Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it is dangerous to buy/or support buying alcohol for under 16s

162 replies

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 19/10/2023 16:08

“It is illegal to buy alcohol for someone under 18 in a licensed premises, the only exception is for 16 or 17 year-olds who are allowed to drink beer, wine or cider with food if with an adult (but they may not buy the alcohol themselves).”

However, I hear of more and more ‘adults’ justifying buying alcohol for children. It makes me question how safe children are?. Particularly when we find ourselves in a largely split parent/coparenting demographic in the UK. It makes enforcing parental boundaries and measures to keep our children safe, all the more difficult.

OP posts:
Theemeperorsnewclothes · 22/10/2023 22:35

BCCoach · 20/10/2023 10:01

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 19/10/2023 23:21

@Mumof2teens79 ”At the end of the day its not illegal. Children can drink alcohol at home, the only way they can do that is if sn adult buys it.

My daughter wasn't allowed alcohol at parties till she was 15.5, “

I think if you look up UK legislation, you will find that your behaviour is illegal/criminal.
You've misunderstood the law. Parents giving alcohol to their under-16s, either to drink at home or take to a party in another private dwelling, are not breaking any law.

@BCCoach oh yes they are breaking the law, and perhaps part of the major problem with underage drinking, is that people like you need to be educated and prosecuted, if you are found to be supplying minors with alcohol and seriously harming them.

OP posts:
Theemeperorsnewclothes · 22/10/2023 22:29

Vettrianofan · 20/10/2023 07:12

We allow DS (16) to drink with us at home. Sadly for him I tend to only have the odd shandy. We hardly drink alcohol at home. He has the odd cider at home with DH if he has bought some but that's not a regular thing either. He doesn't make a big deal out of alcohol which is a relief.

@Vettrianofan why is it “sadly for him”? Surely it’s a good thing that you only have “the odd shandy”?

OP posts:
Flamingogirl08 · 21/10/2023 10:31

MidnightOnceMore · 20/10/2023 16:41

But people do drink to self medicate, it is no different to any drug.

I know a fair bit about wine, as used to work in the industry and of course drank when younger.

But drink is not necessary - it is a massive part of our culture, but not all cultures.

It is not puritanical not to drink. There's so much denial about drinking culture.

The bacon butty I just ate wasn't necessary either but it was bloody delicious.

Remaker · 20/10/2023 21:24

I am not puritanical about alcohol. I drink, my children know I drink. But alcohol is not safe for developing brains. My kids are social and popular, they have friends, they go out at night. They are not controlled or restricted, quite the opposite in fact. It is quite possible to be a parent who trusts your child and encourages their independence but does not facilitate or normalise underage drinking.

Remaker · 20/10/2023 21:01

@Graciebobcat here you go. From The Lancet

Association of Parental supply of alcohol with adolescent harms

Findings:
Providing alcohol to children is associated with alcohol-related harms. There is no evidence to support the view that parental supply protects from adverse drinking outcomes by providing alcohol to their child. Parents should be advised that this practice is associated with risk, both directly and indirectly through increased access to alcohol from other sources.

Isheabastard · 20/10/2023 19:36

@BCCoach The instance I was thinking of was when I was taking her to a party. We stopped at an off license, she stayed in the car, I went into the offy and bought some booze (cans of lager I believe). I then continued to drive her to the party, gave her the booze and departed (lagerless).

At the time I thought that even buying by proxy was against the law, and that was the reason she stayed in the car. Was I wrong?

fratellia · 20/10/2023 18:56

I remember at 16 my dad would always buy me a couple of blue WKDs to take to a house party, and always pick me up afterwards however late it was 🥰

I haven’t got to that point yet with my own DC, I’m secretly hoping alcohol is seen as millennial and uncool for teens now?

ToastMarmalade · 20/10/2023 18:44

Graciebobcat · 20/10/2023 11:01

And parents providing alcohol to minors leads to more problematic drinking, not less

Any studies to show this?

Yes that’s the whole point of this thread. The NHS and the world health organisation are both based on evidence, and it is clear from the evidence that normalising alcohol and giving alcohol to children is more likely to lead to problematic issues with alcohol for those children. If you want to look up individual studies go to both website and look for the references.

It is a likelihood, so many children will be fine but why would you do something that would make it more likely to lead to harm for your kids later on?

I think most parents are trying their best, but it really shows that anecdotes and myths are not reliable to guide our parenting. And for some reason this myth of being the cool parent who helps their kids by giving them wine or beer whether occasional or regular before they are 16 has been really pervasive.

