Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To share the actual definition of antisemitism

541 replies

LemonyTicket · 18/10/2023 16:38

The boards have been full for a week with cries of woe that you can't criticise Israel without being accused of antisemitism. So to make life easy, below is a summary of what defines antisemitism as agreed by more or less the leading experts in the world. If you'd like to discuss Israel without being antisemitic, you can follow these guidelines to say what you would like to say without causing pain to Jewish people:

POINT 1
What is particular in classic antisemitism is the idea that Jews are linked to the forces of evil. This stands at the core of many anti-Jewish fantasies, such as the idea of a Jewish conspiracy in which “the Jews” possess hidden power that they use to promote their own collective agenda at the expense of other people. This linkage between Jews and evil continues in the present: in the fantasy that “the Jews” control governments with a “hidden hand,” that they own the banks, control the media, act as “a state within a state.

Making mendacious, dehumanizing, demonizing, or stereotypical allegations about Jews as such or the power of Jews as collective — such as, especially but not exclusively, the myth about a world Jewish conspiracy or of Jews controlling the media, economy, government or other societal institutions.

So when you're criticising Israel, please do so without implying Jews, Israel or anything relating to Jews is part of a plot to control things or act in evil ways generally or that Jews or any Jewish organisation have control over institutions. This isn't how other countries are spoken about and it's particularly antisemitic in line with Nazi propaganda.

POINT 2
Antisemitism can be manifested in words, visual images, and deeds. Examples of antisemitic words include utterances that all Jews are wealthy, inherently stingy, or unpatriotic. In antisemitic caricatures, Jews are often depicted as grotesque, with big noses and associated with wealth

This is one most people instinctively know is racist - to apply certain characteristics to Jews - like having lots of money or big noses etc.

POINT 3
Antisemitism can be direct or indirect, explicit or coded. For example, “The Rothschilds control the world” is a coded statement about the alleged power of “the Jews” over banks and international finance. Similarly, portraying Israel as the ultimate evil or grossly exaggerating its actual influence can be a coded way of racializing and stigmatizing Jews. In many cases, identifying coded speech is a matter of context and judgement, taking account of these guidelines

This means, don't be antisemitic when using any words which clearly refer to Jews in particular. "Jews own the banks" is antisemitic. It remains antisemitic when you substitute words, like "The Israel lobby owns the banks" or "Zionists own the banks" or "George Soros owns the banks". Substituting code words is not a free pass for being antisemitic.

POINT 4
Denying or minimizing the Holocaust

A pretty obvious one which needs no explanation.

POINT 5
Applying the symbols, images and negative stereotypes of classical antisemitism to the State of Israel

So this means taking classic antisemitic tropes or canards, such as "The Jews are puppet masters" and applying the same language to the only Jewish state. We see right through this, please don't do it!

POINT 6
Requiring people, because they are Jewish, publicly to condemn Israel or Zionism (for example, at a political meeting)

This means making a Jewish person, anywhere, anytime feel obligated, pressured or required in any way to condemn Israel or Zionism. It means you don't "put them on the spot" in public by singling them out as a Jew to ask their opinions on Israel's atrocities. Their views of these things will be coloured by a completely different perspective to yours, and likely more personal knowledge, their family history and so on - so please be respectful of their right to determine their Jewish identity and opinions without your critique.

POINT 7
Calling for, aiding, or justifying the killing or harming of Jews in the name of a radical ideology or an extremist view of religion

Another one which should be obvious, but clearly "gas the Jews" is unacceptable.

POINT 8
Accusing Jews as a people of being responsible for real or imagined wrongdoing committed by a single Jewish person or group, or even for acts committed by non-Jews

Again, fairly obvious.

POINT 9
Accusing Jewish citizens of being more loyal to Israel, or to the alleged priorities of Jews worldwide, than to the interests of their own nations

This is a common form of prejudice in Britain where Jews are frequently accused of being in on some plot with Israel, or part of a group of Jews acting against their own country for the benefit of Israel. It's madness, and please don't do it.

POINT 10
Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor

Jews, like everyone else, have a right to self-determination. If you don't make other countries feel ashamed of existing or if you don't make other groups feel ashamed of their national identity; then Jews should be entitled to the same. You are free to have your own opinion on if Israel should be a country or not, and how it should be. You are not free to deny Jews the right to decide that for themselves though.

POINT 11
Applying double standards by requiring of Israel a behavior not expected or demanded of any other democratic nation

Another very common one, where Israel is often held to a very different standard to other countries. An allowance can be made for the fact surrounding countries generally aren't democracies and as such are generally held to a different standard, but you should aim to treat Israel in the same, balanced way that you would treat any other country.

POINT 12
Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis

This is another very common one. Do not compare things which are incomparable just for the sake of hyperbole. It's very offensive. Almost every Jew in existence lost family in the Shoah. Please don't use it to attack.

