Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I have unreasonable expectations of SAHP role?

560 replies

Babysharkdodo123 · 18/10/2023 12:01

Currently on mat leave with 4 month old. 22 month old in nursery couple of days as no family around to help and wanted to keep routine.

Dog needed to go to vets this morning for routine boosters so I asked DH if he could take her as i would have to juggle both kids and dog. Appointment at 8.30am so before work. He said no "why couldn't I do it as he was at work earning the money" (for ref I only get SMP).

I then got asked what I was doing today (meeting friends new baby) which was met with "oh, I thought you could get through some of the laundry".

So AIBU that household maintenance ie dogs, drs appointments, cleaning, laundry, cooking, grocery shopping should be shared in non working hours? If I was at work and DCs in nursery then no one would be home to do all of these jobs so they'd have to be shared out. Just because I'm on mat leave I don't think it should be expected that I do everything and DH wakes up, leaves and earns money.

OP posts:
Jem123456789 · 19/10/2023 15:19

Do what works for you. When I was on maternity I did everything, shopping, housework, washing, ironing etc - everything - and got up with the baby during the night apart from a Saturday night. The kids were usually in bed when my hubby arrived home from work. I was quite happy with that tbh and still had loads of free time to spend doing whatever. This changed when I went back to work however and then chores were split but if you’re not working and your kids aren’t poorly then I’d expect to do the lions share at home. Having said that, if my DH could fit something like taking the dog to the vets then he would! He never got on my back about things like laundry not done either.

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 19/10/2023 15:09

IActuallyDidItMyself · 19/10/2023 15:01

So many of these posts smack of the typical MN perspective that absolutely nothing in the word could possibly be as difficult as looking after a baby / child - it’s all a bit smug and irritating. You can 100% look after children, manage a household, and have a social life if you’re a SAHP. And having a job that you have to work at 9-5 (likely longer) is hardly all that relaxing. OP booking the appointment for the vet intentionally for her husband to do before he goes to work is ridiculous. Book it for one of the days the toddler is in nursery. As a few PP have said, there is an astonishing level of entitlement in some of these posts.

@IActuallyDidItMyself , I just find it so odd that for generations women have looked after the children, done the housework the shopping and cooking and laundry and all of a sudden simply looking after the children is a full time job. Sometimes in difficult circumstances it might be but generally it really isn’t and they are being deeply unfair to their partners who do have full time jobs. Not a popular opinion on here but the truth as I see it.

howshouldibehave · 19/10/2023 15:09

I found being at home with my own brood of children much easier than being at work at looking after thirty if other people’s!

I loved all of my maternity leaves. Some people love it, others hate it-that’s fine.

IActuallyDidItMyself · 19/10/2023 15:01

So many of these posts smack of the typical MN perspective that absolutely nothing in the word could possibly be as difficult as looking after a baby / child - it’s all a bit smug and irritating. You can 100% look after children, manage a household, and have a social life if you’re a SAHP. And having a job that you have to work at 9-5 (likely longer) is hardly all that relaxing. OP booking the appointment for the vet intentionally for her husband to do before he goes to work is ridiculous. Book it for one of the days the toddler is in nursery. As a few PP have said, there is an astonishing level of entitlement in some of these posts.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 19/10/2023 14:51

Coffeerum · 19/10/2023 14:41

Having been on maternity leave twice meeting loads of mums I can honestly say I've never come across a single person who would claim they never had a one second to themselves all day.

Sitting on the sofa with a napping baby, a biscuit and a cup of tea isn't classed as down time to you?

No. It’s perfectly lovely but what I and lots of mothers crave is to be alone, not touched, and not responsible for another human being: that’s downtime.

Of course the baby napping on you is one of the easier points of the day but that phase doesn’t last long at all, and coincides neatly with the needing to recover bit, so of course you should be sitting down. It’s also only relevant if your baby does that. My first only napped in the sling, outdoors, if I kept walking. My second would have happily kept me glued to the sofa but I had my first to look after and give attention to, and answering endless “do cats fly? Where is space?” questions with a baby napping on you, and no biscuit because then the preschooler wants one too, isn’t downtime.

Plus the off-the-charts step count phase as you do pram naps before they’re old enough to train into cot naps, then the off-the-charts step count phase once they start crawling, and the can’t-sit-down-during-naps (because weaning and food prep and clearing up and the laundry suddenly doubles) phase are all just around the corner. So even if you do consider a baby snoozing on you as equivalent to a pint after work with friends, it’s got a cut-off point.

Fogwisp · 19/10/2023 14:46

Coffeerum · 19/10/2023 14:41

Having been on maternity leave twice meeting loads of mums I can honestly say I've never come across a single person who would claim they never had a one second to themselves all day.

Sitting on the sofa with a napping baby, a biscuit and a cup of tea isn't classed as down time to you?

It depends on what you call downtime. It never happened for me, as my baby only napped when being walked in the pushchair, then would wake up and want feeding if I stopped to sit in a cafe.

Also, the sheet exhaustion means if you do get time sitting down, you can't really relax or enjoy it. As for the idea of running a hoover round the home, actually I had to preserve every bit of energy I could in order to be able to manage difficult essentials like getting out or shopping. Extras like hoovering were way down the priority list.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 19/10/2023 14:44

Coffeerum · 19/10/2023 14:30

Oh for godsake doing 70% of the chores and being at home with a 4 month old and a toddler who is in nursery multiple days a week is not wrecking your mental health by trying to do it all!

Of course a coffee out with a friend is an indulgence … would it not be classed as an indulgence if the DH wanted to meet a friend after work for a pint?

Literally no one is saying every second of her day is or should be spent slaving away but the most important factor is equal down time, considering OP has the opportunity for down time during the day it also makes sense that she does more of the home
stuff too.

God you’re making it out like being at home with 1, sometimes 2 children is an impossible task.

Because most working people / people pursing gainful employment have interpersonal contacts with other adults during a regular workweek.
Whether that’s a short tea/coffee break, lunch with coworkers (or a friend), smoke breaks, team meetings, “water cooler talks” etc.

SAHM won’t have that unless they make the conscious choice to go out and meet other adults. Aka meeting a friend for coffee, mummy meet-ups etc.

and these interpersonal contacts are incredibly important for (most) people’s mental health.

I also believe that non-work related socialising is important for people that work (whether FT or PT) btw. It is simply my belief that it is much more important for the primary carers of small children / during maternity leave.

Coffeerum · 19/10/2023 14:41

spitefulandbadgrammar · 19/10/2023 14:35

considering OP has the opportunity for down time during the day
When?

Having been on maternity leave twice meeting loads of mums I can honestly say I've never come across a single person who would claim they never had a one second to themselves all day.

Sitting on the sofa with a napping baby, a biscuit and a cup of tea isn't classed as down time to you?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/10/2023 14:36

I think it's a bit different when you're on mat leave with a very young baby, possibly still recovering from the birth etc. That isn't exactly a SAHP role imo.

For an actual SAHP, I think it really just depends on what you've negotiated and agreed between you when the decision is made to have one person SAH. There are no rights and wrongs to it, just what you agree between both parties. The default arrangement is that everything needs to be shared 50/50 - earning, childcare, domestic tasks etc. Any deviation from that would need to be by mutual agreement as to what is fair from both perspectives.

Personally, I wouldn't have been willing to be sole breadwinner with DH as a SAHP unless he had been willing to take on the vast majority of the household stuff as well as childcare - I would have felt that he wasn't pulling his weight and I would have resented that. Having him at home to just do childcare would have felt really unfair to me. That isn't a judgement on anyone else, just a statement on how I would have felt.

I totally get that some people feel differently and think that a SAHP role is mainly about childcare and that everything else should be shared 50/50. I think that's totally fair enough as long as both partners are on the same page with it.

The problem only arises when one person - whether it is the WOHP or the SAHP - feels like they are doing more than their fair share, or at least that they are expected to do so. That way lies resentment and it will fester.

So personally, if you are planning to SAH post mat leave, I don't think you will find your answer to these questions on MN. The only effective way is to sit down with your DH and negotiate an arrangement that feels fair to both of you. If you can't get to that, then I guess the only option is to revert to the default position in which each of you are equally responsible for everything.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 19/10/2023 14:35

considering OP has the opportunity for down time during the day
When?

anon0007 · 19/10/2023 14:34

@Sayitaintso33 generous for him working? He's always worked. Nothing much changed for dh after I had ds. He continued to work whereas my life was turned upside down looking after ds. It was expected that I do his share of the load that was previously shared tasks because I was at home. So he had to learn quickly that I wasn't doing anymore than I usually did because I now had a baby to look after too.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 19/10/2023 14:34

@Lovepeaceunderstanding I’m on maternity leave right now. I’m not a SAHP: I’m on leave from my job. Of course the person working needs time off as well as to contribute to chores and to spend time with the family, no one is saying they don’t? But when’s OP’s time off? People are characterising her day as time off unless she’s doing chores, but at all points of the day she’s responsible for a baby, and three days of the week she’s responsible for a baby and a toddler. It doesn’t matter if she goes for a walk or has a coffee or sees a friend: it’s not time off if she’s with the children.

Her job is childcare, his job is job (his job is just beach!); she does some chores as she goes along, around her job, he apparently won’t take the dog to the vet or do laundry around his job. That’s the issue.

Coffeerum · 19/10/2023 14:30

Cornflakes44 · 19/10/2023 13:52

@Katypp trying to do it all is what wreaks women's mental health. Being told that every second of their day should be spent doing things for other people. Or that coffee with a friend or playgroups are an indulgence and if they just cleaned the bathroom while having a bath they could keep on top of it. The only solution to women burning out is men also doing their share. But that seems too radical based on a lot of the replies on here.

Oh for godsake doing 70% of the chores and being at home with a 4 month old and a toddler who is in nursery multiple days a week is not wrecking your mental health by trying to do it all!

Of course a coffee out with a friend is an indulgence … would it not be classed as an indulgence if the DH wanted to meet a friend after work for a pint?

Literally no one is saying every second of her day is or should be spent slaving away but the most important factor is equal down time, considering OP has the opportunity for down time during the day it also makes sense that she does more of the home
stuff too.

God you’re making it out like being at home with 1, sometimes 2 children is an impossible task.

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 19/10/2023 14:28

spitefulandbadgrammar · 19/10/2023 14:03

What is your “gotcha” here? Are you saying that laundry etc is OP’s job as a SAHM (she’s not, she’s on maternity leave), therefore if DH does some, OP should do some of his work? Because extrapolating from that, childcare is OP’s job…but it’s also DH’s job, since they’re his children. And OP does it all day, therefore she does lots of DH’s job. Gotcha checkmate white rabbits and no returns.

@spitefulandbadgrammar I’m saying that while on maternity leave a person is in the role of stay at home parent. I’m saying that the parent who goes out to work is as deserving of appreciation for their contribution to the household as the stay at home parent. I’m saying I’ve bought up two children and have a reasonable understanding of what’s entailed and that under most circumstances it should be possible to get through most general household tasks while at home with children. I’ve done it. I do think that not much consideration is being given to the parent who goes out to work here, they work full time and need some time off too not to mention leisure time all together as a family. The OP has one of her children in nursery two days a week for goodness sake! I’m saying that I wouldn’t blame her partner for becoming resentful which reading between the lines it sounds like he might be.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 19/10/2023 14:27

I have been a full-time mum, a full-time worker, a part-time worker, self-employed and a home worker, and being a full-time mum was the easiest and most leisurely by a county mile

But that’s your experience and your kids and your jobs. It’s not that way for everyone. I find my job a million times easier and less tiring than taking care of two children all day; I don’t find it at all leisurely. And I’m fairly slatternly and not aiming to be super mum.

It’s also easier to go for coffee with a friend in my lunch break and finish whole sentences and thoughts and hot beverages. Coffee with a friend on maternity leave isn’t downtime if you have children with you: it’s childcare with caffeine.

anon0007 · 19/10/2023 14:27

@Katypp where did I say my house was messy or that I was mother of the year?

Katypp · 19/10/2023 14:25

anon0007 · 19/10/2023 14:20

My husband learnt very quickly that my job as sahm was to our child and not maid/cleaner/chef/event planner to everyone.

Such a pompous response. I honestly don't know how you can say that with a straight face. Or are you one of those people who thinks a messy house is a badge of honour because you are too busy being mother of the year?

Sayitaintso33 · 19/10/2023 14:25

anon0007 · 19/10/2023 14:20

My husband learnt very quickly that my job as sahm was to our child and not maid/cleaner/chef/event planner to everyone.

I hoped you learnt just as quickly to thank your Dh for his generous good nature.

LolaSmiles · 19/10/2023 14:25

The only solution to women burning out is men also doing their share. But that seems too radical based on a lot of the replies on here.
To be fair have many people on this thread said men shouldn't do their share?

There's always a healthy dose of poor hard working man needs his slippers warming on housework threads, or weird posts desperate to attribute neurodiversity to good old fashioned male-pattern laziness, but I don't think expecting a parent at home to do some chores is the same as saying the other parent doesn't have to lift a finger.

Katypp · 19/10/2023 14:23

Cornflakes44 · 19/10/2023 13:52

@Katypp trying to do it all is what wreaks women's mental health. Being told that every second of their day should be spent doing things for other people. Or that coffee with a friend or playgroups are an indulgence and if they just cleaned the bathroom while having a bath they could keep on top of it. The only solution to women burning out is men also doing their share. But that seems too radical based on a lot of the replies on here.

Don't agree, sorry. I would expect exactly the same if my husband was at work, as would many on this thread I suspect. People are projecting this to be a feminist issue when it isn't - it's just a case of whoever has the most spare time should be doing the most chores so that both parties can have maximum down time. That's common sense, surely?
Having a coffee with a friend IS downtime. People are keen to describe looking after children as 'their job' but you wouldn't be able to go for coffee with friends in a 'real' job, therefore this is leisure time and to suggest it's anything else is just silly.
As I said upthread, looking after 2+ children and doing the housework used to be the norm for a lot of women, and much less of a fuss was made about it.
I have been a full-time mum, a full-time worker, a part-time worker, self-employed and a home worker, and being a full-time mum was the easiest and most leisurely by a county mile

anon0007 · 19/10/2023 14:20

My husband learnt very quickly that my job as sahm was to our child and not maid/cleaner/chef/event planner to everyone.

Goldbar · 19/10/2023 14:16

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 19/10/2023 13:59

@Babysharkdodo123 @SouthLondonMum22

I wonder how much of her husband’s work the OP does?

You should have said 'paid work'. I wonder how much of the OP's paid work her husband does?

Chores and childcare (unpaid work) are a joint responsibility, although the precise allocation might vary depending on circumstances.

All adults in a household have a responsibility to contribute towards the running of that household.

SouthLondonMum22 · 19/10/2023 14:06

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 19/10/2023 13:59

@Babysharkdodo123 @SouthLondonMum22

I wonder how much of her husband’s work the OP does?

Very similar to how much DH looks after their baby alone, I imagine.

GCSister · 19/10/2023 14:06

I wonder how much of her husband’s work the OP does?

Ridiculous comment.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 19/10/2023 14:03

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 19/10/2023 13:59

@Babysharkdodo123 @SouthLondonMum22

I wonder how much of her husband’s work the OP does?

What is your “gotcha” here? Are you saying that laundry etc is OP’s job as a SAHM (she’s not, she’s on maternity leave), therefore if DH does some, OP should do some of his work? Because extrapolating from that, childcare is OP’s job…but it’s also DH’s job, since they’re his children. And OP does it all day, therefore she does lots of DH’s job. Gotcha checkmate white rabbits and no returns.