Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He will go to the police? Would they take this seriously?

217 replies

ThanksDep · 19/10/2023 12:36

I recently asked ex to contribute to our daughter’s nursery fees. He pays maintenance through cms but it covers a fraction of it and obviously there are everyday costs too for her that I shoulder.

I asked him politely and referenced another couple that we both know are separated and they divide all cost fairly and not just 12 % cms which is a minimum. He has responded to say he won’t be paying more and if he finds out I have told people what he is and isn’t paying that he will go to the police and log it as harassment. I haven’t actually said I would do that but I suppose I have implied it by referring to another couple we both know and to be honest I think I would be transparent about it as it’s having a hugely detrimental impact on my life. I have a decent job but I am in debt each month by a small amount because the nursery is so expensive. There is nowhere cheaper in the area either. It’s average UK price for nursery.

I feel weird that he has suddenly said this? Would the police take this seriously? My post probably sounds like I am guilty of something but I am just very anxious (as he knows) and what he has said has upset me on top of all the struggles he has caused. He refuses to see Dd so I don’t get any input from him with anything practically either.

OP posts:
Bivarb · 19/10/2023 18:14

I would post something like this on Facebook.
"Good thing I'm not easily intimidated eh? 😂
Oh and he refuses to see her at all" then the screenshot text attached.

DeeKitch · 19/10/2023 18:12

If he finds out you've told people what a tight git he is more like.

notapizzaeater · 19/10/2023 18:09

I'd def check if you can claim UC - with childcare costs losts of people who don't think they'd qualify actually do.

oksothisisusnow · 19/10/2023 18:02

Using cms calculator
If he has a 65k wage before tax and nics he should be paying you £579 a month. A bit more than the 430 he pays

Imagwine · 19/10/2023 18:02

I’d be shouting it from the rooftops.

caringcarer · 19/10/2023 17:58

ThanksDep · 19/10/2023 14:24

I just can’t believe I’m faced with a 1300 bill a month, as well as all the daily costs and all the day to day care… and he pays 430? Really? I didn’t choose this. He abandoned DD and I have been left to cope alone and nowhere is he forced to pay half her costs.

I feel for you and your DD. The law should change to make people like your ex pay half for childcare until your DC reaches school age.

Tryingmybestadhd · 19/10/2023 17:58

Go to the police to say what ? I’m a test and I can’t admit it or want others to know how crappy if a dad I am ? Ignore it and if I were you I would make sure to tell anyone you mutually know .

caringcarer · 19/10/2023 17:54

He's embarrassed because he knows he's a bastard for refusing to contribute to his DC childcare so you can work. He doesn't want his friends to know. You however can tell whoever you want the truth. If you want to tell his friends or even any of his colleagues you know you are finding it hard to afford childcare on the basic CMS calculation, what with your ex refusing to contribute towards childcare and refusing to visit your DC.

Hayliebells · 19/10/2023 17:49

No the police would not do anything, this isn't harrassment. But he very obviously doesn't want people to know that he only pays CMS. That gives you some leverage, you're within your right to tell whoever you like this information, so I'd be telling him that if he wants people to think he contributes more than just CMS, he needs to actually contribute more than just CMS....

SomethingWycked · 19/10/2023 17:49

Have you got a Tax Free Childcare account? This is a government scheme where for every £8 you put in, they put £2 in.
You can get up to £500 every 3 months (up to £2,000 a year) to help with the costs of childcare.

https://www.gov.uk/tax-free-childcare

Tax-Free Childcare

What Tax-Free Childcare is, eligibility and how to apply

https://www.gov.uk/tax-free-childcare

GabriellaMontez · 19/10/2023 17:47

He won't go to the police you know? He'd be just as embarrassed to go to them as he is of his friends finding out.

If he did, they wouldn't care.

He's just trying to frighten you. He sounds awful.

I'd tell his friends about his threat too.

Cashew22 · 19/10/2023 17:40

ThanksDep · 19/10/2023 12:36

I recently asked ex to contribute to our daughter’s nursery fees. He pays maintenance through cms but it covers a fraction of it and obviously there are everyday costs too for her that I shoulder.

I asked him politely and referenced another couple that we both know are separated and they divide all cost fairly and not just 12 % cms which is a minimum. He has responded to say he won’t be paying more and if he finds out I have told people what he is and isn’t paying that he will go to the police and log it as harassment. I haven’t actually said I would do that but I suppose I have implied it by referring to another couple we both know and to be honest I think I would be transparent about it as it’s having a hugely detrimental impact on my life. I have a decent job but I am in debt each month by a small amount because the nursery is so expensive. There is nowhere cheaper in the area either. It’s average UK price for nursery.

I feel weird that he has suddenly said this? Would the police take this seriously? My post probably sounds like I am guilty of something but I am just very anxious (as he knows) and what he has said has upset me on top of all the struggles he has caused. He refuses to see Dd so I don’t get any input from him with anything practically either.

Haven't read all the posts OP but, as others have said, this is not harassment. Harassment would be if you were phoning his work to tell them what a loser he is, waiting for him outside his house to demand money, leaving notes on his car, etc. Telling an acquaintance that their friend (your ex) isn't helping with nursery fees is just having a chat about money. It makes him look bad, but you're entitled to discuss your finances with others, including friends of your ex.

The police would tell him to get lost. But all of this is moot, because he won't go to the police. He's just using your anxiety against you to try and get you to shut up. There's no way he's going to go and humiliate himself at the police station - he's made it pretty clear that he doesn't want others to know about his own lousiness.

MyMiniMetro · 19/10/2023 17:35

Keep telling ALL his friends about what he is or isn't paying and is or isn't doing. Obviously, only in a way that doesn't make you a bore.

He's literally flagged up the best way for you to keep him in check. He is most worried about what his friends think about him, so use that to your advantage make sure they're kept fully informed.

Talking about factual elements of your life is not harassment and the police won't give a sh*t. Look at it this way, there are women who are clearly, obviously and dangerously stalked and the police don't want to know. They are not going to give two-hoots about a man whose pride has been a bit hurt 😆 Tell him that too.

DriftingDora · 19/10/2023 17:34

LadyGaGasPokerFace · 19/10/2023 12:41

Nah! I’d tell everyone. Btw, I think CMS is the absolute bare minimum and it’s lousy and doesn’t really take in the actual costs of everything. The police will be wetting themselves laughing at this knob.

He really is clutching at straws, isn't he? The police will surely tell him to go and look for one. I'd love to see him try - he'll make a complete p%&t of himself!

Pallisers · 19/10/2023 17:33

Did he send that threat by text? What a fool he is. Basically if he doesn't want people to know about it, he knows damn well that he shouldn't be doing it. He pays the bare minimum and doesn't see his child. He knows deep down what his friends would think if they knew this. So as well as acting like a fucker he doesn't want anyone to know.

Ignore the threat OP (although I'd be tempted to text back "gosh I can't believe you actually put that in writing to me!"). Also you can't get blood from a turnip - he will not pay more no matter how unfair it is. But I would certainly tell people my situation if it comes up "no her dad won't see her although I'd love him to. And he pays the bare minimum of CMS. It's tough and I am barely getting by but it is worth it for my daughter"

you are a very good mother OP.

ThanksDep · 19/10/2023 17:24

@Ejismyf who is getting 2k a month?!?

OP posts:
jannier · 19/10/2023 17:11

My answer would be...so you know you're not doing right by your child and don't want to admit it to your friends well that's on your conscience and one day your kids will realise how you chose to let them go without if I see X and the conversation turns to finances that's my choice to discuss my budget.

itsgettingweird · 19/10/2023 17:09

Ejismyf · 19/10/2023 16:06

Was it you who posted wanting more money recently than the 2k a month you get and were going to go to the papers about it and earn a really good wage too?

If you read the posts you'd know it isnt 🙄

Silvers11 · 19/10/2023 17:09

ThanksDep · 19/10/2023 16:25

I’m not sure why it’s 430 as he only has DD (that I know of anyway!!). I don’t think I’m entitled to anything by way of support, I earn 38k but the nursery fees are a massive struggle.

@ThanksDep I'm not well up on benefits, but I think you might be able to get some Universal Credit. I think you need to speak to someone ( maybe Citizen's Advice or a similar organisation and make sure that you are claiming any benefits you might qualify for. You have nothing to lose by trying?

overtaxedoverworked · 19/10/2023 17:07

@ThanksDep Harassment no, but be aware that many police 'services' are focusing all of their attention on hate crimes at present. If there is some aspect that could be used for a vexatious claim on that basis, be more careful about keeping copies of any communications.
For others who have been ill-treated by partners hiding assets or income, is it too mean to hand over a comprehensive list of the payments made by the other parent to a child when they reach 18?
I'm aware that many fathers become more interested when children are old enough to go to the pub, many then spinning yarns about being denied access and mums not passing on payments and gifts as they should.

ClawedButler · 19/10/2023 16:59

@powderherface has nailed it.

His choices are:

  1. Don't be a ballbag or
  2. Accept that everyone will soon find out that you're a ballbag
Lifeomars · 19/10/2023 16:59

Sounds like you are doing an amazing job as a mum and I am so sorry your ex is such a git. My ex paid nothing, not a penny and he was always vilely unpleasant to me as well, I put this down to his knowing deep down that he was an utter shit when it came to his responsibilities for our child. Sadly there seem to be quite a few men out there who will try any daft nonsense to evade their responsibilities and come out with nonsense to make themselves feel better

Powderherface · 19/10/2023 16:57

"He is basically saying I can’t say anything or give any impression of anything on social media etc to anyone he knows. I wouldn’t actually do this as I hate social media but it’s made me feel really uncomfortable"

He should not act in a way that he would be embarrassed for others to know about.
Or
He should only act in a way which is honorable and which he can feel comfortable with people knowing.

Can you go to the courts to get a little more from him to ensure you are not in debt

ClawedButler · 19/10/2023 16:57

I imagine his thought processes run something like this:

  • I am marvellous. I mean, I can't get over how great I am
  • I am very clever, and have found a way to pay evil ThanksDep the absolute bare minimum I can get away with
  • I tell all my friends and family how marvellous I am, what a great dad I would like to be, but evil ThanksDep is completely insane and is stopping me seeing my child because she is vindictive and I am a victim
  • Oh heck, ThanksDep is talking to my friends as well. She may give the game away. I need to find a way to stop her talking and ruining my lovely narrative in which I am the hero and victim, and she is the villain
  • Oh, I know, she's really anxious so I'll cook up some vague threat - that should frighten her into silence
  • I only want my friends and family to HEAR, from ME, what a great dad I am. I don't want to actually be a parent, that's too much like work

Echoing what PPs have said, the sooner you let go of what should be, and accept what is, the sooner you and your DD can move on. I hope you manage to get some benefits or similar to help you with your costs, it's astronomical isn't it. On the plus side, those costs drop once L/O goes to school.

Your ex, however, will continue to be a poxed bellend till the day he dies. Oh well.

whatausername · 19/10/2023 16:54

Repeat after me: that man is a twit.