MidnightOnceMore · 20/10/2023 16:41

SharonEllis · 20/10/2023 15:31

Nobody needs to drink. People like to drink. A gorgeous wine, or real ale, or gin is a delicious and enjoyable thing. You lot really are weird. People have put so much effort into creating delicious alcoholic drinks for centuries - the puritanical attitudes on here are really out of step with a long cultural tradition. Nobody has to drink it - its up to you. Drinking to self medicate is an entirely different thing and I would advise against it & certainly would not bring my children up to think it's wise. If you need medication, see a doctor.

But people do drink to self medicate, it is no different to any drug.

I know a fair bit about wine, as used to work in the industry and of course drank when younger.

But drink is not necessary - it is a massive part of our culture, but not all cultures.

It is not puritanical not to drink. There's so much denial about drinking culture.

cardibach · 20/10/2023 16:28

rocknrollaa · 19/10/2023 16:39

It's situational as to what actually will or won't be OK.

For example -

A sensible 14/15 year old being given wine at home by a parent who isn't an alcoholic and will also discuss safe drinking with them - that is not likely to cause any problems.

A 14/15 year old who is easily led 'off the rails', might be in with a 'bad crowd', is very interested in alcohol/ drugs, being given wine at home by a parent with a similar ethos - well - that's much more likely to go badly.

Obviously we need a law in place because if we didn't then people in the latter category would be doing a huge amount of damage to children and young people (more than they will anyway).

I recognise this. I think I’m category 1 there. DD wasn’t completely forbidden but I was modelling and discussing sensible drinking. She had a school friend whose parents were category 2. The only times she ever needed picking up or came home having drunk too much was from parties at this friend’s house. We lived rurally - even all night camping parties on farms were fine, it was just this one friend.
She’s late 20s now and still says it’s a risk going out with this friend.

JuvenileEmu · 20/10/2023 16:22

ToastMarmalade · 19/10/2023 21:11

This is an area where we believe in the myth that teenagers will
a) drink anyway so the myth is it’s safer for them at home.
b) somehow ‘learn’ to drink better with adults.
c) drinking at home or ‘allowing’ will have no adverse affects.
d) that not normalising alcohol will lead to repressed kids who will then go crazy about alcohol later.

The above are all myths. They are not true.

There is good, reliable evidence out there. What does it say?

It says:
That the longer teenagers can stay off alcohol the better their outcomes - they are more likely NOT to bave problematic behaviour related to alcohol.

The longer that parents can set the tone that alcohol is better abstained from until at least 16, again the kids are more likely NOT to have problematics behaviour or alcohol dependency.

This is not the same as banning alcohol or telling kids never to drink alcohol. But it is that if parents can avoid normalising alcohol and avoid introducing it to kids in the home - the better the outcomes.

It doesn’t matter that a lot of parents on mumsnet believe otherwise - they just believe a myth that is all hearsay.

I think this is the most important post on the thread. And no, I wouldn't buy alcohol for teenagers to take to a party, I'd rather them learn to relax and enjoy themselves without needing a prop to artificially boost their confidence.

SomersetBrie · 20/10/2023 16:13

SharonEllis · 20/10/2023 15:31

Nobody needs to drink. People like to drink. A gorgeous wine, or real ale, or gin is a delicious and enjoyable thing. You lot really are weird. People have put so much effort into creating delicious alcoholic drinks for centuries - the puritanical attitudes on here are really out of step with a long cultural tradition. Nobody has to drink it - its up to you. Drinking to self medicate is an entirely different thing and I would advise against it & certainly would not bring my children up to think it's wise. If you need medication, see a doctor.

I enjoy drinking but I am an adult.
It's possible to model safe drinking around children without buying it for them

SomersetBrie · 20/10/2023 16:11

SharonEllis · 20/10/2023 15:22

This is ridiculous. As you well know there is no responsible or healthy level of smoking, because of fire & environmental risk as well as health risks which are irrefutable. There absolutely is a responsible level of drinking. Responsible drinking is not just about units. It's about modelling a responsible culture around drinking. I.e drinking alcohol can be part of enjoying good food & company. Drinking to get drunk or drinking cheap booze just to get drunk is a completely different activity.

I don't think there is any safe level for someone of 15 or under to be drinking.

BCCoach · 20/10/2023 16:09

@Isheabastard

"I did buy her or supply alcohol when she was about 17. I knew it was illegal,..."

No it wasn't. I don't know where people have got this idea from.

It's illegal for a licenced premises to supply alcohol to under 18 year old (with the exception of wine, beer or cider with a meal, where the age limit is 16).

It's illegal to proxy buy for an under 18 year old - this is where the child gives you money and you buy alcohol on their behalf.

It's absolutely not illegal for someone to give alcohol to an under 18 year old in non-licenced premises (such as a private dwelling).

Warum · 20/10/2023 15:50

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 20/10/2023 15:19

My 14 year old has an occasional cider shandy with a roast or a big meal. I think it's better to introduce teens to alcohol in the home than having their first drink in a park.

