Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it is dangerous to buy/or support buying alcohol for under 16s

162 replies

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 19/10/2023 16:08

“It is illegal to buy alcohol for someone under 18 in a licensed premises, the only exception is for 16 or 17 year-olds who are allowed to drink beer, wine or cider with food if with an adult (but they may not buy the alcohol themselves).”

However, I hear of more and more ‘adults’ justifying buying alcohol for children. It makes me question how safe children are?. Particularly when we find ourselves in a largely split parent/coparenting demographic in the UK. It makes enforcing parental boundaries and measures to keep our children safe, all the more difficult.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thepeopleversuswork · 23/10/2023 08:36

@CherryMyBrandy

You are conflating "normalising alcohol" with "being an alcoholic". They are two completely different things. Drinking in a normal and sociable way around children is fine. It models responsible drinking and behaviour. What happened to you was calling something one thing, in an attempt to cover up alcoholism and all that comes with that.

Of course not everyone who drinks is an alcoholic: but this position is problematic for a few reasons:

  1. There isn't a hard dividing line between "alcoholics" and "normal drinkers". Alcoholism is a progressive disease which usually involves some underlying psychological underpinning but "normal" drinking which becomes less normal is usually the trigger point. Alcoholics don't start as fully-formed alcoholics. They are people who use alcohol as a crutch and for whom the relationship progressively becomes problematic. You say drinking in a "normal and sociable" way around children is fine and it is fine -- up to a point. But anything that signals to children that alcohol is a normal copying mechanism or a part of day to day life has the potential to lead to a problematic relationship.
  2. It's possible to drink in an unhealthy way even if you stop short of being alcohol dependent. Masses of people who are not alcohol dependent still damage their internal organs and shorten their lives by drinking more than is healthy for them.

I'm not suggesting people need to live an alcohol-free and puritanical life. But I do think the idea that drinking around children and "modelling" frequent but non-alcoholic drinking with them sets a good example is misguided.

It's not wrong to allow your children to see you drinking at times but why wouldn't it be better to minimise the amount of time they see you drinking? I can't see the upside to making alcohol a central part of family life.

SharonEllis · 23/10/2023 06:12

CherryMyBrandy · 23/10/2023 00:00

You are conflating "normalising alcohol" with "being an alcoholic". They are two completely different things. Drinking in a normal and sociable way around children is fine. It models responsible drinking and behaviour. What happened to you was calling something one thing, in an attempt to cover up alcoholism and all that comes with that.

Exactly this!

SharonEllis · 23/10/2023 06:09

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 23/10/2023 00:01

SharonEllis · 20/10/2023 15:31

Nobody needs to drink. People like to drink. A gorgeous wine, or real ale, or gin is a delicious and enjoyable thing. You lot really are weird. People have put so much effort into creating delicious alcoholic drinks for centuries - the puritanical attitudes on here are really out of step with a long cultural tradition. Nobody has to drink it - its up to you. Drinking to self medicate is an entirely different thing and I would advise against it & certainly would not bring my children up to think it's wise. If you need medication, see a doctor.

@SharonEllis this reply makes me wonder what your own relationship is with alcohol? Alcohol is a drug, nothing more, nothing less. It alters our brain chemistry and physical responses like any other drug. It is effectively a poison to our human beings, no matter how we dress it up.

“Nobody has to drink it - it’s up to you.” I beg to differ. Alcoholism is a worrying and complex disease. Yes, that’s right, ‘disease’… not “choice” it starts somewhere, but as it is so complex, it makes sense to avoid any ‘triggers’ one major one being… caregivers supporting and facilitating drinking at a young age. This isn’t exclusive to the UK. ‘Continental drinking’ now agrees with the science and those in the know would also agree that we should all be on the same page. It will take a severe stance and properly enforced legislation and prosecutions to truly protect children. This thread has demonstrated how dangerously entrenched we are in the drinking laws of the past… “you can give your five year old alcohol” pfft. Given the scientific research into the damage underage drinking does to a child’s physical and mental health and current and future life chances, this should be a priority in the political agenda.

