Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He will go to the police? Would they take this seriously?

217 replies

ThanksDep · 19/10/2023 12:36

I recently asked ex to contribute to our daughter’s nursery fees. He pays maintenance through cms but it covers a fraction of it and obviously there are everyday costs too for her that I shoulder.

I asked him politely and referenced another couple that we both know are separated and they divide all cost fairly and not just 12 % cms which is a minimum. He has responded to say he won’t be paying more and if he finds out I have told people what he is and isn’t paying that he will go to the police and log it as harassment. I haven’t actually said I would do that but I suppose I have implied it by referring to another couple we both know and to be honest I think I would be transparent about it as it’s having a hugely detrimental impact on my life. I have a decent job but I am in debt each month by a small amount because the nursery is so expensive. There is nowhere cheaper in the area either. It’s average UK price for nursery.

I feel weird that he has suddenly said this? Would the police take this seriously? My post probably sounds like I am guilty of something but I am just very anxious (as he knows) and what he has said has upset me on top of all the struggles he has caused. He refuses to see Dd so I don’t get any input from him with anything practically either.

OP posts:
WellIdontknowwhattocallmyself · 19/10/2023 15:58

i had a break in by a drug addict and the police didn’t do anything about him so I highly doubt they’d do something about this in fact they’d have a dim view of him paying so little towards his own child they’ll probably tell him to get lost

Fusterclucked · 19/10/2023 15:58

Think about it - what could the police charge you with? Telling the truth?

NalafromtheLionKing · 19/10/2023 15:53

Not harassment and not slander (as totally true).

sandyhappypeople · 19/10/2023 15:52

Is the calculation correct OP? It seems quite low compared to his income, does he have other children?

WowOK · 19/10/2023 15:52

Have you gone through CM? £430 when he is on a £65K seems on the low side.

thelonemommabear · 19/10/2023 15:52

I'd call his bluff and take out a full page ad in the paper and drop it into every conversation on social media oh and probably hire one of those planes that can write it in the sky 😂

But on a serious note there is literally nothing you can do. My ex pays £300 a month for our 3 children. Two of whom are twins - the childcare bill for them alone is £2k 😳

housethatbuiltme · 19/10/2023 15:45

I maybe petty but I would tell EVERYONE who would have reason to have it pop up in conversation (like the couple you mention where you talk about a similar life scenario).

His embarrassment at being a shit dad is entirely his own problem... as long as you are only telling the truth then theres nothing anyone can do to silence you.

Maybe he will actually pay for his child after he sees the backlash from others thinking less of him.

itsgettingweird · 19/10/2023 15:44

"How is asking other couples what they do re child payments harassment? Also if you are happy with what you are doing and think you're right why do you care what others do or their opinion?"

I'd send this.

We'll probably actually best not to respond but it would be interesting to hear how he thinks it's harassment!

LakieLady · 19/10/2023 15:43

Peanuts2000 · 19/10/2023 15:17

I find it really sad reading on here about all these ar$eholes who refuse to pay for THEIR children or only the bare minimum and refuse to see them. They should be getting hounded by CMS to pay up.
OP I agree with others that I would be telling everyone he doesn't see his child and pays bare minimum for them despite earning a good wage.
Communicate only by text or email. If he thinks you are harassing him or has cause for slander, let him complain to police or take you to court. Don't think he will get anywhere as everything is true.

I don't find it sad at all, it gives me the absolute rage. Women make up 90% of single parents, get paid less, on average, than men, have their careers impacted by having children, and have to fight tooth and nail to get a fair contribution from the fathers.

My DSS is in a well-paid trade, is undoubtedly earning good money (someone else I know in the same line of work is on over £40k), rents out his house while living rent-free with his mother and a few months ago cut the money he pays to his ex from £200 a month to £100 a month. Apparently, he thinks that's more than enough because young kids don't eat much!

Quite apart from the fact that DGD needs clothes and loads of other stuff, not just food, he's completely overlooked the fact that her mother is having to pay £1,300 a month rent for a 2-bed flat and if she was child-free she could rent a room in a house share for £100 pw.

If his father was still alive, he would have gone bloody ballistic. He was angry enough when they split up and DSS stayed in the nice 3-bed house in a good area while the mother of his grandchild could only afford the rent on a flat above a shop on a busy main road.

Men get away with it time and time again and the CMS are useless. And even if they weren't, the amount absent fathers have to pay is absurdly low.

Theunamedcat · 19/10/2023 15:38

Does he take advantage of any day when they are in childcare? I would confirm what hecssid back in writing and tell him you will no longer be paying for childcare on his days

StoneWashJeansWithAMatchingJacket · 19/10/2023 15:34

Legally he doesn’t have to pay any more child support than the minimum. But if he can afford to he absolutely should, I think any decent person would agree…

I assume from his fucking ridiculous threat that he is a control freak and a bully. Don’t let him to scare you with a visit from the police. I highly doubt they will entertain his ridiculous behaviour and if anything, it would make him look worse. You haven’t harassed him at all by the sound of it.

You can talk to whoever you like about this but in my experience choose your audience wisely.

WhycantIkeepthisbloodyplantalive · 19/10/2023 15:34

Does he have her overnight? Any way you could split the time so he has to cover nursery fees on his time?

Radiodread · 19/10/2023 15:30

Read up on grey rock method.
you can listen to all threats and not respond, it’s so liberating.

Thing is, as your child grows up, she will know you are her and acted in her best interests. Him, not so much.

I wouldn’t be hiding the lack of financial support from anyone. Sunlight is the best disinfectant

Appleofmyeye2023 · 19/10/2023 15:29

He’s just threatening you in same way as powerful men shut their victims up with non disclosure orders for compensation.
don’t dance to his tune
he is , by this statement, admitting he’s not doing anything other than basic necessities towards his own children and he’s not entirely guilt free in that, . He is afraid he’ll be judged by someone, who is still important to him (eg these friends, his parents, others?) so wants you to keep it secret. Not your circus….

the bottom line is this is your/your children’s money (once paid), therefore your finances. You can tell who you want about your financial situation and where your/ your kids money comes from. As long as you keep to facts, don’t slander and don’t indulge in emails ,social media, calls with him, threaten or abuse.

so only communicate through letter and solicitors /mediators, keep everything in writing. Keep a diary of when you see him and what was said.

And give yourself confidence that he’s bluffing by reading law on harassment
“Protection from harassment 1997” . here’s a good link to what would pass the bar of an actual charge for harassment . https://www.carruthers-law.co.uk/articles/the-protection-from-harassment-act-1997/
but simply put needs a series of incidents in which “Harassment is a persistent and deliberate course of unacceptable and oppressive conduct, targeted at another person, which is calculated to and does cause that person alarm, fear or distress.”

maybe if he tries threatening agin, have a card (ready prepared) with reference to this definition and the act written out and ask him sweetly for help in understanding what you’re doing that breaks this law?

Carruthers Law | The Protection from Harassment Act 1997

The Protection from Harassment Act 1997 provides protection from harassment in disputes such as stalking, bullying at work, protection from the media, libel disputes.

https://www.carruthers-law.co.uk/articles/the-protection-from-harassment-act-1997/

SerafinasGoose · 19/10/2023 15:28

Ha ha! What a blithering eejit.

jlpth · 19/10/2023 15:27

Get a diary that is only goign to be used for recording shit encountered with him

record all interactions in the diary
print screen snaps of his messages and stick in diary

rhen you have evidence of all communications

so today, you would write that at 11am or whatever, you phoned to ask about a contribution to nursery fees and he threatened police for harassment.

if he does accuse you, you have all the records

Passepartoute · 19/10/2023 15:24

Presumably he thinks he is doing nothing wrong, or would at least claim that he is doing nothing wrong. So you should ask him, if he is so totally in the right, why is he so worried about people that he knows getting the facts about him? After all, he can totally justify everything, surely?

Hibiscrubbed · 19/10/2023 15:21

ThanksDep · 19/10/2023 14:49

Thanks, I’m too weary of him to cause any further issue to be honest. Just wish he was a better man. My own fault, I chose a bad’un!

In which case, you’re inadvertently protecting him.

Emotionalsupportviper · 19/10/2023 15:18

MamaBear2210T · 19/10/2023 12:37

The police would just laugh at this. It's not harassment.

They certainly would!

Blimey - you can't get them out to an assault these days, never mind a "my ex-wife has said nasty things about me to her friend."

It isn't even slanderous because it's true.

Peanuts2000 · 19/10/2023 15:17

I find it really sad reading on here about all these ar$eholes who refuse to pay for THEIR children or only the bare minimum and refuse to see them. They should be getting hounded by CMS to pay up.
OP I agree with others that I would be telling everyone he doesn't see his child and pays bare minimum for them despite earning a good wage.
Communicate only by text or email. If he thinks you are harassing him or has cause for slander, let him complain to police or take you to court. Don't think he will get anywhere as everything is true.

54isanopendoor · 19/10/2023 15:16

mewkins · 19/10/2023 12:43

It's not harassment and you're not even slandering him if it's true.

This.
I found my exH was happy to not pay CMS.
Less happy if I told other people about it.
Crappy behaviour to use your anxiety against you too.
Dont give him another moments thought! (easier said than done I know).
There is no way he would go to the Police as he knows he's a sad little man.
They'd laugh at him anyway.

Nicole1111 · 19/10/2023 15:15

The police would laugh him out the door. Don’t let his attempts to control and manipulate you even when you’re not in a relationship work.

TheyAlwaysWin · 19/10/2023 15:15

It is an empty threat meant to intimidate you. Do whatever is best for you and your DD. If that includes speaking to friends about your situation, you are free to do that.

What a dick.

horseyhorsey17 · 19/10/2023 15:15

He's a massive prick, no wonder you're not with him. But no, there's no chance of him either going to the police or them taking it seriously. Just another chancer trying to dodge paying what he should be paying towards his child. Bellend.

Notmetoo · 19/10/2023 15:13

The police won't do anything. You haven't done anything wrong. He is being ridiculous and sounds like a bully.