Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How is this possible - mortgage

195 replies

Mortgageh · 18/10/2023 20:00

If I take out a mortgage of £200k over 35 years with an interest rate of 6%, my monthly payments would be £1250. This would mean I'm paying nearly £500k?!!

It's my first time doing something like this and I'm really confused so just wondering if anyone can explain this, thank you

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Threadreplier · 18/10/2023 22:12

Colourfulponderings · 18/10/2023 21:27

You’re right that they are much rarer now but I think we must have struck lucky because have an offset mortgage at 1.54%, fixed for two more years.

We’ve always had them and have been brilliant for massively overpaying.

Wow, that's awesome. We managed to fix earlier this year for 5 years at 3.89% when mortgages were going crazy. Best offset at the time was around 6%. You have struck gold. Thankfully, there's no 10% limit on overpaying our mortgage, so we're squirreling away in 5.5-7% fixed rate savings and then will lump sum if they come down. It's a hard time for new mortgages though and those without the equity to get the more decent rates.

ElFupacabra · 18/10/2023 22:03

They might teach compound interest in school but do you remember every single thing you were taught in school? I certainly don’t and I never needed to know about it until 15+ years later when it actually affected my life.

Papillon23 · 18/10/2023 21:58

BorisIsACuntWaffle · 18/10/2023 21:53

The loan principle is decreasing but you pay interest on the amount left to pay (which may include some of last year's interest depending on how much you pay each month/year)

Mortgage payments definitely always cover the interest. It's literally the entire mechanism of how they work - you can't be paying off the principal if you haven't paid off the interest and if you didn't pay off the interest you'd never pay off the mortgage.

FatOaf · 18/10/2023 21:56

The interest is 6% a year, not 6% in total.

It might make more sense if you scale down the numbers.

Suppose you borrowed £100 over 35 years at an interest rate of 6% per annum and paid back £7.50 a year (i.e. about 1/13 of the sum borrowed, equivalent to £15,000 on a loan of £200,000).

After the first year you would have paid back £7.50 but would have had £6 added in interest (actually very slightly less but let's not go into that level of detail). So you would now owe £100 - £7.50 + £6 = £98.50.

After the next year you would have paid back another £7.50 and would have had another £5.91 added in interest (6% of £98.50, keeping up the over-simplification for purposes of illustration). So you would now owe £96.91.

After the next year you would have paid back another £7.50 and have had another £5.81 added in interest. So you would now owe £95.22.

After three years you would have paid back £22.50 but your outstanding loan is only £4.78 less than the original sum you borrowed. This is why it takes you 35 years to pay it all back, and why you pay back well over twice as much as you borrowed.

Even doing a very crude calculation, 6% per annum x 35 years = 210%, so if it were simple interest, not decreasing in line with the sum remaining, you would pay 2.1 x the original sum in interest, so you would repay £200,000 + (2.1 x £200,000) = £620,000. It's only as low as £500,000 because the amount of interest accruing goes down each year because the sum you owe goes down. But it goes down very, very slowly in the first few years.

AmandasFleckerl · 18/10/2023 21:56

This is from money saving expert website. Hope it helps.

How is this possible - mortgage
How is this possible - mortgage
How is this possible - mortgage
BorisIsACuntWaffle · 18/10/2023 21:53

The loan principle is decreasing but you pay interest on the amount left to pay (which may include some of last year's interest depending on how much you pay each month/year)

Papillon23 · 18/10/2023 21:52

BorisIsACuntWaffle · 18/10/2023 21:49

@Adviceplease123456

Compound interest is calculated based on the principal and already-existing interest from the previous period. For loans, compound interest may happen when interest due is not paid and then added to the loan's principle, which then builds upon itself, so repaying the loan takes more time.

But in a mortgage the whole point is that you pay the interest off every month - and a little bit of capital. So the interest doesn't compound.

If you didn't pay anything towards the mortgage then the interest would compound, but as you are paying it off it doesn't.

(Agreeing in fact with your words above but not your disagreement with Adviceplease!)

Adviceplease123456 · 18/10/2023 21:51

BorisIsACuntWaffle · 18/10/2023 21:48

Of course it's compound interest. Ffs

I’m genuinely confused because I don’t understand that. Google says

“Compound interest is calculated based on the principal and already-existing interest from the previous period. For loans, compound interest may happen when interest due is not paid and then added to the loan's principle, which then builds upon itself, so repaying the loan takes more time.”

interest due is paid every month PLUS a small amount of capital. So the loans principle is never increasing?

Papillon23 · 18/10/2023 21:50

Adviceplease123456 · 18/10/2023 21:47

I’m confused - this isn’t compound interest though? It’s not interest on interest…

it’s just paying of 6% every year over a long period on a decreasing sum of money cos you are paying off a small amount of capital each year.

all those saying compound interest should be taught in schools should probably also learn what it is?!

compound interest is what you get on a savings account - in year 1 you have £100 in it. Then you get 6% interest so make £6 and have £106 in there. Year 2 you get 6% interest on £106 so make £6.36 interest and have £112.36. Year 4 you make 6% on that and make £6.74 and so on etc. So you’re making more and more.

This is what I was thinking.

Compound interest I think would be what causes problems with those equity release mortgages, but not a normal one where you pay the interest off.

BorisIsACuntWaffle · 18/10/2023 21:49

@Adviceplease123456

Compound interest is calculated based on the principal and already-existing interest from the previous period. For loans, compound interest may happen when interest due is not paid and then added to the loan's principle, which then builds upon itself, so repaying the loan takes more time.

BorisIsACuntWaffle · 18/10/2023 21:48

Adviceplease123456 · 18/10/2023 21:47

I’m confused - this isn’t compound interest though? It’s not interest on interest…

it’s just paying of 6% every year over a long period on a decreasing sum of money cos you are paying off a small amount of capital each year.

all those saying compound interest should be taught in schools should probably also learn what it is?!

compound interest is what you get on a savings account - in year 1 you have £100 in it. Then you get 6% interest so make £6 and have £106 in there. Year 2 you get 6% interest on £106 so make £6.36 interest and have £112.36. Year 4 you make 6% on that and make £6.74 and so on etc. So you’re making more and more.

Of course it's compound interest. Ffs

IhearyouClemFandango · 18/10/2023 21:47

Even a teeny overpayment makes a difference. We have always rounded ours up to the nearest £100 even when broke, in some years that was only £15; normally about £80. It all helps.

Galatine · 18/10/2023 21:47

Spirallingdownwards · 18/10/2023 20:05

It's because it's compound interest

Exactly. In the first few years most of your payments go towards the interest on the debt and only a small amount of the capital is paid off as time goes on more and more of the capital is paid of and less in interest.

SharonTheHappySquirrel · 18/10/2023 21:47

Newuser284 · 18/10/2023 21:29

It's probably worth saying I didn't over stretch when I bought, I bought very comfortably within my affordability (despite a pushy broker trying to encourage me to borrow more) so I can prioritise overpayment. Equally I'm prioritising overpayment over savings because I want my mortgage gone as quickly as possible, if I have a tough month I don't make the overpayment.

We didn’t either, we only bought for half what they offered us. We split our extra money between overpayments and building up a buffer, and once we had the buffer put as much as we could each year in the mortgage and then paid for chunks at the end of the fixed term

Adviceplease123456 · 18/10/2023 21:47

I’m confused - this isn’t compound interest though? It’s not interest on interest…

it’s just paying of 6% every year over a long period on a decreasing sum of money cos you are paying off a small amount of capital each year.

all those saying compound interest should be taught in schools should probably also learn what it is?!

compound interest is what you get on a savings account - in year 1 you have £100 in it. Then you get 6% interest so make £6 and have £106 in there. Year 2 you get 6% interest on £106 so make £6.36 interest and have £112.36. Year 4 you make 6% on that and make £6.74 and so on etc. So you’re making more and more.

Differentstarts · 18/10/2023 21:45

Noodledoodledoo · 18/10/2023 21:03

I have taught maths for 15 years, and it is taught in Yr 8, Yr 9 and part of the GCSE and has been for the whole 15 years..........

I really didn't pay attention in school I have no memory of this at all

GettingPast · 18/10/2023 21:45

The mortgage term is very long at 35 years. You are dragging it out. Hence the high amount of repayment.
Do some online simulations to see the effect of different length terms and you will see what the different outcomes can be. Keep the term as short as you can afford.

BorisIsACuntWaffle · 18/10/2023 21:41

supersop60 · 18/10/2023 21:30

Absolutely. There should be a basic maths test (not GCSE) which covers the number operations, weights and measures, percentages and compound interest. And everyone has to pass it, retaking it as many times as necessary

Foundation maths does this. All students have to get grade 4 or re sit until 18.

agent765 · 18/10/2023 21:40

When we had our first mortgage in the early 90s the advisor told us that our interest rate would be around about the 5% and might one day briefly go as high as 8%.

By 1997 it was 15%. It would have crippled us and ended us in negative equity at best if we hadn't been paying more off.

A friend working in the City told us to never go for anything other than a repayment mortgage and pay off as much as possible early. Which we did. Even a very basic calculation of the overall interest was shocking enough to make us determined to save every spare penny.

My sister took out an interest-only mortgage at the same time with the intent of paying off the lump sum of the original mortgage at the end with a policy that would give her the lump sum plus a nice little amount as a windfall.

She's still paying off her third mortgage as the policy meant to pay off the mortgage and give her a nice lump sum never worked out. She'll now end up paying her mortgage off in 3 year's time when she's 70.

My City friend said that anything other than a straightforward repayment was a con - they were being heavily pushed at the time - and the only people to benefit were the bankers.

My nephew took out a mortgage rate several years ago when it was 5%. As rates lowered to exceptionally low he's continued with his original payments. He has to pay an admin fee every few years when he locked in at lower rates but it's been a small amount. Now that the rates are back up he hasn't been hit so hard despite increasing his mortgage considerably to pay for improvements.

We were taught compound interest in school so I had a basic grasp of it but the old adage of not what you know but who you know literally paid for us.

Tiredalwaystired · 18/10/2023 21:39

AlexaCanYouHearMe · 18/10/2023 20:18

And people bash people who rent their home, and say 'renting is dead money!' LMFAO! 😆 Buying a home, and paying a quarter of a million back more than you have borrowed in the first place (even more in some cases,) now THAT is dead money. And you're paying your mortgage until you draw your pension in some cases. Yep, sod that. People renting social housing have the best deal out of anyone else these days.

As people have said @Mortgageh it's compound interest. And yeah it IS possible and it IS right. Shit isn't it?! And we are all encouraged to buy a property. Very few people get any advantages from buying now!

Kind of depends when you bought though. Yes we will end up paying twice what we actually bought it for but house prices have gone up over 150% since we bought. So we and many who bought at a similar time to us are actually still profitable. Plus we have a secure roof over our heads and something to either pay for later care or give to the children.

easylikeasundaymorn · 18/10/2023 21:36

Biscuitsandpizza · 18/10/2023 20:33

But by your example, you would pay £1250 rent per month for 35 years and have NOTHING at the end of it. OP will pay that (although realistically over the course of 35 years the interest rate is going to change and likely be lower at times), and have a house at the end of it.

not to mention that the house will very likely increase in price over 35 years.
obviously most people will move several times over that period but even given the most straightforward example, say it was worth £200k in 2023 and £300k in 2058 that's a 'free' £100k profit made which goes a good way to cancelling off the interest. Likely it would increase a lot more, look at house prices in 1988 compared to now (although I don't think we'll see AS significant jumps again, for a lot of people the equity will cancel out or even profit over the interest rate, particularly if rates go down again).

CatOnTheCarpet · 18/10/2023 21:35

Will people stop saying it’s compound interest 😂

Lolaandbehold · 18/10/2023 21:34

I have a mortgage of £350k. 19 years left. I’m coming off my fixed rate next month which had payments of £795 per month. The standard variable rate I’m moving to is 9.99% so monthly payments of almost £3,000 per month.

The new stress tests indicate that if I look for a better deal on the open market, the total amount I could borrow is £200k! So I’d be stuck with my current lender on their best fix of about 6.54% with payments of £1950 per month. Plus £500 arrangement fee. I’m sure this isn’t an unusual situation.

Fun times.

OnedayIwillfeelfree · 18/10/2023 21:34

Our house was £80k. We paid 230k for it in total. Our interest rate was 8.45%. It’s worth just under a million now, 30 years later, so 230k seems like a bargain now!

Newuser284 · 18/10/2023 21:30

PaxOmnibus · 18/10/2023 21:25

Yes that’s sounds about right.
Its always best to get as big a deposit as possible and pay off lump sums as much as you can.
Make sure your mortgage allows you to do this

Most are capped at 10% if you're on a fixed rate, something to be mindful of if you get a windfall and want to throw it at the mortgage.