Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I have unreasonable expectations of SAHP role?

560 replies

Babysharkdodo123 · 18/10/2023 12:01

Currently on mat leave with 4 month old. 22 month old in nursery couple of days as no family around to help and wanted to keep routine.

Dog needed to go to vets this morning for routine boosters so I asked DH if he could take her as i would have to juggle both kids and dog. Appointment at 8.30am so before work. He said no "why couldn't I do it as he was at work earning the money" (for ref I only get SMP).

I then got asked what I was doing today (meeting friends new baby) which was met with "oh, I thought you could get through some of the laundry".

So AIBU that household maintenance ie dogs, drs appointments, cleaning, laundry, cooking, grocery shopping should be shared in non working hours? If I was at work and DCs in nursery then no one would be home to do all of these jobs so they'd have to be shared out. Just because I'm on mat leave I don't think it should be expected that I do everything and DH wakes up, leaves and earns money.

OP posts:
Cornflakes44 · 19/10/2023 07:40

spitefulandbadgrammar · 19/10/2023 07:29

So if you’re on maternity leave you’ve swapped your job for childcare. Fine. Let’s pretend that’s a straight swap. On top of that, though, you’re adding the recovery from pregnancy and childbirth. On top of that maybe you’re adding lactating and learning to breastfeed (and teaching an infant to!) Plus now you have a night shift as well. And your day starts earlier than before and finishes later. And once you’ve got breastfeeding settled there’s only a short window before you add weaning and all the cleaning that comes with it. Then they’re crawling, cruising, climbing and can’t be left alone for a second. But on top of this you’re meant to suddenly start doing the bulk of household chores that were previously shared more equitably? Because the man is working? So you get nine months reduced pay, career damage and reduced pension contributions, and all the extra work, and he gets nine months break from his chores, and probably doesn’t pick them up when you go back to work? Why? What’s the point of him, then?

This, completely.

Appleontherocks · 19/10/2023 07:34

LolaSmiles · 19/10/2023 07:25

Your baby won't learn to be put down unless you teach them. You can get a sling which helps you carry a baby while doing work. You can encourage your child to be confident out of your arms but within sight.
I agree with this.
When there's threads like why can't I get anything done with my 5 year old. They won't play on their own so don't suggest that it's always eye opening how many people seem to think that other parents are naturally blessed with 5 year olds who can colour or play with Lego or watch a show on cbeebies without having parent as entertainer. It's obviously never crossed their mind that getting shit done with an older child comes from years of age-appropriate down time.

The culture of (usually mum) mum guilt, marketing of baby classes, sensory play and all that guff have done a number on us. It's all based on the idea that if you're a good parent you'll sign them up to sensory classes, baby music, baby massage, baby yoga, have a beautiful tuff tray on the go, have the perfect play shelf set up.

Babies get sensory experience from the world around them. They don't need class after class and beautifully created enriching activities one after the other for every waking minute.

It's the norm in many parts of the world to babywear an infant and have them with you doing whatever the parents are doing. It seems like a fairly modern UK/western world thing to act like loading the dishwasher or hanging laundry out is impossible because baby.

I see it all the time where parents now bring toys and activities to entertain their kids on a short train ride through London. Literally little penelope and maximillian on the floor of the train doing some sort of puzzle thing. Fucking crazy!

babyproblems · 19/10/2023 07:34

I’ve done a complex vets appointment with a toddler and can confirm it’s carnage. The vet was very kind and gave him some equipment so he could ‘help’. You can imagine the scene. I was v apologetic.
DH did childcare the next time!!!!!

spitefulandbadgrammar · 19/10/2023 07:29

So if you’re on maternity leave you’ve swapped your job for childcare. Fine. Let’s pretend that’s a straight swap. On top of that, though, you’re adding the recovery from pregnancy and childbirth. On top of that maybe you’re adding lactating and learning to breastfeed (and teaching an infant to!) Plus now you have a night shift as well. And your day starts earlier than before and finishes later. And once you’ve got breastfeeding settled there’s only a short window before you add weaning and all the cleaning that comes with it. Then they’re crawling, cruising, climbing and can’t be left alone for a second. But on top of this you’re meant to suddenly start doing the bulk of household chores that were previously shared more equitably? Because the man is working? So you get nine months reduced pay, career damage and reduced pension contributions, and all the extra work, and he gets nine months break from his chores, and probably doesn’t pick them up when you go back to work? Why? What’s the point of him, then?

