Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I have unreasonable expectations of SAHP role?

560 replies

Babysharkdodo123 · 18/10/2023 12:01

Currently on mat leave with 4 month old. 22 month old in nursery couple of days as no family around to help and wanted to keep routine.

Dog needed to go to vets this morning for routine boosters so I asked DH if he could take her as i would have to juggle both kids and dog. Appointment at 8.30am so before work. He said no "why couldn't I do it as he was at work earning the money" (for ref I only get SMP).

I then got asked what I was doing today (meeting friends new baby) which was met with "oh, I thought you could get through some of the laundry".

So AIBU that household maintenance ie dogs, drs appointments, cleaning, laundry, cooking, grocery shopping should be shared in non working hours? If I was at work and DCs in nursery then no one would be home to do all of these jobs so they'd have to be shared out. Just because I'm on mat leave I don't think it should be expected that I do everything and DH wakes up, leaves and earns money.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Deborah54 · 06/11/2023 08:25

Sorry, but I think you’re being unreasonable. Even with 2 kids at home I managed the laundry, cleaning and other house stuff. When you’re back at work that’s different and should be shared.

As for the dog. Book an appointment that works for hubby after work or you when oldest child is at nursery. Surely you can push a pram and walk the dog.

RantyAnty · 05/11/2023 17:09

Sayitaintso33 · 24/10/2023 10:24

Many jobs are far longer than 40 hours a week. If you've only ever worked in jobs where you didn't have to take work home then you've only had very easy jobs.

But do you also cook, clean, and do laundry?

MissDani27 · 05/11/2023 13:12

Because he'd been harping on about having clean clothes and that when he comes in for work he just wants to chill. This was at a time when I was a community carer, so his excuse was that I was in the house more than him.

Backagain23 · 24/10/2023 23:58

Sayitaintso33 · 24/10/2023 23:30

What you said was a full time job is only 40 hours a week. You now disagree. It is not my fault you keep changing your mind.

I haven't changed my mind once.
If I had stated "a full time job can only be 40 hours per week and not a moment more or less" and then stated "a full time job can only be (for example only, I feel the need to stress this as you seem not to be able to tell the difference between an example and a catch all statement) 45 hours" then yes, that would fall under the umbrella of "changing my mind".
I didn't. All I said was that 40 hours per week is considered a full time job. As was my job when I was working 60 hours.
Congratulations, this is possibly now the silliest non argument I have ever had on MN. I hope you can try to grasp what I said, I won't be derailing the thread further.

Sayitaintso33 · 24/10/2023 23:30

What you said was a full time job is only 40 hours a week. You now disagree. It is not my fault you keep changing your mind.

Backagain23 · 24/10/2023 23:20

Sayitaintso33 · 24/10/2023 20:33

What you said in your first post was a full time job is only 40 hours a week.

You contradicted that in your second post so we now agree that I was right which is good.

Was it news to you that 40 hours per week was considered a full time job? So is 41 hours. Or 39. Or 50.
There's 168 hours in every week though so still a smaller portion of time than a SAHP is going to be on the clock if they have a lazy partner, regardless of the particulars of an employment contract

Sayitaintso33 · 24/10/2023 20:33

Backagain23 · 24/10/2023 20:26

That's quite a leap to make.
I made no comment on how many jobs are 40 hours, just that 40 hours is a full time job.
I've worked 60 hours per week in the past actually, not that it's even vaguely relevant to the thread 😒
Still had to do my own laundry and housework, incidentally.

What you said in your first post was a full time job is only 40 hours a week.

You contradicted that in your second post so we now agree that I was right which is good.

Backagain23 · 24/10/2023 20:26

Sayitaintso33 · 24/10/2023 10:24

Many jobs are far longer than 40 hours a week. If you've only ever worked in jobs where you didn't have to take work home then you've only had very easy jobs.

That's quite a leap to make.
I made no comment on how many jobs are 40 hours, just that 40 hours is a full time job.
I've worked 60 hours per week in the past actually, not that it's even vaguely relevant to the thread 😒
Still had to do my own laundry and housework, incidentally.

Sayitaintso33 · 24/10/2023 10:24

Backagain23 · 19/10/2023 23:22

Nope, bollocks to that.
A full time job is only 40 hours per week.
If looking after tiny babies, toddlers, dogs and houses is so easy, it should be fine for someone only working 40 hours to get involved during the many hours a week they are not at work. Not a big deal.
If looking after tiny babies, toddlers, dogs and houses is hard work, then it's certainly unreasonable to expect one person to manage it all 24/7 and the parent who only works 40 hours outside the home can get involved during the many hours a week they are not at work. Not a big deal.
My mat leave was primarily for my babies, not to turn DH into a pampered prince who suddenly could not operate the washing machine or hoover since he had fathered a child.

Many jobs are far longer than 40 hours a week. If you've only ever worked in jobs where you didn't have to take work home then you've only had very easy jobs.

Fogwisp · 23/10/2023 14:31

LolaSmiles · 23/10/2023 13:27

The extent to which people use sophistry to exaggerate their daily routine is incredible
There was a thread years ago that was hilarious. At one point a poster resorted to arguing they were so unbelievably busy because they were responsible for organising the family photos.

In general I find there's people in all parts of life who are prone to talking up every little detail and acting like they're so much busier than everyone else. I can never quite tell whether it's a permanent victim role or that they fetishise busy-ness. Once children are on the scene it makes it more noticeable.

Person A and B have identical mornings.

Person A's outlook: It's a nice day. We've been to the park to feed the ducks this morning, the kids have let off steam and then we've pottered at home and I've done some odd jobs.

Person B: We've had to go to the park this morning because it's so exhausting entertaining DC. Before we've even left the house I've had to check the weather, pack the coats, sort the wellies out, make sure there's snacks, then DC needed to go to the toilet before we left... Typical! Obviously once we got to the park I had to run around after them, check they didn't kill themselves, supervise them carefully at the duck pond. Find somewhere for snack and inevitably one of them got fruit shoot down themselves so I had to get that cleaned up. Then we had to load everything back in the car to go home...

I think it's a very different experience for A and B, probably depending on factors such as sheer exhaustion (which makes everyday tasks very difficult), how much security and support one has in life, and other life stressors.

Also, as the previous comment points out, B is often a response to questions or criticism, an explanation as to why they had no free time to do x y z.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 23/10/2023 13:33

@LolaSmiles Hmm, I think some of the Person B factor is just “explaining things on the internet”, isn’t it? I’m very much Person A in person, but if someone asked me on Mumsnet dot com for a breakdown of my morning, particularly in the context of, say, a thread about lack of time, or balance of chores, or tiredness when caring for small children, it might read like Person B. And the internet lacks tone – so someone might type a Person B explanation while quite happily chasing their toddler round the house, having fun, and be interpreted as angry and harried.

LolaSmiles · 23/10/2023 13:27

The extent to which people use sophistry to exaggerate their daily routine is incredible
There was a thread years ago that was hilarious. At one point a poster resorted to arguing they were so unbelievably busy because they were responsible for organising the family photos.

In general I find there's people in all parts of life who are prone to talking up every little detail and acting like they're so much busier than everyone else. I can never quite tell whether it's a permanent victim role or that they fetishise busy-ness. Once children are on the scene it makes it more noticeable.

Person A and B have identical mornings.

Person A's outlook: It's a nice day. We've been to the park to feed the ducks this morning, the kids have let off steam and then we've pottered at home and I've done some odd jobs.

Person B: We've had to go to the park this morning because it's so exhausting entertaining DC. Before we've even left the house I've had to check the weather, pack the coats, sort the wellies out, make sure there's snacks, then DC needed to go to the toilet before we left... Typical! Obviously once we got to the park I had to run around after them, check they didn't kill themselves, supervise them carefully at the duck pond. Find somewhere for snack and inevitably one of them got fruit shoot down themselves so I had to get that cleaned up. Then we had to load everything back in the car to go home...

Coffeerum · 23/10/2023 11:45

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/10/2023 18:46

I consider my weekend as down time too. They are called days off for a reason.

It's funny because there are people on this site who chastise us for working rather than staying at home FT with young children, and yet we're the ones who don't seem to be making every single interaction with them into one huge big chore which we resent.

Fogwisp · 23/10/2023 11:36

Huge amounts of mother-shaming going on here.

I wonder what's behind it, why the need to shame people for not all being the same, for not being able to do the same things ir have the same circumstances?

And why the bizarre lies, pretending that for hundreds of years mothers have been made to look after children alone, when that's simply untrue? What's in it for people making up these stories, politically, socially?

GroomedForSerfdom · 23/10/2023 07:18

In the 10 mins that posters toddler was trying to put their shoes on for, the poster could have got all the washing hung out and sorted.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/10/2023 07:13

AfterWeights · 23/10/2023 07:00

*Toddler: spends 5 minutes arguing about coming outside. Then once you've decided to do it without them they scream they want to come and throw a tantrum. So you start helping them put their shoes on which they then spend 10 minutes arguing they can do it themselves. Eventually you cajole them outside where they find a puddle/birdbath/plant pot and empty it on themselves. They are now muddy and wet and decide that's the moment they're going to help with the washing. So now they are cold and wet and your clean washing is muddy. You then spend another 10 minutes persuading them to come inside and now you have to clean and change them.
Or you leave them inside and while you're gone they drag the baby across the floor, wee on the sofa or find a tissue box that they empty every tissue individually out of. Or worse and they actually injure the baby.

Baby: screams the entire time regardless of where you put them because they're no longer being held. Or you have them in the sling and they spend the whole time trying to grab/look at what you're doing and you try desperately not to tip them out as your thighs aren't built for this much squatting to the basket with an extra weight strapped to you.*

This just reads like you are trying to make it hard for yourself.

Put toddler strapped into buggy/high chair/garden swing for ten mins. Put telly on for ten mins. Let baby bellow in bouncy chair for ten mins. Put laundry basket on a chair so you aren't squatting. Hang washing out. Mankind has survived with parents getting chores done with toddlers and babies in tow for millennia.

My first thought on reading the above was that that poster could benefit from learning some better strategies for managing her toddler's behaviour. Obviously, all kids have their moments, but if the pattern that she describes is really typical of her day-to-day reality, she probably needs to shift something in her own approach to make life easier for herself.

AfterWeights · 23/10/2023 07:00

*Toddler: spends 5 minutes arguing about coming outside. Then once you've decided to do it without them they scream they want to come and throw a tantrum. So you start helping them put their shoes on which they then spend 10 minutes arguing they can do it themselves. Eventually you cajole them outside where they find a puddle/birdbath/plant pot and empty it on themselves. They are now muddy and wet and decide that's the moment they're going to help with the washing. So now they are cold and wet and your clean washing is muddy. You then spend another 10 minutes persuading them to come inside and now you have to clean and change them.
Or you leave them inside and while you're gone they drag the baby across the floor, wee on the sofa or find a tissue box that they empty every tissue individually out of. Or worse and they actually injure the baby.

Baby: screams the entire time regardless of where you put them because they're no longer being held. Or you have them in the sling and they spend the whole time trying to grab/look at what you're doing and you try desperately not to tip them out as your thighs aren't built for this much squatting to the basket with an extra weight strapped to you.*

This just reads like you are trying to make it hard for yourself.

Put toddler strapped into buggy/high chair/garden swing for ten mins. Put telly on for ten mins. Let baby bellow in bouncy chair for ten mins. Put laundry basket on a chair so you aren't squatting. Hang washing out. Mankind has survived with parents getting chores done with toddlers and babies in tow for millennia.

Missdemeanorz · 23/10/2023 06:41

Goldbar · 22/10/2023 17:20

Full disclosure - I'm not a SAHP, I'm on mat leave like the OP and returning to work part-time soon.

I love spending time with my children, yes, but they are full-on so I wouldn't describe it as 'down-time'. Chasing after two very active mobile children of completely different ages, both keen to push their physical boundaries to the limit, is not exactly what I would class as a relaxing experience. I am awed and in wonder at what they achieve daily, the progress they make and how brave and wonderful they are. I am also running around like a crazy lady underneath them both trying to catch them when they fall, while they live life to the fullest. Perhaps other people's experiences might be different if they have more sedate children, but this is mine. Go figure - kids are different.

Apart from when we have a babysitter or DH takes the kids, the closest thing to down-time for me will be when I'm back at work going for the occasional coffee or lunch with colleagues. Actually being able to eat my lunch hot (a lunch I didn't cook) because I'm not tending to others the whole time. And no cleaning up to do.

Why are you running around attempting to stop your children from falling?
The extent to which people use sophistry to exaggerate their daily routine is incredible.

pphammer · 22/10/2023 21:41

YABU.
You're a SAHP, you should be doing the bulk of the chores. When he's home he can help

Nothing7 · 22/10/2023 19:32

Possibly yes. Depends on the circumstances. If the sahp can keep on top of it whilst the other is at work, why not??
Or should the person at work, do the work then come home and clean whilst the other has 9 months off work and just relaxes?
I didn’t say the person at work does no housework, but it should be fair, so why should one work and the other just put their feet up and socialise if baby is napping? It’s a partnership, so to be fair the one at home surely would want to put as much in as the other at work. This may very well be the case, and there still be things that need doing when the partner comes home. And when they come home they can share what remains to be done.
Again it depends on the circumstances and I guess your relationship with your partner.
If baby is napping and other child is at nursery then hopefully the parent at home can get some bits done, so there is less for both of them to do in the evening.

VulcanVause · 22/10/2023 19:02

OP, YANBU - this is stuff that my H used to say and used to leave me to do everything. Now that I’m back full time, I still do more than him but he does help quite a bit. But the mental workload lies with me. he was moaning if I ask him to take kid to any appt so I had to have a word about it and now he’s doing some.
but yes taking kids to cafe or mates is not really downtime for you. Aldo baby sleeping does not coincide with toddler sibling napping so not a break just slightly less chaos.

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/10/2023 18:46

Coffeerum · 22/10/2023 17:02

Surely you chose to have children and stay home with them though?
I class basically all of my weekend as “down time” even though I’m going for coffee with my kids, making lunches, wiping up spills.

Otherwise same shit, different place, potentially with company.

Imo this is just a miserable outlook.

I consider my weekend as down time too. They are called days off for a reason.

Backagain23 · 22/10/2023 18:24

Nothing7 · 22/10/2023 18:08

But they’re not both working? So yeah when OP is back to work, but surely when at home there can be more done?

Begs the question of why the person who is recovering from pregnancy and childbirth (and more than likely contending with all the night feeds "because he's got work in the morning" ) is suddenly expected to take on more of the domestic labour over and above what's required to get through the day with a baby?
And the other person, having become a parent with zero effort or physical strain on their part, gets to just sail on as before but with even less domestic responsibility than before?

MigraineOfSalt · 22/10/2023 18:20

LolaSmiles · 22/10/2023 16:31

I wonder if WOH makes people appreciate time with their kids more, because they don't view it as a job?
This might get me flamed but I don't think it's a SAHP/WOHP divide.

I think it's that some parents (regardless of whether they are a SAHP/WOHP) have a generally positive outlook, accept not everything in life is easy and are busy getting on with things, and other people have a more whiny hard done to outlook (again regardless of SAHP/WOHP) so they feel the need to moan about everything and act like they're the first people on earth to have a child.

You know the types in the workplace: despite other people having similar workloads, there's always some people who are always huffing and puffing, have a huge to do list, prattle on about how they wish they could have a cup of coffee but they can't because they have to go and collect their printing, send 5 emails, make a call (insert list here of every tiny thing in the day that most other people in the office are getting on with without making a fuss).

The parenting version is similar. Whilst most parents have ups and downs, easy days and hard days, some people have to huff and puff because they woke up, made breakfast for the kids, had to put the dishes in the dishwasher, sit at playgroup saying they've absolutely no idea how anyone manages to have a drink or a wee during the day because they're so exhausted and they'll have to think about lunch soon, come on Mumsnet saying they have no time to do anything because they're so busy being parent of the century.

I think some people just have a woe is me mindset.

I roll my eyes when I read, ‘I am sooo busy that I can’t even have a wee in peace as they follow me in!!’ Well shut the door then 🤷🏼‍♀️

spitefulandbadgrammar · 22/10/2023 18:17

Nothing7 · 22/10/2023 18:08

But they’re not both working? So yeah when OP is back to work, but surely when at home there can be more done?

So the working parent gets nine months off doing any housework?