Clearly it's better to be in a safer environment, but they really don't need to be drinking any alcohol at 14!

SharonEllis · 20/10/2023 15:31

MidnightOnceMore · 20/10/2023 15:26

Not drinking is healthier than drinking.

Why do people need to drink? Self medication. Drinkers always justify drinking. L

Nobody needs to drink. People like to drink. A gorgeous wine, or real ale, or gin is a delicious and enjoyable thing. You lot really are weird. People have put so much effort into creating delicious alcoholic drinks for centuries - the puritanical attitudes on here are really out of step with a long cultural tradition. Nobody has to drink it - its up to you. Drinking to self medicate is an entirely different thing and I would advise against it & certainly would not bring my children up to think it's wise. If you need medication, see a doctor.

MidnightOnceMore · 20/10/2023 15:26

SharonEllis · 20/10/2023 15:22

This is ridiculous. As you well know there is no responsible or healthy level of smoking, because of fire & environmental risk as well as health risks which are irrefutable. There absolutely is a responsible level of drinking. Responsible drinking is not just about units. It's about modelling a responsible culture around drinking. I.e drinking alcohol can be part of enjoying good food & company. Drinking to get drunk or drinking cheap booze just to get drunk is a completely different activity.

Not drinking is healthier than drinking.

Why do people need to drink? Self medication. Drinkers always justify drinking. L

SharonEllis · 20/10/2023 15:22

EarthlyNightshade · 20/10/2023 15:02

So as it stands 68% of people think it is reasonable to buy alcohol for children aged 15 and under.
I wonder do some of these people also buy vapes, cigarettes for their children to teach responsible smoking?
(I do know someone who buys vapes for their 16 year old as they worry about them getting hold of unregulated products but that is literally one person, while I know quite a few who would buy drink.)

This is ridiculous. As you well know there is no responsible or healthy level of smoking, because of fire & environmental risk as well as health risks which are irrefutable. There absolutely is a responsible level of drinking. Responsible drinking is not just about units. It's about modelling a responsible culture around drinking. I.e drinking alcohol can be part of enjoying good food & company. Drinking to get drunk or drinking cheap booze just to get drunk is a completely different activity.

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 20/10/2023 15:19

My 14 year old has an occasional cider shandy with a roast or a big meal. I think it's better to introduce teens to alcohol in the home than having their first drink in a park.

EarthlyNightshade · 20/10/2023 15:02

So as it stands 68% of people think it is reasonable to buy alcohol for children aged 15 and under.
I wonder do some of these people also buy vapes, cigarettes for their children to teach responsible smoking?
(I do know someone who buys vapes for their 16 year old as they worry about them getting hold of unregulated products but that is literally one person, while I know quite a few who would buy drink.)

Isheabastard · 20/10/2023 12:14

My ex and I were social drinkers only. But I get your point about making it the norm to be a bit pissed in front of your kids. We were older parents and she is now mid twenties, so you can see I’m much older. It was just something we didn’t think about then. We could easily drink underage in pubs because they were very lax then.

On the assumption my Dd would be going to parties where alcohol was I thought about how I could mitigate the dangers. It wasn’t the drinking itself, it was being inexperienced, getting drunk and being in unsafe situations.

At first she could only go to a party if I knew the parents were going to actively be there and I was picking her up. Eg 15 yrs

Obviously there were lots of chats about not only her possible safety, but her friends and any risky behaviour from the bravado of being drunk.

I kept cash under the inside door mat so she could always get a taxi , and never walk home alone from town. (10min walk). She also had to text me when she was back home. Then when I woke in the night I could read that.

Next I had an arrangement that if she ever felt uncomfortable somewhere I would come and get her no questions asked. I had practically stopped drinking by then. The next day we would discuss what went wrong and how she could do things differently next time.

Finally I bought her a breathalyser off Amazon. I hoped that she could use it with her friends, so they could learn to see how quickly you can be drunker than you think. And also if she ever stayed over and was driving the next day.

I did buy her or supply alcohol when she was about 17. I knew it was illegal, but my reasoning at that time was that she was off to university within months and I sort of wanted to be able to see her being responsible about alcohol before she left home entirely. (See my fudgey thinking there).

OP I don’t agree with everything you say, but I think this is a thought provoking thread asking us to examine our assumptions about allowing teens to drink when it is in fact unlawful, and it will be unlawful because presumably people who are experts in this field have decided iI is unsafe for teens.

By the way, my ex still drinks as much as he ever did. Times have changed and now his drinking seems excessive to me, my Dd and future son in law.

PhantomUnicorn · 20/10/2023 11:49

I was bought up with alcohol in the house, around my Dads social life and being in the working mens club and seeing him have a couple of pints, at home it was a glass of wine with dinner, a bacardi and coke of an evening watching TV.

My parents drank responsibly, and they taught us to drink responsibly.

