Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers shouldn't post controversial thoughts publicly (Hamas related)

71 replies

ermno3 · 18/10/2023 21:03

In light of the war a teacher I have on social media has been quite vocal about their thoughts/feelings (fine). However, they are now on a public platform stating they don't believe Hamas are terrorists, rather a resistance who's actions are justified.

AIBU to think they shouldn't be airing these thoughts so publicly in light of their profession?

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 18/10/2023 22:31

I would prefer it if those who held extreme views were encouraged to make them public. Then we can make informed decisions about their suitability for teaching our children.

SylvanianFrenemies · 18/10/2023 22:27

mellowgrape · 18/10/2023 22:20

@SylvanianFrenemies yes of course but Israel mostly at this stage for using disproportionate force on civilians but the problem is the narrative being shown is that the civilians are also Hamas so they are allowed to break any war rules and commit massacres. No child should die and lose parents on any side whether you are Israeli or Palestinian. Every life is worth the same.

Back to the thread, A lot of teachers I know have all changed their names so they aren't easily tracked down by students. For instance they will change the spelling of their names and surnames and use a profile pictures that aren't identified and profiles are private. Anything they post shouldn't be used against them in my opinion unless it's safeguarding issues.

These times are dangerous times and remember the covid times and the anti Vaxers particularly in the NHS and look how things have changed and turned out in the end.

But that isn't what you were saying. You were condescendingly praying for me because I had the audacity to talk about atrocities committed by Hamas on a thread about someone supporting Hamas, and you wildly projected and assumed I don't have equal compassion for Palestinian victims. If the thread was about someone supporting IDF war crimes that is what I'd have talked about. I wonder if you really think every life is worth the same if you think I have an empty soul because I openly care about Israeli citizens who were massacred in the most grotesque way.
I'll take your huge backpedal as an apology - accepted.

mellowgrape · 18/10/2023 22:20

@SylvanianFrenemies yes of course but Israel mostly at this stage for using disproportionate force on civilians but the problem is the narrative being shown is that the civilians are also Hamas so they are allowed to break any war rules and commit massacres. No child should die and lose parents on any side whether you are Israeli or Palestinian. Every life is worth the same.

Back to the thread, A lot of teachers I know have all changed their names so they aren't easily tracked down by students. For instance they will change the spelling of their names and surnames and use a profile pictures that aren't identified and profiles are private. Anything they post shouldn't be used against them in my opinion unless it's safeguarding issues.

These times are dangerous times and remember the covid times and the anti Vaxers particularly in the NHS and look how things have changed and turned out in the end.

Mum2jenny · 18/10/2023 22:10

Personally, as a professional, I feel if you post things on social media with an identifiable name, you could be risking your job. Unless your posts are only accessible by friends and family who you trust not to grass you up.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 18/10/2023 22:00

EasterIssland · 18/10/2023 21:19

As long as it’s in sm they can do whatever they want. Different thing would be if they did it in the school.

Actually you can still be in trouble if comments made in a personal sm if account is not private.

EasterIssland · 18/10/2023 21:59

Mum2jenny · 18/10/2023 21:34

Yes, but life outside work does not need to be broadcast to everyone on social media. Discretion should be considered in any such posts. Limit the audience.

Does this apply to anything posted on SM?

DomPom47 · 18/10/2023 21:57

Secretary of State for Education did write to all schools and made it explicit that teachers need to be impartial and also their stance on Hamas which is a terrorist organisation.
If kids are not aware of what the teacher has posted and they are not inciting anything I think their view is fine, personally wouldn’t agree with it but freedom of expression. If kids can see it then it’s an issue.

Teachers shouldn't post controversial thoughts publicly (Hamas related)
SylvanianFrenemies · 18/10/2023 21:49

mellowgrape · 18/10/2023 21:46

@SylvanianFrenemies I am praying for you 🙏 with being ok with babies, children and women being blown up into pieces and watching every war crime being committed. I am praying that the emptiness and blindness
In your soul will be filled with humanity.

It is possible to hold the view that both Hsmas and the IDF are behaving appallingly. Do you realise that? Do you see that it is ok to feel revulsion both for massacaring Israelis and for massacaring Palestinians?

mellowgrape · 18/10/2023 21:46

@SylvanianFrenemies I am praying for you 🙏 with being ok with babies, children and women being blown up into pieces and watching every war crime being committed. I am praying that the emptiness and blindness
In your soul will be filled with humanity.

Floralnomad · 18/10/2023 21:46

There are lots of professions where you should be careful about what you put on SM and teaching is one of them .

Mum2jenny · 18/10/2023 21:44

I think anyone could expect consequences from a work employer for posting anything supporting terrorism or alternative views.

