Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To avoid my mother in law like the plague

62 replies

Mcemmabell · 18/10/2023 22:15

It's not a new and novel story, mother doesn't get on with her mother-in-law. But I just feel like I would like an honest opinion about being done with me MIL. I've got two lovely boys, aged 4 and 2 and I've been married to my DH for 5 years. The in-laws live a 40 minute drive away and from the get-go have always said whenever we need help to ask for anything at all. We're super lucky because they'll take the boys every Thursday while DH and I are both working. But even though they've said they're keen to help more I never take them up on that offer, because they drive both my husband and I up the wall. Well specifically MIL. She is very self-interested and self-absorbed. Loves talking about herself and her friends. Pushing her agendas for how she thinks we should raise the kids. When either myself or my DH have struggled with something, she's just been like oh you're fine whatever.

I once mentioned how stressful a couple days I'd had alone with my newborn and 2.5 year old and she was like oh but it's not that bad though. Now I know I'm not entitled to her empathy but I also don't need to have people around who make me feel rubbish. In contrast, when she has talked about stomach problems, anxiety etc. I have provided a listening ear and sympathised with her. I really appreciate the day of childcare we get but MIL also benefits because I know she loves seeing the kids. But when I come home from work the day she and FIL have the kids, I dread coming in the door to her negativity and self-absorbed stress. When DH leaves in the morning when they have the kids, he also gets really stressed out because they needle away at him saying he needs to do stuff around the house and sort this and that. Our house is fine, and there were literally no problems with it.

She also hands in clothes and toys to the kids every week or two no matter how many times we say no more. We've literally put our collective feet down and said please only give presents at Christmas and Birthdays, many many times. The kids have way too many toys and more than enough clothes. But she does not stop.

Lastly, the last time I left the kids at her house for a few hours, when I went to pick them up she went on a diatribe about how I need to appreciate so much how hard DH works. I said yes, I really do appreciate that. She went on about how great it is that he's been working in a further away location than usual. My response: That's not good, he leaves at 7am and doesn't get back until 7pm. Her: But, he allows you to life the lifestyle you lead. My glamorous lifestyle of teaching in an inner-city primary school 3 days a week, and being a mother to two young kids the other four days (DH also works Saturdays so I get one day of help from him). I guess looking after children is not valuable, or indeed work according to my MIL.

She also bigs up how her sons are so smart and accomplished and that she wanted them to get a job that made good money. I'm like oh yeah I'm just the teacher here who wanted to make a difference, look at me with my crappy masters degree and ten years of trying to help kids.

Anyway, if you've made it this far thank you for reading and please AIBU trying to avoid her as much as possible and not ask for help even though it would make my life easier, because being around her makes me unhappy and stressed.

OP posts:
Ktime · 20/10/2023 07:23

PrinceHaz

Her comment about you having to appreciate your husband would be enough for me to cut ties.

Seriously? For all we know she could be telling her son to appreciate his wife as well.

Fifireee · 20/10/2023 07:22

Just pay for your own childcare. She probably saves you over £500 a month. For £500 free childcare I’d probably let her tell me anything she liked. Just because she says it doesn’t make it true.
As for the clothes and toys - donate them?

PrinceHaz · 20/10/2023 07:20

Her comment about you having to appreciate your husband would be enough for me to cut ties.
I would get someone else to have the boys on Thursdays. You don’t want to be in hock to someone who has no qualms about putting you down and and going out of their way to make you feel uncomfortable about yourself.

Notinthegroupchats · 20/10/2023 07:18

You sound a bit insecure. Yes, she sounds annoying but really that’s all. Sure blow up your wider family relationship because she bought too many toys it wasn’t that empathic about a couple of days you spent alone with your own children if that’s what you want to do.

Ktime · 20/10/2023 07:17

I thought you were going to say some worse things.

She doesn’t sound too bad, I think you’re overreacting.

You need to develop better boundaries.

DH should be able to tell his own mum not to go on so much, why is he such a wet lettuce?

I really appreciate the day of childcare we get but MIL also benefits because I know she loves seeing the kids.

YABU. You need to appreciate the FREE childcare without dismissing it as MIL benefiting too. She is doing you and H a favour.

Fairyliz · 20/10/2023 07:14

Mcemmabell · 19/10/2023 07:07

DH is never around when she's talking to me. I get home from work before him. The kids jump on me and start trying to talk to me when I get home and MIL will talk over the top of them and it's like whoa, this is a lot. I don't like ignoring my children when I haven't seen them all day. The other week, 2 year old started pulling my hair really hard and while I was saying "Ow, gentle hands. Mummy is hurting" and trying to extract the hair from his iron grip, MIL just keeps talking as if nothing is happening.

But if she’s just spent all day looking after two small children perhaps she is desperate for some adult interaction?
Shes had to give to your children all day, so now wants time and attention from you.

K4tM · 20/10/2023 07:10

I think reasonable people should treat others as they would like to be treat (treated?) themselves. Take the moral high ground and Be Nice. Remember you will probably be a MIL yourself one day.