I have seen people drunk, and sure, couple of times i went out as an 18/19yo and drank past my limit and suffered for it.

I think teaching kids that drink in moderation is ok, is a sensible approach.

As an adult i don't really drink, might have a bottle of fruit cider, or a rum and coke on a friday/saturday night, or a glass of wine with sunday dinner, so my kids are being bought up the same.. as yet neither have shown interest in even trying anything alcoholic, but we do chat about being sensible, what it feels like, finding limits, eating before drinking, using mixers to stay hydrated, alternating with soft drinks...etc.

I also ascribe strongly to the belief that to keep drinking once you're merry is a waste of money and alcohol and repeat that belief to my kids.

SharonEllis · 20/10/2023 11:40

Foxesandsquirrels · 20/10/2023 11:32

@SharonEllis I agree with your take. I think there seems to be two extreme views when it comes to alcohol and there is a middle ground. Alcohol isn't the devil and it's not bad for you in small doses, however the concept of a small dose is so different to everyone. I drink a glass of wine, maybe once per week.
I like your comparison to cake. It's interesting as my mum would very often 'treat' herself to a cake or dessert after a long day. I distinctly remember this happening, and she still stress eats! I struggled with comfort eating for a long time. If she did the same with alcohol, I'm sure I'd have probably struggled with that.
It's the attitude we model that's the important part. I think the alcohol part is neither here nor there.
Ultimately as a society we won't have very healthy coping mechanisms for stress that we show our kids, and that's what should be nipped in the bud.

Yes, I think you're right, that's a good way of thinking about it. It's about the attitude. Alcohol was another delicious thing like good food that you do in good company - & is moderated by that company (& btw my mum was working class in response to an earlier comment). It was not modelled as an emotional crutch.

Foxesandsquirrels · 20/10/2023 11:32

@SharonEllis I agree with your take. I think there seems to be two extreme views when it comes to alcohol and there is a middle ground. Alcohol isn't the devil and it's not bad for you in small doses, however the concept of a small dose is so different to everyone. I drink a glass of wine, maybe once per week.
I like your comparison to cake. It's interesting as my mum would very often 'treat' herself to a cake or dessert after a long day. I distinctly remember this happening, and she still stress eats! I struggled with comfort eating for a long time. If she did the same with alcohol, I'm sure I'd have probably struggled with that.
It's the attitude we model that's the important part. I think the alcohol part is neither here nor there.
Ultimately as a society we won't have very healthy coping mechanisms for stress that we show our kids, and that's what should be nipped in the bud.

SharonEllis · 20/10/2023 11:24

Thepeopleversuswork · 20/10/2023 10:39

@SharonEllis

So are you suggesting that parents can never drink in front of their children? Or that drinking is something that people should feel guilty about? That sets kids up for a very unhealthy relationship with alcohol. Alcohol was never taboo in family. Getting drunk absolutely was though. The normalisation of being drunk in British culture is the problem. Not drinking alcohol.

I'm absolutely not saying parents can never drink in front of their children.

There's a huge difference between parents offering to give their kids some watered down wine or beer occasionally, and doing what my dad did, which was to offer me a glass of wine every night from the age of about 14. That's where the normalisation part comes in. I think modelling responsible drinking is good as long as it genuinely is responsible drinking (ie occasional and little).

An awful lot of people will talk about giving their teenagers "a little bit of watered down wine with their meal" but it will turn out to mean every meal. Which is not responsible at all.

Also I sort of agree with you that its the normalisation of being drunk which is the problem. But let's be honest alcohol is a problem in itself. It's bad for people, even in surprisingly small doses. A lot of people like to pretend there's a hard line between "drinking" and "being drunk". It's much more complicated than this. Yes plenty of people drink regularly but without damaging their health.

But its perfectly possible to drink in a very respectable way which nevertheless is very dangerous for your body and mind. Normalising the idea that drinking is fine as long as you aren't vomiting into a bin in the City Centre or bashing some bloke's head in isn't really responsible drinking. It's normalising respectable alcoholism.

Basically the less alcohol you drink, the better. Any kind of "normalisation" is slightly unhealthy.

My parents wouldn't have dreamt of giving me a glass of wine every night at 14. Not ever, at that age, undiluted. I think you're proving my point. But they modelled a responsible enjoyment of alcohol, which my Mum got from her parents (also loved a drink, never, ever got drunk) which is not only fine, but has been really effective with both me & my sister. I don't think alcohol is, in itself a problem & its obvious nonsense to say normalising drinking is normalising alcoholism. Liking wine or beer, and being an alcoholic, are quite literally 2 different things and one doesn't lead to the other any more than eating a piece of cake automatically leads to obesity or diabetes. I certainly intend to carry it on my mum's philosophy with my own teenagers who think getting drunk sounds completely disgusting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread