Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He will go to the police? Would they take this seriously?

217 replies

ThanksDep · 19/10/2023 12:36

I recently asked ex to contribute to our daughter’s nursery fees. He pays maintenance through cms but it covers a fraction of it and obviously there are everyday costs too for her that I shoulder.

I asked him politely and referenced another couple that we both know are separated and they divide all cost fairly and not just 12 % cms which is a minimum. He has responded to say he won’t be paying more and if he finds out I have told people what he is and isn’t paying that he will go to the police and log it as harassment. I haven’t actually said I would do that but I suppose I have implied it by referring to another couple we both know and to be honest I think I would be transparent about it as it’s having a hugely detrimental impact on my life. I have a decent job but I am in debt each month by a small amount because the nursery is so expensive. There is nowhere cheaper in the area either. It’s average UK price for nursery.

I feel weird that he has suddenly said this? Would the police take this seriously? My post probably sounds like I am guilty of something but I am just very anxious (as he knows) and what he has said has upset me on top of all the struggles he has caused. He refuses to see Dd so I don’t get any input from him with anything practically either.

OP posts:
hwaclanhdead · 19/10/2023 16:50

Ignore the bullshit about the police. I'd like to bet he won't go. On the off chance he does they will ignore it - it's not harrassment, even if you were telling people.

Contact CMS and ask them to look into it again. 430 seems low.

Be very glad you are shot of this asshole.

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 19/10/2023 16:44

ThanksDep · Today 16:25

“I’m not sure why it’s 430 as he only has DD (that I know of anyway!!). I don’t think I’m entitled to anything by way of support, I earn 38k but the nursery fees are a massive struggle.”

Also make a UC application now.

Reugny · 19/10/2023 16:43

ThanksDep · 19/10/2023 16:25

I’m not sure why it’s 430 as he only has DD (that I know of anyway!!). I don’t think I’m entitled to anything by way of support, I earn 38k but the nursery fees are a massive struggle.

Get CMS to reassess.

If it is still correct tell him in writing you would like your DD to know her half-sibling(s).

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 19/10/2023 16:42

I’m not sure why it’s 430 as he only has DD (that I know of anyway!!). I don’t think I’m entitled to anything by way of support, I earn 38k but the nursery fees are a massive struggle.

It doesn’t matter what you earn. Is he PAYE or self employed?

ThanksDep · 19/10/2023 16:42

@Cakeandcoffee93 i didn’t think I was eligible?

OP posts:
Cakeandcoffee93 · 19/10/2023 16:40

Why aren’t you claiming fees paid 85%

dancingorange · 19/10/2023 16:39

No he can't. He's scaring you because he embarrassed that he's a deadbeat father

Startyabastard · 19/10/2023 16:38

He's a twat, he just doesn't want people knowing he is one by not contributing.

Angelsrose · 19/10/2023 16:28

I'm sorry op, this is a very upsetting situation. Of course the police would have zero interest in what your ex has to say and you have committed no crime. Please do not worry. Abusive men do take advantage of many women's anxieties. I am sorry your ex has abandoned your dd but if that is the case there is probably no need to have any contact with him. Hopefully, the money you receive for your daughter will still arrive automatically without the need for further interaction with your ex. There is no point in trying to persuade selfish people to be reasonable, it will adversely affect your mental health trying to do so and you won't get any further.

ThanksDep · 19/10/2023 16:25

I’m not sure why it’s 430 as he only has DD (that I know of anyway!!). I don’t think I’m entitled to anything by way of support, I earn 38k but the nursery fees are a massive struggle.

OP posts:
LeefsPrings · 19/10/2023 16:21

Things you say about someone are not slander or libel if they are the truth.

In any case, how would you be harassing him by talking to other people? Seems to me that he is trying to prevent you from letting other people know what a bastard he is. Which proves that he knows that he is one.

Theemeperorsnewclothes · 19/10/2023 16:19

ThanksDep · Today 12:36
“I recently asked ex to contribute to our daughter’s nursery fees. He pays maintenance through cms but it covers a fraction of it and obviously there are everyday costs too for her that I shoulder.

I asked him politely and referenced another couple that we both know are separated and they divide all cost fairly and not just 12 % cms which is a minimum. He has responded to say he won’t be paying more and if he finds out I have told people what he is and isn’t paying that he will go to the police and log it as harassment. I haven’t actually said I would do that but I suppose I have implied it by referring to another couple we both know and to be honest I think I would be transparent about it as it’s having a hugely detrimental impact on my life. I have a decent job but I am in debt each month by a small amount because the nursery is so expensive. There is nowhere cheaper in the area either. It’s average UK price for nursery.

I feel weird that he has suddenly said this? Would the police take this seriously? My post probably sounds like I am guilty of something but I am just very anxious (as he knows) and what he has said has upset me on top of all the struggles he has caused. He refuses to see Dd so I don’t get any input from him with anything practically either.”

Is he self employed or a Ltd Company Director? It might be that he’s worried that you might actually get the child maintenance that your child is entitled to? If you know how to navigate the system. This is standard abuse. Very difficult when you are in the middle of it. He is an abuser. Contact Women’s Aid for counselling.

Reugny · 19/10/2023 16:15

Tlolljs · 19/10/2023 16:09

I expect he’s told people he’s paying loads. He doesn’t want you telling them he pays the basic amount.

The OP doesn't even have to say how much he does pay or when he see their DD.

She just needs to say what she exactly pays for in regards to her financial contribution to their DD. She can also say how often she has her daughter e.g. 24/7 outside nursery.

TheFormidableMrsC · 19/10/2023 16:14

What a twat! He's probably lied to everybody about how much he supports you and your child and doesn't want anybody to find out the truth. On that basis, I'd tell absolutely everybody and let the police laugh at him. Some men are such cunts.

Gettingbysomehow · 19/10/2023 16:10

Haha what a jerk. He doesn't want anyone to know what a piece of shit he is.
He knows full well the police can't arrest you for this.
Maybe a full page ad in the papers might be harrassment or going about town with a banner.

Peanuts2000 · 19/10/2023 16:10

LakieLady · 19/10/2023 15:43

I don't find it sad at all, it gives me the absolute rage. Women make up 90% of single parents, get paid less, on average, than men, have their careers impacted by having children, and have to fight tooth and nail to get a fair contribution from the fathers.

My DSS is in a well-paid trade, is undoubtedly earning good money (someone else I know in the same line of work is on over £40k), rents out his house while living rent-free with his mother and a few months ago cut the money he pays to his ex from £200 a month to £100 a month. Apparently, he thinks that's more than enough because young kids don't eat much!

Quite apart from the fact that DGD needs clothes and loads of other stuff, not just food, he's completely overlooked the fact that her mother is having to pay £1,300 a month rent for a 2-bed flat and if she was child-free she could rent a room in a house share for £100 pw.

If his father was still alive, he would have gone bloody ballistic. He was angry enough when they split up and DSS stayed in the nice 3-bed house in a good area while the mother of his grandchild could only afford the rent on a flat above a shop on a busy main road.

Men get away with it time and time again and the CMS are useless. And even if they weren't, the amount absent fathers have to pay is absurdly low.

You are absolutely right, it's an absolute disgrace so many women are put in this position. Thankfully I wasn't but it's usually the mother and children who will suffer.
I'm sorry this is happening in your family, £100/month is nothing. How your DSS and his mother can sleep at night I don't know but money can have that effect on people. Unfortunately many (usually) men use money to control the women, they see that as "getting back at them'.

Tlolljs · 19/10/2023 16:09

I expect he’s told people he’s paying loads. He doesn’t want you telling them he pays the basic amount.

FartSock5000 · 19/10/2023 16:08

@ThanksDep you can ask CS to review how much he is paying.

Don't take legal advice from him and don't hide what a garbage person he is.

He is choosing to ignore DD and not pay a fair sum to support her. He's paying the bare minimum and nothing else. He knows that and doesn't care because he is a shit person and he enjoys watching you squirm.

Remember, it's only slander or defamation if what you say is untrue or cannot be proven. Telling everyone that he doesn't see her and pays minimum amount is the truth and he doesn't have a leg to stand on.

Reugny · 19/10/2023 16:08

Ejismyf · 19/10/2023 16:06

Was it you who posted wanting more money recently than the 2k a month you get and were going to go to the papers about it and earn a really good wage too?

If you follow the OP's posts you would see she gets far less than that.

ProfSleepzz · 19/10/2023 16:08

He sounds very similar to my ex. My ex’s friends were willingly talking to me of their own volition because they thought he was being a shit. He sent me a cease and desist letter via his solicitor. My solicitor fired a response back explaining that his friends were willingly contacting me and if they asked me to stop contacting them, of course I would but he couldn’t control who spoke to me. He shut up after that. The whole thing made me feel like a criminal though so I totally get how you feel. My ex is a scumbag, sounds like yours is too. Sadly, while he pays the minimum, there’s nothing you can do but I’m sending a big hug. You are wonderful and doing everything for your daughter. Try to take solace in that. He doesn’t want people to know he’s a shit. Tough luck. Maybe he should just try not being a shit if that’s the case. The nursery years are tough but I just survived them financially, although I did have to take on a second job.

Feraldogmum · 19/10/2023 16:08

He's a thug. If you're not lying you can tell whoever you like what he pays,its your finances. If I had proof of his threats ( were they texts) I'd be inclined to report him to the police.

Ejismyf · 19/10/2023 16:06

Was it you who posted wanting more money recently than the 2k a month you get and were going to go to the papers about it and earn a really good wage too?

tabulaisrasa · 19/10/2023 16:05

It's not harrassment, and in your shoes I'd be tempted to tell everybody he doesn't bother paying for his daughter above what he is legally obliged to pay. What a twat.

mathanxiety · 19/10/2023 16:01

It's actually his attempt to control you by threatening police involvement that is harassment.

Go ahead and talk to anyone you want to about this turd's approach to being a parent.

The only person you can't mention any of this to is your child.

If you want a revised financial arrangement, you could take him to family court.

Honeybee798 · 19/10/2023 15:58

I doubt you’re the type but perhaps you should just tell him to go ahead if that’s what he thinks is necessary. They wouldn’t care - they barely care about actual real crimes!