Those are the things you can't do. What you can do is criticise Israel robustly, like you would any other country

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
WhatWouldJeevesDo · 20/10/2023 08:34

MadderthanMorris · 19/10/2023 20:41

@AFieldGuideToTrees

What @LemonyTicket has "quoted" appears to be a portmanteau of the two documents, choosing the parts that best suit her own definition. This has of course been accepted by every government and jewish organisation in the world (even though it's never actually appeared in precisely this form until she put it together here) because all right-thinking people (who aren't antisemites) agree with her.

You're correct that there are differences between the two, differences between which organisations have signed up to one and not the other, and criticisms by various high profile people including experts in the field and jewish academics of one or the other.

One example: One of the IHRA examples of antisemitic conduct is:

"Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor."

But the JD changes this to:

"Denying the right of Jews in the State of Israel to exist and flourish, collectively and individually, as Jews, in accordance with the principle of equality."

And then goes on to specify, in it's list of things that are NOT antisemitic:

"Criticizing or opposing Zionism as a form of nationalism, or arguing for a variety of constitutional arrangements for Jews and Palestinians in the area between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean. It is not antisemitic to support arrangements that accord full equality to all inhabitants “between the river and the sea,” whether in two states, a binational state, unitary democratic state, federal state, or in whatever form."

IOW, the IHRA equated anti-zionism with antisemitism, and said the former is by definition the latter. Many people took issue with that, and after some debate and consultation the JD revised that to say that anti-zionism, ie opposing the establishment of the specifically jewish state of Israel that expelled many of the original inhabitants of the area and denies their right of return, is NOT antisemitic. Obviously denying the current jewish inhabitants of Israel their right to live in peace and equality under ^some political structure or other" would be, but that political structure does not have to be Israel. (This seems perfectly reasonable to me).

Who'd a thunk it? It's almost like it's a complex question without a single eternally certain answer, with room for nuance, debate, disagreement and revision.

But guess which statement @LemonyTicket included in her "quote", despite pretending that the quote was basically of the JD with only some additional material from the IHRA. 😁

I see. That explains why the OP’s explanation of point 10 didn’t ring true. If the paraphrased explanation was of a different, narrower definition then it wouldn’t. Thanks

StopReligiousDivides · 20/10/2023 03:16

GrumpyPanda · 18/10/2023 19:03

Breathtaking you would call her first paragraph "bollocks" when it quite literally starts with the founding of Pakistan in 1947. Are you at all aware that the partition of India involved the forcible ethnic cleansing, on both sides, not of a mere "several hundred thousand" people but according to estimates between 10 and 20 million, not to mention up to 2 million dead? Great way to make OPs point for her.

Maybe just complete (stunning, criminal) ignorance on your part but there's very little justification for then going on to focus on Palestinian displaced at the time without even mentioning the at least equal numbers of Jews displaced from other regions of the Middle East at the exact same time. Guess they don't count, and don't fit your narrative of Ashkenazi "settlers."

I'm not sure that you can compare the formation of Pakistan/East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) with the formation of Israel. The biggest difference is that the Jewish people who had been displaced/incarcerated during WWII wanted a Jewish state. The religious differences between the people of India, exacerbated by Colonialism meant that the country had to be divided into separate states. It should also be noted that those nations don't celebrate their independence on the actual day - that day is a day of mourning. There are some excellent books available to read with first person accounts, and I can link them if you would like?

StopReligiousDivides · 20/10/2023 02:52

FloweryName · 18/10/2023 18:18

It says this on the UK government website, so I don’t think everyone does agree agree actually.

One issue identified by international partners, is the absence of an agreed international definition of antisemitism.

Personally I don’t think anyone needs the right to live in a country that is aligned to their religion. I think giving people land that has been lived on by others for centuries based on their religion is wrong, especially when it creates homelessness and suffering for people who follow a different religion. Apparently that is enough to make me anti semitic according to some people, but it won’t be enough for others.

Religion and land have been conjoined in human consciousness since the beginning of time. Whether it's paganism, Islam, Buddhism, etc., etc., all countries have had some sort of religious belief, or not, that the majority abide by. I wouldn't say that you're antisemitic for your opinion, as it's just that, your opinion but I do believe that if religious beliefs weren't so "out there" in the public consciousness then we would all get along much better! This is probably why there's that old saying about religion and politics - nothing divides people so well!

StopReligiousDivides · 20/10/2023 02:07

EdithStourton · 18/10/2023 17:42

It's certainly possible to criticise Israel without resorting to antisemitic tropes, holding Israel to an unattainable standard or denying its right to exist. I'm not Jewish, and I have managed to criticise certain actions of the state of Israel to Jewish friends without being called antisemitic.

Some of the stuff I have seen on here over the past week or so has made me wince. There appear to be a lot of people who just can't wait to put the boot into the Jews.

Op, YANBU. People need to know.
I'm staggered that currently 40% of people who have voted think otherwise.

That 40% should be taking a good hard look at themselves.

The 40% (now 49%!) may just think that there was no reason for the post and/or definitions and therefore think OP was being unreasonable.

If that is their opinion, because they already knew the definitions etc., then that is exactly just their opinion. Thus, by virtue of the fact it is an opinion, it's neither right or wrong, so they don't need to take a long hard look at themselves. What would be the reason? Because they personally don't feel the need for a post defining a particular word or phrase? I've seen a lot of assumptions on MN in the past couple of weeks. Not only about the Israel/Palestine topic but on myriads of threads. I've seen posters egg each other on, or pile on other posters. Again, on a variety of threads. A mindset seems to be emerging and that mindset seems to be that Y thing is good and Z thing is bad. Well, human nature, regardless of religious belief, isn't black and white. There's no Y is good and Z is bad. I despair of humanity right now, when we have to post definitions like this because people can't just be respectful 😔

LemonyTicket · 20/10/2023 01:14

Yep, I was also moved @etmoietmoietmoi so much so that I emailed him.

It was really touching that he acknowledged it so well and understood

OP posts:
etmoietmoietmoi · 20/10/2023 00:59

@LemonyTicket I never saw your post before I posted, but it was Martin Rowson I was thinking of!

etmoietmoietmoi · 19/10/2023 23:30

cakeorwine · 19/10/2023 22:44

I remember an incident where a cartoonist (I think) was criticised because his cartoon was said to be anti-Semitic because there was something in the image that had an association with Jewish stereotypes and the person the cartoon depicted was Jewish.

He argued that he had no idea the person was Jewish and his imagery was relevant to the news story involving the person. I had no idea the person was Jewish - and I could see how the imagery was relevant to the story.

If you don't know someone is Jewish and you associate something with them that is seen as a Jewish stereotype, is that anti-Semitic?

It is if you double down on it once you're made aware - a certain Guardian cartoonist in the news recently has done this on one occasion too many now for it to be anything other than intentional.

On the other hand, another Graun cartoonist did this and showed genuine contrition, which I actually found quite moving. Forget his name now, but it was also quite recent.

And even if you don't know someone is Jewish, there's no need to use these odious stereotypes anyway, unless you're a shit cartoonist that's devoid of ideas and originality.

LemonyTicket · 19/10/2023 23:21

Worriedmum159 · 19/10/2023 23:11

Hi @LemonyTicket i posted very early on, probably because I’m really naive to the antisemitic tropes and canards you’ve just cited. I genuinely had no idea puppets or octopi /uses were considered so. Although the hooked nose type image I would recognise as highly prejudiced.

any advice on how someone like me could recognise and challenge what seems so obvious to you? FWIW, I’m from a Romany background so i recognise the imagery which goes unnoticed and frequently enters common usage due to innocent ignorance.

Edited

I have a close Romany friend and I know you guys experience absolute twattery in this country, so first of all, sorry for that.

To answer the question: I wouldn't expect anyone to know that. I would expect a professional political cartoonist to know it though, but not the everyday person on the street.

It's built into the subconscious because people would have been exposed to antisemitic imagery their entire lives. So many people would not know they are doing it.

The trick is, I suppose, when someone tells you - just take it on board without getting angry.

The Octopus is a classic symbol from anti-Jewish images and cartoons, representing the antisemitic canard of Jewish control with it's tentacles wrapped around things.

Similarly the puppet master uses its power to control the world, whether it be the economy, the media or politics. to quote

"When a reader sees this, they are able to blame their societal position on the Jews; they couldn’t succeed in one way or another because everything is being controlled. As the antisemitic German historian Heinrich von Treitschke put it, “the Jews are our misfortune”.

I have included below a list of the most obvious canards, and if you read it you would probably observe over time how many people incorporate these things into imagery, language and the ideas they have.

Some of this stems from very old ideas - like the concept of devil worship, which was from the early days of Christianity where most people openly believed Jews were linked withe the devil, but also a lot of it comes from Nazi and Russian anti semitic propaganda.

The idea always being the same: to portray Jews as evil, sneaky, dishonest, and responsible for whatever bad things are happening in the world at any give time. You'll find once you see it, it's impossible to unsee it!

xx

https://antisemitism.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Antisemitic-imagery-May-2020.pdf

https://antisemitism.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Antisemitic-imagery-May-2020.pdf

OP posts:
Worriedmum159 · 19/10/2023 23:11

Hi @LemonyTicket i posted very early on, probably because I’m really naive to the antisemitic tropes and canards you’ve just cited. I genuinely had no idea puppets or octopi /uses were considered so. Although the hooked nose type image I would recognise as highly prejudiced.

any advice on how someone like me could recognise and challenge what seems so obvious to you? FWIW, I’m from a Romany background so i recognise the imagery which goes unnoticed and frequently enters common usage due to innocent ignorance.

LemonyTicket · 19/10/2023 23:04

cakeorwine · 19/10/2023 22:44

I remember an incident where a cartoonist (I think) was criticised because his cartoon was said to be anti-Semitic because there was something in the image that had an association with Jewish stereotypes and the person the cartoon depicted was Jewish.

He argued that he had no idea the person was Jewish and his imagery was relevant to the news story involving the person. I had no idea the person was Jewish - and I could see how the imagery was relevant to the story.

If you don't know someone is Jewish and you associate something with them that is seen as a Jewish stereotype, is that anti-Semitic?

The cartoon was extremely antisemitic.

It featured a Jewish man, with a hooked nose
It featured him carrying Rishi Sunak as a puppet (antisemitic canard)
It featured the name of a Jewish Bank with a literal octopus wrapped around it (which is one of the most antisemitic canards in existence)

The artist himself issued a fantastic statement as he was able to understand how, despite not being intention, he had drawn a severely antisemitic cartoon.

He acknowledged what few have the courage to do - that he has antisemitic stereotypes and prejudices unconsciously that spilled out of him without thinking.

I was actually so touched by his apology that I emailed him to thank him for doing what so very few people bother to do....thinking!

Here are some excerpts from the apology he wrote:

"At the end of April, I drew a cartoon, part of which included a depiction of the former BBC chairman Richard Sharp as a typical employee after being sacked, carrying out their possessions in a cardboard box. After the cartoon was published on the Guardian’s website, another wholly plausible description was posted on Twitter by Dr David Rich of the Community Security Trust, describing it as brimming with vicious antisemitic tropes.

You can read my account of what I thought I’d drawn on my website, written within hours of Rich’s initial tweet. In the same piece I apologised unconditionally and took full responsibility for the enormous hurt and upset I had unintentionally caused. But how could both things be true? I had drawn an antisemitic cartoon, yet I had not been aware I was doing so.

I could now only see what Rich and thousands of others saw, and saw it for what it was. I was now consumed with deep, devouring shame. That coming Friday, I was due to draw a cartoon covering the coronation, but by this stage I had long since lost all sense of moral authority or even agency to draw anything or judge anyone, and two days after the Sharp cartoon was published I asked for time off.
All of this matters so much because this mistake – though “car crash” comes closest in my mind to describe the jagged intermeshing of accident, chaos, loss of control, damage and huge hurt to blameless bystanders – happened within a context I’m very conscious of.

I’d like to think that I’m not even remotely antisemitic, but what do I know? As a visual artist operating in a genre dependent on exaggeration and mockery, I also swim in a swamp being constantly fed with poisonous slurry from two millennia of European Christian art portraying Jews as ugly, avaricious monsters.

Worse, 50 years ago, with the Holocaust rawly fresh in everyone’s minds, at my Anglican school the chaplain dismissed the suffering of the Jews as punishment for Christ’s crucifixion. And 25 years ago, a senior figure at a major UK charity, thinking I was Jewish because he’d mistakenly assumed “Rowson” is an anglicisation of “Rosen”, instantly told me an antisemitic joke on discovering I wasn’t. Far, far worse manifestations of antisemitism continue unabated. This is the air we breathe; the miasma many of us choke on.

Take Sharp, a friend of Boris Johnson, whom I believed I had drawn in a particular, fairly unkind way, reflecting what he does and thinks. But at the very instant that depiction was seen – as it was, whatever my intention, by many deeply shocked and frightened people – as a cruel depiction of what he is, a Jewish man in his 60s, caricatured grotesquely (though in hideously familiar ways), the power dynamic completely collapsed.

The public, satirisable appearance of Sharp dissolved to reveal the real, breathing, victimised human being beneath. Worst of all, victimised and bullied by me, in ways wholly anathema to me both personally and professionally. Carelessly and terrifyingly easily, I had utterly and comprehensively failed. It was and is inexcusable on every level.

What I do in my work is a twisted and dreadful magic, and it needs to be practised with extreme care. Over the past few weeks, clambering through the wreckage resulting from my last cartoon, I have been talking to lots of people, prominent and otherwise, from across the Jewish community both to atone and to help me understand how I could have done this terrible thing.

I thank all of them enormously for their generosity, their time and, let’s be frank, their forgiveness. And they’ve helped me learn, bit by bit and ahead of my return to these pages in September, to remember what I already knew. The business of satire has never been to give indiscriminate offence, and nor is it my job. Its price therefore must always be eternal vigilance"

What a brilliant attitude he took!

People can make mistakes, but the point is, if they listen and have empathy then they are doing well. It's the ones who shout back in denial who cause the most harm

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 19/10/2023 22:44

I remember an incident where a cartoonist (I think) was criticised because his cartoon was said to be anti-Semitic because there was something in the image that had an association with Jewish stereotypes and the person the cartoon depicted was Jewish.

He argued that he had no idea the person was Jewish and his imagery was relevant to the news story involving the person. I had no idea the person was Jewish - and I could see how the imagery was relevant to the story.

If you don't know someone is Jewish and you associate something with them that is seen as a Jewish stereotype, is that anti-Semitic?

Trulywonderful · 19/10/2023 22:43

Interesting, even if a BBC article and they barely recognised their own antisemitism (I am still annoyed about the whole slur thing. Can't even be bothered about their behaviour these days. Waste of energy to even ponder it)

UK permits antisemitism, says counter-extremism adviser

Commissioner for Countering Extremism Robin Simcox

UK permits antisemitism, says counter-extremism adviser

But security minister Tom Tugendhat takes issue with Robin Simcox's "wake-up" call on multiculturalism.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-67155942.amp

LemonyTicket · 19/10/2023 22:30

MadderthanMorris · 19/10/2023 20:41

@AFieldGuideToTrees

What @LemonyTicket has "quoted" appears to be a portmanteau of the two documents, choosing the parts that best suit her own definition. This has of course been accepted by every government and jewish organisation in the world (even though it's never actually appeared in precisely this form until she put it together here) because all right-thinking people (who aren't antisemites) agree with her.

You're correct that there are differences between the two, differences between which organisations have signed up to one and not the other, and criticisms by various high profile people including experts in the field and jewish academics of one or the other.

One example: One of the IHRA examples of antisemitic conduct is:

"Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor."

But the JD changes this to:

"Denying the right of Jews in the State of Israel to exist and flourish, collectively and individually, as Jews, in accordance with the principle of equality."

And then goes on to specify, in it's list of things that are NOT antisemitic:

"Criticizing or opposing Zionism as a form of nationalism, or arguing for a variety of constitutional arrangements for Jews and Palestinians in the area between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean. It is not antisemitic to support arrangements that accord full equality to all inhabitants “between the river and the sea,” whether in two states, a binational state, unitary democratic state, federal state, or in whatever form."

IOW, the IHRA equated anti-zionism with antisemitism, and said the former is by definition the latter. Many people took issue with that, and after some debate and consultation the JD revised that to say that anti-zionism, ie opposing the establishment of the specifically jewish state of Israel that expelled many of the original inhabitants of the area and denies their right of return, is NOT antisemitic. Obviously denying the current jewish inhabitants of Israel their right to live in peace and equality under ^some political structure or other" would be, but that political structure does not have to be Israel. (This seems perfectly reasonable to me).

Who'd a thunk it? It's almost like it's a complex question without a single eternally certain answer, with room for nuance, debate, disagreement and revision.

But guess which statement @LemonyTicket included in her "quote", despite pretending that the quote was basically of the JD with only some additional material from the IHRA. 😁

This is quite sad and embarrassing isn't it? You are trying to twist a Jewish person, sharing information about what antisemitism is to people who asked for that information into yet another sneaky plot. How sad that the only time in your life you have taken the time to actually bother investigating what antisemitism is, rather than engaging in it, is to try and "gotcha" a Jew.

But let's do this anyway for the audience!

  • I stated very clearly that I had put together an amalgamation of both lists, and referred to both throughout several times.
  • They are very close to the same, I have omitted nothing, added nothing and have only left out things where they are duplicates
  • You are wrong, the Jerusalem Declaration isn't an "update" - it is the other way around - it is the more extensive IHRA definition that is internationally enshrined, and that is accepted by most countries and governments (including this one) as the most up to date definition.
  • My post literally says at the bottom of it, underlined, that you can criticise Israel as much as you like within those guidelines. I underlined it. So no idea why you are implying I said otherwise.

This thread is intended to explain antisemitic behaviors for those who are enquiring.

It therefore, obviously, includes the current government approved version from the IHRA. This is the one in use in the UK and most of the world. The suggestion me including it's additions is somehow wrong is pathetic.

However, the Jerusalem Declarions - whilst sharing most of the same points, uses much more descriptive and wordy language which was very useful to use - hence I did.

I genuinely feel quite sick realising there are people like you and other users in the UK. It makes me scared for my children that they might encounter this sort of crap out in the world.

Shame on you.

OP posts:
Sugaristheenemy · 19/10/2023 22:21

I do wonder if there is an element of Israel being seen as “one of us” though. Your examples are all of objectively terrible regimes who don’t care about the human rights of their own populations let alone of other countries.

I view Israel as an extension of the west, so to me the citizens have the same values as Australians, Canadians etc - I would feel just as safe walking around Tel Aviv as I would Vancouver (minus the threat of rockets obviously).

There may be some truth in that. Israel was essentially created by the British Empire and a lot of the people who went there were originally European. Perhaps that is why people are more inclined to take note of what they do than a regime that has been just been one human right violation after another since the year dot.

LemonyTicket · 19/10/2023 22:05

AFieldGuideToTrees · 19/10/2023 19:48

I've just been looking into this more, both the Jerusalem Declaration of Antisemitism (JDA) and the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's (IHRA) working definition of antisemitism.

The House of Commons website states that it has adopted the IHRA's definition.

House of Commons website page

That definition being: “Antisemitism is a certain perception of Jews, which may be expressed as hatred toward Jews. Rhetorical and physical manifestations of antisemitism are directed toward Jewish or non-Jewish individuals and/or their property, toward Jewish community institutions and religious facilities.”

It includes a list of eleven "manifestations" or definitions from the IHRA website. I've listed these at the end of this post.

IHRA website definitions

And the CST (Community Security Trust), a British Jewish organisation has an article about the JDA, criticising it for its flaws.

CST Blog post by Dr Dave Rich

From what I can gather the JDA has been heavily criticised elsewhere, and it is the IHRA definition that has been adopted by numerous countries. This also has flaws, but it is the one that has been adopted.

The list of countries you've provided OP is a list of countries who have signed up to the IHRA's working definition, not the Jerusalem Declaration. The EU, UN and Council of Europe have also signed up to the IHRA definition.

The 200-odd academics who published the JD want it to replace the IHRA definition, but that has not happened.

Link to the JDA

When I read the eleven manifestations I see that you've used some (all? I haven't gone through all of them to check) of them in your examples plus some extra ones (are these from the JDA?).

So why have you said that your list is the JDA with extra ones from the IHRA? When, if anything, it's the other way around?

And why have you intimated that it's the full list of 15 points from your OP that is, quoting from your post, "the legal definition of antisemitism in most countries around the world, including this one" when it's not?

The IHRA themselves say it's a "working definition" and the House of Commons website (link above) also says that it is not enshrined into law in the UK.

Yes, it's good to highlight what antisemitism is, but don't make things up by conflating the two definitions, and saying your list that you've compiled is a legal definition when it's not. (In fact, I seem to recall in one of your posts you telling someone that it wasn't your list it was the official list!)

If you'd posted the correct information we could have at least had a discussion on the two different definitions and what the flaws are in both, and what the good parts of both are. That might have been productive.

LIST of ELEVEN MANIFESTATIONS

  • Contemporary examples of antisemitism in public life, the media, schools, the workplace, and in the religious sphere could, taking into account the overall context, include, but are not limited to:Calling for, aiding, or justifying the killing or harming of Jews in the name of a radical ideology or an extremist view of religion.
  • Making mendacious, dehumanizing, demonizing, or stereotypical allegations about Jews as such or the power of Jews as collective — such as, especially but not exclusively, the myth about a world Jewish conspiracy or of Jews controlling the media, economy, government or other societal institutions.
  • Accusing Jews as a people of being responsible for real or imagined wrongdoing committed by a single Jewish person or group, or even for acts committed by non-Jews.
  • Denying the fact, scope, mechanisms (e.g. gas chambers) or intentionality of the genocide of the Jewish people at the hands of National Socialist Germany and its supporters and accomplices during World War II (the Holocaust).
  • Accusing the Jews as a people, or Israel as a state, of inventing or exaggerating the Holocaust.
  • Accusing Jewish citizens of being more loyal to Israel, or to the alleged priorities of Jews worldwide, than to the interests of their own nations.
  • Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor.
  • Applying double standards by requiring of it a behavior not expected or demanded of any other democratic nation.
  • Using the symbols and images associated with classic antisemitism (e.g., claims of Jews killing Jesus or blood libel) to characterize Israel or Israelis.
  • Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis.
  • Holding Jews collectively responsible for actions of the state of Israel.
Edited

Yes, as I have already said when we started, my list is an amalgamation of both. The IHRA adds in some additional things, but many of them are the same on both. The Jerusalem declaration has some very helpful context.

OP posts:
MadderthanMorris · 19/10/2023 20:41

@AFieldGuideToTrees

What @LemonyTicket has "quoted" appears to be a portmanteau of the two documents, choosing the parts that best suit her own definition. This has of course been accepted by every government and jewish organisation in the world (even though it's never actually appeared in precisely this form until she put it together here) because all right-thinking people (who aren't antisemites) agree with her.

You're correct that there are differences between the two, differences between which organisations have signed up to one and not the other, and criticisms by various high profile people including experts in the field and jewish academics of one or the other.

One example: One of the IHRA examples of antisemitic conduct is:

"Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor."

But the JD changes this to:

"Denying the right of Jews in the State of Israel to exist and flourish, collectively and individually, as Jews, in accordance with the principle of equality."

And then goes on to specify, in it's list of things that are NOT antisemitic:

"Criticizing or opposing Zionism as a form of nationalism, or arguing for a variety of constitutional arrangements for Jews and Palestinians in the area between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean. It is not antisemitic to support arrangements that accord full equality to all inhabitants “between the river and the sea,” whether in two states, a binational state, unitary democratic state, federal state, or in whatever form."

IOW, the IHRA equated anti-zionism with antisemitism, and said the former is by definition the latter. Many people took issue with that, and after some debate and consultation the JD revised that to say that anti-zionism, ie opposing the establishment of the specifically jewish state of Israel that expelled many of the original inhabitants of the area and denies their right of return, is NOT antisemitic. Obviously denying the current jewish inhabitants of Israel their right to live in peace and equality under ^some political structure or other" would be, but that political structure does not have to be Israel. (This seems perfectly reasonable to me).

Who'd a thunk it? It's almost like it's a complex question without a single eternally certain answer, with room for nuance, debate, disagreement and revision.

But guess which statement @LemonyTicket included in her "quote", despite pretending that the quote was basically of the JD with only some additional material from the IHRA. 😁

AFieldGuideToTrees · 19/10/2023 19:48

I've just been looking into this more, both the Jerusalem Declaration of Antisemitism (JDA) and the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's (IHRA) working definition of antisemitism.

The House of Commons website states that it has adopted the IHRA's definition.

House of Commons website page

That definition being: “Antisemitism is a certain perception of Jews, which may be expressed as hatred toward Jews. Rhetorical and physical manifestations of antisemitism are directed toward Jewish or non-Jewish individuals and/or their property, toward Jewish community institutions and religious facilities.”

It includes a list of eleven "manifestations" or definitions from the IHRA website. I've listed these at the end of this post.

IHRA website definitions

And the CST (Community Security Trust), a British Jewish organisation has an article about the JDA, criticising it for its flaws.

CST Blog post by Dr Dave Rich

From what I can gather the JDA has been heavily criticised elsewhere, and it is the IHRA definition that has been adopted by numerous countries. This also has flaws, but it is the one that has been adopted.

The list of countries you've provided OP is a list of countries who have signed up to the IHRA's working definition, not the Jerusalem Declaration. The EU, UN and Council of Europe have also signed up to the IHRA definition.

The 200-odd academics who published the JD want it to replace the IHRA definition, but that has not happened.

Link to the JDA

When I read the eleven manifestations I see that you've used some (all? I haven't gone through all of them to check) of them in your examples plus some extra ones (are these from the JDA?).

So why have you said that your list is the JDA with extra ones from the IHRA? When, if anything, it's the other way around?

And why have you intimated that it's the full list of 15 points from your OP that is, quoting from your post, "the legal definition of antisemitism in most countries around the world, including this one" when it's not?

The IHRA themselves say it's a "working definition" and the House of Commons website (link above) also says that it is not enshrined into law in the UK.

Yes, it's good to highlight what antisemitism is, but don't make things up by conflating the two definitions, and saying your list that you've compiled is a legal definition when it's not. (In fact, I seem to recall in one of your posts you telling someone that it wasn't your list it was the official list!)

If you'd posted the correct information we could have at least had a discussion on the two different definitions and what the flaws are in both, and what the good parts of both are. That might have been productive.

LIST of ELEVEN MANIFESTATIONS

  • Contemporary examples of antisemitism in public life, the media, schools, the workplace, and in the religious sphere could, taking into account the overall context, include, but are not limited to:Calling for, aiding, or justifying the killing or harming of Jews in the name of a radical ideology or an extremist view of religion.
  • Making mendacious, dehumanizing, demonizing, or stereotypical allegations about Jews as such or the power of Jews as collective — such as, especially but not exclusively, the myth about a world Jewish conspiracy or of Jews controlling the media, economy, government or other societal institutions.
  • Accusing Jews as a people of being responsible for real or imagined wrongdoing committed by a single Jewish person or group, or even for acts committed by non-Jews.
  • Denying the fact, scope, mechanisms (e.g. gas chambers) or intentionality of the genocide of the Jewish people at the hands of National Socialist Germany and its supporters and accomplices during World War II (the Holocaust).
  • Accusing the Jews as a people, or Israel as a state, of inventing or exaggerating the Holocaust.
  • Accusing Jewish citizens of being more loyal to Israel, or to the alleged priorities of Jews worldwide, than to the interests of their own nations.
  • Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor.
  • Applying double standards by requiring of it a behavior not expected or demanded of any other democratic nation.
  • Using the symbols and images associated with classic antisemitism (e.g., claims of Jews killing Jesus or blood libel) to characterize Israel or Israelis.
  • Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis.
  • Holding Jews collectively responsible for actions of the state of Israel.

What is antisemitism?

About the IHRA non-legally binding working definition of antisemitism The IHRA is the only intergovernmental organization mandated to focus solely on Holocaust-related issues, so with evidence that the scourge of antisemitism is once again on the rise...

https://www.holocaustremembrance.com/resources/working-definitions-charters/working-definition-antisemitism

KrisAkabusi · 19/10/2023 19:04

What's wrong with the current definition?

Read back through the thread. People, including Jewish people, have disagreed with many of the points. Although a lot of posts have been deleted by Mumsnet.

crimsonfleet · 19/10/2023 18:52

Sayitaintso33 · 19/10/2023 18:50

"But for anyone with a genuine interest in understanding antisemitism, what is quoted is the Jerusalem Declaration, Initially signed by 210 scholars, which now around 350 signatories of top academics and leading experts from around the world"

I think those 210 scholars should work on a simpler definition of anti-semitism. they might find it more effective in reducing anti-semitisim..

What's wrong with the current definition?

Sayitaintso33 · 19/10/2023 18:50

LemonyTicket · 18/10/2023 17:04

I have noted those showing up to call this "Rubbish". But for anyone with a genuine interest in understanding antisemitism, what is quoted is the Jerusalem Declaration, Initially signed by 210 scholars, which now around 350 signatories of top academics and leading experts from around the world, as well as 3 additional points from the updated International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance. They are not both quoted in full as the later contains many points already on the former. So this is the full list.

These definitions have been adopted by all these countries at a national level:

Albania
Argentina
Australia
Belgium
Bosnia
Bulgaria
Canada
Colombia
Croatia
Cyprus
Czech Republic
Denmark
Estonia
Finland
France
Germany
Greecy
Guatemala
Hungary
Italy
Latvia
Lithuania
Luxumbourg
Muldova
Netherland
North Macedonia
Panama
Phillipines
Poland
Portugal
Serbia
Slovakia
Solvenia
South Korea
Spain
Sweden
Switzerland
United Kingdom
United States
Uruguay

As well as by the EU, the UN and the Council of Europe.

They are not "rubbish".

They give the legal definition of antisemitism in most countries around the world, including this one :)

"But for anyone with a genuine interest in understanding antisemitism, what is quoted is the Jerusalem Declaration, Initially signed by 210 scholars, which now around 350 signatories of top academics and leading experts from around the world"

I think those 210 scholars should work on a simpler definition of anti-semitism. they might find it more effective in reducing anti-semitisim..

LemonyTicket · 19/10/2023 18:41

MadderthanMorris · 19/10/2023 17:17

Actually you brought me into this thread by misquoting and lying about my contribution to another thread, then accusing me of being antisemitic on the basis of it.

I'm sorry your passive aggression is offended by my choosing to be clear about what I actually said and what I actually believe.

I didn't mention your name at all! You were obviously scouring. Undoubtedly as you've expressed a specific topic in the corbynite hobby of telling Jews they're wrong about antisemitism.

OP posts:
LemonyTicket · 19/10/2023 18:38

MadderthanMorris · 19/10/2023 17:47

Actually I'll say outright that I don't accept the idea that just because something is said by jewish people to be antisemitic, it therefore is. And to be clear, I'd say exactly the same thing about any other form of racism or discrimination against minorities.

A simple example should make it clear that many Mumsnet contributors, particularly, can't sustain this attitude consistently:

"If a trans person says it's transphobic, then it is transphobic."

As we all know, there's a massive industry spanning the media, medical profession, online and real life activists, expressing a particular - largely incoherent and unevidenced - set of beliefs about gender identity. And one of those beliefs is the deep harm caused to trans people by anyone expressing gender critical views. So must we all refrain from doing so because we're told it's transphobic, and we as not-trans people don't have the right to question that? Well a certain forum on Mumsnet would be a hell of a lot less active if we did. 😀

This idea of unquestionable minority authority about their own sources of offence is largely accepted across the left, but there's a simple reason why it can't work. That is that minorities are not singular entities that speak entirely and always with one voice. To return to the example above, there are plenty of trans people who are gender critical, or who have beliefs about the subject which contradict the dogma of those activists who shout loudest and claim to speak for everyone.

Returning to the issue at hand, I personally have jewish friends who believe that the state of Israel is a racist endeavour and various other things that contradict the IHRA definition of antisemitism. How many of them are there in the world? I have no idea, but I'm pretty sure my friends are not the only ones. The OP refers confidently to what "nearly all jews" think, without enlightening us exactly when somebody did a census of Every Jew In The World and exactly what the results were. And then when confronted with the fact of those jews who disagree, turns to personal attack to silence the uncomfortable facts that don't fit her narrative and verbally bulldoze over them. Because actually engaging with the argument would be so much more difficult than just calling everyone who disagrees with you an antisemite or a crackpot.

There are all kinds of reasons why people can be wrong about things, and people belonging to minorities are no different to anyone else in that respect. It's perfectly possible to acknowledge that somebody has a set of experiences you don't, and make an effort to take those into account in understanding what they say, without pretending that that makes them some fount of Absolute Truth on the subject that is beyond question.

And as has already been pointed out, if you really believe your beliefs are beyond question, WTF would you choose a forum whose specific status purpose is to question people's beliefs, on which to express them?

I don't believe my beliefs are unquestionable. There's several things I find antisemitic which aren't on the list because they've not been agreed upon in consensus.

What I do believe is that if any minority group largely believe something to be racist or discriminatory, and that's agreed by most of the experts on the topic, major institutions globally and most governments, I'd accept they:

A) likely knew more than me
B) deserved me to respect it even if I didn't agree

But, of course, many on the Corbynite left take the same attitude as you - which is why there was and contines to be a huge problem. That's why we've more or less left political life in the country I was born in.

But I guess it's more important that you get to continue to say what you want :)

OP posts:
Rehab4rightmove · 19/10/2023 18:21

I appreciate this thread and all your contributions @LemonyTicket