AnneElliott · 18/10/2023 21:43

I agree op - I'm a civil servant where doing this would get you sacked. I think any professional that uses their real name on social media or is able to be outed should keep politics to themselves.

SylvanianFrenemies · 18/10/2023 21:42

hitherandhither · 18/10/2023 21:38

Does this just apply to teachers? Any other professions? What about TAs? School receptionists? Catering staff? Lunchtime supervisors? Caretakers? School counsellors? Speech and Language therapists? School nurses?

All these people have interactions with children too.

Yes, any of these people should expect work consequences for supporting terrorism.

Mum2jenny · 18/10/2023 21:42

I feel it applies to all professions. I’m not a teacher but I wouldn’t post my own views on such matters, so that anyone can read it

SylvanianFrenemies · 18/10/2023 21:41

mellowgrape · 18/10/2023 21:36

I would rather have my kids taught by teachers who have views and opinions than people who are forced to obey what the government says because they are in bed with the bullies with big guns and money.

You don't seem to understand that Hamas is not Palestine.

Who were the bullies with big guns when an elderly holocaust survivor was pulled from her shelter and shot in the head? When youngsters at a pro-peace music festival were sprayed with bullets and/or raped?

Supporting genocide is not a mainstream view or opinion.

SahliJ · 18/10/2023 21:41

There will be a social media use policy - assuming they are employed at a school/college. They will be held to account by this.

Dependent on material shared there may also be a risk under safeguarding.

hitherandhither · 18/10/2023 21:38

Mum2jenny · 18/10/2023 21:34

Yes, but life outside work does not need to be broadcast to everyone on social media. Discretion should be considered in any such posts. Limit the audience.

Does this just apply to teachers? Any other professions? What about TAs? School receptionists? Catering staff? Lunchtime supervisors? Caretakers? School counsellors? Speech and Language therapists? School nurses?

All these people have interactions with children too.

mellowgrape · 18/10/2023 21:36

I would rather have my kids taught by teachers who have views and opinions than people who are forced to obey what the government says because they are in bed with the bullies with big guns and money.

Mum2jenny · 18/10/2023 21:34

Yes, but life outside work does not need to be broadcast to everyone on social media. Discretion should be considered in any such posts. Limit the audience.

Eddyraisins · 18/10/2023 21:34

Xenia · 18/10/2023 21:30

My bigger concern is if teachers don't let children freely express their own views eg if the child supports the Conservatives or has different views in any area from those of most teachers.

A group called themselves The Torys the other day for a quiz name. I didn't even raise an eyebrow.
I love overhearing their opinions when talking to each other.

hitherandhither · 18/10/2023 21:33

@wheatsheaf8 Then that is what should be complained about. Teachers should be allowed a life outside of the classroom, even if it's holding beliefs that not many would support or agree with. Voicing them inside the classroom is different though!

HeidiInTheBigCity · 18/10/2023 21:32

wheatsheaf8 · 18/10/2023 21:25

Because they are in a position of influence over children who are still forming their views about the world. It would be fine if there was an equal spread of different views across the teaching profession, but teachers, by virtue of being teachers, are more likely to have certain views (e.g. public sector workers are more likely to be left wing), so it isn't like they're going to be fed every kind of opinion so they can decide for themselves.
They need to be as neutral as possible, presenting the facts only, so children can form their own worldviews.

Do you REALLY want the total intellectual non-items that genuinely have zero controversial opinions to be in charge of teaching your kids to think critically, though?

Or, alternatively: the "compliant - to the extent that they will pretend to have neither personality nor opinions, if their employer so demands"?

Again: DO complain when teachers take their ideology into the classroom - and leave them the hell alone on "they do not, they just, like the rest of us, happen to have a life outside of work!"

Eddyraisins · 18/10/2023 21:31

Because they are in a position of influence over children who are still forming their views about the world. It would be fine if there was an equal spread of different views across the teaching profession, but teachers, by virtue of being teachers, are more likely to have certain views (e.g. public sector workers are more likely to be left wing), so it isn't like they're going to be fed every kind of opinion so they can decide for themselves.
They need to be as neutral as possible, presenting the facts only, so children can form their own worldviews.

Not one student has mentioned the middle East to me. Apart from one, he said it was boring hearing it on radio on the way to school.🥶
I am sure this teacher isn't spouting to students. Maybe they are but in my years of experience they aren't as students are not interested.

Xenia · 18/10/2023 21:30

My bigger concern is if teachers don't let children freely express their own views eg if the child supports the Conservatives or has different views in any area from those of most teachers.

Bluevelvetsofa · 18/10/2023 21:30

Personally, I think teachers should be very careful about using social media, but it irks me that they are, for some reason, often held to higher account than other professions or jobs.

Considering that so many folk are critical of schools and teachers, it feels hypocritical to expect them to not have opinions or feel passionately about issues.