I have explained my relationship with alcohol - its all there. I have said don't drink to self medicate - that leads to alcoholism. The whole point of my moderate approach to alcohol is to avoid dependence. That is how I was brought up. I haven't had a drink for several weeks. I go through phases of drinking a bottle of wine across a week - you do the maths - hardly excessive. Occasional gin & tonic. Maybe a whole 2 glasses of wine or a whole 2 × half pints of beer if I have dinner out or at home with friends maybe once a month. I never suggested giving a five year old alcohol. My life chances have in no way been affected in any negative way by my parents giving me heavily diluted alcohol as a child & modelling extremely moderate drinking. Being so sanctimonious towards us won't save a single child from the negative effects of living with alcoholism or excessive binge drinking which plague our society.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 23/10/2023 00:39

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 23/10/2023 00:37

StripedElephant · Today 00:20

I think people are finding it difficult to follow because you appear to be copying and pasting the comment you are replying to. It’s very hard to tell which text is the original comment and which is your response.

apologies, I thought that made it easier, to copy and paste what I’m actually replying to? Or not?

Better to quote (like this)

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 23/10/2023 00:37

StripedElephant · Today 00:20

I think people are finding it difficult to follow because you appear to be copying and pasting the comment you are replying to. It’s very hard to tell which text is the original comment and which is your response.

apologies, I thought that made it easier, to copy and paste what I’m actually replying to? Or not?

OP posts:
StripedElephant · 23/10/2023 00:20

I think people are finding it difficult to follow because you appear to be copying and pasting the comment you are replying to. It’s very hard to tell which text is the original comment and which is your response.

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 23/10/2023 00:10

“Now you're just coming across as puritanical and against alcohol completely. Which is fine if that's your opinion but it wasn't what your OP was about.

Did you mention underage drinking in your OP as a way to start a debate about alcohol use in general? Furthermore you're obviously set in your opinion so clearly not an AIBU situation.”

nope, it’s just how the thread has evolved. My point is still about underage drinking and those normalising/supplying underage drinkers. Making it hugely difficult for parents who are trying to say “no” based on science and ‘new thinking’

OP posts:
TooOldForThisNonsense · 23/10/2023 00:08

On the other hand…

I didn’t drink underage
my parents never bought me alcohol or encouraged/enabled me to drink it
didn’t even drink that much as a student

Still ended up with alcohol use disorder

Even when parents do everything right it can still go wrong 😑

Flamingogirl08 · 23/10/2023 00:05

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 23/10/2023 00:01

SharonEllis · 20/10/2023 15:31

Nobody needs to drink. People like to drink. A gorgeous wine, or real ale, or gin is a delicious and enjoyable thing. You lot really are weird. People have put so much effort into creating delicious alcoholic drinks for centuries - the puritanical attitudes on here are really out of step with a long cultural tradition. Nobody has to drink it - its up to you. Drinking to self medicate is an entirely different thing and I would advise against it & certainly would not bring my children up to think it's wise. If you need medication, see a doctor.

@SharonEllis this reply makes me wonder what your own relationship is with alcohol? Alcohol is a drug, nothing more, nothing less. It alters our brain chemistry and physical responses like any other drug. It is effectively a poison to our human beings, no matter how we dress it up.

“Nobody has to drink it - it’s up to you.” I beg to differ. Alcoholism is a worrying and complex disease. Yes, that’s right, ‘disease’… not “choice” it starts somewhere, but as it is so complex, it makes sense to avoid any ‘triggers’ one major one being… caregivers supporting and facilitating drinking at a young age. This isn’t exclusive to the UK. ‘Continental drinking’ now agrees with the science and those in the know would also agree that we should all be on the same page. It will take a severe stance and properly enforced legislation and prosecutions to truly protect children. This thread has demonstrated how dangerously entrenched we are in the drinking laws of the past… “you can give your five year old alcohol” pfft. Given the scientific research into the damage underage drinking does to a child’s physical and mental health and current and future life chances, this should be a priority in the political agenda.

Now you're just coming across as puritanical and against alcohol completely. Which is fine if that's your opinion but it wasn't what your OP was about.

Did you mention underage drinking in your OP as a way to start a debate about alcohol use in general? Furthermore you're obviously set in your opinion so clearly not an AIBU situation.

