Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I have unreasonable expectations of SAHP role?

560 replies

Babysharkdodo123 · 18/10/2023 12:01

Currently on mat leave with 4 month old. 22 month old in nursery couple of days as no family around to help and wanted to keep routine.

Dog needed to go to vets this morning for routine boosters so I asked DH if he could take her as i would have to juggle both kids and dog. Appointment at 8.30am so before work. He said no "why couldn't I do it as he was at work earning the money" (for ref I only get SMP).

I then got asked what I was doing today (meeting friends new baby) which was met with "oh, I thought you could get through some of the laundry".

So AIBU that household maintenance ie dogs, drs appointments, cleaning, laundry, cooking, grocery shopping should be shared in non working hours? If I was at work and DCs in nursery then no one would be home to do all of these jobs so they'd have to be shared out. Just because I'm on mat leave I don't think it should be expected that I do everything and DH wakes up, leaves and earns money.

OP posts:
Sayitaintso33 · 19/10/2023 05:57

Assuming you have a washing machine and a dryer or enough space to dry clothes either inside or out, then doing laundry is such an easy chore that it is odd that a married couple are arguing about it.

Childcare can be incredibly demanding, particularly when sleep deprived, but it also can be fairly easy with mornings spent meeting friends and afternoons watching DVDs (I might be showing my age, it is probably streaming on tablets now or something I am unaware of). So it depends.

It takes time getting used to the second child, but if you can get them both to a coffee shop you can get them both to the vets. The problem there seems to be the time. 8.30am was asking for trouble. Just as children vary, jobs vary. In my job I wouldn't have known 2 weeks in advance whether I could do a 8.30am vets appointment. I had to be flexible at the start of the day. But luckily my partner did the same job so we knew what was doable and sensible and what wasn't. So it depends.

SilverLining28 · 19/10/2023 05:31

Gosh there's a lot of judgement going on here. We have no idea about how each parent is finding transitioning to being parents to two DC or how much housework OP is doing during the day. She is just asking whether during non office hours is the house maintenance, admin jobs, general life tasks still all on her or should her DP also take a role.

I'm astounded how many women are still under the illusion we live in the 1950s, I'm astounded how little thought we give ourselves whilst lifting up paid work on a pedestal, and I'm also astounded how, when there is not shared responsibility whilst one parent is a SAHP, people are then surprised when it falls to the mum when she goes back to work after mat leave?!

For this specific example I'd say OPs job looks different now and, in the same way as when she was doing paid work, prioritisation needs to take place. Kids first, housework and life admin second. If there's space in the day to do housework and life admin then that can be done within reason (don't go killing herself and end up resenting DP / spiralling about how much there is to do). However we all know that plans don't really work when regulating two small humans. The vet appt time could have been discussed before making it to avoid assumptions from both parties about who would take the dog. Neither is in a good position too as it would be difficult for DP depending on the flexibility of his job and start time, and it would be difficult for OP as she will be managing an animal and two humans at an early time in the day.

In short YANBU and we should be supporting each other more. Not pulling each other down to the expectations of our grandmas.

Cowlover89 · 19/10/2023 05:22

Yanbu

Zanatdy · 19/10/2023 05:00

Well I’d have taken the dog and the baby, and did many times so don’t see the issue. Yes it’s easier without a toddler in tow but I think if you wanted your DH to take time off to do that without discussing then you’re being unreasonable. It would probably be easier to go late evening, last appointment. I’m super busy right now so if someone who was at home all day asked me to take time off for that I’d say that I could do it at a time of my convenience and would have to rebook.

re housework, yes I would expect someone on Mat leave (once over newborn period) to do most of the housework, and putting some laundry in isn’t exactly tough work. But the way he said it, unfair. He’s clearly having a dig and thinks you’ve got it easy on Mat leave.

givemeasunnyday · 19/10/2023 04:35

YaWeeFurryBastard · 18/10/2023 12:51

I’m usually fully on the side of the woman when it comes to things like this but you’re just being ridiculous. The OP has said the toddler is in nursery a few days a week and unless the baby is extremely high needs or the OP lives in a mansion that is plenty of time to keep on top of the bulk of the housework and laundry.

And as for “doing all his chores comes at the expense of bonding with the baby”, what about the father bonding with the baby?! The mother is with the baby 24/7 whereas the father has very limited time to spend with the baby, which you seem to expect him to use a significant chunk of to do chores?

In my marriage we act as a team and support each other, so of course I’d do my best to do the bulk of the chores and give my husband some breathing space and time to bond with the baby when he’s not working. Likewise he always mucks in and helps wherever he can. I can’t believe the way some people in relationships treat each other to be honest.

I agree with this. Why do young SAHMs think all they have to do is look after the children and nothing else? I have actually read threads on here with people moaning about their mothers or MILs (let's be honest, it's often MILs), saying what great lives they had, they stayed home when they had young children, blah blah blah. Maybe they did, but I can guarantee that they were doing all the household stuff as well as looking after the children (and sometimes had evening or weekend jobs).

The idea that one partner can be working for a whole day while the other one swans around, visiting friends, sending one child off to nursery, and doesn't have time to do anything else is just nuts. And yes, the same should apply if the SAHP is a male.

Beachwaves127 · 19/10/2023 04:27

Yanbu. When I was on Mat leave we really struggled to get the cat to her routine jabs vet app. We were about five months late! Which is really unlike us. Taking an animal and baby to the vets would be impossible unless it’s in walking distance maybe. Also would you even be able to? The only possible way to do any chores would probably be a sling, but I didn’t like doing any kitchen chores with baby attached to me in case I dropped a knife or something heavy. Also it’s easier to run round without a baby on you. We did the bare minimum for months.

RantyAnty · 19/10/2023 03:54

How were chores split the first time you went back from maternity leave?

Flittingaboutagain · 19/10/2023 03:45

Allthingsdecember · 18/10/2023 19:29

I’m currently a SAHP to a toddler and baby. Through the days, I meet other mum friends, take the kids to clubs/playgroups/soft play/the park, and do activities at home.

I do bits of housework when I have time (and usually slowly, since the toddler helps). Everything else is shared between me and DH on evenings and weekends.

My job is to look after the children, not to do everything around the house (though this would be different if I were still at home when they started school).

I am exactly the same. I think what threw me is the OP puts the toddler in childcare so on those days there is a lot more time even if baby is in sling to do some chores and I initially read the expectation she shouldn't do any.

WandaWonder · 19/10/2023 03:34

I was a FT SAHM for year then PT for a few years, the housework/food/washing took an hour at the day most - what on earth was I mean to be doing if not relaxing or caring for my child? caring for my child did not take a full 7 hours

so what are people doing when they work from that is equivalent to an approx. 40 work week?

Blahblah254 · 19/10/2023 03:24

spitefulandbadgrammar · 19/10/2023 00:45

What Lilliputian houses is everyone living in that hoovering takes “a minute”? And of course OP can stick a wash on and has said she does, she’s not sitting around. But four month old babies are tricksy hobbits and putting the wash on is the easy, one-minute part: hanging it all out and putting it away is the ballache if there’s a baby glued to your boob/teething and fractious/sleepless and fractious, or a toddler demanding attention who can’t be left alone with the baby for that minute. Her job is recovering from pregnancy and birth and looking after the baby, first and foremost. She is also not her husband’s employee. And if he’s so good at spotting the laundry and finding time to hound OP about it, he too could put a wash on. It only takes a minute!

This!

spitefulandbadgrammar · 19/10/2023 00:45

What Lilliputian houses is everyone living in that hoovering takes “a minute”? And of course OP can stick a wash on and has said she does, she’s not sitting around. But four month old babies are tricksy hobbits and putting the wash on is the easy, one-minute part: hanging it all out and putting it away is the ballache if there’s a baby glued to your boob/teething and fractious/sleepless and fractious, or a toddler demanding attention who can’t be left alone with the baby for that minute. Her job is recovering from pregnancy and birth and looking after the baby, first and foremost. She is also not her husband’s employee. And if he’s so good at spotting the laundry and finding time to hound OP about it, he too could put a wash on. It only takes a minute!

healthadvice123 · 18/10/2023 22:42

When i was a sahm i did the majority of the housework, because it was easy to run hoover around , stick a wash on etc when dc napped or were content on chair etc , dh worked from 7 am until 6 pm and then when home spent time with the dc normally , incl bathing etc whilst I generally cooked tea. Then weekends we both chipped in and did more thorough cleans etc. i had def more free time being at home , meeting for coffees etc where as DH was working non stop so was happy to pock up vast majority of housework mon- fri.
for me being a sahm was the best and easiest job i have ever had and my dh would of loved to of been able to be a sahd but money never allowed.
but when ae both worked if he had day off looking after dc if ill etc he would always do a bit housework as well or if he had some annual leave for childcare he would do housework alongside childcare where possible.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 18/10/2023 22:30

ASCCM · 18/10/2023 12:26

You are completely unreasonable. Your job currently is to do all the childcare and housework you possibly can. Surely you can put a wash on and hang it up during the day? I work full time and have kids but as I wfh I do pretty much all the housework and washing so I don’t really understand why you can’t?

Sure, he could have taken the dog, who arrange the appointment for that time? Why wasn’t it arrange when you have one at nursery? Better planning would help you all it sounds like!

Her ‘job’ is to recover and look after her baby before she returns to her actual job.

I work full time and have kids but as I wfh I do pretty much all the housework and washing so I don’t really understand why you can’t?

I assume that you are a single parent but op has a husband so I don’t see why she should have to do everything when there is another adult living in the house. She’s a wife not a skivvy. If my dh threw the fact that he was ‘earning the money’ back in my face while I was at home taking care of our children (and saving him a fuck-tonne on childcare) I wouldn’t have been there when he got back. He’s a fucking knobber.

HerMammy · 18/10/2023 22:27

@muggart
they might be cutting corners elsewhere- maybe they let the kids have half an hour of TV while they get their chores done, maybe they have a grandparent help out from time to time, maybe their kids sleep better because they're given bottles not breastfed etc.
you ARE judging, you're judging mothers who bottle feed, allow tv saying they are cutting corners; therefore not the gold standard mother.
None of these things is cutting corners, we all do things differently.

Duechristmas · 18/10/2023 22:26

It isn't a race to the bottom. Both are parents both have work /child related duties - the rest should be 50/50 why should it be less?

... So he works a 40 hour week, does the bedtimes, another 5 hours, then hangs out with the kids on a Saturday for another 5 hrs. Then he needs to do half the housework which you estimate to take several hours a day. When does he see friends for coffee?
After the first six weeks mat leave is convenient for childcare but it doesn't stop you picking up the slack so your partner CAN spend time with the kids when they're not working.
Your job whilst on our lovely long mat leave is to keep house. It wasn't so long ago that you went back to work when the kids were 3 months old. It's not a partnership if you're expecting your OH to work, do childcare and be a good parent, it's exploitation.

Duechristmas · 18/10/2023 22:18

In our house whoever is not out at work does the life admin and housework. It tends to fall to me too do paperwork but dh will do any jobs I outsource to him.
During mat leave the housework fell to me because I was home, when I went back to work we spread it more evenly.
I don't think it's unreasonable to get the washing done or do a vet run while you're home.

muggart · 18/10/2023 22:08

I don't think there's much value in comparing what the OP is capable of achieving on mat leave with what other posters are capable of achieving because there are so many variables that we aren't privy to.
For example, a (hypothetical) mother who keeps a perfect house and supervises multiple kids sounds impressive but they might be cutting corners elsewhere- maybe they let the kids have half an hour of TV while they get their chores done, maybe they have a grandparent help out from time to time, maybe their kids sleep better because they're given bottles not breastfed etc.
I'm not judging any of those things of course, but unless we can see all the parenting decisions collectively then it makes no sense to say that just because another mother gets the laundry done everyday then every mother should be able to. The mother that doesn't get the laundry done every day could possibly just as easily judge the organised mum for something else.

What matters is that both the OP and her DH are doing their best to pull their weight, and that any imbalance is addressed. If it's too much for them to collectively handle despite their best efforts then they need to see about getting outside help.

itsalongwaybackfromsorry · 18/10/2023 21:55

ASCCM · 18/10/2023 12:26

You are completely unreasonable. Your job currently is to do all the childcare and housework you possibly can. Surely you can put a wash on and hang it up during the day? I work full time and have kids but as I wfh I do pretty much all the housework and washing so I don’t really understand why you can’t?

Sure, he could have taken the dog, who arrange the appointment for that time? Why wasn’t it arrange when you have one at nursery? Better planning would help you all it sounds like!

Agreed

Yes, he should be splitting childcare and household stuff when he's not working so you both get breaks, etc, but you should be doing a lot of this stuff during the week to free up time for both of you at weekends.

Dacadactyl · 18/10/2023 21:45

If you intend to return to work, you are not a SAHP in my eyes and so should continue to share chores as you did prior to the kids coming along.

GreenFields07 · 18/10/2023 21:45

YABVVU
Sorry but I was on maternity leave with newborn twins and a 3.5yo and still managed to keep on top of the laundry and cleaning etc. No I didnt do it everyday, but I did it enough that it didn't become too much.
Your DH is not unreasonable to expect a little more from you when youre at home and hes out at work. My DH still helped out alot and did his fair share but I also acknowledged it was easier for me. I was able to leave the kids for a few minutes here and there to pop the washing machine on or run the hoover. Its not impossible and shouldn't even be an issue.
Now im back at work and wfh I can still manage to keep on top of the laundry and cleaning, even whilst working 8 hours a day. Its not even about him being a man and having these expectations from you as a woman, its about doing the right thing and taking responsibility instead of making excuses. You cant tell me that its impossible to spend a few minutes doing household chores, sounds more like you just dont want to

JRM17 · 18/10/2023 21:42

Of course you should be doing the household jobs you are the one at home, you should also be booking any necessary appointments for times that are more manageable. I would hardly expect my husband to go to work all day then come home and do jobs that could have been doing while I was at home. Obviously you should have some time to go and do things with friends but that doesn't mean everything at home just gets left.

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 18/10/2023 21:37

Cornflakes44 · 18/10/2023 12:39

Why is her job to do all the childcare and housework? She has a full time job looking after the kids during the day. Two small kids means all hands on deck, all the time. As soon as he's not in work he should also be doing childcare and housework. Doing all his chores for him comes at the expense of bonding with baby, recovering from birth/ pregnancy and giving attention to toddler - the point of mat leave. The reason women burn out so quickly is because of this bollocks, and the idea they should do everything and men should be protected from it. If he didn't want to look at after his own children or do housework he shouldn't have had a family.

This! ☝️

MystyLuna · 18/10/2023 21:33

When I first gave birth to my son I was a stay at home mum and my husband worked full time. For the first 18 months I was in a lot of physical pain so I struggled with things like hoovering. However because my husband worked full time I did the majority of the housework focusing on the important things. I always made sure we had clean dishes, bottles and clothes and that my son always had milk and food. My husband would do the things that were too painful for me to do like hoovering, taking the rubbish out etc.
Our son is disabled so 12 years later he still requires 24 hour care but my husband and I have changed roles a couple times over the years.
We tried both working part time so we could share our son's care a bit more.
Now I work full time and my husband is a stay at home parent.
We have 3 dogs and get text from the vets one month before their boosters are due. At 3 different times during the year.
My husband just calls the vets and makes an appointment that is convenient to him.
Usually about 9.30 in the morning so it is after our son has gone to school but early enough so my husband still has time to do whatever he wants during the day.
It isn't difficult to organise a vet appointment at a convenient time.
If after a long stressful day at work if I then found out I didn't have any clean clothes to wear to work the next day I would probably be slightly annoyed if my husband just couldn't be bothered to do any washing. It takes minutes to put clothes in the washing machine. I usually put my son's school clothes onto wash every evening on a quick 15 minute wash but a 15 minute wash isn't long enough for a full load. I also do bath times and a few other quick jobs but my husband does the main bulk of the housework, shopping, phone calls, school stuff, due to him being a stay at home parent and me working full time. He still manages to find time every day to watch TV, speak to friends and work on his car and go swimming with our son's school once a week.

billy1966 · 18/10/2023 21:04

Sounds like with his new promotion he thinks he is also your boss.

How convenient that he is now expecting you to do even more with two children and ongoing recovery.

He sounds like a bit of a dick with his attitude.

Get back to work asap and hand more over to him.

His attitude would give me the ick.

Let him do his own laundry.

CurlewKate · 18/10/2023 20:58

As I said earlier-when I was a SAHP I prioritised family time and dp spending time with his children and free time for me. When he wasn't at work I wanted him to be with his children, not hoovering. And I wanted to spend the weekend either doing family stuff or lying on the sofa reading and drinking wine on my ownZ