my DC have learnt to decline and get listen to (with back up from us).

I see no evidence that our approach hasn't worked - they aren't desperate to try forbidden alcohol - haven't like DH been brought up normalising heavy drinking and going weeks of months with no alcohol is normal behaviour to them but they know enough to treat it with respect.

But how others raise their kids is not under my control though we don't seem out of step from most other parents we know -and I'm sure research is showing young people are drinking less than ever before so we must be doing something right.

MidnightOnceMore · 19/10/2023 17:12

Motheranddaughter · 19/10/2023 16:30

My DD did not drink until she was 17 and my son who is 22 does not drink at all
Not all teens will drink .

Quite. And the % of teens who drink is dropping.

UK has a high drinking culture. Parents who drink expect their kids to drink, and often encourage their kids to drink. The single biggest predictor of child drinking behaviour is parental drinking behaviour.

I wouldn't buy alcohol for my children, any more than I'd buy cigarettes or vapes.

jannier · 19/10/2023 17:07

In most of Europe there is a more relaxed attitude to alcohol with meals and less of a problem with alcohol so I think this shows our approach to alcohol is wrong.
Split parenting is an irrelevant prejudice

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 19/10/2023 17:03

pointythings · Today 16:57

Your copy and pasted post from NACOA is just patronising, by the way. You are now presuming that you are the sole arbiter of wisdom and that everyone on Mumsnet needs preaching to. You mean well, but this is an approach that will get people's backs up. It irritates me, and I was married to an alcoholic, have one DC who never drinks at all and one who barely drinks. Both didn't touch it when teenagers.

Stop it with the preachiness.

Your inability to take on board research and sources of information to protect children irritates me. How on earth could I be the “sole arbiter of wisdom” on this topic, don’t be ridiculous. There are many many other sources much wiser than me.

OP posts:
ntmdino · 19/10/2023 17:02

If anything, I absolutely support children experiencing alcohol with their parents relatively early on.

My daughter came home crying one day when she was 13, because the other girls at school had been bullying her about not knowing what various alcoholic drinks were. I ordered pizza, then went to the shop next door and bought one of every kind of booze I could for about £50 (we didn't have anything in the house anyway) so she could try them all and figure out what she did/didn't like. Obviously, I made sure that she wasn't getting absolutely blotto, and there were plenty of breaks for food etc - it was about trying it, and experiencing the feeling of getting merry.

OH and in-laws were absolutely horrified and convinced that I was turning her into an alcoholic.

But...do you know what? She liked a few of the drinks, but woke up with a bit of a hangover the next day and decided she didn't want anything to do with alcohol. She didn't touch another drop until she was 18, even when offered, and she very rarely gets drunk (she's 29 now) compared with all of her friends who're out getting blasted every Friday and Saturday night.

When the girls at school found out, they stopped needling her about it because she'd tried everything. It also had the effect of making us the coolest parents in school, which weirdly made her more popular (I'll never understand teenagers).

My grandfather was Italian, and so the idea of not drinking wine with dinner was completely alien to him - that was basically my inspiration. He insisted that my cousin and I (same age) had "a bit of wine" with Sunday dinner from the age of about 12. Of course, being Italian, "a bit" meant he was making a concession that it should only be half a pint of wine...our parents always had to sleep it off before driving home, and we never managed to finish the glass...which was another good lesson for us: you don't have to finish every drink that's in front of you. Stop when it stops feeling good.

Point is, if it's maturely handled by the family in question (rather than the prohibition-era thinking that leads to it being a taboo), then drinking earlier than 18 can actually be an educational experience and alcohol doesn't have to be the dangerous thing that it becomes for so many folk as they transition into adulthood.

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 19/10/2023 16:59

You have a very black and white view of this, OP. Reality is as usual shades of grey. There's plenty of evidence that young people today are drinking less than previous generations, so I'd like to see your evidence that it's increasing and that this is caused by children having parents who are no longer together. That sounds like pearl clutching about the good old days to me.

That said, teaching your kids to treat alcohol with respect matters. That doesn't mean forbidding it, because that is likely to make things worse, but it also doesn't mean shoving it into their hands. There are many parents who make it work, using a variety of approaches. There isn't a single right way. But permissiveness without boundaries isn't good (it never is when raising children).

How do I have a “black and white view of this”? I’m asking for feedback and different opinions. You have a very ‘mumsnet’ standard response, attack the OP. Get off your own high horse and consider the very valid points from those who have actually researched the topic.

OP posts:
pointythings · 19/10/2023 16:57

Your copy and pasted post from NACOA is just patronising, by the way. You are now presuming that you are the sole arbiter of wisdom and that everyone on Mumsnet needs preaching to. You mean well, but this is an approach that will get people's backs up. It irritates me, and I was married to an alcoholic, have one DC who never drinks at all and one who barely drinks. Both didn't touch it when teenagers.

Stop it with the preachiness.

pointythings · 19/10/2023 16:54

You have a very black and white view of this, OP. Reality is as usual shades of grey. There's plenty of evidence that young people today are drinking less than previous generations, so I'd like to see your evidence that it's increasing and that this is caused by children having parents who are no longer together. That sounds like pearl clutching about the good old days to me.

That said, teaching your kids to treat alcohol with respect matters. That doesn't mean forbidding it, because that is likely to make things worse, but it also doesn't mean shoving it into their hands. There are many parents who make it work, using a variety of approaches. There isn't a single right way. But permissiveness without boundaries isn't good (it never is when raising children).

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 19/10/2023 16:50

We all like to do our best for our children but sometimes we are not too sure what that is. We may feel ill-informed, or like we’re drowning in too much information.
Here we look at some of the most common questions parents ask about alcohol and young people, and try to help you work out some answers that work for you.
How young is too young for alcohol?
In the UK, no one under the age of 18 can buy alcohol, and adults can’t buy it for them. Thanks to a historic law, any child aged 5 or older can have an alcoholic drink at home or in any private house – although we certainly wouldn’t recommend it!
The UK’s Chief Medical Officers say that an alcohol-free childhood is best. That means no alcohol until at least 15 years of age; only very small amounts between the ages of 15 and 18, and never more than once a week. The main reason for this is that young people’s bodies are continuing to grow and change, and so alcohol can cause serious and long-lasting damage.
Can parents show children how to drink sensibly?
One reason parents sometimes give for drinking in front of their children is that they’re showing them how to drink sensibly. It’s a common-sense approach – we teach children how to do all sorts of things by doing them ourselves. Unfortunately, it’s not that simple with alcohol.
For starters, different parents will have very different ideas about what sensible drinking looks like. When researchers have asked parents about how they demonstrate sensible drinking to their children, parents don’t tend to talk about teaching children how to drink moderately. They talk more about the importance of not behaving badly or becoming embarrassing – how be drunk without being annoying.
That’s one way of thinking about drinking. An alternative way is to think seriously about how much we’re drinking and why. That could raise a much trickier question for us as parents. If we want to show our children how to use alcohol safely and healthily, are we willing to change our own drinking habits – to drink less or drink less often – in order to set them a good example?
Should we be a bit more Continental about this – mixing wine with water for kids?
Britain sometimes seems to have a binge-drinking problem that our European neighbours don’t share. So, do we need to be more like parents in places like France and Italy, where (we are told) it’s more normal to introduce children to alcohol at an early age? Unfortunately, once again, it might not be that simple.
For one thing, the amounts of alcohol given to children in the wine-drinking countries of Europe are very small. It’s more a matter of adding a little bit of wine to some water, rather than the other way around. The aim is to introduce children to the colours and flavours of wines without the intoxicating effects.
Another all-important factor is that children in much of Europe learn about wine as part of an overall moderate drinking culture. Alcohol is enjoyed at mealtimes and being drunk is unacceptable. The situation is the UK is very different, and there is a real risk that by introducing children to alcohol we are simply assisting them to join in with British drinking culture rather than our Continental ideal.
And finally, it’s only fair to ask why we want to introduce our children to drinking. Research has shown that, when parents in the UK give alcohol to their children, it’s often the parents’ idea, not the children’s. Could it be that some of us are encouraging our children to try alcohol because we think that drinking is ‘normal’?
As more young people turn their backs on alcohol, it’s quite possible that more parents will be challenged by their children about why they’re drinking.
Is it best to stay off the alcopops?
The ready-to-drink cocktails known as ‘alcopops’ have been getting bad press since they first appeared in the 1990s. Many people worry that because they are so sweet, they offer an easy route into drinking – unlike traditional drinks like beer and wine.
We need to be cautious about singling some drinks out for blame. The alcohol in alcopops is the same chemical that’s in all other alcoholic drinks. And they don’t tend to be particularly strong – around the same strength as beer and much less alcoholic than wine.
That said, there are a few things it is worth parents thinking about before letting young people have alcopops:

  • Young people sometimes say they prefer alcopops because they don’t like the taste of alcohol. If that’s the case, could they simply avoid alcoholic drinks?
  • There’s no particular reason for anyone to start drinking alcohol if they don’t like it. So why seek out drinks that make it easier to start?
  • If it isn’t the flavour of alcoholic drinks that young people like, what is it that they like about them? Are we as parents just helping them to experience intoxication?
Tips for you The truth is that helping young people have a healthy relationship with alcohol doesn’t always have much to do with alcohol itself. Self-confidence and a sense of self-worth are what matters most. That comes in large part from young people having good relationships with the adults around them. So often the best things parents can do include:
  • Spending time with your children and be willing to listen
  • Knowing where your children go and what they do – there’s no need for constant surveillance, but take an interest and make it clear that you care about them
  • Keeping channels of communication openand be willing to apologise when you are wrong
  • Being firm. If you make rules and then relax them again and again, you could be setting yourself up for years of confrontation and negotiation
  • But also be fair. If you have to discipline, do it calmly. And don’t forget to offer praise when things go well
  • Remember that you are still important to your children even when they are teenagers. Parents often under-estimate how much influence they have on older children
What if my child starts drinking too much? Family members can feel isolated, anxious and even guilty when a loved one is experiencing drinking problems. There will be many other people in a similar situation, and help is available for you and your child, whether they are under 18 or an adult. Charities such as Adfam, DrugFam, Al-Anon and Nacoa exist to provide advice and support.

Nacoa: Helping everyone affected by their parent's drinking - Nacoa

Nacoa UK helps everyone affected by a parent's drinking. 1 in 5 people in the UK are affected by their parent's drinking. #URNotAlone

https://nacoa.org.uk/

OP posts:
Bbq1 · 19/10/2023 16:49

Not every teenager age 16/17/18 drinks. It's becoming far more common for young people to be teetotal tgan it used to be. They're not all out trying to sneak alcohol.

StripedElephant · 19/10/2023 16:46

You haven’t said how old your DC are OP? I think it’s really easy to say providing alcohol to teens is the wrong thing to do, when your own DC are pre teens.

Once they all start turning 16 and the parties start, it’s a completely different situation. I provide my teens with alcohol for parties. So far, that have been pretty sensible. Their friends on the other hand often end up in a pretty sorry state, and I’m sure half the reason is they are mixing god knows what because they haven’t got their own drink. 4 cans of cider will have far less impact than a beer, a swig of vodka, a shot of Jack Daniels and shot of Sourz.

Caipirovska · 19/10/2023 16:45

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 19/10/2023 16:33

How would you feel if another family member/parent supplied your teen with alcohol without your consent?

IL did offer young teens odd acholic drink they usually turned it down themselves or tried a sip them stopped as didn't like.

Oddly only one they've really liked has been my Christmas tipple of snowballs and as we don't get that much in - plus they've been good at not too many.

IL made a huge song and dance about getting DD1 an acholic drink it pub with meal for her 18 - she wasn't bothered and didn't want the drink and MIL ended up drinking it. I don't doubt she encountered more alcohol now she off at university but she knows few drinks she likes and what effect it has on her and how to say no thanks or just not drink.

If this is more a co-parenting issue I can't comment DH and I are still married and while he was brought up drinking much more than I was we've been on the same page with alcohol and our kids.

rocknrollaa · 19/10/2023 16:44

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/10/2023 16:43

It is situational, but there is a real danger of thinking that if its "middle class drinking" policed by parents in the home it's OK.

When in fact my family were very much "middle class drinkers": only wine, never spirits, lots of guff about always eating with meals etc and "this is how they do it in France". And still their drinking, and the influence it had on me, was very dangerous, just with a very respectable veneer.

Clearly a parent encouraging their kid to neck vodka neat is a different ballgame from an occasional glass of wine with a meal. But I think parents sometimes kid themselves about the example their drinking sets to their children.

I mean yes but I would say in that situation, they probably were alcoholics, so doesn't actually fit my definition at all.

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/10/2023 16:43

rocknrollaa · 19/10/2023 16:39

It's situational as to what actually will or won't be OK.

For example -

A sensible 14/15 year old being given wine at home by a parent who isn't an alcoholic and will also discuss safe drinking with them - that is not likely to cause any problems.

A 14/15 year old who is easily led 'off the rails', might be in with a 'bad crowd', is very interested in alcohol/ drugs, being given wine at home by a parent with a similar ethos - well - that's much more likely to go badly.

Obviously we need a law in place because if we didn't then people in the latter category would be doing a huge amount of damage to children and young people (more than they will anyway).

It is situational, but there is a real danger of thinking that if its "middle class drinking" policed by parents in the home it's OK.

When in fact my family were very much "middle class drinkers": only wine, never spirits, lots of guff about always eating with meals etc and "this is how they do it in France". And still their drinking, and the influence it had on me, was very dangerous, just with a very respectable veneer.

Clearly a parent encouraging their kid to neck vodka neat is a different ballgame from an occasional glass of wine with a meal. But I think parents sometimes kid themselves about the example their drinking sets to their children.

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/10/2023 16:39

TheSpruce · 19/10/2023 16:33

My favorite part of these threads will be all the posters announcing their saintly DC never drank as teens and don't drink a drop to this day! Sure there might be the odd one but let's be honest, most will not be telling you if they did!

Of course teens drink. But teens of this generation drink markedly less than teens of my generation (born early 70s).

I can't help thinking that a large part of that was a very permissive approach to drinking from our parents (who had lived through the 60s and all that and thought it was a normal "letting off steam" process when in fact it was absurdly self-destructive). Kids do drink today but the ruinously self-destructive drinking of my youth is far less of a badge of honour for teenagers today (praise the Lord).

People bang on a lot about the dangers of video games, phones and social media etc and there are dangers with these obviously but I'd far rather my DD was over-indulging in this than drinking heavily behind my back. If I knew then what I know now about the risks of addiction and the link with cancer etc.

It's not either/or obviously but I do think the "glamorous hedonism" of kids drinking behind their parents backs is thankfully less common than it used to be.

I would be horrified if my DD drank the way I did as a teen.

rocknrollaa · 19/10/2023 16:39

It's situational as to what actually will or won't be OK.

For example -

A sensible 14/15 year old being given wine at home by a parent who isn't an alcoholic and will also discuss safe drinking with them - that is not likely to cause any problems.

A 14/15 year old who is easily led 'off the rails', might be in with a 'bad crowd', is very interested in alcohol/ drugs, being given wine at home by a parent with a similar ethos - well - that's much more likely to go badly.

Obviously we need a law in place because if we didn't then people in the latter category would be doing a huge amount of damage to children and young people (more than they will anyway).

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 19/10/2023 16:37

@TheSpruce totally agree

“My favorite part of these threads will be all the posters announcing their saintly DC never drank as teens and don't drink a drop to this day! Sure there might be the odd one but let's be honest, most will not be telling you if they did!”

I was drinking as a teenager! Just want to hear others experiences of teenagers right now, and the different approaches.

OP posts:
Caipirovska · 19/10/2023 16:37

Catza · 19/10/2023 16:24

I don’t buy alcohol FOR children. I buy it for myself and my partner. The kiddo can have a little sip with a meal if she wants to, most of the time she says no. Since we don’t make a big deal out of alcohol, she has zero interest in it.

This is how we've done it with our teens.

I've never provided alcohol to go to parties with or offered other under 18 acholic drinks but if they want small glass of buzz fizz, wine, cinder or even beer with a meal we were having at home- or odd sip of something we have in that's fine.

We don't drink much anyway - and our teens seem even less interested in drink than us.

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 19/10/2023 16:33

How would you feel if another family member/parent supplied your teen with alcohol without your consent?

OP posts:
TheSpruce · 19/10/2023 16:33

My favorite part of these threads will be all the posters announcing their saintly DC never drank as teens and don't drink a drop to this day! Sure there might be the odd one but let's be honest, most will not be telling you if they did!

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/10/2023 16:30

Dacadactyl · 19/10/2023 16:26

@Thepeopleversuswork I don't necessarily disagree with you, however that is very different to what the OP is asking about.

What are your thoughts on teens being bought alcohol for parties?

I don't know really. I guess its probably safer for an adult to buy an amount of alcohol and limit it to that amount, as opposed to having the kids go off and try to obtain it on their own.

My point was a slightly different one and maybe a red herring. But I do think the more the parents normalise their own drinking the more likely it is that the kids will see it as a normal and desirable leisure activity.

Motheranddaughter · 19/10/2023 16:30

My DD did not drink until she was 17 and my son who is 22 does not drink at all
Not all teens will drink .

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 19/10/2023 16:29

Police have the power to charge those over 18 who knowingly buy alcohol for anyone under the legal drinking age (buying by proxy). It is important that older friends and family know that they could be charged for supplying alcohol irresponsibly.

OP posts:
RubyBoozeDay · 19/10/2023 16:29

I'm with pp - I would rather my teenagers go to parties with a couple of cans than club together with their friends for a litre of cheap vodka.

Teenagers will drink alcohol regardless of whether adults have provided it.