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 23/10/2023 00:01

SharonEllis · 20/10/2023 15:31

Nobody needs to drink. People like to drink. A gorgeous wine, or real ale, or gin is a delicious and enjoyable thing. You lot really are weird. People have put so much effort into creating delicious alcoholic drinks for centuries - the puritanical attitudes on here are really out of step with a long cultural tradition. Nobody has to drink it - its up to you. Drinking to self medicate is an entirely different thing and I would advise against it & certainly would not bring my children up to think it's wise. If you need medication, see a doctor.

@SharonEllis this reply makes me wonder what your own relationship is with alcohol? Alcohol is a drug, nothing more, nothing less. It alters our brain chemistry and physical responses like any other drug. It is effectively a poison to our human beings, no matter how we dress it up.

“Nobody has to drink it - it’s up to you.” I beg to differ. Alcoholism is a worrying and complex disease. Yes, that’s right, ‘disease’… not “choice” it starts somewhere, but as it is so complex, it makes sense to avoid any ‘triggers’ one major one being… caregivers supporting and facilitating drinking at a young age. This isn’t exclusive to the UK. ‘Continental drinking’ now agrees with the science and those in the know would also agree that we should all be on the same page. It will take a severe stance and properly enforced legislation and prosecutions to truly protect children. This thread has demonstrated how dangerously entrenched we are in the drinking laws of the past… “you can give your five year old alcohol” pfft. Given the scientific research into the damage underage drinking does to a child’s physical and mental health and current and future life chances, this should be a priority in the political agenda.

OP posts:
CherryMyBrandy · 23/10/2023 00:00

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/10/2023 16:22

I'm going to go against the grain here: I don't think its great to normalise alcohol around kids.

My parents (dad functional alcoholic, mum not but enabled him) both subscribed to the bullshit theory that "continental-style" drinking (wine with meals etc) was fine and it was better to introduce children to drinking moderately at home than not drink and have them go off and drink unsupervised. I understand the theory but in practice more often than not it was just a fig leaf to allow the parents to get slaughtered in front of their children but feel OK about it because it was in the guise of "being like the French".

I grew up to loathe being around my dad when he was drinking wine and I dreaded him offering it to me. I'd far rather they just didn't drink at home, or drank very modestly.

Teens do drink and it probably is better to have some overview as to what they are drinking and with whom but I think quite a lot of this is just parents allowing themselves to drink in front of kids in a guilt-free way. Far healthier for kids to get used to alcohol not being involved in every get together and served with every meal than to introduce it all the time and kid yourself its healthier just because its done with parents.

You are conflating "normalising alcohol" with "being an alcoholic". They are two completely different things. Drinking in a normal and sociable way around children is fine. It models responsible drinking and behaviour. What happened to you was calling something one thing, in an attempt to cover up alcoholism and all that comes with that.

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 22/10/2023 23:38

SharonEllis · Today 23:26

This thread is completely impossible to follow now.

Sorry @SharonEllis I was trying to keep up/reply to some reply’s after a few days away from the forum. Apologies that you are finding it impossible to follow.

OP posts:
Flamingogirl08 · 22/10/2023 23:35

SharonEllis · 22/10/2023 23:26

This thread is completely impossible to follow now.

Yep, what is the OP doing?!

SharonEllis · 22/10/2023 23:26

This thread is completely impossible to follow now.

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 22/10/2023 23:17

*warning

OP posts:
Theemeperorsnewclothes · 22/10/2023 23:15

fost · Today 22:42

No, parents giving alcohol under 16's to drink at home are not breaking the law. The PP is not the one who needs to be educated.

Licensing (Young Persons) Act 2000
"Proxy purchase

5.Prior to the Act, the law did not prohibit an adult buying alcohol on behalf of a child in off-licensed premises. This has been referred to as “proxy purchase”. The Act creates a new offence of buying or attempting to buy alcohol on behalf of a child in any licensed premises. A similar offence has existed in Scotland since 1976. A defence is available if the adult had no reason to suspect that the child was under 18. A parent who bought alcohol and subsequently gave it to his child would not commit an offence. The offence covers those who act as the agents of children in contracting sales. A parent contracts the sale in his or her own right, and is not acting as the child’s agent or go-between to effect the child’s own purchase."

Yes, the PP is the one that needs to be educated, if you are buying alcohol for under 18’s you are the problem.

“A defence is available if the adult had no reason to suspect that the child was under 18. A parent who bought alcohol and subsequently gave it to his child would not commit an offence.”

How utterly bonkers that you are looking for a defence in law to excuse giving minors alcohol. There are many campaigns in my area right now warming over 18’s that they will prosecute those who are found to be knowingly buying alcohol for minors… because of new legislation… because they now know the risks and harms to a developing body and brain. No one is saying that 16 and 17 year olds won’t find a way. 14 and 15 year old children being supplied alcohol (effectively a poison) by their own parents? It should be taken very seriously as a criminal offence and then we wouldn’t even be having this debate. It shouldn’t even be a debate given the very clear scientific evidence. And sadly, this is when we acutely need the help of a Nanny state.

OP posts:
Theemeperorsnewclothes · 22/10/2023 23:01

EarthlyNightshade · 20/10/2023 15:02

So as it stands 68% of people think it is reasonable to buy alcohol for children aged 15 and under.
I wonder do some of these people also buy vapes, cigarettes for their children to teach responsible smoking?
(I do know someone who buys vapes for their 16 year old as they worry about them getting hold of unregulated products but that is literally one person, while I know quite a few who would buy drink.)

@EarthlyNightshade it’s a real eye opener. I would like to think the powers that be in the UK, that should be protecting our CHILDREN are hanging their heads in shame. The GUARDIANS’ of these CHILDREN, are in the majority for arguing that they are ‘right’ to supply them with alcohol. Many many organisations need some joined up working to protect our children. MPs, Police, Education, NHS… and many many more.

OP posts:
Theemeperorsnewclothes · 22/10/2023 22:53

Remaker · 20/10/2023 10:59

I have a 17.5 year old and an almost 16 year old. I have never supplied alcohol for them in any form and I won’t until they are 18. I’m in Australia and alcohol isn’t legal until 18 though I think it isn’t strictly illegal to give your own child alcohol in your home. I’ll admit I am always completely horrified by the MN discussions where people cheerfully say they give their 13 or 14 yo alcohol on special occasions. I think it is irresponsible.

I think parents these days have bought into the myth that if they know their child is drinking then it is safer than if they don’t know. In reality there is no safe level of drinking for under 18s. And parents providing alcohol to minors leads to more problematic drinking, not less. Mumsnet doesn’t agree but those are the facts.

I don’t guarantee that my stance will stop my kids from sampling any alcohol. However I see them when they come home from being out with friends and they are clearly not drunk. So if they’re having it, it’s not to excess.

We have had many conversations about alcohol and drugs and they know they can always call me or DH if anything has happened to them or a friend. And that when in doubt they should call an ambulance. Our primary concern is their health and wellbeing

@Remaker thank you 👏❤️

OP posts:
Theemeperorsnewclothes · 22/10/2023 22:48

PinkRoses1245 · 20/10/2023 07:25

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 19/10/2023 16:29

Police have the power to charge those over 18 who knowingly buy alcohol for anyone under the legal drinking age (buying by proxy). It is important that older friends and family know that they could be charged for supplying alcohol irresponsibly.
I think the police have better use of their time.

@PinkRoses1245 it depends what you view as important. I would like to think any educated, person/child centred police force would have had adequate training about the dangers of over 18’s supplying alcohol to children and the damage and harm that does to children, and how vulnerable it makes those CHILDREN to other abuse and crimes.

OP posts:
TooOldForThisNonsense · 22/10/2023 22:44

It is not easy to navigate as a parent and especially not as a parent who has had a drink problem myself (now sober).

My eldest is 17 and since he was about 16.5 and started wanting to drink at parties etc I have purchased him some. I’d rather he didn’t drink but I am realistic I can’t ban it and I’d rather he was drinking a controlled amount of what I buy (beers, corona usually) rather than cans of Dragon Soop, bottles of spirits or anything else he can get his hands on.

If he has people round here then they are not allowed to have alcohol unless there is an adult (me or DH) here as I am not having other people’s children drinking in my house with no adult present. The other parents of kids he is friends with all seem pretty responsible too when they are at their houses.

my youngest is nearly 15 and I won’t be buying or condoning him drinking alcohol for the foreseeable future. He’s not interested just now anyway

gotomomo · 22/10/2023 22:44

@MidnightOnceMore

I drink alcoholic drinks I like the taste of, I don't drink the ones that I don't like. Whiskey in particular is revolting!

I don't drink to get drunk or even tipsy, I only drink for flavour. What I really don't like is fizzy drinks so that's most non alcoholic pub drinks and lager, it's the fizz - I let my tonic go flat! I'll happily drink redbush tea, lime cordial and water (not fizzy soda water though) etc but nothing beats the flavour of good red wine, a nice Bordeaux perhaps

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 22/10/2023 22:42

Dacadactyl · 20/10/2023 07:25

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 19/10/2023 22:31

@Chchchanging

Totally agree. I think a lot of adults want to validate their own alcohol use by starting their kids off early so ' they do it in a safe environment'...
So would they do that with cigarettes? Vapes? Other legal yet very harmful habits? Because the kids will do it anyway?
As a society our relationship with alcohol is very unhealthy. Its relied upon as a social crutch, to unwind, to deal with stress, to treat one's self, to forget worries, because social interaction is no fun without it. The whole 'wine o'clock' culture, drinking at home in the evening because its been earned, or its been a hell of a day, all those birthday cards with jokes about old women and gin etc etc. That is not healthy and teaching kids to do the same is not healthy either.
Modelling having fun and dealing with life's stresses without alcohol is far healthier for kids.
It's just not many people want to do that. Because it means addressing their own relationship with alcohol. Which probably wouldn't stand up to scrutiny.
I don't drink. I didn't buy my DC alcohol. I talked a lot about the downsides. Mine never went nuts. They don't really drink. They don't feel the need to..meanwhile all the kids whose parents put on drink laden parties for their kids and friends aged 15 are still regularly hammered and often doing worse things.
It's just not true that normalising alcohol use 'helps' kids.

That is such an interesting point and so valid. It goes against every maternal instinct in my body to supply alcohol to a child 14/15. I understand that 16/17 gets trickier and laws change at that age therefore surely that’s the time for a balanced discussion. Given the scientific information that we know, it would be so much more helpful if all parents had a blanket “no” pre 16. Perhaps there needs to be more serious consequences for those who knowingly harm children.
I feel your last sentence is hyperbole tbh.

As a parent, I am equipped to know whether my actions in buying a few cans are causing harm to my child or not. I do not think it is harmful. If I did, I wouldn't be doing it.

@Dacadactyl don’t be ridiculous why would I hyperbole on my own post, that’s genuinely trying to understand this worrying UK approach to children and alcohol. I would strongly advise that you are not equipped to know if you are doing your child harm from what you have disclosed. I urge you to do further research and take further advice.

OP posts:
fost · 22/10/2023 22:42

No, parents giving alcohol under 16's to drink at home are not breaking the law. The PP is not the one who needs to be educated.

Licensing (Young Persons) Act 2000
"Proxy purchase

5.Prior to the Act, the law did not prohibit an adult buying alcohol on behalf of a child in off-licensed premises. This has been referred to as “proxy purchase”. The Act creates a new offence of buying or attempting to buy alcohol on behalf of a child in any licensed premises. A similar offence has existed in Scotland since 1976. A defence is available if the adult had no reason to suspect that the child was under 18. A parent who bought alcohol and subsequently gave it to his child would not commit an offence. The offence covers those who act as the agents of children in contracting sales. A parent contracts the sale in his or her own right, and is not acting as the child’s agent or go-between to effect the child’s own purchase."

fost · 22/10/2023 22:39

It isn't illegal to supply an under 16 year old with alcohol, your very first post says "in a licensed premises". So sure, you can't buy them a drink in the pub, but you can give them alcohol at home from the age of 5. The rules about proxy purchasing don't apply to parents buying alcohol and then going on to give it to their kids.

gotomomo · 22/10/2023 22:36

I have young adults, they were allowed alcohol at home and they could take drink to parties, they are well adjusted, didn't have issues with out of control drinking at university and one chosen a not to drink apart from special occasions. Forbidding them causes more problems in my experience. All my friends allowed their teens alcohol too, even my DD's Asian friend whose parents had a rather extensive wine cellar it turned out. Perhaps it's the circles we were in but wine with meals for teens was normal