DSN88 · 20/10/2023 07:07

A little unreasonable, yep! You have help, you don’t know how fortunate you are that you have at least one day of childcare sorted, for 2 kids! I assume if you want a date with your husband, you can ask them?
Mum’s tend to big up their sons as well as their own parenting. My MIL lives over 4 hours away, so she’s never had our child…I’m not sure she would if she was closer. Yet I’m still told (when I’ve said parenting is hard) to think how hard it must’ve been for her (the amount of kids and terrible husband she had)..at the start, it would grind on me and I’d feel knocked, but now I take it with a pinch of salt. So many people like to talk about themselves, some are just built that way and until you accept that, she’ll always annoy you. Be grateful they bring presents to your kids, you can always donate older toys or the gifted ones if your kids don’t play with them, to charity.
This isn’t a comment to make you feel bad, as it used to wind me up getting unsolicited advice off my MIL, but I’d love to have her around more now…my husband and I often say how nice having help would be, but then see the flip side that we don’t feel obliged at having to host family at special occasions or that there’s no expectations from us. So I guess it swings both ways. I’d try to accept her narcissism (?) and that she is how she is, and learn to appreciate the help.

Honeybee798 · 19/10/2023 22:51

Yanbu. She’s being rude. She is rude. She might be your MIL but she needs to keep her mouth shut.

Goldbar · 19/10/2023 22:06

Since it sounds like she's generally obnoxious (to your DH as well as to you) and it's not specifically targeted at you, I'd let it wash over you.

If she says anything about how lucky you are/how hard your DH works, I'd smile pleasantly and just say, 'That's between DH and myself. I'm sure you don't intend to interfere in our relationship.'

JussathoB · 19/10/2023 09:35

If you are picking the DC up from Mil house, just make sure she knows what time and ask her to get the children ready to come straight out. Smile and get children straight in car and say you have to get home now as DH needs you back on time, and you have housework/dinner to do.

billy1966 · 19/10/2023 09:10

In your place it doesn't appear to be worth the childcare.

I would pay for the childcare if you can as your mental health is worth more.

Tell your husband it is his job to bring the children to visit her when he can.

See a lot less of her.

Years ago a friend of mine had something similar.

Her MIL had begged to mind the baby 2 days after she returned to work even though my friend had a wonderful childminder.

She was only a month into the arrangement when she was very stressed.

Despite working fulltime as was her husband, her MIL was giving HER grief at the state of the house, with critical comments about being more organised.

She was VERY upset.
Her husband said ignore her, but did nothing.

It went on for a while longer and then after a hard day she cracked.
She just rang her childminder who agreed to take the baby 5 days.

Her husband and her had a falling out and she said she was doing the dropping and collecting and she was getting the grief from his mother and she wasn't putting up with it any longer.

She told him she dreaded coming home and she wasn't having it.

She was prepared to move home to her parents.

He saw how upset she really was and he had to go and tell his mother it wasn't working out.
He told his mother her cleaning remarks were very unfair and had caused huge upset.

There was huge upset and hurt feelings as her MIL had no idea her "advice" was causing such upset.
She had no explanation for why she never gave her son any "advice".

My friend was tired, worn out and overwhelmed after returning to work, and just couldn't be dealing with criticism after coming through the door.

She was much happier having her pivacy back.

Things did settled down but it was a much cooler relationship going forward.

Busephalus · 19/10/2023 08:13

My mil is pretty similar, except no regular childcare, I just try and get on with the other bits of her that I like, no-ones perfect

Khvdrt · 19/10/2023 07:19

My mil used to look after our DC one day a week which seemed a lovely idea but it just caused more stress for me and DH for a multitude of reasons. Through a change of circumstances the kids started childcare instead and it has been a hundred times better. It means we’re more in control of when we see her so it doesn’t feel too much and can ask her to babysit etc without feeling bad for asking for two things in a week. If you can afford it change the arrangements.

Mcemmabell · 19/10/2023 07:07

DH is never around when she's talking to me. I get home from work before him. The kids jump on me and start trying to talk to me when I get home and MIL will talk over the top of them and it's like whoa, this is a lot. I don't like ignoring my children when I haven't seen them all day. The other week, 2 year old started pulling my hair really hard and while I was saying "Ow, gentle hands. Mummy is hurting" and trying to extract the hair from his iron grip, MIL just keeps talking as if nothing is happening.

OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · 19/10/2023 06:06

Let her chat away. You'll be a mil one day too.

And? I never understand such comments like these as if that makes a lick of difference. OP will either act the same or remember how her own MIL treated her and do the exact opposite.

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable OP and as a pp said, I rather pay for the one day of childcare than deal with someone who goes out of their way to nitpick, complain, and overstep boundaries. It would be rude if it was anyone else but family always seem to get a pass just because their blood and even more so if they do the tiniest bit of childcare because you should be oh so grateful and put up with them, when it is constantly said it takes nothing to be nice. I don’t even know you OP, but I can have sympathy for your situation because it is difficult with two children under 5 and working part-time, and then having to deal with people who can’t seem to bear to say something positive.

Them constantly buying clothes and toys despite you and your DH is a problem because either you or your DH have to deal with it and sort it out giving you another chore that you don’t need to have. With what they’re choosing to spend on such things, they could be putting it into a bank account instead. They nitpick your home yet our filling it up with unnecessary stuff. I’d be tempted to say “sort it for us if it bothers you so much” every time one of them says something about your home.

You can either pay for childcare, keep it strictly business-like with MIL as a pp said, only concentrating on the children and asking question about their days and making a quick exit, or ask her why she treats you this way and see if she realises she does this. If she is knowingly doing this, then you can consider paying for childcare or tell her that you won’t accept this treatment and that you will do xyz from now on (have a think about what you want beforehand). If she is not, she will either apologise and stop or be defensive. Either way, you need to figure something out so you’re not going through this every interaction. What does your DH think, does he notice how she talks to you?

Firefly1987 · 19/10/2023 00:49

The amount of people who only wanna talk about themselves is quite staggering really...I don't even mind it because I'd rather talk about others lives anyway but it's quite amusing when you finally get a word in and all you get is a slight "mm" as acknowledgement before they just go straight back to talking about themselves! They're not bad people though. Some people also just talk crap all the time because they have a need to fill the silence. She probably genuinely thinks she's helping you and you want her advice.

Also I don't really get where you have the idea she thinks "looking after children is not valuable, or indeed work according to my MIL." Just because she said you have a nice lifestyle?

I'm like oh yeah I'm just the teacher here who wanted to make a difference, look at me with my crappy masters degree and ten years of trying to help kids." seriously think you may be reading more into this and it's not meant with any offence that she happens to be proud of her sons, is it really a slight on you?

SwingTheMonkey · 18/10/2023 23:59

Yeah there’s nothing there that seems that bad tbh. There’s certainly nothing going on there that a swift putting her in her place wouldn’t fix fairly quickly.

‘No, we’re not interested in doing anything cosmetic to the house at the moment’.

’Yes Dh works hard to provide our lifestyle but I work equally as hard’.

Nothing rude, just to the point.

Why do you need your mil to give you sympathy? Seek it elsewhere and just don’t speak to her about those things.

Usernamesmushername · 18/10/2023 23:54

YANBU, definitely not. My MIL is the same but thank god they live 4 hours away. When they visit they stay in a BnB as we have no space (on purpose) but during an 8 hour visit my MIL will talk about herself non stop, she never asks us about ours or the DC's lives and if we try and bring it up 'DC did this at nursery this week'. She promptly turns the conversation back to herself. It is mentally exhausting and tbh after a visit from them I am physically exhausted too. She also always starts her visit with 'oh, it's quite clean here today' as if she thinks I raise my children in a pigsty, drives me nuts. I give thanks every time they leave to drive back home. I would never cut contact as they are my DH and DC's family, but I absolutely could not bare frequent contact. Stick with your Thursdays, take them for what they are (aka self absorbed, boring and a little rude!) and enjoy your 6 days a week without them.

OldPerson · 18/10/2023 23:51

You're not unreasonable, but you made a pact with the devil and you know it. In return for one day childcare per week (you know how valuable that is), you have to listen to an unhappy person lord it over you. A. You have to work out if the benefits outweigh the misery. But the longer it goes on, you'll then reach a stage where you have to be eternally grateful to them for being there the first 5 years. B. You have to work out an alternative childcare arrangement, which will probably cost a lot. C. You have to learn to enter MIL home with your own agenda asking lots of questions about your children's day and what they've learned and what new milestones they've achieved, and under that backfoot interrogation, absolutely need to have in place option B, the back-up expensive childcare.
Unless you are able to set a few boundaries, or a quid pro quo offer for something to the in-laws that equates to their childcare. There is a cost. You're paying it every time you turn up to collect your children.

Gottaworkwhatever · 18/10/2023 23:30

Why don’t you try changing the dynamics when you walk in, so she doesn’t have a chance to be negative?
Turn up with a little gift for everyone( a packet of chocolate buttons etc..), pizza, Fish and chips, a small bunch of flowers, box of chocolates, to show your appreciation. Anything to break the cycle you’ve got into…

Firefly1987 · 18/10/2023 23:24

I doubt she realises she is upsetting you. Family are like that sometimes, maybe she views you as close enough now that you can handle a bit of good natured criticism, which could actually be a positive thing? I feel like she means well, but just isn't good with empathy-so if that's the case you're probably better off not venting to her if she's going to dismiss your problems.

Blackandwhitemakesgrey · 18/10/2023 23:23

Add repeat detailed long monologues of the numerous holidays she's had over her (long) lifetime along with pointless and endless stories about people I've never met yet feel I know intimately and you have my MIL except she doesn't take the kids one day a week. At least I can reduce contact without obligation.

SunCreamQueenie · 18/10/2023 23:12

Gotta be honest, I'd rather skint myself paying for childcare than put up with that nonsense (in fact I did!)

ZenNudist · 18/10/2023 22:46

This sounds like standard MIL DIL relationship. Once a week when they are really helping you out is fine and then see them monthly socially at the weekend so it's not all take take take.