Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go no contact with my mum?

64 replies

kindredsp · 19/10/2023 12:41

I’ve not spoken to my mother for several months now and haven’t responded to a couple of texts and emails she’s sent since. The last time I spoke to her, I told her I wanted some space from her and to leave me be, with a very clear explanation as to why. I have since heard through other family members that she’s saying that I’m blanking her, that I’m denying her access to her grandchildren and that I have insulted her, and quite frankly I’m pissed.
Our relationship is very complex and I won’t bore you with too many details. But the straw that broke the camels back was when we decided to move away to a cheaper part of the country to gain some financial stability with a small mortgage (first time buyers with a limited deposit).
She then offered us 150k so we could stay local to her and still have a small mortgage. We said no originally as there’s always a condition or catch to her “help”, but eventually she wore me down and I accepted.
We house hunted, put an offer in for an incredible house, and had it accepted. The dream of living in an area we loved in a house we loved really was intoxicating.
Then she withdrew her offer. No real reason was given, other than that she couldn’t access that kind of money (she obviously originally said it was easy for her to access). I was so emotionally invested in the move that I persuaded my husband to go ahead with the purchase anyway despite it totally maxing ourselves out affordability wise. So we moved.
We’ve lived in our house for 5 years and money has been horribly tight. We love the area and the house, but we’ve literally lived month by month saving nothing. We have no money to live, just meet the basics. It is not the financial stability we were looking for. Add a pandemic, cost of living crisis and now the end of our fixed rate, we’re tighter than ever before.
We work our arses off and we’re missing everything. We can’t live, we can’t enjoy ourselves, we hardly see our children. It’s miserable and so stressful and the whole situation has put a huge strain on our marriage.
My mother breezes in and out with zero remorse for what happened. As far as she can see, we’re close by with a roof over our head so what’s the big deal. The last conversation I had with her was just as we were remortgaging and coming to terms with our monthly rate going up by a few hundred pounds. I said that if she’d let us make our own decisions we’d be in a financially stable position now and able to ride the spiralling expenses much better. She said she was only trying to help and had no idea it had put us under financial stress. She said we shouldn’t have bought the house if we couldn’t afford it.
Hindsight is a wonderful thing, especially when you remove emotion from it. If I could go back I would have absolutely not bought our house. I would have reverted to the original plan. But at the time house prices were shooting up, we’d wasted 6 months on a fools errand and were about to be at a point where moving elsewhere wouldn’t have been the financial break we’d hoped for anyway and we’d still be stuck in rental today most likely.
But here we are. She hasn’t apologised for what she did. In fact, she said she couldn’t even remember how much she’d promised us. It feels like it was just a tactic to stop us from moving away so she could still see her grandchildren rather than allow us the freedom to make our own decisions.
I felt proud of myself for finally speaking up about it and her response also made me realise that I don’t want her in our lives. But now she’s telling everyone that I’ve insulted her (I haven’t), but I have stopped her seeing the grandchildren because I’m not seeing her myself and I am ignoring her messages because I asked for space the last time we spoke. So am I the AH?

OP posts:
MrsElsa · 19/10/2023 13:16

People who didn't grow up with narcissistic mothers won't understand what you're saying OP. I completely understand. My M has pulled identical stunts in the past. And yes you do feel that she is to blame because you are still emotionally enmeshed with her and struggling to identify your own boundaries.

You are right to go NC. You are wrong to expect anyone to believe or support you in your family of origin (FOO). They will likely want to appease her to keep her off their backs, and that means siding with her, undermining you, making you feel guilty etc.

By going NC with her you will start to see how deeply fucked up the entire family system is. I would describe it as no one is innocent and they don't like it when anyone dares to take a stand.

You are doing the right thing and I would encourage you to go ahead with moving away, selling the unaffordable house and moving to somewhere cheaper as you originally planned. There will be the advantage of putting some distance between you and M, this will help reduce the amount of havoc she can wreak on your life.

You will have built up some equity in the house so fingers crossed will be able to either take some money out on sale or use that for a larger deposit and reduce mgage monthly payments down to a comfortable level.

yogasaurus · 19/10/2023 13:11

One of the OP’s other threads is them asking if they should make an official complaint about their GP not recommending an abortion back when they were mid twenties, as by then their DC was then 11/12 and they’d found it very difficult financially over the years.

A pattern of lack of accountability emerges, tbh.

Whattodo112222 · 19/10/2023 13:11

I don't think you can blame her for the fact you went ahead with the house purchase. You're adults. It's fine to say you were emotionally invested, but surely you knew in your heart of hearts that this was overstretching you massively.

I can understand the disappointment of her retracting the deposit however.
I would go LC with her.

OhNoForever · 19/10/2023 13:08

I think yanbu. It was awful of her to manipulate you in that way and I'm not surprised you haven't forgiven her.

alongcameboo · 19/10/2023 13:02

Whilst it must have been so frustrating and annoying for her to back out at the last minute, it was ultimately your choice to buy the house you currently live in, so I don't think you can blame your Mum for your financial situation now (although I understand why you may feel resentful).

These other family members; do they know about your 'complex relationship' with your Mum? Are they likely to believe her? And what do their opinions mean to you? Why are you so bothered by what they think of you? Are you able to set the record straight with any of the family members?

MatildaTheCat · 19/10/2023 13:00

@HilaryWank the OP is very clearly explained. No need for your insults. In no way does OP sound ‘grabby’. Just disappointed and let down. And now broke.

@kindredsp if you can manage a move financially I’d think about it even if it’s a few years down the line. Now ( in my area anyway) is a very bad time to sell unless you can buy at a similar discount.

I would personally keep your mother at very low contact. If something terrible happened to her would you really not want to know/ visit? By remaining at distance you keep the moral high ground. She has treated you badly but probably few others would truly see that and you’ll be judged.

I hope things improve for you.

BoohooWoohoo · 19/10/2023 12:57

Yanbu

Use this opportunity to save money and finally be free of her shit.

cartagenagina · 19/10/2023 12:55

You have posted about this situation before I think?

YANBU. Just move and get on with your lives.

HilaryWank · 19/10/2023 12:53

So you're not talking to your mum because she offered to give you £150K, then you proceeded to make a financial decision based on having that £150K, then she decided not to spend her money in that way, but you proceeded with that financial decision despite being £150K in cash worse off?

YABU and grabby.

hotcandle · 19/10/2023 12:52

Your mother didn't make you buy the house. YOU were emotionally invested, and you persuaded your husband to go along with the purchase. You have ample time to change your mind.

You can go no contact with your mother for whatever reason you like. She sounds like a pain. So I wouldn't blame you.

BrownTableMat · 19/10/2023 12:49

On the information being presented here, YABU. You didn’t have to buy the house after she withdrew the offer, and you could still sell up and move somewhere cheaper.

CICTGIGF · 19/10/2023 12:48

I can understand the disappointment you felt when she withdrew the financial help with buying your house. You would have been well within your rights to complain about that.
But if I’m reading it correctly you chose to buy the property anyway without the support and are now blaming her for your decision to do that. You could have chosen to pull out of that house and carried out your original plan of moving away. You can’t blame her for your choices.

yogasaurus · 19/10/2023 12:48

Sell the house and move as PP said. And she didn’t make you buy it, you made that decision yourselves.

Bivarb · 19/10/2023 12:46

Can you put the house up for sale and move somewhere cheaper? The house isn't worth the financial strain, marriage problems and not seeing your children. Have you looked into this?