Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I have unreasonable expectations of SAHP role?

560 replies

Babysharkdodo123 · 18/10/2023 12:01

Currently on mat leave with 4 month old. 22 month old in nursery couple of days as no family around to help and wanted to keep routine.

Dog needed to go to vets this morning for routine boosters so I asked DH if he could take her as i would have to juggle both kids and dog. Appointment at 8.30am so before work. He said no "why couldn't I do it as he was at work earning the money" (for ref I only get SMP).

I then got asked what I was doing today (meeting friends new baby) which was met with "oh, I thought you could get through some of the laundry".

So AIBU that household maintenance ie dogs, drs appointments, cleaning, laundry, cooking, grocery shopping should be shared in non working hours? If I was at work and DCs in nursery then no one would be home to do all of these jobs so they'd have to be shared out. Just because I'm on mat leave I don't think it should be expected that I do everything and DH wakes up, leaves and earns money.

OP posts:
Hayliebells · 19/10/2023 09:53

To a degree I think YANBU, but then also a bit that YABU. It depends how demanding and full on your baby is really. If you're exhausted from lack of sleep, your baby isn't a napper etc, then you can't be expected to squeeze laundry into your day when you struggle to get enough rest. If however your baby sleeps well at night and it's napping for three hours a day, you should be able to do some housework. That's presuming you share childcare when your DH isn't working, if not then he needs to pull his weight more. With regards to things like the vets appointment, if it's something you can't easily do with kids in tow, I'd give your DH a choice, he can either take the dogs to the vets, or look after the kids. Noone needs to do both if you book the appointments for times when he's also available.

Boymum2104 · 19/10/2023 09:51

Sounds like you have an unreasonable DH. I am on maternity leave. Yes I do majority of laundry and household chores etc but DH would never comment or criticise. He would never expect me to be staying in doing chores over going out for the day.

JLM1981 · 19/10/2023 09:47

I'm currently on maternity leave with 4 children under 9. I do all of the life admin, appointments, laundry. I have a year off and feel I should- however it does annoy me when DH gives me direction e.g ' can you make sure such and such is cleaned today'. My baby tends to sleep 2 hours in the morning so I get all the laundry and cleaning done then and in the afternoon I get a coffee date or a bit shopping done before collecting the older children from primary school. If I didn't have such a good baby I would feel differently maybe but I do think the balance works. At the weekend when DH is off he shares the housework but Mon-Fri I cover everything.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 19/10/2023 09:47

ASCCM · 18/10/2023 12:26

You are completely unreasonable. Your job currently is to do all the childcare and housework you possibly can. Surely you can put a wash on and hang it up during the day? I work full time and have kids but as I wfh I do pretty much all the housework and washing so I don’t really understand why you can’t?

Sure, he could have taken the dog, who arrange the appointment for that time? Why wasn’t it arrange when you have one at nursery? Better planning would help you all it sounds like!

Are you out of your mind?

her job is to bond with the baby. And to provide a positive and stimulating environment to the 22 month old.

her job is definitely not to do all the housework that would have been shared if both of them were still working FT.
and she definitely should not prioritise housework or chores (like bringing the dog to the vet) over childcare.

As for why couldn't I do it as he was at work earning the money. Well, that clearly shows that he values his contribution (money) more than keeping their children alive, happy and bonded to their primary carer.

ThriceInALifetime · 19/10/2023 09:41

Does he ever look after the children on his own? I think when he's off you need to go out and leave him with the kids so he knows how hard it is.
My two are 21 months apart so had a baby and toddler too,it was so difficult especially as the baby didn't sleep for the first year.
Are you planning on going back to work? You can't be expected to do everything. My DH and I both worked 12 hour shifts. So he was looking after them on his own and knew how hard it was.
I had to get out most days too to take them to the park or classes,for my sanity as well!

SilverLining28 · 19/10/2023 09:40

What a sad view of the world and what a negative way to frame your opinion.

Don't listen OP. What you do in a week is most definitely not the definition of lazy. It sounds as though you're going to have well rounded children and fond memories of mat leave rather than looking back and thinking what did you do, because let's face it nobody remembers the laundry they put on 3 weeks ago and whether the floor was sparkling.

InchResting · 19/10/2023 09:38

CurlewKate · 19/10/2023 09:04

This is such a non Mumsnet thing to say and think. But when I was a SAHM I was aware that my dp was doing a shit commute and working at a very hard stressful job and missing his children fiercely, my job involved a lot of playing in the park in the sun with those children and drinking coffee with my friends. Obviously there were tough bits to my job too-but the good bits were so very good.
Also- on my bad days, I knew that he would come home and happily take those children and do whatever needed to be done with them. I would a million times rather cook some dinner than spend another second with those children! 🤣 So fair does not mean equal.

And I am so sorry so many people seem to have had a shit time raising small children.

This was my experience, too. Raising small children was bloody brilliant - by far the best and most rewarding and most fun thing I have ever done. I might have felt differently if I'd also had to work.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 19/10/2023 09:37

@Katy123456 This is very sensible and something easily forgotten when both parties do invisible work! I think the best division of labour really is when one person does the whole of a task and the other person does the whole of another task – rather than taking it in turns to put a wash on, dry a wash, put it away. I find that just leads to either one person bearing the brunt of it if they’re a “just do it” type versus a “I’ll get round to it” type, or neither of you do it because you expect the other to pick up the task.

In the case of the vet appointment, if the agreement was the DH was meant to take the dog, he then should also have been the one to book it and put it in the calendar, owning the whole task.

TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 19/10/2023 09:34

If you are on maternity leave then presumably you are still financially providing.
To then be expected to do all the childcare and all the housework seems an unfair division.

Katy123456 · 19/10/2023 09:21

Your not being unreasonable, but neither is he. With two kids and a dog, and work for one of you, there is just a lot to do and it's easy to both feel like your doing more than your fair share.

I find that we resolve this type of thing a lot easier if we both come at it with the above attitude.

SouthLondonMum22 · 19/10/2023 09:16

There's a difference between SAHP and maternity leave. I never considered myself a SAHP when on maternity leave.

If someone is at home more and currently not working, it does make sense for them to do a little more at home but when on maternity leave, I wouldn't expect them to be doing every single thing.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 19/10/2023 09:13

Appleontherocks · 19/10/2023 06:27

This is ridiculous.

Why isn't your dog heel trained and walking on a lead appropriately?

I'd be able to take my staff and my DDB to the vet together, with any of my babies or toddlers.

Why are you people's kids and dogs so badly behaved?

They're both very well behaved, thank you. But the vets is a place that can cause the best behaved dogs to act out, because they can be afraid of it. And at our vets, there's occasions they'll ask you to hold the dog while they do things. I'm not willing to risk my toddler (who isn't even 2 yet) getting hurt because I have to hold onto and reassure my dog, who's possibly having an injection, and therefore don't have enough arms to stop the toddler from getting in the way because she's curious, or worried about her best friend (dog) being upset.

You do you though, I'm not judging you for doing what I don't consider safe. Don't judge me for doing what I DO consider to be safe. Jog on.

YouJustDoYou · 19/10/2023 09:10

SAHP here, husband out the country a lot, no family, no help, 3 kids under 3 years old. You just strap a kid on you, and you just get on with it.

CobwebsAndCauldrons · 19/10/2023 09:04

Wherever possible, children should not be in vets - imo. The animals (esp the dogs) there are often very scared, stressed and there is a liklihood they are also in pain. That makes them behave in ways they wouldn't normally and the presence of a child may stress them further (lots of dogs not that used to children) and or react if the child gets too close. Waiting rooms are often small and vets often run late in my experience - and all that makes it even harder to keep everyone safe and happy.

CurlewKate · 19/10/2023 09:04

This is such a non Mumsnet thing to say and think. But when I was a SAHM I was aware that my dp was doing a shit commute and working at a very hard stressful job and missing his children fiercely, my job involved a lot of playing in the park in the sun with those children and drinking coffee with my friends. Obviously there were tough bits to my job too-but the good bits were so very good.
Also- on my bad days, I knew that he would come home and happily take those children and do whatever needed to be done with them. I would a million times rather cook some dinner than spend another second with those children! 🤣 So fair does not mean equal.

And I am so sorry so many people seem to have had a shit time raising small children.

MarkWithaC · 19/10/2023 09:02

grayhairdontcare · 18/10/2023 12:57

I would expect most basic household drudgery to be done.
I would also expect two adults not to book the vets for a time that no one can do

It’s not a time no one can do; he just didn’t want to do it.

crumblingschools · 19/10/2023 09:02

@NumbersEverywhere there is a difference between maternity leave and being SAHP. You don’t go on maternity leave to do chores. It is a legal right to have maternity leave. The whole point of maternity leave is to recover from the birth and then have time with the baby. Then becoming a SAHP is a choice

InchResting · 19/10/2023 08:58

SAHP should do the bulk of domestic stuff, including taking the dog to the vet. I count 'parent on maternity leave' as SAHP for the purposes of this thread. Being a SAHP is brilliant fun. You get to choose what you do, and when, and with whom. You can see friends and drink at least one mouthful of tea and manage half a sentence before a small person needs something. You can be outside a lot. No annoying boss is telling you what to do, and if you want to stay at home all day, you can. The payoff for that is that you have to do more domestic shit. Or the minimum, if you're that way inclined (as I am - doing things with the children and friends was more interesting than housework when they were little).

The only thing that is not ok is the working parent trying to tell the SAHP what they should be doing at home. I always did the bare minimum when it came to cleaning etc - if my husband had wanted the skirting boards to be polished, he could have done that himself.

OP has an easier time than most SAHPs/women on mat leave as her older child is at nursery part of the time. I just used to have to take my children everywhere. There was a very long period when I just didn't do things like have my hair cut, because it wasn't feasible to do it with the DC in tow.

Marchitectmummy · 19/10/2023 08:58

Don't understand why you wouldn't want to do as much as you can so your family can spend time together after work or weekends.

Threads like this feel like the two adults are too busy tit for tatting each other to even care about each other. Why wouldn't either of you want to make the other ones life easier as a base of being together. Rather than it's your turn to do the washing!

PloddingAlong21 · 19/10/2023 08:57

I am usually on the side of splitting it but I don’t think your DH is being unreasonable.

flip it round, you go to work and your husband is at home where 2 of the days he is home with a 4 month old who are pretty easy to care for and take round and do whatever with and he is not doing laundry or the general hits and pieces of house chores. you would come home annoyed too as it’s n it a difficult task.

That’s a total breeze to do in those two days. When you’ve got your mobile toddler that’s very different as logistically you are doing a lot more.

Why organise a vets appointment 830am in the middle of commuter traffic and right before work, presumably making him late if he were to do it? Wouldn’t it be better to use your 2 easy days to get ‘admin’ done so you can all be together in the evenings? It’s also not much time commitment to throw clothes in a washing machine.

when he gets home he can spend time with the kids. Bath time etc.

I don’t think he’s being unreasonable at all.

Goldbar · 19/10/2023 08:55

spitefulandbadgrammar · 19/10/2023 08:55

how do you think women managed without all the mod cons for housework and multiple babies?
Gin, drugs, nervous breakdowns, probably.

And a lot of really poor quality parenting.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 19/10/2023 08:55

how do you think women managed without all the mod cons for housework and multiple babies?
Gin, drugs, nervous breakdowns, probably.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 19/10/2023 08:53

@Missdemeanorz My daily chores? Well I got up at 6am with the baby, pooey nappy change, dressed for the day, breastfeed. Took him in to wake up DD for school and supervise her brushing her teeth. Put the dishwasher on because DP forgot last night, but first took out the high chair tray and breakfast things and hand washed them while he sorted breakfast. Supervised the baby’s breakfast then cleaned him up, then he did a poonami so a nappy change and starting again with a new outfit. DP’s currently doing the school run while I supervise the kamikaze baby practising cruising (Mumsnetting over his head, obviously). He’ll nap at 9am for precisely 30 minutes which is my window to clear up breakfast things, wipe down high chair, unload dishwasher, prep his snack and lunch, assess the calpol stocks because it’s sick season, and whip round the house to tidy all the rooms for the cleaner who’s coming at 9.30. If I’m lucky I’ll have time to shower.

I’m actually not fully sure on what DP’s chores are because we split things fully to decrease the mental load (though he does like to give me endless laundry reports). He does bins, recycling, the tip, food shop and top-up shops, all laundry. Plus a bunch of other stuff I can’t remember, and as and when stuff like DIY, tech, changing lightbulbs. I do all cleaning (in-between weekly cleaner visits), tidying, the garden, decluttering as the baby rapidly grows through things, weekday dinners, half the weekend meals, meal plans, school communication, childcare admin, manage home renovation, everything car-related, everything cat-related, school holiday planning, homework, celebrations (anything ever needed for Halloween, Christmas, birthdays, Easter, tooth fairy, pancake day, firework night), bunch of other stuff that’s more as and when – tonight I have to make a fancy cake and tomorrow night prep some side dishes for a family thing we’re hosting this weekend, for instance.

Generally in the baby’s lunch nap of 90 mins I clear up his lunch and the blast zone, make and eat mine, prep the family dinner for that night or batch cook or batch freezer bags of sofritto, and deal with the endless to do list of random shite that family life entails. I usually sit down for a whole 20 minutes towards the end of the nap with a cup of tea, as that’s my last chance til the oldest goes to bed at 8pm. The rest of the day he’s awake and it is filled with breastfeeds and the baby’s dinner and going to the library for rhyme time and the playground for swings and the ducks to throw kale at them even though they want bread, and supervising him going up and down the stairs and nappy changes and snot sucking and calpol for teeth and occasional baby classes and, rarely, coffee with a friend – we’re all too busy. Although I don’t touch laundry I do put the baby’s clothes away because he’s always asleep in DP’s window to do that. Once he’s in nursery I’ll be completely hands-off.

When the baby was four months I did far, far less and DP either did more or we let things slide: my job at four months was surviving the sleep regression, regaining my fitness (I couldn’t walk during pregnancy so had completely atrophied), breastfeeding approximately 9,000 times a day, and watching 19 seasons of Grey’s Anatomy while I did so, because it’s not often you have a baby and it’s a big deal. I cannot fathom DP questioning anything I was doing at four months: I was doing exactly what I was supposed to. Everyone was fed and bathed and the house was a bit of a tip.

SallyWD · 19/10/2023 08:53

Hmm neither of you unreasonable really. I have to say I just did all the housework when I was a SAHP. I saw it as part of my role. DH worked long hours and when he wasn't working I wanted him to spend time with the kids.
Yes my main role was childcare but I had plenty of time to do the laundry and prepare meals.

crumblingschools · 19/10/2023 08:51

@IDontOftenComment do you live in the 1950s