Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go no contact with my mum?

64 replies

kindredsp · 19/10/2023 12:41

I’ve not spoken to my mother for several months now and haven’t responded to a couple of texts and emails she’s sent since. The last time I spoke to her, I told her I wanted some space from her and to leave me be, with a very clear explanation as to why. I have since heard through other family members that she’s saying that I’m blanking her, that I’m denying her access to her grandchildren and that I have insulted her, and quite frankly I’m pissed.
Our relationship is very complex and I won’t bore you with too many details. But the straw that broke the camels back was when we decided to move away to a cheaper part of the country to gain some financial stability with a small mortgage (first time buyers with a limited deposit).
She then offered us 150k so we could stay local to her and still have a small mortgage. We said no originally as there’s always a condition or catch to her “help”, but eventually she wore me down and I accepted.
We house hunted, put an offer in for an incredible house, and had it accepted. The dream of living in an area we loved in a house we loved really was intoxicating.
Then she withdrew her offer. No real reason was given, other than that she couldn’t access that kind of money (she obviously originally said it was easy for her to access). I was so emotionally invested in the move that I persuaded my husband to go ahead with the purchase anyway despite it totally maxing ourselves out affordability wise. So we moved.
We’ve lived in our house for 5 years and money has been horribly tight. We love the area and the house, but we’ve literally lived month by month saving nothing. We have no money to live, just meet the basics. It is not the financial stability we were looking for. Add a pandemic, cost of living crisis and now the end of our fixed rate, we’re tighter than ever before.
We work our arses off and we’re missing everything. We can’t live, we can’t enjoy ourselves, we hardly see our children. It’s miserable and so stressful and the whole situation has put a huge strain on our marriage.
My mother breezes in and out with zero remorse for what happened. As far as she can see, we’re close by with a roof over our head so what’s the big deal. The last conversation I had with her was just as we were remortgaging and coming to terms with our monthly rate going up by a few hundred pounds. I said that if she’d let us make our own decisions we’d be in a financially stable position now and able to ride the spiralling expenses much better. She said she was only trying to help and had no idea it had put us under financial stress. She said we shouldn’t have bought the house if we couldn’t afford it.
Hindsight is a wonderful thing, especially when you remove emotion from it. If I could go back I would have absolutely not bought our house. I would have reverted to the original plan. But at the time house prices were shooting up, we’d wasted 6 months on a fools errand and were about to be at a point where moving elsewhere wouldn’t have been the financial break we’d hoped for anyway and we’d still be stuck in rental today most likely.
But here we are. She hasn’t apologised for what she did. In fact, she said she couldn’t even remember how much she’d promised us. It feels like it was just a tactic to stop us from moving away so she could still see her grandchildren rather than allow us the freedom to make our own decisions.
I felt proud of myself for finally speaking up about it and her response also made me realise that I don’t want her in our lives. But now she’s telling everyone that I’ve insulted her (I haven’t), but I have stopped her seeing the grandchildren because I’m not seeing her myself and I am ignoring her messages because I asked for space the last time we spoke. So am I the AH?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mumoftwinsandasingleton · 16/03/2024 23:40

Your mother clearly lied and tried to keep you in the area despite not having that kind of money. Maybe she didn't think you'd fall for it so she quickly backed out just before you sealed the deal. That was your opportunity to quickly pull out of the deal. However, even if I had pulled out, I would still have been really disappointed with her and would not be able to trust her again

Whatthefrance2024 · 15/03/2024 14:08

Its disappointing that it fell through but you can’t blame her for your choices. Sell up

Pollyanna31 · 20/01/2024 20:28

She sounds like a narc your mother saying she could help then she can't and then she couldn't remember but she didn't give you anything at all. I understand why you still made the move due to this situation even though it's left you in this financial problems. You and your hubby will need to think about what's best for you and yours

Appleofmyeye2023 · 20/10/2023 00:03

SatsumaNightmare · 19/10/2023 23:31

Ah, so you’re a parent a child went no contact with. Makes so much more sense now.

🤣🤣🤣meow!

AllyArty · 19/10/2023 23:46

Do u think she is going to change? I suspect not from what you say. I’d sell up. Your children want happy parents and this situation you find yourself in seems to have made you very unhappy.

SatsumaNightmare · 19/10/2023 23:39

Cumbrianlife · 19/10/2023 23:35

@SatsumaNightmare I think she means dear dad, not daughter. She is the child in her scenario.

If that’s the case, fair enough, I retract my previous statement and apologise. However, I stand by what I said previously. It’s nobody else’s place to tell OP whether she should or shouldn’t be going NC. Her situation is unique to her, and I feel it’s deeply problematic to make sweeping statements about ‘family.’

Cumbrianlife · 19/10/2023 23:35

@SatsumaNightmare I think she means dear dad, not daughter. She is the child in her scenario.

SatsumaNightmare · 19/10/2023 23:31

Appleofmyeye2023 · 19/10/2023 23:22

Nope, not at all Hollywood or good intention on both parties.
my dd went NC with me for years. It was resolved after 10 years. It caused me huge mental health issue, him less so but nonethe less his actions in NCing me did not make him happy or move on. Sadly his rage at me was displaced rage for my mother who was dead.

I learnt techniques of crucial conversation through work, then determined to use it to repair my relationship..it was bloody hard work, over a few years to build back trust. But we did it mostly, and learnt a lot about who we really were along the way.
sadly he now has dementia, I am glad we made peace with each other

I also left an abusive ex. Used methods to achieve divorce amicably and cheaply.

We all have crosses to bear- you are very naive if you think people get through life without immense struggles. . NC makes the crosses that much harder to drag around on our backs. In some cases it will be best in end to NC, but it seems that in some cases, like the Op, she is searching for solutions or she wouldn’t post, and it’s very clear they both have their own differing narrative on what happened.

Ah, so you’re a parent a child went no contact with. Makes so much more sense now.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 19/10/2023 23:22

SatsumaNightmare · 19/10/2023 20:11

I think it’s disgusting that so many posters are coming in here and telling the OP (and others, by extension) that going NC is petulant or wrong. You don’t know the intricacies of what OP (or others) have had to deal with, often for prolonged periods of time. The majority of your ‘solutions’ work on the assumption the family member is willing to be honest, open, take responsibility, and has good intentions. In what Hollywood movie do you live that you think everyone is lucky enough to be in such situations to enable reasonable resolution?

OP, I’m sorry about what you’ve dealt with. You know you shouldn’t have bought the house and you know why, and I think the best takeaway you can have from this is working on your own self-esteem and your own boundaries. You have a right to live your life the way you want to. I would strongly suggest counselling to help you work through the issues.

Nope, not at all Hollywood or good intention on both parties.
my dd went NC with me for years. It was resolved after 10 years. It caused me huge mental health issue, him less so but nonethe less his actions in NCing me did not make him happy or move on. Sadly his rage at me was displaced rage for my mother who was dead.

I learnt techniques of crucial conversation through work, then determined to use it to repair my relationship..it was bloody hard work, over a few years to build back trust. But we did it mostly, and learnt a lot about who we really were along the way.
sadly he now has dementia, I am glad we made peace with each other

I also left an abusive ex. Used methods to achieve divorce amicably and cheaply.

We all have crosses to bear- you are very naive if you think people get through life without immense struggles. . NC makes the crosses that much harder to drag around on our backs. In some cases it will be best in end to NC, but it seems that in some cases, like the Op, she is searching for solutions or she wouldn’t post, and it’s very clear they both have their own differing narrative on what happened.

howdoesyourgardengrowinmay · 19/10/2023 21:23

Put the house on the market, don't tell your mother so she doesn't have a chance to manipulate you to stay. Move far away and enjoy the rest of your life

Fab973 · 19/10/2023 21:14

@yogasaurus Where did you pluck this information from?

SpatulaSpatula · 19/10/2023 20:49

Your mum is a dick. She knew exactly what she was doing and you fell for it because that's how you keep her happy.

Move away from this toxic relationship and start enjoying your lives. You can't control what she says about you but you can stop letting it control what you do.

If the move means you can have more time with your family then I think it's a no-brainer.

Startingagainandagain · 19/10/2023 20:37

Your mother behaved really poorly by pretending to have access to money and offering it to you in order to convince you not to move.

It sounds like she purposely wanted you to get invested into a local property knowing fully that she would never be able to help you purchase it but hoping that you would still go ahead with buying the house.

It is incredibly manipulative of her and you will never be able to trust her again.

Yes, you and your husband decided to buy the property regardless, but that does not change the fact that your mother behaved appallingly.

As suggested by others, consider selling this house and moving away as you initially planned and put some distance between yourself and your mother.

Butchyrestingface · 19/10/2023 20:30

How do your kids feel about not seeing your mother, @kindredsp ? Do they miss her or not bothered?

As everyone has said, sell up and get on with your life. You may feel differently towards your mother once you're no longer living hand to mouth (equally you may not). But don't let her influence any of your future decisions.

Stomacharmeleon · 19/10/2023 20:21

@kindredsp I am in a similar situation except she did give me the money.... was for a house alteration. She then changed her mind and sued me for it back.

I haven't seen her or spoken to her in nearly a decade. It has caused irreparable damage to both our and my siblings relationship with me and I have had to go through trauma counselling to feel 'normal' again. It was the straw that broke a rather big fat camels back.

Move. Cut contact. Have peace of mind.

SatsumaNightmare · 19/10/2023 20:11

I think it’s disgusting that so many posters are coming in here and telling the OP (and others, by extension) that going NC is petulant or wrong. You don’t know the intricacies of what OP (or others) have had to deal with, often for prolonged periods of time. The majority of your ‘solutions’ work on the assumption the family member is willing to be honest, open, take responsibility, and has good intentions. In what Hollywood movie do you live that you think everyone is lucky enough to be in such situations to enable reasonable resolution?

OP, I’m sorry about what you’ve dealt with. You know you shouldn’t have bought the house and you know why, and I think the best takeaway you can have from this is working on your own self-esteem and your own boundaries. You have a right to live your life the way you want to. I would strongly suggest counselling to help you work through the issues.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 19/10/2023 19:53

yogasaurus · 19/10/2023 13:11

One of the OP’s other threads is them asking if they should make an official complaint about their GP not recommending an abortion back when they were mid twenties, as by then their DC was then 11/12 and they’d found it very difficult financially over the years.

A pattern of lack of accountability emerges, tbh.

That’s interesting.

But then a root cause of an inability to take responsibility can be overbearing parent(s), so I guess it fits in.

I think both YANBU and YABU - yes she was horribly manipulative at the time, and probably never intended to give you the money. But you needed to take the decision either never to accept the money (knowing what she was like), or to pull out when it transpired you weren’t going to be getting it.

I still think you would probably be wise to sell up and move now though, if you’re that miserable.

pikkumyy77 · 19/10/2023 19:49

You can’t have a productive conversation with some people. The posters who think so just have no experience of manipulative or abusive people. The minimum safe distance is ver far.

kindredsp · 19/10/2023 19:45

I’ve not gone into detail here. I could write a novel, but emotionally abusive and controlling is absolutely on the table.

OP posts:
wildnightswildnights · 19/10/2023 19:42

@Appleofmyeye2023

Apple is spot on.

The whole 'NC' thing is often petulant and rash. We live in families and communities and we need to learn to be solution- focused and communicate with difficult people, especially family.

Unless they are violent, cruel or abusive these relationships are important and worth preserving. From what I can glean from your predicament it does not seem fair to cut your mum off.

Hugosauras · 19/10/2023 19:25

@Appleofmyeye2023

How refreshing to see some decent calm and rational advice here!! It is very hard working through difficult situations. We're not shown or taught how to do it or manage relationships. It's even harder if we've not been modelled it by our parents. But it can be taught. There are lots of brilliant resources online with advice on how to reconnect with family and whether going NC is the right decision.

potatoheads · 19/10/2023 19:19

HilaryWank · 19/10/2023 12:53

So you're not talking to your mum because she offered to give you £150K, then you proceeded to make a financial decision based on having that £150K, then she decided not to spend her money in that way, but you proceeded with that financial decision despite being £150K in cash worse off?

YABU and grabby.

So you don't think the mother has in any way behaved badly?

Hugosauras · 19/10/2023 19:12

You make it sound as though she deliberately lied to you out of spite and control. Of course she wanted you close by. She loves you and she loves her children. Perhaps she got carried away, thought she might be able to access money and made a promise in the heat of the moment that she couldn't keep. Ultimately you decided to buy that house. It's only now that you're struggling due to remortgaging and interest rates going up that you feel resentment. It was your decision.

You going NC is, quite frankly, a cruel way to punish her. Of course, you will receive support from all those MNetters who have also gone NC with parents (some justified and most down to their inability to work through difficult situations and politely draw a few respectful boundaries). I come from a very difficult family where there has been a lot of trauma through several generations. My mother is not easy, but I would never dream of going NC with her. My sister cut herself off from the entire family (due to mental health and addiction problems) and it is unbelievably hard for us all to bear. We miss her immeasurably. My sister is terminally ill now as is my father. We most likely won't be together again. I cannot tell you what this has done to my mother.

I am absolutely determined to set a better example for my children. I tell them when I believe that she has acted unreasonably and I will call her out on her behaviour. But I also show my children how to not escalate arguments and teach them how sometimes people act in hurtful ways even if that was not their intention. I teach them that it's ok to be pissed off with people, but how to calm down and move forward without stewing on it. If I went NC, I would risk them seeing this as a way to manage relationships and to run away from problems. And they might well turn around and do the same to me one day. We reap what we sow. Family is family and going NC rarely results in greater happiness/peace of mind (it does for some bit generally doesn't). Honestly OP, I know that you won't like what I have said, but it comes from a good place. Life really is too short to carry so much angst. It's far better to resolve things where at all possible and move on.

Goodornot · 19/10/2023 18:26

kindredsp · 19/10/2023 17:42

I do 100% take responsibility for ploughing ahead. My issue is that when I raised what happened with her, there was no remorse for doing what she did which was why I sought the break. That in itself wouldn’t be an issue if it was an isolated incident. I would have gotten over it. But as you suggest, this is the last thing in a long line of problems. Incidentally, I’ve not mentioned to the children that I’m not talking to grandma right now. We had to block her on my son’s phone (he’s now a teenager) for emotionally manipulative texts she would send him and made him feel very uncomfortable. But neither child has asked where she is or when we are seeing her next as they have done and do with other family members. I find that quite interesting…

I'd you 100% accept responsibility for doing it anyway why do you expect remorse from your mum?

kindredsp · 19/10/2023 17:42

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 19/10/2023 17:17

It was incredibly manipulative and selfish of her to do that to you. However you actively chose to go ahead with a house that sounds like it was significantly outside budget and that isn't her fault, you could have moved anyway. So it's fine to blame her for her shitty behaviour and if you can't forgive her for that then that's fine. But I don't think you can forgive her for any of the subsequent financial strain, I'm afraid that's on you. I'm guessing that there is a history of this behaviour rather than a complete one off because she was desperate to stay close to her grandchild. If so then yanbu to have had enough of it. If not then I think stopping the grandparent and grandchild contact because of one incident between parent and grandparent does sound a bit extreme

I do 100% take responsibility for ploughing ahead. My issue is that when I raised what happened with her, there was no remorse for doing what she did which was why I sought the break. That in itself wouldn’t be an issue if it was an isolated incident. I would have gotten over it. But as you suggest, this is the last thing in a long line of problems. Incidentally, I’ve not mentioned to the children that I’m not talking to grandma right now. We had to block her on my son’s phone (he’s now a teenager) for emotionally manipulative texts she would send him and made him feel very uncomfortable. But neither child has asked where she is or when we are seeing her next as they have done and do with other family members. I find that quite interesting…

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread