Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

£30 - surely no longer enough for work expenses and Xmas party!

285 replies

Thursday5pmisginoclock · 19/10/2023 11:27

For those in corporate roles where you can claim expenses…what are you company policy amounts for an evening meal when working away? Our £30 allowance feels so mean, and it’s the same amount for Christmas party! I mean what do you get for that nowadays??? Especially if we were to meet in London?

also why is the personal car payment still £0.45ppm - I am pretty sure it was that 10 maybe even 15/20 years ago!

inflation has not caught up surely…?

Is this commonplace?

OP posts:
McIntire · 19/10/2023 13:42

brokenmug · 19/10/2023 13:35

It is a Christmas party!

Not a night away!

30 minutes in Pizza Pxpress with just a pizza and water may be a great night out for you but most people wouldn't make the journey for that!

So you’re referring to the once a year Christmas Party part of the OP. That really wasn’t clear and why the hell would you go for a pizza?

C8H10N4O2 · 19/10/2023 13:42

user1497207191 · 19/10/2023 13:37

But you're saving money by not eating at home, so surely what you're saving in groceries at home needs to be offset against your "eating out" costs?

And? Even if I removed the differential between the shopping bill when I was at home all week and the bill when I was away it doesn't cover the costs of being away and eating away on a regular basis.

There are a number of incremental out of pocket expenses of which food is a big one but everything which would 'be at home' just isn't available to you and has to be bought at whatever price you can get it. Most of those are not covered by any HMRC allowance.

Our grads all start by thinking "business travel" is exciting and a perk, within 12 months of living out of a suitcase and eating junk and hotel food most are eyeing up roles they can commute to. That's how much of a "perk" it is.

newhere24 · 19/10/2023 13:41

@user1497207191 I spend maybe £10 a day eating at home, if that.
If you are in tokyo, Zurich etc, that’s a coffee (and not s particularly nice one), which isn’t covered by expenses anyway.
If you are in the US, you pay more in tips than that (and tips often don’t show up on receipts, so can’t be claimed).
I also work 12-14 hour days (its a business trip, I’m there to work!), so I expect a little bit of comfort.

Cadenza12 · 19/10/2023 13:41

I have a relative who was given a selection box at Xmas . Must people get 0, so sounds perfectly reasonable to me.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 19/10/2023 13:39

C8H10N4O2 · 19/10/2023 13:33

From the OP:

"For those in corporate roles where you can claim expenses…what are you company policy amounts for an evening meal when working away?"

Nothing about "the odd night", its about the policy when working away from home. Too many people here seem to think the grind of living out of hotels is some kind of perk to be punished. Anyone who does this regularly will cheerfully swap their "perk" for getting into their own bed at night.

I'd hazard a guess that most of the PPs saying "eat cheap junk food" or that its easy have never done long periods doing the weekly travel for work. The allowances based on HMRC guidelines haven't changed in 20 years and don't distinguish between "a day in London" and "three months of five nights per week in the arse end of nowhere".

👏👏crossed posts a bit…

user1497207191 · 19/10/2023 13:37

newhere24 · 19/10/2023 13:26

A lot of people don’t understand that its not just the occasional one night/day of travelling, its often many days/weeks away with nonstop work. I want to get decent nutrition and I don’t have the time to look for the best cheap places (its not a holiday!). one night fast food is fine, but 10 days straight?

But you're saving money by not eating at home, so surely what you're saving in groceries at home needs to be offset against your "eating out" costs?

C8H10N4O2 · 19/10/2023 13:36

Appleofmyeye2023 · 19/10/2023 13:30

🤣yes, we used a cute littl app in my final days…cute when it worked 🤷🏼‍♀️

maybe I was more experienced and closer to retirement to be playing hard ball with my senior directors. They were asking me to travel, at one point, every other week into Basel . Well if they wanted me to do that, I needed to eat properly. So, I just refused to use app and would manually take around the good old fashioned expense sheets when I got back. Would tell them to pay or I would stop travelling. Simples.
I was senior enough and with an expertise they couldn’t get elsewhere, plus they knew my salary was under competitive. Generally a little focusing on that point helped them understand my position.

id also add, that as I travelled on my own, I mostly didn’t want to go out of hotel at night searching for restaurants and sitting at a table by myself. I said explicitly I would be mainly eating in hotel, and reserved my rights to have room service if I was tired and couldn’t face a formal restaurant ( e.g. just wanted to chill with iPad and pjs). Room service isn’t cheap- but it IS what I had a t home effectively.

it’s fine eating fast food, cheap food and finding random cheaper restaurants if you’re travelling only very occasionally and maybe 1 or 2 nights. If you’re only in your own bed at home for 100 nights per year, they better bloody well remeber it’s me doing them a favour and not quibble about paying some £ extra for a decent meal. I never charged them over time (wasn’t allowed to) for all the extra hours travelling incurred, all the late arrivals home, all the Sundays spent travelling out. It was the very least they could do.

don’t under sell yourself. Remember it’s you that will be giving up your time and home comforts.

thank god I retired 5 years ago. I have still not felt the slightest urge to get on a plane or stay away from my own bed 🤣🤣

This is spot on. The reality of being away from home a lot is nothing like doing the odd trip and by the time you have done 12 hours in the client office the last thing you want to be doing is traipsing around a new location to find some cheap local Nandos (even if you don't care about your diet).

Appleofmyeye2023 · 19/10/2023 13:35

HollaHolla · 19/10/2023 13:31

I really don't think it's helpful running a race to the bottom. We should all be fighting for fairer pay and conditions.

But, for what it's worth... Higher Education here, and yes, there's sick pay, but not much in the way of job security nowadays. Don't get me started on the pensions debacle. However, these were traditionally the pay off for lower pay - and it's not the 'benefit' many think it is, any more.

I agree. Low paid and rewarded staff are treated like shot irrespective of whether you are private or public.

higher paid staff in both sectors get taken advantage of in terms of unpaid overtime and pushing your limits of goodwill.

The post is on expenses. And why rates are set where they are. And that’s HMRC. And applies to anyone who gets expenses.

no one gets freebies from their employer. Might think they do, but they’re always a bribe to get employees to go above and beyond, or to merely pay back what’s owned to employees in terms of what they spend doing what the employer wants them to do.

newhere24 · 19/10/2023 13:35

@Appleofmyeye2023 I’m usually in Zurich and know zurich well enough to find what I want in budget - or let the client pay ;)
Tokyo i usually fight to get the proper expensive meals reimbursed and pay the cheaper ones (around £20 over) out of pocket. And get a hotel with an amazing breakfast.

brokenmug · 19/10/2023 13:35

McIntire · 19/10/2023 12:13

The idea is that you’re fed and the cost of the meal is covered. It’s not the company’s responsibility to provide fun! What would you normally do of an evening if you weren’t away?

It is a Christmas party!

Not a night away!

30 minutes in Pizza Pxpress with just a pizza and water may be a great night out for you but most people wouldn't make the journey for that!

FarEast · 19/10/2023 13:34

Supper at Wagamama will cost you not a lot more than £15. Of course you’re unreasonable.

HappyMavis · 19/10/2023 13:34

My company is £35 outside of London and £55 inside.

For Christmas there's a £70 per person budget to be spent on a lunch/dinner as seen fit within the teams.

MrsMiddleMother · 19/10/2023 13:34

We don't get anything from the company towards our Christmas do

C8H10N4O2 · 19/10/2023 13:33

Flatulence · 19/10/2023 13:03

"Would you think it reasonable to eat like that five days a week?"

But the OP doesn't ask about allowances for working away all week; where have you even got the idea that this is some poor soul spending days and days and days a month away from home?

They ask about an evening meal allowance - a short-term thing for a night away - and £30 for a meal allowance is perfectly reasonable.

From the OP:

"For those in corporate roles where you can claim expenses…what are you company policy amounts for an evening meal when working away?"

Nothing about "the odd night", its about the policy when working away from home. Too many people here seem to think the grind of living out of hotels is some kind of perk to be punished. Anyone who does this regularly will cheerfully swap their "perk" for getting into their own bed at night.

I'd hazard a guess that most of the PPs saying "eat cheap junk food" or that its easy have never done long periods doing the weekly travel for work. The allowances based on HMRC guidelines haven't changed in 20 years and don't distinguish between "a day in London" and "three months of five nights per week in the arse end of nowhere".

Colinorpercy · 19/10/2023 13:33

We get £26 for a whole 24 hour period so I’d be eating like a king if I had £30 to spend on one evening meal!

HollaHolla · 19/10/2023 13:31

JaninaDuszejko · 19/10/2023 12:52

For those in the public sector saying 'I get nothing' can I just point out:

  1. job security
  2. sick pay
  3. defined benefits pension

All of which are worth far more than £30 for dinner when travelling for work.

I really don't think it's helpful running a race to the bottom. We should all be fighting for fairer pay and conditions.

But, for what it's worth... Higher Education here, and yes, there's sick pay, but not much in the way of job security nowadays. Don't get me started on the pensions debacle. However, these were traditionally the pay off for lower pay - and it's not the 'benefit' many think it is, any more.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 19/10/2023 13:30

newhere24 · 19/10/2023 13:15

@Appleofmyeye2023 we sometimes get around it as well, but it is difficult. We have an automated expense system that auto rejects all claims deemed too high. There is an alternative way, but it’s extremely time consuming and luck of the draw if you get reimbursed. I’m ok navigating Switzerland on a budget, but tokyo I find very difficult and usually end up out of pocket.

🤣yes, we used a cute littl app in my final days…cute when it worked 🤷🏼‍♀️

maybe I was more experienced and closer to retirement to be playing hard ball with my senior directors. They were asking me to travel, at one point, every other week into Basel . Well if they wanted me to do that, I needed to eat properly. So, I just refused to use app and would manually take around the good old fashioned expense sheets when I got back. Would tell them to pay or I would stop travelling. Simples.
I was senior enough and with an expertise they couldn’t get elsewhere, plus they knew my salary was under competitive. Generally a little focusing on that point helped them understand my position.

id also add, that as I travelled on my own, I mostly didn’t want to go out of hotel at night searching for restaurants and sitting at a table by myself. I said explicitly I would be mainly eating in hotel, and reserved my rights to have room service if I was tired and couldn’t face a formal restaurant ( e.g. just wanted to chill with iPad and pjs). Room service isn’t cheap- but it IS what I had a t home effectively.

it’s fine eating fast food, cheap food and finding random cheaper restaurants if you’re travelling only very occasionally and maybe 1 or 2 nights. If you’re only in your own bed at home for 100 nights per year, they better bloody well remeber it’s me doing them a favour and not quibble about paying some £ extra for a decent meal. I never charged them over time (wasn’t allowed to) for all the extra hours travelling incurred, all the late arrivals home, all the Sundays spent travelling out. It was the very least they could do.

don’t under sell yourself. Remember it’s you that will be giving up your time and home comforts.

thank god I retired 5 years ago. I have still not felt the slightest urge to get on a plane or stay away from my own bed 🤣🤣

newhere24 · 19/10/2023 13:30

@TigerQueenie yes, I need more than one course. Breakfast is usually around 6am, lunch a sandwich/small rice dish, so I need a decent sized nutritious meal once a day. I’m a healthy weight 5ft person, my calorie requirements aren’t particularly high, but i can’t live for days on end on tiny meals.

Lochness1975 · 19/10/2023 13:29

I’m outside of London, ours is £25, think it’s £30 for London. I can get three courses plus a drink, and normally pay about £2 myself. Christmas party we have to pay, but do get a Christmas bonus, so I’m not grumbling!

Honeybee798 · 19/10/2023 13:27

I am shocked that some of your companies don’t just pay for the whole thing (not talking about any public services or LA jobs as I know the funding isn’t there).
We arrange two corporate events (a Summer and Christmas one). Both are all expenses paid for the employee and a plus one, excluding travel! This Christmas, we’re attending a ticketed event which includes an all inclusive bar which does keep the cost down but it’s around £120pp. Summer event costs more pp as it’s an all day and night event. This is on top of Christmas bonus and Christmas gift packages that we hand out. Our team are incredible, we want them to feel appreciated and not feel pressured to spend money on socialising with the team.

anothertrainwreck · 19/10/2023 13:27

I am a civil servant and my department allows me to claim £21 for 24 hours so that’s dinner and lunch but thankfully(?) not breakfast as we are expected to book a B&B rate. The idea of a subsidised Christmas meal is up there with flying pigs etc so I guess on that basis YABU.

TigerQueenie · 19/10/2023 13:26

£30 is plenty for dinner. Why do you need multiple courses? Most people wouldn't have multiple courses if they were at home and it's a subsistence payment, not entertainment which is different.

Is the Christmas party mandatory or optional? If its mandatory then the full cost should be covered. If optional then you have to accept that you're choosing to go so £30 contribution is fine. Again, you choose what you do presumably so choose something cheaper or pay the difference.

Usernamen · 19/10/2023 13:26

At my workplace, it’s £40 dinner allowance for staff working away from home, but if you’re taking out a client it’s £120 a head. Essentially if you dine with the client on a business trip, the budget is triple. Ludicrous.

newhere24 · 19/10/2023 13:26

A lot of people don’t understand that its not just the occasional one night/day of travelling, its often many days/weeks away with nonstop work. I want to get decent nutrition and I don’t have the time to look for the best cheap places (its not a holiday!). one night fast food is fine, but 10 days straight?

VORE · 19/10/2023 13:23

As someone who has worked in corporate London for years… £30 a head sounds incredibly mean!

I would say minimum £50 a head and then you might get one drink included if you’re lucky!

£30 is basically just a main course! Unless they want you to go to Weatherspoons?!?!