FloofCloud · 19/10/2023 07:29

It's a hell of a lot easier for you to sort laundry out on the day, shopping, cooking etc. When DH gets home all jobs are shared. Even if you're out seeing a friend you can easily fit in laundry

Vet trip would be tricky with kids so book at a sensible time

It's all about pulling together, not snickering at each other

LolaSmiles · 19/10/2023 07:25

Your baby won't learn to be put down unless you teach them. You can get a sling which helps you carry a baby while doing work. You can encourage your child to be confident out of your arms but within sight.
I agree with this.
When there's threads like why can't I get anything done with my 5 year old. They won't play on their own so don't suggest that it's always eye opening how many people seem to think that other parents are naturally blessed with 5 year olds who can colour or play with Lego or watch a show on cbeebies without having parent as entertainer. It's obviously never crossed their mind that getting shit done with an older child comes from years of age-appropriate down time.

The culture of (usually mum) mum guilt, marketing of baby classes, sensory play and all that guff have done a number on us. It's all based on the idea that if you're a good parent you'll sign them up to sensory classes, baby music, baby massage, baby yoga, have a beautiful tuff tray on the go, have the perfect play shelf set up.

Babies get sensory experience from the world around them. They don't need class after class and beautifully created enriching activities one after the other for every waking minute.

It's the norm in many parts of the world to babywear an infant and have them with you doing whatever the parents are doing. It seems like a fairly modern UK/western world thing to act like loading the dishwasher or hanging laundry out is impossible because baby.

LAMPS1 · 19/10/2023 07:22

Sounds like a lot of resentment on both sides…a kind of race to the bottom about who can get away the most, with ignoring the normal domestic work of the household.
Specifically, the 8.30am vet appointment would be difficult with a toddler and a new baby …but doable with a bit of forward planning. If the dog is suffering, I would expect you both to be keen to take it to the vet instead of both dragging your heels. If it’s routine, simply arrange a more convenient time.
And I see no reason why you can’t sort the laundry pile up before it even becomes a problem if you aren’t out of the house all day. It’s harder to get on top of it all if you let it mount up.

A bit of understanding from each of you over the other’s situation would help.
Have you stopped communicating ?

Iwishicouldflyhigh · 19/10/2023 07:22

I have to say that if roles were reversed , I was going out to work and DH was as at home and planning on going out socialising whilst there was a huge mound of laundry, that is expect him to do that before he went out and I woujd not expect to have to do it when I’d been at work all day.

I wouldn’t expect him to not go out and have fun, but I would definitely expect to have at least the bare minimum of chores completed.

Blahblah254 · 19/10/2023 07:20

SilverLining28 · 19/10/2023 05:31

Gosh there's a lot of judgement going on here. We have no idea about how each parent is finding transitioning to being parents to two DC or how much housework OP is doing during the day. She is just asking whether during non office hours is the house maintenance, admin jobs, general life tasks still all on her or should her DP also take a role.

I'm astounded how many women are still under the illusion we live in the 1950s, I'm astounded how little thought we give ourselves whilst lifting up paid work on a pedestal, and I'm also astounded how, when there is not shared responsibility whilst one parent is a SAHP, people are then surprised when it falls to the mum when she goes back to work after mat leave?!

For this specific example I'd say OPs job looks different now and, in the same way as when she was doing paid work, prioritisation needs to take place. Kids first, housework and life admin second. If there's space in the day to do housework and life admin then that can be done within reason (don't go killing herself and end up resenting DP / spiralling about how much there is to do). However we all know that plans don't really work when regulating two small humans. The vet appt time could have been discussed before making it to avoid assumptions from both parties about who would take the dog. Neither is in a good position too as it would be difficult for DP depending on the flexibility of his job and start time, and it would be difficult for OP as she will be managing an animal and two humans at an early time in the day.

In short YANBU and we should be supporting each other more. Not pulling each other down to the expectations of our grandmas.

This!

Spottyblobby · 19/10/2023 07:17

YABU I would expect that once the initial physical recovery of birth is done & you are out of the woods to some extent (3 + months in, some semblance of routine etc) then household chores/life admin would become more of the stay at home persons day. 2 reasons

  1. Stay at home person gets to spend more time with baby, working parent once home should just hold/coo over/ have some time with baby to bond/get to know each other. That bond is more important than household chores being 50/50.
  2. You chose to have a baby with your lovely partner, I am assuming you quite like them? Why would you want your evenings & weekends to be spent doing chores when it could be spent doing things together? Why not smash as much of that stuff out as possible during the day so that in an evening you can chat/have a bottle of wine together etc. rather than doing chores.
I will add as a caveat, when I had a baby at home my older one was at school so this is a big difference which I respect. If your day is that overwhelming & there is physically no time in the day for housework I would consider doing a month of shared parental leave (you can return for a month on full pay/he stays home that month on SPP) it’s a great way to understand the challenges that each other is facing & come back with a greater deal of empathy. Everyone I know that has used SPL has found it to be a positive experience.
Wowzerdowzer · 19/10/2023 07:13

The thing with me is that I'd WANT to be on top of all the laundry and cleaning. When my dc were small , I'd get up and do everything house related ( took an hour max) then get on with my day. I also had them a year apart and could always shower and eat AND get some down time, never had to replace one with the other. Think you need to manage your time better.
Oh and as for the dog that's his job

Tryingmybestadhd · 19/10/2023 07:04

If you where a sahm the whole time while he either then o would say most if the household chores would be your but as you are on maternity leave then your “ job “ is recover and take care of the baby

Appleontherocks · 19/10/2023 07:03

"They spout things like 'put the baby in the baby chair and let her watch you unload the dishwasher' or 'clean the bathroom whilst the toddler plays nicely'. They think SAHPing involves loads of 'leisure'/'relaxing' time because they don't ever attempt to do too much with the children and don't have a baby that they literally can't put down."

Your baby won't learn to be put down unless you teach them. You can get a sling which helps you carry a baby while doing work. You can encourage your child to be confident out of your arms but within sight.

Keeping a clean and tidy organised home is how you make time and space to do fun things with your kids while still teaching them the skills needed to be clean and lead a home.

Missdemeanorz · 19/10/2023 07:02

Cornflakes44 · 18/10/2023 12:39

Why is her job to do all the childcare and housework? She has a full time job looking after the kids during the day. Two small kids means all hands on deck, all the time. As soon as he's not in work he should also be doing childcare and housework. Doing all his chores for him comes at the expense of bonding with baby, recovering from birth/ pregnancy and giving attention to toddler - the point of mat leave. The reason women burn out so quickly is because of this bollocks, and the idea they should do everything and men should be protected from it. If he didn't want to look at after his own children or do housework he shouldn't have had a family.

Two small children don't require 24/7 attention. Socialising isn't a chore. I don't understand why some people stress over laundry or housework.
Why leave everything and then play the let's divide game when the other arrives home?
Madness.

Hibiscrubbed · 19/10/2023 06:59

If my husband dared ask me what I was doing today, checking up on my productivity and making suggestions about domestic shit I ‘should’ be doing, like he’s my fucking manager, I’d be straight back to work.

Bumpitybumper · 19/10/2023 06:43

YANBU though loads of posters will suggest you are.

Maternity leave and SAHPing doesn't come with a job description so people will approach it completely differently. For some, it's a menial role where you focus first and foremost on domestic chores and keeping in top of the children/cooking/daily load. They often see childcare as quite a passive activity and are lucky enough to have babies and children that don't demand an insane amount of attention. They spout things like 'put the baby in the baby chair and let her watch you unload the dishwasher' or 'clean the bathroom whilst the toddler plays nicely'. They think SAHPing involves loads of 'leisure'/'relaxing' time because they don't ever attempt to do too much with the children and don't have a baby that they literally can't put down.

SAHPing and Maternity Leave can be all consuming. If you have a baby that wants to be continually held and an intense toddler that needs constant input. It's also about the childcare standards you set for yourself. If you are keen to socialise the children through taking them to clubs, making sure they get out and about every day and giving them new experiences then it is obviously going to be infinitely harder to get housework done than if you were to rarely leave the house.

The idea that expending energy looking after your children and enriching their lives is 'lazy' whilst prioritising housework is admirable is ridiculous. It is all rooted in misogyny and women proving their worth to men. Devoting your energy and time towards your kids doesn't help your partner whilst doing all the chores saves him time. Once again, sadly, it all boils down to men and what value women add to them.

rwalker · 19/10/2023 06:33

I think the arsey response was probably because the dog was booked for at ridiculous time then dumped on him

as for other stuff irrespective if it was my wife or me the one at home has always done the lions share of not all of the house stuff

Soontobe60 · 19/10/2023 06:31

Babysharkdodo123 · 18/10/2023 13:15

Vet apt was organised two weeks ago purposely for before work and emailed to him to put in his calendar. He ignored email and never put it in.

As for what do I expect to be doing? Entertaining a toddler and a baby? What would a toddler do all day at nursery? I want to be taking them out to enriching activities not sat at home all day whilst I do laundry and cleaning! I'm totally not adverse to cleaning and laundry and do them all as I'm going along anyway. What I'm adverse to is the expectation that the SAHP does everything because the other parent works. Also, I do chores etc where I can when baby naps but during that time I also have to eat, shower drink etc. I don't see working parents having to use their lunchbreak to decide whether to shower, mop the floor or eat?

Maybe you could arrange shared parental leave and let your dp spend a month at home whilst you return to work?
You’ve got 2 babies and a dog. Life will be busy. It does sound a bit like you’re scoring points - why on earth did you arrange a non urgent vets appointment at such a bad time for him to have to take the dog? A simple conversation would have been helpful! ‘Hey DP, dog’s vaccination is due, can you take him?’ Would have solved that issue.
My guess is that the laundry is piling up hence the comment about it. It happens! However, what you both do about it is important. Perhaps if you’re so adamant that you’re not doing it in the week as you’re looking after the baby, one day at the weekend he could spend looking after them whilst you get it all done? Or are you expecting him to do it instead of spending quality time with the babies?
You both need to sit down and sort this out before it becomes a massive issue.

Appleontherocks · 19/10/2023 06:30

"It takes time getting used to the second child, but if you can get them both to a coffee shop you can get them both to the vets."

Key message.

LolaSmiles · 19/10/2023 06:29

I'm amazed that someone at home putting a load of laundry on gains cries of "1950's".

If I went by some of this thread DH and I did shared parental leave all wrong. We both managed to load the dishwasher or put the washing on whilst looking after DC. We both had days where nothing was done before DC were hard work, our house was far from spotless, but I don't think either of us would have been impressed if the general message was that making memories is more important than cleaning. DC don't seem to be ruined for life because we hung some washing on the line instead of ensuring there's a packed day of enriching activities from birth.

Appleontherocks · 19/10/2023 06:27

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 19/10/2023 06:24

I only have one DC, but once she started being able to move I couldn't do vets visits with her (lively dog and lively toddler, almost impossible to keep them both safe), so two and a dog I can imagine being really difficult.

I work PT and mostly from home, so I do do most of the washing etc. But the days I have the toddler, sometimes I might get housework done if she's in a mood to "help", sometimes it's impossible because she's clingy or running around like a hurricane etc. When I was on mat leave I did more because I did it while she was napping and it meant DH could come in and have his time with her. Now, we share it all. If it needs doing, one of us does it. End of.

This is ridiculous.

Why isn't your dog heel trained and walking on a lead appropriately?

I'd be able to take my staff and my DDB to the vet together, with any of my babies or toddlers.

Why are you people's kids and dogs so badly behaved?

MrsAmaretto · 19/10/2023 06:26

I wfh and yes I do chores for a bit during my lunch break. When I work in the office I go to the post office/ return library books etc 🤷‍♀️ Your dh should have dropped the dog to the vet, Job + wife on maternity leave does not mean he gets to act like a 1950s husband.

Appleontherocks · 19/10/2023 06:26

Babysharkdodo123 · 18/10/2023 13:15

Vet apt was organised two weeks ago purposely for before work and emailed to him to put in his calendar. He ignored email and never put it in.

As for what do I expect to be doing? Entertaining a toddler and a baby? What would a toddler do all day at nursery? I want to be taking them out to enriching activities not sat at home all day whilst I do laundry and cleaning! I'm totally not adverse to cleaning and laundry and do them all as I'm going along anyway. What I'm adverse to is the expectation that the SAHP does everything because the other parent works. Also, I do chores etc where I can when baby naps but during that time I also have to eat, shower drink etc. I don't see working parents having to use their lunchbreak to decide whether to shower, mop the floor or eat?

Sorry but you're really lazy. Showing your kids how to keep a clean house is part of raising them. You don't show your kids that life is just playing all day and going our for coffee with your mates. Let your kids see the house get cleaned and smell fresh from first thing. Let them see an empty laundry basket. Not just you plonked on the sofa playing with their rattle and eating their rusks.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 19/10/2023 06:24

I only have one DC, but once she started being able to move I couldn't do vets visits with her (lively dog and lively toddler, almost impossible to keep them both safe), so two and a dog I can imagine being really difficult.

I work PT and mostly from home, so I do do most of the washing etc. But the days I have the toddler, sometimes I might get housework done if she's in a mood to "help", sometimes it's impossible because she's clingy or running around like a hurricane etc. When I was on mat leave I did more because I did it while she was napping and it meant DH could come in and have his time with her. Now, we share it all. If it needs doing, one of us does it. End of.

Firebug007 · 19/10/2023 06:18

Maternity leave isn't being a SAHP FFS!